Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-t5tsf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-05T11:20:23.209Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The end of the reign of Menilek II

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

Harold G. Marcus
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

This article describes the debilitating illness of Menilek and its effects upon the Ethiopian state. Prior to his incapacity, the old emperor established a European-style cabient, reformed the appelate judiciary, named Lij Eyyasu as his heir, and appointed Ras Bitwodded Tessema Nado as regent. The latter two actions were opposed by Empress Taitou, who hoped to become the real ruler of Ethiopia, operating behind the scenes. As the emperor weakened, she managed to concentrate many of his functions and much of his authority in her own hands. Given the confusion caused by Menilek's condition, she went unchallenged for a time, during which she attempted futilely to construct a viable power base in the north. Finally, in reaction, the Shoan, southern faction, which had much to lose if Menilek's settlement was upset, united and successfully deposed the empress in 1910. A regency government, composed of Menilek's council of ministers and the more important provincial governors, operated more or less functionally until April 1911, when the Ras-Regent died. At the time Lij Eyyasu became chairman of the regency council, and by 1913 he was exercising more or less full authority over the empire. Contrary to contemporary official European expectations and calculations, Menilek's empire did not crack apart upon his removal, nor from regional and personal rivalries. The diplomats showed complete ignorance about the effectiveness of the administrative and military occupation of the newly annexed parts of the empire; they grossly undervalued the strength of Amhara–Tigrean nationalism; they misunderstood the vitality of the mythology of the Solomonic dynasty; and they failed to consider the veneration which Menilek elicited from his people. More than any other point, this article demonstrates the transcendent vitality of the empire which Menilek constructed.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 11 , Issue 4 , October 1970 , pp. 571 - 589
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1970

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Marcus, H. G., ‘A Preliminary History of the Tripartite Treaty of 13 December 1906’, Journal of Ethiopian Studies, III 4 (1965), passim.Google Scholar

2 F.O. 401/9, Harrington, to Grey, , 29 06 1906.Google Scholar

3 F.O. 401/9, Harrington, to Grey, , 11 09 1906.Google Scholar

4 F.O. 401/9, Harrington, to Grey, , 12 10 1906.Google Scholar

5 SirThomas, Hohier, Diplomatic Petrel (London, 1942), 122, 125, 127, 129, 141, 143.Google Scholar

6 F.O. 401/10, Hohler, to Hardinge, , 20 08 1907.Google Scholar

7 F.O. 401/10, Harrington, to Grey, , 10 09 1907.Google ScholarGrey, to San, Giuliano, Cambon, , Metternich, and Poklewski-Koziell, , 23 09 1907.Google Scholar

8 F.O. 401/10, Hohler, to Grey, , 23 10 1907.Google Scholar

9 F.O. 401/10, Menilek, to Hohler, , 25 10 1907.Google Scholar

10 Barois, M. J., ‘Impressions de Voyage en Abyssinie’, Bull. de l'institut Egyptien, II (12 1908), 36.Google Scholar

11 Guèbrè, Sellasié, Chronique du Règne de Ménélik II (Paris, 1931), II, 527–8Google Scholar

12 Guèbrè, Sellasié, Chronique, II, 531–53.Google Scholar

13 Hohier, , Diplomatic Petrel, 133–7.Google Scholar

14 F.O. 401/11, Hervey, to Grey, , 14 10 1908.Google Scholar

15 Docteur, Merab, Impressions d'ethiopie (Paris, 1922), II, 226.Google Scholar

16 F.O. 401/11, Harrington, to Grey, , 14 06 1908.Google Scholar

17 ‘Faits Divers’, Le Semeur d'ethiopie, 4 (07 1908), 432.Google Scholar

18 F.O. 401/11, Harrington, to Grey, , 13 10 1908.Google Scholar

19 F.O. 401/11, Hervey, to Grey, , 30 10 1908.Google Scholar

20 Marcus, ‘The Tripartite Treaty’, passim.

21 Always a notable exception are those writers whose absurd ethnocultural or racist bias invalidate their reporting. For example see Baroness Löwenkreuz, Emanuela (ed.), In Reiche Kaiser Menileks: Tagebuch einer Abessinischen Reise von Friedrich Freiherrn von Kulmer (Leipzig, n.d.).Google Scholar

22 DrGeorge, Montandon, Au Pays Ghimirra, 1909–11 (Paris, 1913), 21.Google Scholar

23 Dr George, Montandon, ‘A Journey in South-Western Abyssinia’, The Geographical Journal, XL, 4 (10 1912), 383.Google Scholar

24 Rein, G. K., Abessinien, Eine Landeskunde Nach Reisen und Studien in den Jahren 1907–13 (Berlin, 1918), 1, 253.Google Scholar

25 Lagana, G., ‘Abissinia’, L'Africa Italiana, XXXIV, X (10 1915.) 259, 263.Google Scholar

26 Barois, , ‘Impressions’, 34.Google ScholarClifford, Halle, To Menilek in a Motor Car (London, 1913), 262, 267, 268, 269, 274, 300.Google ScholarHenry Savage Landor, A., Across Widest Africa (New York, 1907), 1, 77, 86, 89, 90, 97, 98.Google Scholar

27 George, Rémond: ‘L'Agonie de I'Empereur Ménélik’, Le Correspondent 244 (25 07 1911), 377.Google Scholar

28 Guèbrè, Selassié, Chronique, II, 596.Google Scholar

29 Rémond, , ‘L'Agonie’, 399.Google Scholar

30 F.O. 401/12, Hervey, to Grey, , 02 1909.Google Scholar

31 F.O. 401/12, Rodd, to Grey, , 4 02, 1909.Google Scholar

32 F.O. 408/12, Hervey, to Grey, , 6 02 1909.Google Scholar

33 F.O. 402/12, Count, de Bosdari to Grey, , 8 02 1909.Google Scholar

34 The date of his return is reported differently. See ‘Faits Divers’, Le Semeur d'Ethiopie, 5 (02 1909),Google Scholar and F.O. 401/12, Hervey, to Grey, , 13 02 1909.Google Scholar

35 F.O. 401/12, Count, de Bosdari to Grey, , 23 02 1909Google Scholar and Montandon, , Pays Ghimirra, 40.Google Scholar

36 F.O. 401/12, Count, de Bosdari to Grey, , 23 02 1909.Google Scholar

37 ‘Faits Divers’, Le Semeur d'Ethiopie, 5 (03 1909) 566.Google Scholar

38 Hoffman, Philip, Abyssinian Memories (Santa Barbara, California, 1948) 16–17.Google Scholar

39 F.O. 401/12, Count, de Bosdari to Grey, , 16 03 1909.Google Scholar

40 ‘Faits Divers’, Le Semeur d'Ethiopie, 5 (03 1909) 566.Google Scholar

41 Rémond, , ‘l'Agonie’, 342.Google Scholar

42 F.O. 401/12, Count, de Bosdari to Grey, , 16 03 1909.Google Scholar

43 American Archives, Records of the Department of State relating to the internal affairs of Ethiopia, 1910–29, Memo on current affairs in Addis Ababa by Hoffman Philip, Consul General, to the Asst. Secretary of State, 35 January 1910. Also see Arnaldo, Cipolla, Nell' Impero di Menilek (Milano, 1911) 15.Google Scholar

44 F.O. 403/12, Report on Abyssinia, 1907–8 by Lord, Hervey, 31 12 1908;Google ScholarHervey, to Grey, , 13 02 1909;Google ScholarLagana, , ‘Abissinia’, 263;Google ScholarGuiseppe, Piazza, Alla Corte di Menilek (Ancona, 1912), 165ff.;Google ScholarMontandon, , Pays Ghimirra, 50;Google ScholarMérab, , Impressions, II, 226.Google Scholar

45 F.O. 401/12, Hervey, to Grey, , 13 02 1909Google Scholar and F.O. 403/13, Hervey, to Grey, , 16 07 1909.Google Scholar

46 F.O. 401/12, Rodd, to Grey, , 18 05 1909;Google ScholarPiazza, , Alla Corte, 167.Google Scholar

47 Lagana, , ‘Abissinia’, 264;Google Scholar F.O. 401/14, Thesiger, to Grey, , 25 02 1910.Google Scholar

48 F.O. 401/12, Hervey, to Grey, , 4 06 1909.Google Scholar

49 ‘Faits divers’, SE, 5 (06 1909), 603.Google Scholar

50 See below, p. 583.

51 For the standard and opposite view, see Montandon, , Ghimmira, 59Google Scholar and Merab, , Impressions, II, 288 ff.Google Scholar

52 The sources disagree about the dates. The events may have taken place on 16–18 May.

53 In the Chronicles, Eyyasu is mentioned by name, but the other sources are unanimous that no name was specified.

54 Guèbrè, Sellasié, Chronique, II, 540–2;Google ScholarMérab, , Impressions, II, 65–6;Google ScholarRémond, , ‘l'Agonie’, 340;Google Scholar F.O. 401/12, Hervey, to Grey, , 18 05 1909.Google Scholar

55 Guèbrè, Sellasié, Chronique, II, 542, fn. 4.Google Scholar

56 Rémond, , ‘l'Agonie’, 342.Google Scholar

57 F.O. 401/13, Hervey, to Grey, , 16 07 1909.Google Scholar

58 F.O. 401/13, Hervey, to Grey, , 28 07 1909.Google Scholar

59 She may have been correct about Haili Giorgis, and he may have been acting for Ras Mikail, who would have wanted Taitou out of the way to insure his son's immediate succession, now that Menilek had made a more or less precise public proclamation. Later on, Mikail did rescue Haili Giorgis from the obscurity of disfavour, and he became very important in Lij Eyyasu's government.

60 F.O. 401/13, Hervey, to Grey, , 13 08 1909.Google Scholar

61 Rémond, , ‘l'Agonie’, 345;Google ScholarMérab, , Impressions, 11, 165;Google ScholarGuè;brè, Sellasié, Chronique, 11, 621.Google Scholar

62 F.O. 401/13, San, Giuliano to Grey, , 31 10 1909Google Scholar and Hervey, to Grey, , 5 11 1909.Google Scholar

63 Montandon, , Pays Ghimirra, 40.Google Scholar

64 Rémond, , ‘l'Agonie’, 348.Google Scholar

65 F.O. 401/13, Hervey, to Grey, , 5 11 1909.Google Scholar

66 ‘Faits divers’, Le Semeur d'Ethiopie, 5 (10–11 1909), 674–7.Google Scholar

67 Rémond, , ‘l'Agonie’, 349;Google ScholarMontandon, , Pays Ghimirra, 381.Google Scholar

68 F.O. 401/14, Thesiger, to Grey, , 31 12 1909.Google Scholar

69 Ibid.

70 Mérab, , Impressions, 11, 230.Google Scholar

71 This may indeed have been the case. In 1913 he did attempt to obtain personal power. See chapter IX of my forthcoming book ‘The Life and Times of Menilek II of Ethiopia, 1844–1913’.

72 F.O. 401/14, Thesiger, to Grey, , 25 02 1910.Google Scholar

73 F.O. 401/14, Thesiger, to Grey, , 25 03 1910.Google Scholar

74 American Archives, proclamation by Ras, Tessema, 22 03 1910.Google Scholar

75 Ibid.

76 Mérab, , Impressions, II, 230.Google Scholar

77 American Archives, Love to the Asst. Sec. of State, 24 March 1910.

78 F.O. 401/14, Thesiger, to Grey, , 26 03 1910 and 24 04 1910.Google Scholar

79 A.A., Love to the Asst. Sec. of State, 26 04 1910.Google Scholar

80 A.A., Love to the Asat. Sec. of State, 3 06 1910.Google Scholar

81 Guèbrè, Sellasié, Chronique, II, 623.Google Scholar

82 F.O. 401/15, Thesiger, to Grey, , 16 06 1910.Google Scholar

83 A.A., Love to the Sec. of State, 8 08 1910.Google Scholar

84 A.A., Love to the Asst. Sec. of State, 12 05 1910.Google Scholar

85 A.A., Love to the Asst. Sec. of State, 2706 1910.Google Scholar and F.O. 401/15, Thesiger, to Grey, , 16 06 1910.Google Scholar

86 A.A., Love to the Sec. of State, 8 08 1910.Google Scholar

87 A.A., Love to the Sec. of State, 8 10 1910.Google Scholar and F.O. 401/15, Thesiger, to Grey, , 16 09 1910.Google Scholar

88 A.A., Love to the Sec. of State, 11 11 1910.Google Scholar

89 For the best example, see Mérab, , Impressions, II, 240–2.Google Scholar

90 A.A., Love to the Sec. of State, 27 12 1910.Google Scholar

91 A.A., Love to the Sec. of State, 18 02 1911.Google Scholar

92 A.A., Love to the Sec. of State, 12 12 1911.Google Scholar

93 A.A., Smith, to Sec. of State, 14 01 1914.Google Scholar

94 Mérab, , Impressions, II, 248.Google Scholar

95 F.O. 401/15, Thesiger, to Grey, , 2 12 1910.Google Scholar

96 F.O. 405/55, Thesiger, to Grey, , 9 12 1910.Google Scholar

97 F.O. 403/420, Thesiger, to Grey, , 2 03 1911.Google Scholar

98 Ibid.

99 A.A., Love to the Sec. of State, 12 04 1911.Google Scholar

100 A.A., Love to Sec. of State, 20 03 1911.Google Scholar

101 Mérab, , Impressions, II, 248.Google Scholar

102 F.O. 403/420, Doughty-Wylie, to Grey, , 6 05 1911.Google Scholar

103 A.A., Love to the Sec. of State, 1 06 1911.Google Scholar

104 Montandon, , Pays Ghimirra, 385.Google Scholar