Article contents
Folk-economic beliefs: An evolutionary cognitive model
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 12 October 2017
Abstract
The domain of “folk-economics” consists in explicit beliefs about the economy held by laypeople, untrained in economics, about such topics as, for example, the causes of the wealth of nations, the benefits or drawbacks of markets and international trade, the effects of regulation, the origins of inequality, the connection between work and wages, the economic consequences of immigration, or the possible causes of unemployment. These beliefs are crucial in forming people's political beliefs and in shaping their reception of different policies. Yet, they often conflict with elementary principles of economic theory and are often described as the consequences of ignorance, irrationality, or specific biases. As we will argue, these past perspectives fail to predict the particular contents of popular folk-economic beliefs and, as a result, there is no systematic study of the cognitive factors involved in their emergence and cultural success. Here we propose that the cultural success of particular beliefs about the economy is predictable if we consider the influence of specialized, largely automatic inference systems that evolved as adaptations to ancestral human small-scale sociality. These systems, for which there is independent evidence, include free-rider detection, fairness-based partner choice, ownership intuitions, coalitional psychology, and more. Information about modern mass-market conditions activates these specific inference systems, resulting in particular intuitions, for example, that impersonal transactions are dangerous or that international trade is a zero-sum game. These intuitions in turn make specific policy proposals more likely than others to become intuitively compelling, and, as a consequence, exert a crucial influence on political choices.
Keywords
- Type
- Target Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2018
References
- 62
- Cited by
Target article
Folk-economic beliefs: An evolutionary cognitive model
Related commentaries (32)
A grounded cognition perspective on folk-economic beliefs
A theory of how evolved psychology underpins attitudes towards societal economics must go beyond exchanges and averages
Adding culture and context improves evolutionary theorizing about human cognition
Beyond market behavior: Evolved cognition and folk political economic beliefs
Broadening the role of “self-interest” in folk-economic beliefs
Challenges of folk-economic beliefs: Coverage, level of abstraction, and relation to ideology
Coalitional rivalry may hurt in economic exchanges such as trade but help in war
Developmental and cultural factors in economic beliefs
Do the folk actually hold folk-economic beliefs?
Does evolutionary cognitive psychology crowd out the better angels of our nature?
Economic complexities and cognitive hurdles: Accounting for specific economic misconceptions without an ultimate cause
Elaborating the role of reflection and individual differences in the study of folk-economic beliefs
Evolutionary model of folk economics: That which is seen, and that which is not seen?
Fairness, more than any other cognitive mechanism, is what explains the content of folk-economic beliefs
Fear of economic policies may be domain-specific, and social emotions can explain why
Folk-economic beliefs as moral intuitions
Folk-economic beliefs as “evidential fiction”: Putting the economic public discourse back on track
Folk-economics: Inherited biases or misapplication of everyday experience?
How Homo economicus lost her mind and how we can revive her
How does “emporiophobia” develop?
Mapping the terra incognita of economic cognition will require an experimental paradigm that incorporates context
Not all folk-economic beliefs are best understood through our ancestral past
Partisan elites shape citizens' economic beliefs
People are intuitive economists under the right conditions
Social transmission bias and the cultural evolution of folk-economic beliefs
Spoiled for choice: Identifying the building blocks of folk-economic beliefs
The challenge of accounting for individual differences in folk-economic beliefs
The mind of the market: Lay beliefs about the economy as a willful, goal-oriented agent
Understanding the development of folk-economic beliefs
Why do people believe in a zero-sum economy?
Why do people think that others should earn this or that?
Zero-sum thinking and economic policy
Author response
What is seen and what is not seen in the economy: An effect of our evolved psychology