Social Protest and Policy Change: Ecology, Antinuclear, and Peace
Movements in Comparative Perspective. By Marco Giugni. Lanham, MD:
Rowman & Littlefield, 2004. 320p. $75.00 cloth, $32.95 paper.
The same things that provoke social movements also promote
institutional pressures for change, shifts in public opinion, and
policy change. As a result, disentangling the effects of protest on
policy presents an ongoing analytical challenge. If we look, for
example, at the volatile and diverse movement against the American war
in Vietnam, it is virtually impossible to track clear lines of
influence between the volume or disruptiveness of protests covered in
the news and spending on the war or casualties produced in battle. At
the same time, by reviewing memoirs, archives, and the broader outlines
of policy, we know that the movement had longer-term effects, including
(minimally), ending military conscription and establishing much
stricter political and military tests for long-term commitments of
American combat forces overseas. The latter set of constraints,
codified as the Weinberger, then the Powell, doctrines, held sway over
American military policy from the end of Vietnam until, finally,
violated by the current American intervention in Iraq. At the same
time, politicians of both parties vigorously try to reassure nervous
youth, many of whom are children of the protest generation, that the
draft is indeed gone for good. Clearly, the protests against the
Vietnam war mattered, though perhaps not exactly in the ways that
activists hoped or as much as they dreamed.