A new first-order asymptotic theory for
heteroskedasticity-autocorrelation (HAC) robust tests based on
nonparametric covariance matrix estimators is developed. The bandwidth of
the covariance matrix estimator is modeled as a fixed proportion of the
sample size. This leads to a distribution theory for HAC robust tests that
explicitly captures the choice of bandwidth and kernel. This contrasts
with the traditional asymptotics (where the bandwidth increases more
slowly than the sample size) where the asymptotic distributions of HAC
robust tests do not depend on the bandwidth or kernel. Finite-sample
simulations show that the new approach is more accurate than the
traditional asymptotics. The impact of bandwidth and kernel choice on size
and power of t-tests is analyzed. Smaller bandwidths lead to
tests with higher power but greater size distortions, and large bandwidths
lead to tests with lower power but smaller size distortions. Size
distortions across bandwidths increase as the serial correlation in the
data becomes stronger. Overall, the results clearly indicate that for
bandwidth and kernel choice there is a trade-off between size distortions
and power. Finite-sample performance using the new asymptotics is
comparable to the bootstrap, which suggests that the asymptotic theory in
this paper could be useful in understanding the theoretical properties of
the bootstrap when applied to HAC robust tests.We thank an editor and a referee for constructive comments on
a previous version of the paper. Helpful comments provided by Cliff
Hurvich, Andy Levin, Jeff Simonoff, and seminar participants at NYU
(Statistics), U. Texas Austin, Yale, U. Montreal, UCSD, UC Riverside, UC
Berkeley, U. of Pittsburgh, SUNY Albany, U. Aarhus, Brown U., NBER/NSF
Time Series Conference, and 2003 Winter Meetings of the Econometrics
Society are gratefully acknowledged. We gratefully acknowledge financial
support from the National Science Foundation through grant SES-0095211. We
thank the Center for Analytic Economics at Cornell
University.