Skip to main content Accessibility help

We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.

Close cookie message
×

Peer review

Online peer review systems

Where you complete and/or submit your review will vary depending on the journal. At Cambridge University Press, we use two online peer review systems called Scholar One and Editorial Manager, where you'll be expected to submit your review. These systems are user-friendly and should walk you through the process of submitting your review.

Instructions for anonymous manuscript annotation

When submitting your review documents to an online peer review systems, you can help maintain the appropriate confidentiality of reviewers by changing a few settings in Adobe Acrobat or Microsoft Word

You should not use your name in the filename of the review to maintain anonymity.

How to Anonymize Adobe PDFs

To check for and remove personal information from Adobe PDF files from Acrobat versions DC and above:

  1. Open the PDF document.
  2. Choose "Tools" and then select "Redact."
  3. Choose “Remove Hidden Information” and wait for the tool to finish running.
  4. If any items appear in the Results, click “Remove.”
  5. Save the file, note that identity information is not removed until the file is saved.

To check for and remove personal information from Adobe PDF files from Acrobat versions 8, 9, and X:

  1. Open the PDF document.
  2. From the "Document" pull-down menu, select "Examine 3. Document" and wait for the tool to finish running.
  3. If any items appear check-marked, click “Remove.”
  4. Save the file, note that identity information is not removed until the file is saved.

A fast, easy, and recommended manual check is:

  1. File.
  2. Properties.
  3. Click the Description tab and pay particular attention to the block labeled “Author.” This is a frequent location of a name or initials.

How to Anonymize Microsoft Word Files

To check for and remove personal information from Word 2010, 2013, and 2016 (.docx) files:

  1. Click the File tab at the top-left corner of the window.
  2. Click "Info" in the column at the left side of the window.
  3. Click the "Check for Issues" drop-down menu, then click "Inspect Document."
  4. Check the "Document Properties and Personal Information box" (you can uncheck the rest of the options), then click the "Inspect" button.
  5. Click the "Remove All" button at the top of the window, then click the "Close" button. Be sure to save the document after making all of your changes.

To check for and remove personal information from Word 2007 (.docx) files:

  1. Right click the Word .docx file.
  2. Click "Properties" and select the Details tab.
  3. Click "Remove Properties and Personal Information.”
  4. Choose "Create a copy with all possible properties removed" and click OK, or Choose the radio button for "Remove the following properties from this file," checkmark your selections, and click OK.
  5. This removes hidden personal information from the copy that Word has created. The new file has “copy” added to the original file name. Example: Report_on_submission – copy.docx. Take care to send this file and not the original, which will still carry identity information.

To check for and remove personal information from Word 1997-2003 (.doc) files:

  1. Open the Word .doc file.
  2. Create a copy of the file so that you do not overwrite the original version. Click the Microsoft Office Button in the upper left corner and select "Save As. "
  3. NOTE: "Save As" is recommended as you will be unable to restore anything that Word is about to remove.
  4. In the copy, again click the Microsoft Office Button, select "Prepare," and then click "Inspect Document."
  5. In the Document Inspector dialog box click “Inspect.” You may first uncheck any boxes where you wish to exclude selected content from the scan.
  6. Review the results of the inspection in the Document Inspector dialog box and then click "Remove All" for the types of hidden content that you want to remove.
  7. Click "Close" when done. Save the file.

Your file is now clear of personal data and ready to submit!