Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-gb8f7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-29T17:53:29.832Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Managers as Judges in Employee Disputes: An Occasion for Moral Imagination

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 January 2015

Dennis J. Moberg
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract:

Employee-employee conflicts are common occasions for managerial intervention. In judging such disputes, managers bring to encounters a frame that is not conducive to employee due process. Making managers aware of their legal responsibilities in resolving employee disputes is a poor substitute for managers’ understanding and implementation of their ethical due process obligations. Moreover, moral imagination is necessary in order to counter the effects of the managerial frame that employees are either not worthy of due process protections or that such protections are not a priority.

Type
Articles
Information
Business Ethics Quarterly , Volume 13 , Issue 4 , October 2003 , pp. 453 - 477
Copyright
Copyright © Society for Business Ethics 2003

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abbott, A. 1988. The system of professions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Adelman, H. 1991. Morality and ethics in organizational administration. Journal of Business Ethics 12: 665–678.Google Scholar
Aram, J. D., and Salipante, P. F.. 1981. An evaluation of organizational due process in the resolution of employee/employer conflict. Academy of Management Review 6: 197–204.Google Scholar
Arnold, J. A., and O’Connor, K. M.. 1999. Ombudspersons or peers? The effect of third-party expertise and recommendations on negotiation. Journal of Applied Psychology 84: 776–785.Google Scholar
Badaracco, J. R. 2002. Leading quietly: An unorthodox guide to doing the right thing. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.Google Scholar
Baier, A. C. 1986. Trust and antitrust. Ethics 96: 231–260.Google Scholar
Baier, A. C.. 1994. Moral prejudices. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Ballard, M. 2001. In uneasy times, HR reviews is peacekeeping mission. Workforce 89(11): 38–41.Google Scholar
Bandura, A. 1990. Selective activation and disengagement of moral control. Journal of Social Issues 46: 27–46.Google Scholar
Barnard, C. I. 1938. The functions of the executive. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Bateson, G. 1972. Steps to the ecology of the mind. San Francisco: Chandler.Google Scholar
Batson, C. D., Polycarpou, M. P.Harmon-Jones, E.Imhoff, H. J.Mitchener, E. C.Bednar, L. L.Klein, T. R. and Highberger, L.. 1997. Empathy and attitudes: Can feeling for a member of a stigmatized group improve feelings toward the group? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 72: 105–118.Google Scholar
Baumeister, R. F., and Newman, L. S.. 1994. Self-regulation of cognitive inference and decision processes. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 20: 3–19.Google Scholar
Bowie, N. E. 1999. Business ethics: A Kantian perspective. Malden, Mass.: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Brady, F. N., and Dunn, C. P.. 1995. Business meta-ethics. Business Ethics Quarterly 5: 385–398.Google Scholar
Brenner, L. A., Koehler, D. J., and Tversky, A.. 1996. On the evaluation of one-sided evidence. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 9: 59–70.Google Scholar
Bresler, S. 2001. ADR: One company’s answer to settling employee disputes. HRFocus 77(9): 3–5.Google Scholar
Brown, L. D. 1992. Normative conflict management theories: Past, present, and future. Journal of Organizational Behavior 13: 303–309.Google Scholar
Bullying behaviors: How security should respond. 2001. Security Director’s Report 1: 11–13.Google Scholar
Capozoli, T. K., and McVey, R. S.. 1996. Managing violence in the workplace. Delray Beach, Fla.: St. Lucie Press.Google Scholar
Caudron, S. 1997. Blow the whistle on employment disputes. Workforce 76(5): 31–33.Google Scholar
Caudron, S.. 1998. Keeping team conflict alive. Training & Development 52(9): 48–52.Google Scholar
Ceniceros, R. 1999. Caution urged in investigations by employers. Business Insurance 33 (January 25): 19.Google Scholar
Ceniceros, R.. 2001 Measure against supervisory harassment don’t limit employer liability; California strikes use of federal defense. Business Insurance 35 (December 10): 2.Google Scholar
Chappel, D. 1998. Violence at work. Geneva: International Labour Office.Google Scholar
Clements, R. E. 1988. Solomon and the origins of wisdom in Israel. Perspectives in Religious Studies 15: 23–35.Google Scholar
Condon, T. J., and Wolf, R. H.. 1985. Procedures that safeguard your right to fire. Harvard Business Review 63(6): 16–23.Google Scholar
Conte, A. 1996. When the tables are turned: Courts consider suits by alleged sexual harassers. Trial 32(3): 30–35.Google Scholar
Dana, D. 2001. Conflict resolution: Mediation tools for everyday life. New York: McGraw-Hill.Google Scholar
Des Jardins, J. 1985. Fairness and employment at will. Business and Professional Ethics Journal 16: 31–38.Google Scholar
Deutsch, M. 1985. Distributive justice: A social psychological perspective. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Downie, B., Coates, M. L., and Furlong, G.. 1998. Meet me inside. Ivey Business Quarterly 62: 56–61.Google Scholar
Dranoff, S., Dobrich, W., and Lamel, L.. 2001. Employer’s aim to limit liability overlooks value of risk control. Business Insurance 35 (October 15): 12–13.Google Scholar
Edmund, R. W. 2000. NLRB holds nonunionized employees have right to bring coworker to disciplinary meetings. Florida Bar Journal 74: 50–53.Google Scholar
Egan, K. 1992. Imagination in teaching and learning. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Ehlers, H. 1996. Building a case. Internal Auditor 53(5): 38–43.Google Scholar
Elangovan, A. R. 1995. Managerial third-party dispute intervention: A prescriptive model of strategy selection. Academy of Management Review 20: 800–830.Google Scholar
Elangovan, A. R.. 1998. Managerial intervention in organizational disputes: Testing a prescriptive model of strategy selection. International Journal of Conflict Management 9: 301–335.Google Scholar
Elangovan, A. R., and Shapiro, D. L.. 1998. Betrayal of trust in organizations. Academy of Management Review 23: 547–566.Google Scholar
Ewing, D. W. 1989. Justice on the job: Resolving grievances in the nonunion workplace. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.Google Scholar
Fagan, P. 2000. Do you investigate employee complaints in the right way? HRFocus 77(10): 10–13.Google Scholar
Felstiner, W. L., Abel, R. L., and Sarat, A.. 1980–1981. The emergence and transformation of disputes: Naming, blaming, and claiming. Law and Society Review 15: 631–654.Google Scholar
Fisher, R., and Ury, W.. 1981. Getting to yes. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.Google Scholar
Foley, S., and Powell, G. N.. 1999. Not all is fair in love and work: Coworkers’ preferences for and responses to managerial interventions regarding workplace romances. Journal of Organizational Behavior 20: 1043–1056.Google Scholar
Folger, R., and Bies, R. J.. 1989. Managerial responsibilities and procedural justice. Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal 2: 79–90.Google Scholar
Folger, R., Konovsky, M. A. and Cropanzano, R.. 1992. A due process metaphor for performance appraisal. In Research in organizational behavior, ed. Staw, B. M. and Cummings, L. L.. Greenwich, Conn.: JAI Press: 129–177.Google Scholar
Fortado, B. 2001. The metamorphosis of workplace conflict. Human Relations 54: 1189–1221.Google Scholar
Frantz, C. M., and Janoff-Bulman, R.. 2000. Considering both sides: The limits of perspective taking. Basic and Applied Social Psychology 22: 31–42.Google Scholar
Freeborn, M. D. 2001. United States: A pop quiz on sex in the workplace. Montaq Business Briefing (May 11).Google Scholar
Gambill, E. 1990. Critical thinking in clinical practice. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.Google Scholar
George, J. R. 2001. Put in a policy or pay the price. Security Management 45(7): 115–122.Google Scholar
Gert, B., and Culver, C.. 1976. Paternalistic behavior. Philosophy & Public Affairs 6: 45–57.Google Scholar
Glendinning, P. M. 2001. Workplace bullying: Curing the cancer of the American workplace. Public Personnel Management 30: 269–286.Google Scholar
Graen, G. B., and Scandura, T. A.. 1987. Toward a psychology of dyadic organizing. In Research in Organizational Behavior, Volume 9, ed. Staw, B. M. and Cummings, L. L.. Greenwich, Conn.: JAI Press: 175–208.Google Scholar
Hersey, P., and Blanchard, K. H.. 1982. Management of organizational behavior. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall.Google Scholar
Izod, J. 2000. Active imagination and the analysis of film. Journal of Analytical Psychology 45: 267–285.Google Scholar
Jacobs, J. 1991. Moral imagination, objectivity, and practical wisdom. International Philosophical Quarterly 31: 23–37.Google Scholar
Jehn, K. A. 2000. Benefits and detriments of workplace conflicts. The Public Manager 29: 24.Google Scholar
Johnson, M. 1993. Moral imagination. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Kant, I. 1952. Critique of judgment. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Karambayya, R., Brett, J.M., and A. Lytle. 1992. The effects of formal authority and experience on third party roles, outcomes, and perceptions of fairness. Academy of Management Journal 35: 426–438.Google Scholar
Keltner, D., and Robinson, R.J.. 1996. Extremism, power, and the imagined basis of social conflict. Current Directions in Psychological Science 5: 101–105.Google Scholar
King, G., and Hemodson, A.. 2000. Peer reporting of coworker wrongdoing: A qualitative analysis of observer attitudes in the decision to report versus not report unethical behavior. Journal of Applied Communication Research 28: 309–329.Google Scholar
Klaas, B. S., and DeNisi, A.S.. 1989. Managerial reactions to employee dissent: The impact of grievance activity on performance ratings. Academy of Management Journal 32: 705–717.Google Scholar
Kolb, D. M., and Bartunek, J.M., eds. 1992. Hidden conflict in organizations: Uncovering behind the scenes disputes. Newbury Park, Calif.: Sage.Google Scholar
Koven, A. M., and Smith, S.L.. 1992. Just cause: The seven tests. Washington, D.C.: Bureau of National Affairs.Google Scholar
Krefting, L. A., and Powers, K.J.. 1998. Exercised voice as management failure: Implications of willing compliance theories of management and individualism for de facto employee voice. Employee Rights and Responsibilities Journal 11, 263–277.Google Scholar
Kuhn, T., and Poole, M.S.. 2000. Do conflict management styles affect group decision making? Evidence from a longitudinal field study. Human Communication Research 26: 558–590.Google Scholar
Lang, M. D. 2000. The making of a mediator: Developing artistry in practice. San Francisco: Jossey Bass.Google Scholar
Leap, T. L., and Crino, M.D.. 1998. How serious is serious? HR Magazine 43(6): 43–46.Google Scholar
Leventhal, G. S. 1976. Fairness in social relationships. In Contemporary topics in social psychology, ed. Thibaut, J. W.Spence, J. T. and Carson, R.C.. Morristown, N.J.: General Learning: 212–239.Google Scholar
Liden, R. C., Wayne, S. J.Judge, T. A.Sparrowe, R. T.Kraimer, M. L. and Franz, T.M.. 1999. Management of poor performance: A comparison of manager, group member, and group disciplinary decisions. Journal of Applied Psychology 84: 835–850.Google Scholar
Lissak, R. I., and Sheppard, B.H.. 1983. Beyond fairness: The criterion problem in research on conflict intervention. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 13: 45–65.Google Scholar
Louis, M. R., and Sutton, R.I.. 1991. Switching cognitive gears: From habits of mind to active thinking. Human Relations 44: 55–76.Google Scholar
Lovelace, K., Shapiro, D.L., and Weingart, L.R.. 2001. Maximizing cross-functional new product team’s innovativeness and constraint adherence: A conflict communication perspective. Academy of Management Journal 44: 779–793.Google Scholar
Lytle, A. L., Brett, J.M., and Shapiro, D.L.. 1999. The strategic use of interests, rights, and power to resolve disputes. Negotiation Journal 15: 31–49.Google Scholar
Make nice. 1996 PC Week 13(22): E5.Google Scholar
Manz, C. C., Manz, K. P.Marx, R. D. and Neck, C.P.. 2001. The wisdom of Solomon at work: Ancient virtues for living and leading today. San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler.Google Scholar
Maruca, R. F. 1998. How do you manage an off-site team? Harvard Business Review 76(4): 22–25.Google Scholar
Masterson, S. S. 2001. A trickle-down model of organizational justice: Relating employees’ and customers’ perceptions of and reactions to fairness. Journal of Applied Psychology 86: 594–603.Google Scholar
Mayer, R. C., Davis, J.H., and Schoorman, F.D.. 1995. An integrative model of organizational trust. Academy Management Review 20: 709–734.Google Scholar
McCabe, D. M. 1998. Due process procedures in faculty grievance codes. Journal of Business Ethics 17: 1653–1662.Google Scholar
McCoy, B. 1983. The parable of the Sadhu. Harvard Business Review 61(5): 103–109.Google Scholar
McElhaney, R. 1996. Conflict management in nursing. Nursing Management 27(3): 49–50.Google Scholar
McGarvey, R. 1997. Peace talks: Are employee conflicts eating away at your profits? Entrepreneur 25(1): 75–77.Google Scholar
Milgram, S. 1969. Obedience to authority. New York: Harper and Row.Google Scholar
Miller, D. T. 2001. Disrespect and the experience of injustice. Annual Review of Psychology 17: 1–28.Google Scholar
Minsky, M. 1974. A framework for representing knowledge. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Artificial Intelligence Laboratory.Google Scholar
Mintzberg, H. 1973. The nature of managerial work. New York: Harper and Row.Google Scholar
Mitrano, J. R. 1997. That’s not fair: The social construction of organizational injustice among professionals. Sociological Inquiry 67: 182–207.Google Scholar
Moberg, D. J. 1994. An ethical analysis of hierarchic relations in organizations. Business Ethics Quarterly 4: 205–220.Google Scholar
Moberg, D. J., and Seabright, M.. 2000. The development of moral imagination. Business Ethics Quarterly 10: 845–884.Google Scholar
Morris, J. H., and Moberg, D.J.. 1994. Work organizations as contexts for trust and betrayal. In Citizen espionage: Studies in trust and betrayal, ed. Sarbin, T.. Westport, Conn.: Praeger: 163–188.Google Scholar
Murry, W. D., Sivasubramaniam, N., and Jacques, P.H.. 2001. Supervisory support, social exchange relationships, and sexual harassment consequences. Leadership Quarterly 12: 1–29.Google Scholar
Nielsen, R. P. 2000. Do internal due process systems permit adequate political and moral space for ethics, voice, praxis, and community? Journal of Business Ethics 24: 1–27.Google Scholar
O’Blenes, C. 1999. Harassment grows more complex. Management Review 62(6): 49–56.Google Scholar
O’Neill, O. 1989. Constructions of reason. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Opotow, S. 1990a. Moral exclusion and injustice: An introduction. Journal of Social Issues 46: 1–20.Google Scholar
Opotow, S.. 1990b. Deterring moral exclusion. Journal of Social Issues 46: 173–182.Google Scholar
Oshry, B. 1995. Seeing systems: Unlocking the mysteries of organizational life. San Francisco: Barrett-Koehler.Google Scholar
O’Toole, J. 1995. The story of ethics: Narrative as a means for ethical understanding and action. JAMA 273: 1387–1388.Google Scholar
Paul, R. J., and Seeberger, K.A.. 2001. Managing reindeer games: Coping with the dilemmas of superior-subordinate fraternization. Review of Business 22(1): 9–16.Google Scholar
Paul, R. J., and Townsend, J.B.. 1998. Managing the workplace romance: Protecting employee and employer rights. Review of Business 19(2): 25–30.Google Scholar
Phillips, D. G., Cooke, J.A., and Anderson, A.E.. 1992. A surefire resolution to workplace conflicts. Personnel Journal 71(5): 111–113.Google Scholar
Pierce, C. A., and Aguinis, H.. 2001. A framework for the link between workplace romance and sexual harassment. Group and Organization Management 26: 206–229.Google Scholar
Pinzon, L., and Midgley, G.. 2000. Developing a systemic model for the evaluation of conflict(s). Systems Research and Behavioral Science 17: 493–519.Google Scholar
Pirisi, A. 1998. The downside of diversity. Psychology Today 32(6): 18.Google Scholar
Rawls, J. 1971. A theory of justice. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Richey, B., Bernardin, H. J.Tyler, C. L. and McKinney, N.. 2001. The effect of arbitration program characteristics on applicants’ intentions toward potential employers. Journal of Applied Psychology 86: 1006–1010.Google Scholar
Rosen, M. 2001. Not guilty as charged. Security Management 45(6): 59–66.Google Scholar
Rostain, T. 1999. Waking up from uneasy dreams: Professional context, discretionary judgment, and the practice of justice. Stanford Law Review 51: 955–972.Google Scholar
Rowe, M. P., and Baker, M.. 1984. Are you hearing enough employee concerns? Harvard Business Review 62(3): 127–135.Google Scholar
Schwoerer, C., and Rosen, B.. 1989. Effects of employment-at-will policies and compensation policies on corporate image and job pursuit intentions. Journal of Applied Psychology 74: 653–656.Google Scholar
Segal, J. A. 2001. HR as judge, jury, prosecutor, and defender. HR Magazine 46(10): 141–154.Google Scholar
Senge, P. M. 1990. The fifth discipline. New York: Doubleday.Google Scholar
Senge, P. M., Klein, A. C.Ross, R. B. Roberts and Smith, B.J.. 1994. The fifth discipline fieldbook: Strategies and tools for building a learning organization. New York: Doubleday.Google Scholar
Shearer, R. A. 1992. Due process liability in personnel records management: Preserving employee liberty interests. Public Personnel Management 21: 523–532.Google Scholar
Sheppard, B. H. 1983. Managers as inquisitors: Some lessons from the law. In Negotiating in organizations, ed. Bazerman, M.H. and Lewicki, R.J.. Beverly Hills, Calif.: Sage: 193–213.Google Scholar
Sheppard, B. H., Blumenfeld, K.-Minton, J. W. Jones, and Hyder, E.. 1994. Informal conflict intervention: Advice and dissent. Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal 7: 53–72.Google Scholar
Simons, T. L., and Peterson, R.S.. 2000. Task conflict and relationship conflict in top management teams: The pivotal role of intragroup trust. Journal of Applied Psychology 85: 102–111.Google Scholar
Sleeper, B. J., and Walter, R.J.. 1997. Employer liability for employee emotional distress claims. Review of Business 18(2): 5–8.Google Scholar
Smith, C. R., and Hunsaker, D.M.. 1972. The bases of argument: Ideas in conflict. Indianapolis, Ind.: Bobbs-Merrill.Google Scholar
Spencer, H. T., and Shuford, J.A.. 1999. Experiential conflict resolution for prison staff. Corrections Today 61(7): 96–101.Google Scholar
Staub, E. 1990. Moral exclusion, personal goal theory, and extreme destructiveness. Journal of Social Issues 46: 47–65.Google Scholar
Steines, J. 2000. Analyze this. Security Management 44(6): 97–105.Google Scholar
Strong, S. R., and Claiborn, C.D.. 1982. Change through interaction: Social psychological processes of counseling and psychotherapy. New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
Tamborini, R., Salomonson, K., and Bahk, D.. 1993. The relationship of empathy to comforting behavior following film exposure. Communication Research 20: 723–738.Google Scholar
Taylor, M. S., Tracy, K. B.Renard, M. K.Harrison, J. K. and Carroll, S.J.. 1995. Due process in performance appraisal: A quasi-experiment in procedural justice. Administrative Science Quarterly 40: 495–523.Google Scholar
Thibaut, J. W., and Walker, L.. 1975. Procedural justice: A psychological analysis. New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
Tinsley, C. H. 2001. How negotiators get to yes: Predicting the constellation of strategies used across cultures to negotiate conflict. Journal of Applied Psychology 86, 583–598.Google Scholar
Trankell, A. 1972. Reliability of evidence. Stockholm: Beckmans.Google Scholar
Tyler, T. R. 1987. Conditions leading to value expressive affect in judgments of procedural justice. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 52: 333–344.Google Scholar
Tyler, T. R., and Bies, R.J.. 1990. Beyond formal procedures: The interpersonal context of procedural justice. In Applied social psychology and organizational contexts, ed. Carroll, J.S.. Hillsdale, N.J.: Erlbaum: 77–98.Google Scholar
Tyler, T. R., and Lind, E.A.. 1992. A relationship model of authority in groups. In Advances in experimental social psychology, Volume 25, ed. Zanna, M.. New York: Academic Press: 115–192.Google Scholar
Ury, W. L., Brett, J.M., and Goldberg, S.B.. 1993. Getting disputes resolved. San Francisco: Jossey Bass.Google Scholar
VandenBos, G. R., and Bulatao, E.Q., eds. 1996. Violence on the job: Identifying the risks and developing solutions. Washington, D.C.: American Psychological Association.Google Scholar
Van Maanen, J., and Barley, S.R.. 1984. Occupational communities: Culture and control in organizations. In Research in organizational behavior, Volume 6, ed. Staw, B.M. and Cummings, L.L.. Greenwich, Conn.: JAI: 287–365.Google Scholar
Velasquez, M. 2002. Business ethics: Concepts and cases. Upper Saddle River, N.J.: Prentice Hall.Google Scholar
Werhane, P. H. 1985. Persons, rights, and corporations. Englewood, N.J.: Prentice Hall.Google Scholar
Werhane, P. H.. 1999. Moral imagination and management decision making. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Werhane, P. H.. 2002. Moral imagination and systems thinking. Journal of Business Ethics 38: 33–42.Google Scholar
Westin, A. F., and Feliu, A.G.. 1988. Resolving employment disputes without litigation. Washington, D.C.: BNA.Google Scholar
Wilburn, K. O. 1998. Employment disputes: Solving them out of court. Management Review 87(3): 17–21.Google Scholar
Williams, O. F., ed. 1997. The moral imagination: How literature and films can stimulate ethical reflection in the business world. Notre Dame, Ind.: University of Notre Dame Press.Google Scholar
Workplace bullying: Why you need to be concerned about it. 2001. Safety Director’s Report 7: 10–11.Google Scholar