Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-lnqnp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T08:38:41.098Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

English Law and the European Ius Commune 1450–1650

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 October 2017

David Ibbetson
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Sometime around the year 1469, Giovanni Andrea, the Papal Librarian at the Vatican, noted that the Middle Ages were at an end and the modern world had just begun. From his standpoint at the intellectual centre of Christendom, a major transition was occurring.

All across Europe, Law, too, was in a state of transition at this time. We may take as our starting point an early piece of evidence of these changes which comes from the Southern Netherlands. It comes from the small village of St Peters, a village in which legal disputes were decided by local alderman, men who had had no formal legal training but who were very experienced in applying the customary law of the area. An issue had arisen whether a legal right of way had been gained by long use.

Type
Research Article
Information
Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies , Volume 8 , 2006 , pp. 115 - 132
Copyright
Copyright © Centre for European Legal Studies, Faculty of Law, University of Cambridge 2006

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 LeGoff, J The Medieval Imagination (trans A Goldhammer, Chicago, Chicago University Press, 1988) 18 Google Scholar.

2 Van Caenegem, R ‘Bookish Law and Customary Law: Roman Law in the Southern Netherlands in the Late Middle Ages’ in van Caenegem, R, Law, History, the Low Countries and Europe (London, Hambledon Press, 1994)Google Scholar.

3 Ibid at 130.

4 Płaza, S Historia Prawa w Polsce na tle Porównawczym vol 1 (Cracow, Ksiegarnia Akademicka, 2002) 139–144, 168-9Google Scholar; Urusczak, W ‘Essais de Codification du Droit Polonais dans la Première Moitié du XVIe Siècle’ (1981) 59 Revue Historique de Droit Français et Etranger 419 Google Scholar; Bónis, G Einflüsse Des Römischen Rechts in Ungarn (Ius Romanum Medii Aevi vol 10) (Milan, Giuffrè 1964)Google Scholar; Wieacker, F History of Private Law in Europe: With Particular Reference to Germany (Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1995) 71-90Google Scholar; Piano Mortari, V Diritto Romano e Diritto Nazionale in Francia nel Secolo XVI (Milan, Giuffrè, 1962) 19–46Google Scholar; Cairns, J ‘The Civil Law Tradition in Scottish Legal Thought’ in Carey-Miller, D and Zimmermann, R (eds) The Civilian Tradition and Scots Law (Berlin, Duncker and Humblot, 1997)Google Scholar.

5 Wieacker, F, above n 4, 95.

6 Bellomo, M The Common Legal Past of Europe, 1000-1800 (Washington, DC, Catholic University of America Press, 1995) 78–96Google Scholar.

7 Classen, P Studium und Gesellschaft im Mittelalter (Stuttgart, Hiersemann, 1983), 94, 84 Google Scholar.

8 Ourliac, P and Gazzaniga, J-L Histoire du Droit Privé Français: de l’an mil au code civil (Paris, Albin Michel, 1985) 121–143 Google Scholar; Tomás, y Valiente, F Manual de Historia del Derecho Español (Madrid, Tecnos, 1997) 205–262 Google Scholar.

9 Barton, J Roman Law in England (Ius Romanum Medii Aevi, vol 13a) (Milan, Giuffré, 1971), 25–28Google Scholar; Baker, J An Introduction to English Legal History 4th edn (London, Butterworths, 2002) 27–29Google Scholar.

10 Lévy, J-P and Castaldo, A Histoire du Droit Civil (Paris, 2002) 6–7Google Scholar.

11 Ibbetson, D Common Law and Ius Commune (London, Selden Society, 2001)Google Scholar; Tamm, D ‘The Danes and their Legal Heritage’ in Dahl, B Melchior, T et al (eds) Danish Law in a European Perspective (Copenhagen, GadJura, 1996) 33, 38–40Google Scholar.

12 Wieacker, F, above n 4, 91–155.

13 Van Caenegem, R above n 2, 119.

14 Baker, J ‘English Law and the Renaissance’ (1985) 44 CLJ 46 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

15 Eisenstein, E The Printing Press as an Agent of Change: Communications and Cultural Transformations in Early-Modern Europe (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1980)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

16 Baker, J The Law’s Two Bodies: Some Evidential Problems in English Legal History (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2001) 59–90CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

17 Sharington v Strotton (1565) Plo 298, 305, 75 ER 454.

18 Wijffels, A Qui Millies Allegatur: Les Allegations du Droit Savant dans les Dossiers du Grand Conseil de Malines (Leiden, Brill, 1985)Google Scholar.

19 Ibid at 109–162.

20 Ibid at 165–202.

21 Ibid at 202–282.

22 For a different reading of the evidence, see Osler, D ‘The Myth of European Legal History’ (1997) 16 Rechtshistorisches Journal 393 Google Scholar.

23 Wijffels, A ‘Sir Julius Caesar’s Notes on Admiralty Cases: An Alternative to Law Reporting?’ in Stebbings, C (ed) Law Reporting in Britain (London, Hambledon Press, 1995)Google Scholar.

24 Ibid at 106, editing a text from British Library Lansdowne Manuscripts. 132.

25 Tursanus, F Receptae Sententiae, sive ut nunc loquuntur, Communium Opinionum Iurisconsultorum Utriusque Iuris.

26 Alciatus, A De Presumptionibus.

27 Alciatus, A Responsa.

28 Cephalus, J Consilia sive Responsa Iuris.

29 de Mayno, J In Primam (Secundam) Digesti Novi partem Commentaria; A Tartagnus de Imola, Consilia.

30 Rebuffus, P In Titulos Digestorum De Verborum et Rerum Significatione Commentaria.

31 Fulgosius, R In Domini Iustiniani Codicem Commentaria.

32 Menochius, J Consilia sive Responsa.

33 Wijffels, A, Ibbetson, D ‘The Techniques of Judicial Records and Law Reports’ in Wijffels, A (ed) Case Law in the Making: the Techniques and Methods of Judicial Records and Law Reports (Berlin, Duncker and Humblot, 1997) 33-35Google Scholar.

34 Mynsinger, I Singularium Observationum Iudicii Imperialis Camerae, uti vocant, Centuriae Quatuor (Venice, 1563)Google Scholar.

35 Wijffels, A Qui Millies Allegatur: Les Allegations du Droit Savant dans les Dossiers du Grand Conseil de Malines (Leiden, Brill, 1985) 202–282 Google Scholar.

36 Ruiz de Moros, P Decisiones de Rebus in Sacro Auditorio Lituanico ex Appellatione Judicatis (Cracow, 1563)Google Scholar.

37 Riccius, J Collectanea Decisionum (Rome, 1617)Google Scholar.

38 Gilissen, J Introduction Historique au Droit (Brussels, Bruylant, 1979) 258-65Google Scholar.

39 De Covurruvias, D Relectio c Quamvis Pactum de Pactis in VI II.4.25 in Opera Omnia (Cologne 1679)Google Scholar, 1.403, and Variarum Resolutionum I.14.13 in Opera Omnia 2.89.

40 De Albornoz, B Arte de los Contractos I.2.8 (f.4v) (Valencia, 1573)Google Scholar.

41 Mornacius, A Observationes in Quatuor Priores Libros Codicis (Paris, 1654)Google Scholar C.4.27.1 and C.4.50.6.

42 Inleidinge tot de Hollandsche Rechts-geleerdheid, 3.3.38 (Haarlem, 1631); De Iure Belli ac Pacis, 2.11.18 (Paris, 1625) (here with influence from Spain).

43 Dalrymple, J, Viscont Stair The Institutions of the Law of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1681)Google Scholar 1.10.5.

44 Coke, E The Second Part of the Institutes of the Lawes of England (London, 1642)Google Scholar, Proeme.

45 Cardon, H Syntagma Communium Opinionum sive receptarum sex sententiarum ad instar codicis Justiniani in titulos redactum (Lyons, 1608), Praefatio, § 7 Google Scholar.

46 Quoted in Kelley, D Foundations of Modern Historical Scholarship: Language, Law and History in the French Renaissance (New York, Columbia University Press, 1970) 100 Google Scholar.

47 C.7.45.13.

48 Tomás, y Valiente, F Manual de Historia del Derecho Español 4th edn (Madrid, Tecnos, 1997) 318 Google Scholar.

49 Wieacker, F, above n 4, 125–6; Zimmermann, R ‘Romisch-holländsches Recht—ein Überblick’ in Zimmermann, R and Feenstra, R (eds) Das Römisch-Holländische Recht (Berlin, Duncker and Humblot, 1992)Google Scholar.

50 Wieacker, F, above n 4, 159–175.

51 Lombardi, L Saggio sul Diritto Giurisprudenziale (Milan, Giuffrè, 1967) 124–199 Google Scholar.

52 Connected to this is the production of general principles through Natural law thinking in the seventeenth century, though this was (at least in theory) independent of Roman law.

53 Dawson, J Oracles of the Law (Ann Arbor, Mich University of Michigan Law School, 1968) 316-31Google Scholar. The trend is unmistakeable in the early seventeenth century: Louet, G Recueil de Plusieurs Arrests Notables du Parlement de Paris (Paris, 1644)Google Scholar.

54 I give examples in Ibbetson, D, above n 11.

55 Muratori, L Dei Difetti della Giurisprudenza (Venice, 1742)Google Scholar; Falaschi, P Il Problema della Certezza del Diritti nel Trattato ‘Dei Difette della Giurisprudenza’ di L.A. Muratori (Milan, Università degli Studi di Camerino, 1963)Google Scholar.