Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-m6dg7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-05T11:47:44.420Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Victoria Nyanza as a Trade route in the Nineteenth Century

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

Gerald W. Hartwig
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Trading in ivory occurred early in the nineteenth century in the south-eastern region of the Victoria Nyanza. An examination of Kerebe oral tradition partially reveals the extent of African initiative in the early period of the trade. With the arrival of coastal traders, African initiative was diminished, except for outstanding leaders like Mirambo of Unyamwezi and Mutesa of Buganda. Their activities restricted the traders. Mirambo's control over the Unyanyembe–Karagwe route forced both Mutesa and the merchants to make full use of the lake for transporting goods from about 1878 to 1889. Before this time, the lake was only occasionally used for transporting ivory. Canoes provided the chief mode of transport during this period, though these were supplemented by two dhows. The lack of dhows does not reflect the lack of trade on the lake, but rather the extent of reliance upon Ganda assistance in carrying on the trade. With the Ganda in large numbers in the southern lake region for commercial reasons, the people there fell within Buganda's sphere of intervention. The Sukuma chiefdoms did not rely on Ganda military power to settle local quarrels, and thereby avoided the destruction that occurred in Buzinza. Internal factors in Buganda, however, weakened their control of the southern lake region even before the arrival of the Germans.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 11 , Issue 4 , October 1970 , pp. 535 - 552
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1970

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 In two standard reference works on East Africa, the accompanying maps reflect the lack of knowledge about the lake trade route, see Alison, Smith, ‘The Southern Section of the Interior’, History of East Africa, I, ed. Oliver, Roland and Mathew, Gervase (London, 1963), 252,Google Scholar and Norman, R. Bennett, ‘The Arab Impact’, Zamani; A Survey of East African History, ed. Ogot, B. A. and Kieran, J. A. (Nairobi, 1968), 218.Google Scholar Recent publications that have incorporated the same view include Ralph, A. Austen, Northwest Tasmania under German and British Rule (New Haven, 1968), 16, 20–1,Google Scholar and Carl, J. Hellberg, Missions on a Colonial Frontier West of Lake Victoria (Lund, 1965), 40. Father François Renault, Le cardinal Lavigerie, l'esclavage africain et l'europe (Paris, forthcoming), does include the lake route as one of the significant routes. I wish to express my appreciation to E. Hollis Merritt for reading and commenting upon an earlier draft of this paper.Google Scholar

2 Collection of oral traditions among the Kerebe was made possible by a fellowship granted to the author by the Foreign Area Fellowship Program. The statements and conclusions contained in this paper are the sole responsibility of the author. The nomenclature used for the Kerebe (Abakerebe) is based upon Kikerebe. See Malcolm, Guthrie, The Classification of the Bantu Languages (London, 1948), 42–3. Ukerewe and Wakerewe are the standard Swahili forms.Google Scholar

3 Henry, M. Stanley, Through the Dark Continent, I (London, 1878), 329–30.Google Scholar

4 Ibid., 220.

5 Additional information on Songoro can be found inGerald, W. Hartwig, ‘Bukerebe, the Church Missionary Society, and East African Politics, 1877–1878’, African Historical Studies, 1, 2 (1968), 222-3; Smith, ‘The Southern Section of the Interior’, gives a different interpretation of Songoro's role and power.Google Scholar

6 SirJohn, M. Gray, ‘Arabs on Lake Victoria. Some Revisions’, Uganda Journal, XXII (1958), 76.Google Scholar

7 ‘Henry M. Stanley's Erforschung des Victoria Nyanza’, Petermanns Mitteilungen, 1875, 465.Google Scholar

8 Ford, V. C. R., The Lake Trade of Lake Victoria (Kampala, 1955), 18.Google Scholar

9 Gray, J. M., ‘Trading Expeditions from the Coast to Lakes Tanganyika and Victoria before 1857’, Tanganyika Notes and Records, 49 (1957), 236–7;Google Scholar see also his ‘Arabs on Lake Victoria’, and his letter in Tanganyika Notes and Records, 25 (1948), 79–81. Ralph Austen specifically states that missionaries initiated ‘a new route to Buganda across Lake Victoria’. Northwest Tanzania. 20–1.Google Scholar

10 Stanley, The Dark Continent, 1, 330.Google Scholar

11 Prèsdes Grand Lacs, par les missionnaires deS. Em. le Cardinal Lavigerie (Paris, 1886), 35.Google Scholar

12 Franz, Stuhlmann, Mit Emin Pascha ins Herz von Afrika (Berlin, 1894), 733.Google Scholar

13 Robert, W. Felkin, ‘Uganda’, The Scottish Geographical Magazine, 11 (1886), 217.Google Scholar

14 Grant, , ‘Summary of Observations on the Geography…’, Journal of the Royal Geographical Society (hereafter JRGS), XLII (1872), 279, 281–2.Google Scholar

15 The hunters were called abagunda. The group was open to any man interested in hunting elephants. They remained active until about 1890. The musical contribution of this group to Kerebe culture is discussed in Hartwig, , ‘The Historical and Social Role of Kerebe Music’, Tanzania Notes and Records, 70 (1969), 43–4.Google Scholar

16 See Andrew, Roberts, ‘The Nyamwezi’, Tanzania Before 1900, ed. Roberts, A. (Nairobi, 1968), 125;Google ScholarEdward, A. Alpers, ‘The Coast and the Development of the Caravan Trade’, A History of Tanzania, ed. Kimambo, I. N. and Temu, A. J. (Nairobi, 1969), 51–2.Google Scholar

17 Stuhlmann, , Mit Emin Pascha, 727.Google Scholar

18 An interesting discussion of the contemporary issues centering around the controversial map, as well as the map itself, is found in the Church Missionary Intelligencer, VII (1856), 190–2.Google Scholar

19 Richard, F. Burton, The Lake Regions of Central Africa, II (London, 1860), 214;Google ScholarJohn, H. Speke, What Led to the Discovery of the Source of the Nile (Edinburgh, 1864), 255.Google Scholar

20 Wakefield, T., ‘Routes of Native Caravans from the Coast to the Interior of Eastern Africa’, JRGS, XL (1870), 303–38;Google Scholar also his ‘Native Routes through the Masai Country’, Proceedings of the Royal Geographical Society, n.s., IV (1882),Google ScholarGrant, J. A., ‘On Mr H. M. Stanley's Exploration of the Victoria Nyanza’, JRGS, XLVI (1876), 16.Google Scholar

21 Baker, E. C., ‘The Bagirango’, Cory Papers, No. 7: University College Library, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania.Google Scholar

22 Speke, , What Led to the Discovery, 350–1;Google ScholarShergold, Smith to Wright, , 27 08 1877,Google Scholar C. A6/022, Church Missionary Society Archives (hereafter C.M.S.), London; James, Christie, Cholera Epidemics in East Africa (London, 1876), 237–42, also notice the accompanying map.Google Scholar

23 Burton, , The Lake Regions, II, 214–5;Google ScholarSpeke, , What Led to the Discovery, 310–1.Google Scholar

24 David, Livingstone to Lord, Granville, 1 07 1872,Google Scholar reprinted in Stanley, , How I Found Livingstone (London, 1872), 715;Google ScholarAugust, Schynse, Mit Stanley und Emin Pascha durch Deutsch Ost-Afrika (Köln, 1890), 46; ‘Stanley's Erforschung’, 466;Google ScholarFischer, G. A., ‘Geographischer Monatsbericht’, Petermanns Mitteilungen, 1886, 550.Google Scholar

25 Heinz, D. Ludwig, Ukara—Ein Sonderfall tropischer Bodennutzung im Raum des Victoria-Sees (IFo-Institut für Wirtschaftsforschung, München: 1967), 39.Google Scholar

26 What Led to the Discovery, 316–7; O'Neill to Wright, 29 January 1877, C. A6/O 18, C.M.S.; shortage of timber is discussed in Hartwig, ‘Bukerebe and the Church Missionary Society’, 213.Google Scholar

27 The Dark Continent, 1, 113–4, 121.Google Scholar

28 The Kerebe traditions included in this section are primarily the contribution of Bernardino Buyanza s/o Nansagate, in a series of interviews between September and December 1968, Chavery Wanzura s/o Magoyelo, interviewed on 7 November 1968, and Daudi Musombwa, interviewed on 9 August 1968.

29 This incident is discussed and described at length in ‘Bukerebe and the Church Missionary Society’.

30 Edward, Hutchinson, The Victoria Nyanza, a Field for Missionary Enterprise (London, 1876), 81. The author mentioned that the explorer, Verney Lovett Cameron, met a trader at Kazeh (Tabora) who had a permanent camp on Bukerebe; this meeting occurred in 1873.Google Scholar

31 Grant, , ‘Summary of Observations’, 267; Burton, , The Lake Regions, 11, 212,214; Hutchinson, , The Victoria Nyanza, 129.Google Scholar

32 An illustration of this figure can be found in Hartwig, , ‘A Historical Perspective of Kerebe Sculpturing—Tanzania’, Tribus, 18 (1969), 88, 89–90.Google Scholar

33 What Led to the Discovery, 318.

34 Richard, F. Burton, ‘The Lake Regions of Central Equatorial Africa’, J. Roy. Geog. Soc., xxix (1859) 238; Gray, see footnote 9 above.Google Scholar

35 Gray, , ‘Sir John Kirk and Mutesa’, Uganda Journal, xv (1951), 1–16.Google Scholar

36 Felkin, ‘Uganda’, 257, provides an excellent descriptive statement on the conditions under which merchants lived at the Kabaka's court.

37 John, A. Rowe, ‘Revolution in Buganda, 1856–1900. Part One: The Reign of Kabaka Mukabya Mutesa, 1856–1884’, (unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Wisconsin, 1966), 73–4.Google ScholarRowe's, ‘Mjka Sematimba’, Uganda Journal, XXVIII (1964), 179–92, provides biographical material on a Muganda who frequently led flotillas to Kageyi and Mwanza during the 1880s.Google Scholar

38 Chronique trimestrielle de Ia Société des missionnaires d'afrique (hereafter Chronique), 6 (1880), 118;Google ScholarIbid., 7 (1880), 195.

39 Mackay to Wright, 2 November 1879, C. A6/0 16, C.M.S.

40 A l'assaut des Pays Nègres; Journal des missionnaires d'Alger dans l'Afrique equatoriale (Paris, 1884), 249, 256.Google Scholar

41 Waller, Horace (ed.), The Last Journals of David Livingstone (New York, 1875), 455, 432, 449–52.Google Scholar

42 This event and its diplomatic consequences are discussed at length in ‘Bukerebe and the Church Missionary Society’.

43 A I'Assaut des Pays Nègres, 249, 256; Gray, , ‘Arabs on Lake Victoria’, 78–9.Google Scholar

44 Mackay, 2 November 1879, C. A6/0 16, C.M.S.

45 Bukumbi Diary, White Fathers, Nyegezi, 4 January 1883; O'Flaherty to Wigram, 28 February 1883, G 3A 6/0 1, C.M.S.; Martin, B. G., ‘Muslim Politics and Resistance to Colonial Rule’., J. Afr. Hut.; X, (1969), 474–6.Google Scholar

46 Speke, J. H., Journal of the Discovery of the Source of the Nile (Edinburgh, 1863), 178–96;Google ScholarStanley, H. M., In Darkest Africa, II (London, 1890), 385; The Dark Continent, 1, 375. Mit Emin Pascha, 62, 223–224, 734;Google ScholarFischer, G. A., ‘Vorlaufiger Bericht über die Expedition zur Auflindung Dr Junkers’, Petermanns Mitteilungen (1886), 364. See also Andrew, Roberts, ‘Political Change in the Nineteenth Century’, in A History of Tanzania, 75–6.Google Scholar

47 Bukumbi, Diary, and 7 01 and 1 03 1883, 12 02 1884, 13 01 1885;Google ScholarCopplestone, to Wright, , 24 01 1880,Google Scholar C. A 6/09; Pearson, to Wright, , 24 11 1879,Google Scholar C. A6/0 19; Mackay, to Wright, , 2 11 1879 and 9 06 1880,Google Scholar C. A6/0 16; O'Flaherty, to Wigrarn, , 25 12 1881,Google ScholarMackay, to Lang, , 12 07 1883;Google Scholar and Gordon, to Lang, , 5 11 1883,Google Scholar G. A 6/0 1, C.M.S.; Chronique, 17 (1883), 297.Google Scholar

48 Fischer, , ‘Vorlaufiger Bericht’, 366.Google Scholar

49 Smith, to Wright, , 27 08 1877, C. A 6/0 23, C.M.S.Google Scholar

50 Ralph A. Austen has discussed this condition in theoretical terms for the Sukuma in ‘Ntemiship, Trade, and State-Building’, Eastern African History, Boston University Papers on Africa, III, ed. F. McCall, Daniel, R. Bennett, Norman and Butler, Jeffrey (New York, 1969), 133–47.Google Scholar Austen's structural analysis appears sound, though it would be enhanced and modified by case studies. See also Aylward, Shorter, ‘Nyungu-ya-Mawe and the “Empire of the Ruga-Rugas”,’ J. Afr. Hist. IX, 2 (1968), 258.Google Scholar

51 Though his statement is somewhat misleading, Stanley's assessment of hongo rates in Usukuma is suggestive of the problem. Darkest Africa, II, 443.Google Scholar

52 Speke made a significant comment about the response of the Nyamwezi traders to Arab competition, Journal of the Discovery, 131.Google Scholar

53 This interpretation of Buganda's use of military force in the southern Victoria Nyanza does not appear to differ fundamentally from D. A. Low's assessment in ‘The Northern Interior, 1840–84’, History of East Africa, I, 335–6;Google Scholar see also Roberts, , ‘Political Change in the Nineteenth Century’, 80–1.Google Scholar

54 Journal of Girault, L., 8 10 1881,Google ScholarChronique, 15 (1882), 172.Google Scholar

55 What Led to the Discovery, 316–7.Google Scholar

56 Ibid., 312–13; The Lake Regions, II, 214–5. Both sources infer that canoes could only be obtained at Kageyi (Usukuma); the origin of most canoes would have been Bukerebe, thus reflecting the close diplomatic tie between Kageyi and Bukerebe.Google Scholar

57 Smith, to Wright, , 10 12 1878 [sic, 1877], C. A6/0 22, C.M.S.Google Scholar

58 Ibid., 16 06 1877.

59 Ibid., Diary, 22 10 1877.

60 Journal, ‘De Roubaga a Tabora’, 4 January 1883, Chronique, 19 (1883), 430.Google Scholar

61 Mackay, to Wigram, , 06 1884, also 20 04 and 21 07 1884, G 3. A 6/0 1, C.M.S.Google Scholar

62 Stokes, to Wright, , 18 10 1879,Google Scholar C. A 6/0 24; Mackay, to Wright, , 2 11 1879, C. A 6/0 16, C.M.S.Google Scholar

63 O'Flaherty, , 25 12 1881,Google Scholar G 3. A6/0 1, C.M.S.; ‘Ouganda Journal,’ 20 July 1881, Chronique, 17 (1883), 297.Google Scholar

64 Copplestone, to Lang, , 24 04 1882, G 3. A 6/0 1, C.M.S.Google Scholar

65 Journal, ‘De Roubaga a Tabora’, 4 January 1883, Chronique, 19 (1883), 430.Google Scholar

66 O'Flaherty, to Wigram, , 01 1883, G 3. A 6/0 1, C.M.S.Google Scholar

67 Bukumbi, Diary, 15 07 1884.Google Scholar

68 Ibid., 13 02 1886.

69 O'Flaherty, to Hutchinson, , 23 06 1881, 19 06, 1 07 and 31 08 1883;Google ScholarAshe, to Lang, , 13 11 1882;Google ScholarMackay, to Wigram, , 18 09 1883;Google ScholarGordon, to Lang, , 11 1883, G 3. A 6/0 1, C.M.S.Google Scholar

70 Bukumbi, Diary, 8 03 1884.Google Scholar

71 Ibid., 27 09 1884 and 2 11 1884.

72 Ibid., 28 06, 21 07, 19 11, 18, 19, 22 and 24 12 1884, 13–19 04 1885, 13 02, 17 10 1886, 3–7 03 1887.

73 Mit Emin Pascha, 108–112.Google Scholar For background information on the Ganda internal disturbances see SirJohn, Gray. ‘The Year of the Three Kings of Buganda, Mwanga—Kiwewa—Kalema, 1888–1889’, Uganda Journal, XIV (1950), 15–52.Google Scholar