Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-g8jcs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-24T15:25:29.412Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Barotseland's Scramble for Protection

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

Gerald L. Caplan
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The arrival of European concession-seekers in Barotseland coincided with a period of internal instability in that kingdom. King Lewanika, fearing both enemies within the ruling class as well as Ndebele raids, decided to follow the example of his friend Khama of the Ngwato in seeking British protection. With considerable difficulty he prevailed upon a local missionary, François Coillard, to write a letter on his behalf requesting such protection.

It had already become clear that an important faction of the Lozi ruling class opposed the king's decision. Some of its members feared that his ‘protectors’ would make his overthrow that much more difficult; others were concerned that he more powerful white men would undermine the authority of the nation's traditional rulers. These suspicions received apparent confirmation when the representative who appeared to negotiate the concession proved to be an agent, not of Her Majesty's Government, but of the British South African Company. Thanks, however, to the ignorance of the missionaries who were interpreting for the court, as well as to the duplicity of Rhodes's agent himself, this distinction was successfully blurred. Opposition remained, however, until, at a critical moment in the negotiations, Khama's envoy threatened the council with harsh retribution if it refused to sanction the proposed treaty. In the face of this united stand of those who represented the power of the British government and its white associates and black collaborators, the National Council of Barotseland finally agreed to the concession, and, for better or worse, the Lozi found themselves under white ‘protection’.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 10 , Issue 2 , April 1969 , pp. 277 - 294
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1969

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Ranger, T. O., Revolt in Southern Rhodesia, 1896–1897: a Study in African Resistance (London, 1967).Google Scholar

2 Gluckman, Max, ‘The Lozi of Barotseland in North-Western Rhodesia’, in Colson, E. and Gluckman, M., Seven Tribes of British Central Africa (Oxford, 1951);Google ScholarGluckman, , The Ideas in Barotse Jurisprudence (New Haven, 1965), ch. 2.Google Scholar

3 Gluckman, , Essays on Lozi Land and Royal Property (Livingstone, 1943), pp. 13–14; Memorandum on Barotse Representative Indunas by Frank Worthington, 5 June 1908, C.O., African South 899.Google Scholar

4 Omer-Cooper, J. A., The Zulu Aftermath: a Nineteenth Century Revolution in Bantu Africa (London, 1966), pp. 115, 119;Google ScholarBryant, A. T., Olden Times in Zululand and Natal (London, 1929);Google ScholarSmith, E. W., ‘Sebituane and the Makololo’, African Studies, xv, no. 2 (1956), 67.Google Scholar

5 The function of education in Barotseland during the colonial era is a continuing theme of my Ph.D. thesis, ‘A political history of Barotseland, 1878–1965’ (unpublished, University of London, 1968).Google Scholar

6 Brown, Richard, ‘Aspects of the scramble for Matabeleland’, in The Zambesian Past: Studies in Central African History, ed. Stokes, E. and Brown, R. (Manchester, 1966), ch. 4.Google Scholar

7 Coillard, François, Journal, 8 04 1886; Westbeech to Fairbairn, 9 05 1886, National Archives of Rhodesia Historical Manuscripts (hereafter N.A.R. Hist. MSS), Marshall Hole Papers. HO 1, fos. 5–6;Google ScholarJalla, Adolph, The History of the Barotse Nation, 6th ed. (Lusaka, 1961), 44, 50, 52.Google Scholar

8 Westbeech, to Fairbairn, , 9 05 1886, N.A.R. Hist. MSS.Google Scholar

9 Coillard, , Journal, 11 07 1885.Google Scholar

10 Coillard, , Journal, 03 1886 and 23 03 1886; George Westbeech, ‘Part of a Diary’ (Institute for Social Research [Lusaka], Barotseland Historical Manuscripts), p. 8.Google Scholar

11 Coillard, François. On the Threshold of Central Africa (London 1897), 226.Google Scholar

12 Ibid, 221–3.

13 Ibid, 262.

14 diary, William Waddell's, 14 11 1886, N.A.R. Hist. MSS, WA 1/1/3. Waddell was the party's artisan.Google Scholar

15 So Waddell later told Coillard's niece, Catherine Mackintosh, as cited in her Coillard of the Zambesi, 1858–1904 (London, 1907), 381.Google Scholar

16 diary, Waddell's, 14 11 1886, loc. cit.; also Coillard to Mrs Coillard, 14 10 1886, N.A.R. Hist. MSS, Coillard Papers, vol. 2, 1883–1891 (CO 5/1/1/1).Google Scholar

17 Coillard, , Journal 24 06 1885 and 22 01 1887;Google ScholarJalla, L. to Boegner, , 9 09 1889, Paris Missionary Society Archives, Paris (hereafter P.M.S.P.):Google ScholarFavre, Edward, Francois Coillard, 1834–1904, III (3 vols., Paris, 1946), 161.Google Scholar

18 Mackintosh, , Coillard, 372–3.Google Scholar

19 Hall, Richard, Zambia (London, 1965), 63.Google Scholar

20 Westbeech diary, N.A.R. Hist. MSS, WE I, fo. 65.

21 Coillard, , Journal, 20 01 1887,Google Scholar and Coillard, , Threshold, 281.Google Scholar

22 Westbeech, , ‘Part of a Diary’, 45.Google Scholar

23 Coillard, , Threshold, 291.Google Scholar

24 Coillard, , Journal, to 05 1887.Google Scholar

25 Collard, to Boegner, ,? 11 1887, P.M.S.P.Google Scholar

26 Cited in Fraenkel, Peter, Wayaleshi (London, 1959), 110.Google Scholar One of my Lozi informants, Mr I. Njekwa, reported the same fears to me in almost identical words, and Coillard himself learned in 1895 that Induna Nalabutu, leader of the conservative faction in the Kuta, had initially advised people never to shut their eyes during services; Coillard, , Threshold, 599.Google Scholar

27 Oral information from Mr Mupatu, Y., and Memorandum, by Jalla, A., 26 10 1928, National Archives of Zambia (N.A.Z.), KDE, 2/30/0.Google Scholar

28 Coillard, to Jalla, L. and Goy, ,? 12 1891, P.M.S.P.; Coillard, Threshold, 208, 320.Google Scholar

29 Coillard, , Threshold, 329–32; see also Jalla, A. to Harding, Cohn, undated but after Lewanika's death in 1916, in N.A.R. Hist. MSS. C. W. Mackintosh Papers, MA 18/1/4, fos. 2–3.Google Scholar

30 Coillard, . Threshold, 332–3.Google Scholar

31 Coillard, to Jalla, L. and Goy, , ? 12 1891, P.M.S.P.Google Scholar

32 Cited in Hole, H. M., The Making of Rhodesia (London, 1926), 213.Google Scholar

33 Coillard, to Shippard, , 8 01 1889, cited in Baxter, T. W., ‘The Concessions of Northern Rhodesia’, in National Archives of Rhodesia and Nyasaland, Occasional Papers, no. I, 06 1963, p. 4.Google Scholar

34 Coillard, , Journal, 15 04 1889.Google Scholar

35 Coillard, to Boegner, , 20 06 1889, P.M.S.P.Google Scholar

36 diary, Waddell's, 07 1889, N.A.R.Google Scholar

37 Coillard, to Boegner, , 28 06 1889, P.M.S.P.Google Scholar

38 The Ware Concession, 27 June 1889, cited in Baxter, , loc. cit. 5–7.Google Scholar

39 Mr Newo Zaza.

40 Brown, , ‘Aspects of the scramble for Matabeleland’, loc. cit., 70.Google Scholar

41 Khama, to Coillard, and Lewanika, , 17 07 1889, N.A.R. Hist, MSS, Mackintosh Papers, MA 18/4/1, fos. 4–7.Google Scholar

42 Shippard, to Coillard, , 1 09 1889, N.A.R. Hist. MSS, Coillard Papers CO 5/5/I, fos. 13–15.Google Scholar

43 Smith, E. W., ‘The Journal of Andrew Baldwin, pioneer missionary in Northern Rhodesia’ (typescript, 1953, Methodist Missionary Society Archives, London), p. 7.Google Scholar

44 Reported in Coillard, to Mrs Hart, , 28 05, 1890, N.A.R. Hist. MSS, Coillard Papers CO 5/I/sol;I/I, fos. 984–5, and Waddell's Diary, 7 06 1890, N.A.R.Google Scholar

45 Rhodes bought the Ware Concession from Ware's principals, but typically sent Lochner to Barotseland some two or three months before the deal was formally concluded. See Hall, , Zambia, 65.Google Scholar

46 Lochner, to ?, undated, N.A.R. Hist. MSS, Mackintosh Papers, MA 18/4, fo. 32–3.

47 diary, Waddell's, 7 1890, N.A.R.Google Scholar

48 Coillard, to Rev. Smith, 20 07 1890, N.A.R. Hist. MSS, Coillard Papers, CO s/1/1/1, fo. 991.Google Scholar

49 See Jalla, A., Pionniers parmi les Ma-Rotsi (Florence, 1903), 36,Google Scholar and Coillard, to Jameson, , undated, cited in Hall, , Zambia 93.Google Scholar

50 Lochner, to Company, 2 07 1890,Google Scholar reproduced in Maxwell Stamp Associates, A History of the Mineral Rights of Northern Rhodesia, II, (2 vols., typescript, London, 1967), 21.Google Scholar

51 Hepburn, to Coillard, , 22 11 1889, N.A.R. Hist. MSS, Mackintosh Papers, MA 1814, fo. 8–9.Google Scholar

52 Coillard, , Threshold, 385.Google Scholar

53 ‘Of course’, he added, ‘we too shall reap some advantages from these changes, for our postal communications and perhaps also for our supplies’. Coillard, to Hunter, , 12 08 1890, N.A.R. Hist. MSS, Coillard Papers, CO 5/2/1, fos. 62–3.Google Scholar

54 Jalla, A. to Boegner, , 05 1890, P.M.S.P.Google Scholar

55 Coillard, to Jalla, L. and Goy, , ?1891,Google Scholar P.M.S.P. Louis Jalla commented that he had read this statement with ‘great astonishment’ and felt that Coillard ‘had been deceived’ for he himself had lsquo;never believed this’ (Jalla, L. to Boegner, , 18 02 1891).Google Scholar

56 Cited in Mackintosh, , Coillard, 383.Google Scholar

57 Johnston, James, Reality vs. Romance in South Central Africa (London, 1893), 148.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

58 C.O. to F.O., in F.O. 403, vol. 557, no. 169.

59 Hole, , Making of Rhodesia, 257;Google Scholar also Lockhart, J. G. and Woodhouse, C. M., Rhodes (London, 1963), 239.Google Scholar

60 Coillard, to Boegner, , 25 06 1890, P.M.S.P.Google Scholar

61 According to Andrew Baldwin, a Methodist missionary who saw the documents; see Smith, ,‘Journal of Baldwin’, 8–9. No copy of the original Sesuto version of the concession seems extant.Google Scholar

62 Mr N. Simalumba, a schoolmaster and evangelist near Senanga, and an amateur historian.

63 Lochner, to Harris, , 23 04 1890, N.A.R. Hist. MSS, Mackintosh Papers, MA 18/4, fo. 28.Google Scholar

64 Lochner, to Company, 2 07 1890, N.A.R. HC 3/3/1, and Coillard, to Rhodes, , ?1890, N.A.R. Hist. MSS, Mackintosh Papers 18/4, fo. 28.Google Scholar

65 So Jalla, Adolph recalled in a letter written m 1903, cited in Report of the Commission appointed to examine…relations of the Paramount Chief of the Barotse Nation and the Chiefs resident in the Balovale District.… (Lusaka, 1939), 51.Google Scholar

66 Jalla, , Pionniers parmi les Ma-Rotsi, 39.Google Scholar

67 Mackintosh, , Coillard, 385.Google Scholar

68 Cited in Coillard, , Threshold, 388.Google Scholar

69 Cited in Hall, , Zambia, 69, but no source is recorded.Google Scholar

70 Mr N. Zaza agreed, though it should be pointed out that he had read Miss Mackintosh's biography of Coillard.

71 Lochner, to Company, 2 07 1890,Google Scholar reproduced in Maxwell Stamp Associates, op. cit., II, 21.Google Scholar

72 Cited in full in Baxter, , ‘Concessions of Northern Rhodesia’, loc. cit. 8–10.Google Scholar

73 ‘The frontiers of the Barotse Kingdom as defined in a Council by the king Lewanika, his councillors and the principal Headmen of the Nation, held at Lealui, , 25 06 1890,Google Scholar as recorded by F. Coillard', reproduced in Maxwell Stamp Associates, op. cit. II, 24–6.Google Scholar

74 ‘“See how things grow,” said Rhodes gleefully when the news of the treaty was brought to him’ (Lockhart, and Woodhouse, , Rhodes, 239–40).Google Scholar

75 See, for example, the agreements with Kazembe of the Lunda and Nsame of the Itawa branch of the Bemba, in Baxter, , op. cit. 35–7.Google Scholar

76 Ibid. 9.

77 See my Ph.D. thesis, op. cit., chapters 4 and 5, and Eric Stokes, ‘Barotseland: the survival of an African state’, in Stokes and Brown (eds.), The Zambesian Past.

78 Mr N. Zaza.

79 Stokes, , op. cit. p. 261.Google Scholar

80 Gann, L. H., A History of Northern Rhodesia: Early Days to 1953 (London, 1964), 21.Google Scholar

81 Lochner freely acknowledged that ‘the Company owes as much, if not more, to M. Coillard than myself in having secured the Barotse country—he is heart and soul with the Company’. Lochner, to Company, 30 07 1890, N.A.R. Hist. MSS, Mackintosh Papers, MA 18/4, folio 34. Adolph JaIls concurred that ‘Without Coillard, the King would never have agreed to the treaty’Google Scholar (Jalla, to Boegner, , 5 07 1890, P.M.S.P.).Google Scholar

82 And which, thanks to the lessons of the Boer War as well as several shows of force by Company officials in Barotseland, the Lozi rulers retained until the late 1920s. By that stage, they had come to adopt other tribal rulers in Northern Rhodesia rather than Europeans as their reference groups, and reconciled themselves to the fact that, if their status was hardly like that of former days, it was at least superior to that of most other Africans in the territory. (See my Ph.D. thesis, op. cit., ch. 6.)

83 Brown, , ‘Aspects of the scramble for Matabeleland’, loc. cit. 88–90.Google Scholar