Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2brh9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T18:15:01.377Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Joseph Lancaster's Monitorial System of Instruction and American Indian Education, 1815–1838

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 February 2017

Ronald Rayman
Ronald Rayman*
Affiliation:
The Reference Department of the Western Illinois University Libraries
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

From the beginning of white settlement in America, Indian relations presented a major dilemma. The fate of American Indians, confronted as they were with the inexorable, dispossessing creep of white settlement, became a source of white concern. With the exception of a small handful of individuals, that concern was manifested not in a sense of basic human equality, but rather as an expression of white elitism and expansionist expediency. This perplexing dilemma was often referred to as the “Indian question,” as it posed an outwardly simple, yet deceptively complex question: What do we do with the Indians?

Type
Articles
Information
History of Education Quarterly , Volume 21 , Issue 4 , Winter 1981 , pp. 395 - 409
Copyright
Copyright © 1981 by History of Education Society 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1. Berkhofer, Robert F. Jr., Salvation and the Savage: An Analysis of Protestant Missions and Indian Response, 1787–1862 (Lexington, 1965), pp. 11–12.Google Scholar

2. Havighurst, R. J., “Education Among American Indians: Individual and Cultural Aspects,” American Academy of Political and Social Science Annals 311 (May, 1957): 107; McNickle, D'Arcy, “Indian and European: Indian-White Relations From Discovery to 1887,” American Academy of Political and Social Science Annals 311 (May, 1957): 2–3; and Vogt, Evan Z., “The Acculturation of American Indians,” American Academy of Political and Social Science Annals 311 (May, 1957): 137–138.Google Scholar

3. Berkhofer, , Salvation and the Savage, pp. 5–6, footnote 10; and Berry, Brewton, “The Histories of American Indian Education,” The American Indian Reader: Education , ed. Henry, Jeannette (San Francisco, 1972), p. 29.Google Scholar

4. Morris, Harold W., “History of Indian Education in the United States,” (Ph.D. dissertation, Oregon State University, 1954), p. 19; and Thompson, Hildegard, “Education Among American Indians: Institutional Aspects,” American Academy of Political and Social Science Annals 311 (May, 1957): 96–97.Google Scholar

5. Hammerer, John Daniel, “An Account of a Plan for Civilizing the North American Indians,” New England Historical and Genealogical Register 11 (October, 1857): 293–294; and Knepler, Abraham E., “Eighteenth Century Cherokee Educational Efforts,” Chronicles of Oklahoma 20 (March, 1942): 56–58.Google Scholar

6. Berry, , “The Histories of American Indian Education,” pp. 34–36; Layman, Martha Elizabeth, “A History of Indian Education in the United States,” (Ph.D. dissertation, University of Minnesota, 1942), p. 110; and Viola, Herman J., “From Civilization to Removal: Early American Indian Policy,” in Indian- White Relations: A Persistent Paradox , ed. Smith, Jane F. and Kvasnicka, Robert M. (Washington, D. C., 1976), pp. 50–51.Google Scholar

7. Berry, , ibid.; and Layman, , ibid. Google Scholar

8. Lancaster, Joseph, Improvements in Education, As It Respects the Industrious Classes of the Community, 3rd ed. (London: 1805), p. 6.Google Scholar

9. Dictionary of National Biography, s.v. “Lancaster, Joseph.” Google Scholar

10. Ibid.; and Salmon, David, ed., The Practical Parts of Lancaster's Improvements and Bell's Experiment (Cambridge: 1932), p. viii.Google Scholar

11. Balyeat, Frank A., “Arthur Grant Evans,” Chronicles of Oklahoma 38 (Autumn, 1960): 245; Berkhofer, , Salvation and the Savage, pp. 26–27, 41–42; Burston, W. H., “Utilitarians and the Monitorial System of Teaching,” Year Book of Education (1957): 383–385, 404, Kaestle, Carl F., comp., Joseph Lancaster and the Monitorial School Movement: A Documentary History (New York: 1973), pp. 4–17; Lancaster, Joseph, The British System of Education: Being a Complete Epitome of the Improvements and Inventions Practised By Joseph Lancaster (Georgetown Washington, 1812), pp. 5, 11–13, 97; Lancaster, , Improvements in Education, pp. 5–12, 40, 51, 56–57; Salmon, , ed., The Practical Parts of Lancaster's Improvements, pp. vii–xxii, 1–3, 12, 34–35, 42–55; Layman, , “A History of Indian Education in the United States,” p. 234, footnote 19; and Viola, Herman J., Thomas L. McKenney: Architect of America's Early Indian Policy, 1816–1830 (Chicago: 1974), p. 33.Google Scholar

12. Kaestle, , comp., Joseph Lancaster and the Monitorial School Movement, p. 34; McCadden, Joseph J., “Joseph Lancaster in America,” Social Studies 28 (1937): 73–74; and Reigart, John Franklin, The Lancasterian System of Instruction in the Schools of New York City (New York 1969), pp. 94–95.Google Scholar

13. Anderson, Rufus, Memorial Volume of the First Fifty Years of the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions (Boston 1861), pp. 322, 350; Beaver, Robert Pierce, Church, State, and the American Indians: Two and a Half Centuries of Partnership Between Protestant Churches and Government (St. Louis, 1966), pp. 62–79; Beaver, Robert Pierce, ed., Pioneers in Missions: The Early Missionary Ordination Sermons, Charges, and Instructions (Grand Rapids, Michigan: 1966), p. 8; Berkhofer, , Salvation and the Savage, pp. 4–5; Walker, Mary, “Archives of the American Board for Foreign Missions,” Harvard Library Bulletin 6 (Winter, 1952): 52, 58; and American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions Annual Report (1810–1815), pp. 1–114; (1815), p. 117; and (1816), pp. 128, 134–136; hereafter cited as ABCFM Annual Report .Google Scholar

14. ABCFM Annual Report (1816), ibid.Google Scholar

15. ABCFM Annual Report (1817), pp. 153–157; letter of Kingsbury, Reverend Cyrus to Calhoun, John C., May 15, 1818, National Archives, Record Group 75, Bureau of Indian Affairs, Letters Received 1800–1823, M271, Roll 2, frames 716–721: hereafter cited as M271/roll number/ frame number(s), i.e. M271/2/716–721; Allen, Penelope Johnson, “Brainerd Mission,” Daughters of the American Revolution Magazine 68 (June, 1934): 347; Morse, Jedidiah, A Report to the Secretary of War of The United States, Comprising a Narrative of a Tour Performed in the Summer of 1820, Under a Commission from the President of the United States, For the Purpose of Ascertaining the Actual State of the Indian Tribes in Our Country (New Haven, 1822), pp. 159–160, 171; and Williams, Samuel C., “Christian Missions to the Overhill Cherokees,” Chronicles of Oklahoma 12 (1934): 70.Google Scholar

16. Letter of William Crawford to Cyrus Kingsbury, May 14, 1816, National Archives, Record Group 75, Bureau of Indian Affairs, Letters Sent Relating to Indian Affairs 1800–1824, M15, Roll 5, pp. 349–350; hereafter cited as M15/roll number/page number(s), i.e. M15/5/349–350.Google Scholar

17. Kingsbury, Cyrus to Calhoun, John C., May 15, 1818, M271/2/716–721; and Viola, , Thomas L. McKenney, p. 33.Google Scholar

18. Kingsbury, to Calhoun, , ibid. Google Scholar

19. Anderson, Isaac [et al] to ABCFM Prudential Board, ABCFM Papers, Houghton Library, Harvard University, Cherokee Mission, v. 2, no. 109, 1818: hereafter cited as ABCFM Papers.Google Scholar

20. Hoyt, Ardt to Evarts, Jeremiah, July 23, 1819, ABCFM Papers, Cherokee Mission, v. 3, no. 44; and Hoyt, to Evans, , May 11, 1820, ABCFM Papers, Cherokee Mission, v. 3, no. 58.Google Scholar

21. Calhoun, John C. to [?], January 15, 1820, American State Papers: Indian Affairs, 2:200–201 Google Scholar

22. ABCFM Annual Report (1820), p. 313; Kingsbury, Cyrus to Calhoun, John C., December 21, 1829, M271/3/392–404; Morse, , A Report, p. 188; and Bartlett, S. C., Historical Sketch of the Missions of the American Board Among the North American Indians (Boston, 1861), p. 5.Google Scholar

23. ABCFM Annual Report (1820), p. 295.Google Scholar

24. ABCFM Annual Report (1819), p. 240; Journal of the Brainerd Mission, entries for May 27 and 28, 1819, ABCFM Papers, Cherokee Mission, v. 2; Allen, , “Brainerd Mission,” 348; and Walker, Robert S., Torchlights to the Cherokees: Brainerd Mission (New York, 1931), pp. 98–99.Google Scholar

25. Binns, Henry Bryan, A Century of Education: Being the Centennial History of the British and Foreign Schools Society, 1808–1908 (London:, 1908), p. 69; McCadden, , “Joseph Lancaster in America,” 74–75; and Reigart, , The Lancasterian System, pp. 18–20.Google Scholar

26. Lancaster, Joseph, Letters on National Subjects, Auxiliary to Universal Education, and Scientific Knowledge (Washington City [D.C.], 1820), pp. 35–42.Google Scholar

27. Calhoun, John C. to Lancaster, Joseph, March 13, 1820, M15/4/426–427. Lancaster's money woes never improved. In late 1823 or early 1824, Lancaster wrote President John Quincy Adams twice, complaining of his impecunious condition. Obviously piqued at Lancaster's forwardness, crusty Adams sent Lancaster five dollars, saying “…now find this a five dollar bill to relieve thy pressing necessities.” Letter of Adams to Lancaster, January 24, 1824, Houghton Library Manuscripts Collection, Harvard University.Google Scholar

28. ABCFM Annual Report (1820), pp. 283–284; ABCFM Annual Report (1821), pp. 199–200; and Extract of Superintendent's Report of October 1, 1821, in American State Papers; Indian Affairs, 2:278.Google Scholar

29. Kingsbury, to Calhoun, , December 21, 1820, M271/3/392–404; Kingsbury, to Calhoun, , June 5, 1822, M271/4/154–156; Kingsbury, to Calhoun, , October 4, 1822, M271/4/159–161; Kingsbury, to Calhoun, , November 22, 1822, M271/4/163–166; and Kingsbury, to Cornelius, Elias, June 20, 1822, ABCFM Papers, Choctaw Mission, v. 3, no. 57.Google Scholar

30. Tracy, Joseph, History of the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missionaries (Worcester MA, 1840), p. 92.Google Scholar

31. Morse, , A Report, pp. 173–174; and Kingsbury, to Calhoun, , October 30, 1823, M271/4/711–714.Google Scholar

32. ABCFM to Congress (1824), 18 Cong., 1 sess., serial 97, House Documents, no. 102, pp. 3–8; Report of the Commissioner of Indian Affairs, March 23, 1824, 18 Cong., 1 sess., serial 106, House Reports, no. 92, pp. 1, 6–7; and McKenney, Thomas L. to Barbour, , December 13, 1825, 19 Cong., 1 sess., serial 135, House Documents, no. 1, p. 16. Federal expenditures for Indian education never accounted for a signifcant portion of annual expenditures for overall Indian affairs. For example, educational expenses totalled only $12,708 of the 1824 budget of $425,000 (3% of the total). A modest increase to $13,620 occurred in 1825, but the entire budget for Indian affairs jumped to $671,000, reducing educational expenditures to 2% of the total spent: 19 Cong., 1 sess., serial 142, House Reports, no. 226, pp. 5–6.Google Scholar

33. ABCFM Missionary Papers , no. 12 (1829), p. 1; ABCFM Missionary Papers, no. 13 (1830), pp. 1–4; ABCFM Annual Report (1835), p. 88; and ABCFM Annual Report (1838), pp. 120–121.Google Scholar

34. Berkhofer, , Salvation and the Savage, pp. 28–29; and McMillan, Ethel, “First National Indian School; The Choctaw Academy,” Chronicles of Oklahoma 28 (Spring, 1950): 52–62.Google Scholar

35. Johnson, to McKenney, , October 28, 1825, National Archives, Record Group 75, Bureau of Indian Affairs, Letters Received Relating to Indian Affairs 1824–1881, M234, Roll 772, frames 541–544: hereafter cited as M234/roll number/frame number(s); and Meyer, Leland Winfield, The Life and Times of Colonel Richard M. Johnson of Kentucky (New York: 1932), pp. 357–359.Google Scholar

36. Johnson, to Henderson, Thomas, January 9, 1828, in Johnson, Richard M., “Two Letters, 1828, Pertaining to Johnson's, Colonel Richard M. Choctaw Indian School in Scott County,” Filson Club History Quarterly 9 (October, 1935): 245–246; Layman, , “A History of Indian Education in the United States,” p. 327; and Meyer, , ibid., pp. 369–370.Google Scholar

37. Ould, Robert to McKenney, , June 28, 1828, M234/773/1196.Google Scholar

38. Johnson, Richard M. to Secretary of War Peter Porter, July 24, 1828, M234/773/1081; Johnson, to McKenney, , July 25, 1828, M234/773/1084; Henderson, Thomas to Porter, , August 1, 1828, M234/773/1010–1015; Trustees of the Choctaw Academy to Porter, August, 1828, M234/773/1088; and Secretary of War John Eaton's remarks on Choctaw education, March 25, 1830, 21 Cong., 1 sess., serial 193, Senate Documents, no. 110, p. 3.Google Scholar

39. Henderson, to Eaton, , October 31, 1830, M234/774/401; Report of the Trustees of the Choctaw Academy, January, 1831, M234/775/222; and Henderson to Secretary of War Lewis Cass, April 30, 1832, M234/775/516.Google Scholar

40. 22 Cong., 1 sess., serial 220, House Documents, no. 194, p. 14.Google Scholar

41. List of Students, Choctaw Academy, August 1, 1832, M234/775/767.Google Scholar

42. Bourassa, Joseph to Grover, General N. D., February 20, 1833, M234/776/33; Bourassa, to Cass, , February 21, 1833, M234/776/37; and Bourassa to Commissioner of Indian Affairs Elbert Herring, April 18, 1833, M234/776/42.Google Scholar

43. Henderson, to Herring, , April 18, 1833, M234/776/188; and Henderson, to Cass, , November 1, 1833, M234/776/232.Google Scholar

44. Henderson School Reports of February 1, 1834, and May 1, 1834, M234/776/736, 743; and Report of Inspectors of the Choctaw Academy, November 1, 1835, M234/777/291.Google Scholar

45. Fox, George E., “The Choctaw Academy: An Experiment in Indian Education,” (: George Washington University, 1943), pp. 110–111, 119, and Berkhofer, , Salvation and the Savage, p. 29.Google Scholar

46. Binns, , A Century of Education, p. 7; McCadden, , “Joseph Lancaster in America,” 76; Reigart, , The Lancasterian System, p. 22; and Niles' National Register 55 (November 3, 1838), p. 146.Google Scholar

47. ABCFM Annual Report (1843), pp. 165–166; and ABCFM Annual Report (1846), p. 200.Google Scholar

48. Kaestle, , comp., Joseph Lancaster and the Monitorial School Movement, pp. 37, 43–48; and Reigart, , The Lancasterian System, pp. 95–97.Google Scholar

49. Berkhofer, , Salvation and the Savage, pp. 37–38; Cotterill, R. S., The Southern Tribes: The Story of the Civilized Tribes Before Removal (Norman: 1954), pp. 228–230; Knight, Edgar W., “An Early Educational Fad in the South,” High School Journal 31 (March–April, 1948): 60; and Phillips, Clifton Jackson, Protestant America and the Pagan World: The First Half-century of the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions, 1810–1860 (Cambridge MA. 1969), pp. 86–87.Google Scholar