This paper analyzes similar tests for structural change for
the normal linear regression model in finite samples. Using
the approach of Wald (1943, American Mathematical Society
Transactions 54, 426–482), Hillier (1987,
Econometric Theory 3, 1–44), Andrews and Ploberger
(1994, Econometrica 62, 1382–1414), and Andrews,
Lee, and Ploberger (1996, Journal of Econometrics 70,
9–36), we characterize a class of optimal similar tests
for the existence of (possibly multiple) changepoints at unknown
times. We extend the analysis of Andrews et al. (1996) by deriving
weighted optimal similar tests for the case where the error
variance is not known. We also show that when the sample size
is large, the tests of Andrews et al. constructed by replacing
the error variance with an estimate are equivalent to the optimal
test derived in this paper. Power comparisons are provided by
a small simulation study.