Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-fbnjt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-19T16:48:32.707Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The local state in post-war Mozambique: political practice and ideas about authority

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 December 2011

Extract

The article explores the ways in which post-independence political practices in Mozambique's rural areas have shaped attitudes towards official authority, and considers the legacy of those attitudes for the recently promulgated Municipalities Law. The law will transfer a range of state functions to elected district institutions, and grant a greater role to ‘traditional authorities’ (chiefs). Mozambican officials and academics see the law—and decentralisation more widely—as a means of making the state more efficient and more responsive to local needs. However, drawing on case study material from Manica Province, the article argues that neither the Frelimo party-state, nor the opposition military movement Renamo, inculcated a political practice which prepared the way for democratic demands. Nor are chiefs likely to represent community interests effectively. In Manica's rural areas ‘local leaders’ such as businessmen, political party leaders, chiefs and church leaders strongly associate official authority with a level of wealth and education that they do not possess, and which consequently exclude them from holding such positions. They also see elections as potentially destabilising. While there is a strong popular desire for chiefs to resume various roles, officials (and chiefs themselves) usually see their future in terms of a late colonial model, i.e. as an extension of administrative authority. Academic literature on democratisation and civil society often posits an opposition between state and civil society, and democratic aspirations within civil society. However, local attitudes towards authority in Manica Province were strongly based in the history of political practice, and are not necessarily sympathetic to democratic ideals. Nor is there a clear opposition between what has often been called ‘civil society’ and the state: individuals moved in and out of association with official authority; leaders of ‘civil society’ often sought to become part of, not to oppose, the state.

Résumé

Cet article explore la manière dont les pratiques politiques après l'indépendance en milieu rural au Mozambique ont façonné les attitudes envers les autorités officielles, et considère l'effet que ces attitudes ont eu sur la Loi des Municipalités qui a été récemment promulguée. La loi transfèrera une gamme des fonctions de l'Etat à des institutions élues au niveau des districts, et donnera un rôle plus important aux autorités traditionnelles (les chefs). Les officiels et universitaires du Mozambique voient la loi—et plus généralement la décentralisation—comme un moyen de rendre l'Etat plus efficace et plus sensitif aux besoins locaux. Cependant, se basant sur les données d'études de cas dans la province de Manica, cet article affirme que ni le parti au pouvoir ni le mouvement militaire de l'opposition Renamo ont inculqué des pratiques politiques qui auraient préparé la route pour des demandes démocratiques. Il est aussi peu probable que les chefs représentent efficacement les intêrets de la communauté.

Dans le milieu rural de Manica, les leaders locaux tels que les hommes d'affaires, les dirigeants des partis politiques, les chefs, et les leaders de l'église associent fortement l'autorité officielle avec un niveau de richesse et d'éducation qu'ils ne possèdent pas, et qui par conséquent les exclu de ces positions. Ils voient aussi les élections comme étant potentiellement déstabilisantes. Tandis qu'il y a un fort désir populaire pour que les chefs reprennent leurs divers rôles, les officiels (et les chefs eux-mêmes) voient habituellement leur futur selon un model colonial, c'est à dire en tant qu'une extension de l'autorité administrative.

Type
The local and the state
Copyright
Copyright © International African Institute 1997

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Administraçāo do Distrito de Manica. 1993a. Acta No. 01/93. Manica.Google Scholar
Administraçāo do Distrito de Manica. 1993b. Acta No. 02/93. Manica.Google Scholar
Administraçāo do Distrito de Tambara. 1994. ‘Diário de serviço do Mês de Julho de 1994’. Tambara.Google Scholar
ARPAC (Ministry of Culture). 1993. ‘Análise do momento actual do ponto de vista da problemática socio-cultural e o papel da autoridade tradicional africana neste contecto’. Beira: ARPAC.Google Scholar
Alexander, J. 1994. ‘Terra e autoridade política no pós-guerra em Moçambique: o caso da provincia de Manica’, Arquivo (Maputo) 16, 594.Google Scholar
Alexander, J. 1995. Political Change in Manica Province: implications for the decentralization of power. Maputo: Friedrich Ebert Stiftung.Google Scholar
Borges, Coelho J. P. 1993. ‘Protected Villages and Communal Villages in the Mozambican Province of Tete, 1968–82: a history of state resettlement policies, development and war’. D.Phil, thesis, University of Bradford.Google Scholar
Bratton, M., and Liatto-Katundu, B. 1994. ‘A Focus Group assessment of political attitudes in Zambia’, African Affairs 93 (373), 535–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bratton, M., and van de Walle, N. 1992. ‘Popular protest and political transition in Africa’, Comparative Politics 24 (4), 419–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
de Brito, L. 1988. ‘Une relecture nécessaire: la genèse du parti-état Frelimo’, Politique Africaine 29, 1527.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
de Brito, L. 1991. ‘Le Frelimo et la construction de l'État national au Mozambique: le sens de la référence au marxisme, 1962–1983’. Thèse de doctorat, Université de Paris VIII, Vincennes.Google Scholar
Cahen, M. 1985. ‘État et pouvoir populaire dans le Mozambique indépendent’, Politique Africaine 19, 3660.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cahen, M. 1990. ‘Le Mozambique: une nation africaine de langue officielle portugaise?Canadian Journal of African Studies 24 (3), 315–47.Google Scholar
Comissāo Provincial do Piano. 1993. ‘Balanco das actividades realizadas no primeiro semestre’. Chimoio.Google Scholar
Cravinho, J. 1995. ‘Mozambique: modernizing, marketing and maize growing’. MS, Oxford.Google Scholar
Direcçao Provincial de Indústria e Energia. 1986. Relatório das actividades desenvolvidas durante o periodo de 1975 a 1985. Chimoio: Ministério de Indústria e Energia.Google Scholar
Egero, B. 1987. Mozambique: a dream undone. The political economy of democracy, 1975–84. Uppsala: Nordiska Afrikainstitutet.Google Scholar
Englund, H. 1994. ‘Which Peasant, which War? From revolution to Renamo in a Mozambican village’. MS, Manchester.Google Scholar
Flower, K. 1987. Serving Secretly. London: John Murray.Google Scholar
Geffray, C. 1988. ‘Fragments d'un discours du pouvoir, 1975–1985: du bon usage d'une meconnaissance scientifique’, Politique Africaine 29, 7186.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Geffray, C. 1991. A causa das armas: antropologia da guerra contemporânea em Moçambique. Oporto: Ediçōes Afrontamento.Google Scholar
Governo da Provincia de Manica. 1979. Relatório anual, 1978. Chimoio: República Popular de Moçambique.Google Scholar
Governo da Provincia de Manica. 1982a. Relatório anual, 1981. Chimoio: República Popular de Moçambique.Google Scholar
Governo da Provincia de Manica. 1982b. Relatório mensal. Chimoio: República Popular de Moçambique.Google Scholar
Governo da Provincia de Manica. 1982c. XIII Reunião da Assembleia Provincial. Chimoio: República Popular de Moçambique.Google Scholar
Governo da Provincia de Manica. 1982d. 14a Reuniāo da Assembleia Provincial. Chimoio: República Popular de Moçambique.Google Scholar
Governo da Provincia de Manica. 1983. XVIII Sessāo da Assembleia Provincial. Chimoio: República Popular de Moçambique.Google Scholar
Governo da Provincia de Manica. 1984a. XIX Sessāo da Assembleia Provincial. Chimoio: República Popular de Moçambique.Google Scholar
Governo da Provincia de Manica. 1984b. XX Sessāo da Assembleia Provincial. Chimoio: Republica Popular de Moçambique.Google Scholar
Governo da Provincia de Manica. 1990. Relatório anual, 1989. Chimoio: República Popular de Moçambique.Google Scholar
Grest, J. 1995. ‘Urban management, local government reform and the democratisation process in Mozambique: Maputo city, 1975–90’, Journal of Southern African Studies 21 (1), 147–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Guambe, J. 1992. ‘The Problems of Structuring Government in a Democratic Process: central government/local government’.Paper presented to Conferência sobre Moçambique pós-guerra: ‘desafios e realidades’, ISRI/CEEI,Maputo,14–18 December.Google Scholar
Guambe, J. and Cuerenia, A. nd. O processo de descentralizaçāo em Moçambique e seu enquadramento no actual sistema de administraçāo púlica. Maputo: Ministério da Administraçāo Estatal.Google Scholar
Hall, M. 1990. ‘The Mozambican National Resistance Movement (Renamo): a study in the destruction of an African country’, Africa, 60 (1), 3968.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hanlon, J. 1984. Mozambique: the revolution under fire. London: Zed Press.Google Scholar
Hanlon, J. 1995. Mozambique Peace Process Bulletin 15. Amsterdam: AWEPA.Google Scholar
Human Rights Watch. 1992. Conspicuous Destruction: war, famine and the reform process in Mozambique. New York: Human Rights Watch.Google Scholar
Hume, C. 1994. Ending Mozambique's War: the role of mediation and good offices. Washington, D.C.: US Institute of Peace.Google Scholar
Isaacman, A. 1976. The Tradition of Resistance in Mozambique: anti-colonial activity in the Zambezi valley, 1850–1921. London: Heinemann.Google Scholar
Lemarchand, R. 1992. ‘Uncivil states and civil societies: how illusion became reality’, Journal of Modern African Studies 30 (2), 177–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lundin, I. B. 1992a. ‘The Concept of Democracy: the transformation of a given model into a standard model’.Paper presented to Conferência sobre Moçambique pós- guerra: ‘Desafios e Realidades’, ISRI/CEEI,Maputo,14–18 December.Google Scholar
Lundin, I. B. 1992b. ‘Relatório de trabalho de campo nas províncias de Sofala e Manica. A autoridade/poder traditional e suas bases de legitimidade’. Maputo: Ministério da Administraçāo Estatal.Google Scholar
Machel, G. 1992. ‘Energizing the Civil Society in Mozambique: the role of NGOs in development in Mozambique’.Paper presented to Conferência sobre Mocambique pós-guerra: ‘desafios e realidades’, ISRI/CEEI,Maputo,14–18 December.Google Scholar
Magode, J. M., and Khan, A. 1992. ‘The Unitary State and the National Question’.Paper presented to Conferencia sobre Moçambique pós-guerra: ‘desafios e realidades’, ISRI/CEEI,Maputo,14–18 December.Google Scholar
Martin, D., and Johnson, P. 1981. The Struggle for Zimbabwe. London: Faber.Google Scholar
Ministério da Administraçāo Estatal. 1991. ‘Reforma dos orgāos locais’. Maputo.Google Scholar
Ministério da Administraçāo Estatal. 1993. ‘Reforms dos orgāos locais e o papel da autoridade tradicional’. Maputo.Google Scholar
Ranger, T. O. 1992. ‘Legitimacy, Civil Society and the State in Africa’, first Alexander Visiting Professorial inaugural lecture, University of Western Australia, 2 December.Google Scholar
Raposo, I. 1991. O viver de hoje e de ontem: aldeia e musha. Maputo: Documento de Trabalho.Google Scholar
Robinson, P. 1994. ‘Democratization: understanding the relationship between regime change and the culture of polities’, African Studies Review 37 (1), 3968.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Roesch, O. 1992. ‘Mozambique unravels? The retreat to tradition’, Southern Africa Report (Toronto), May, 27–30.Google Scholar
Sabonete, C. L. 1994. ‘Administraçāo pública moçambicana: resume histórico’.Paper presented to the Seminário sobre decentralizaçáao, Movimento Pela Paz, Friedrich Ebert Stiftung, Governo da Província de Sofala,8–9 February,Beira.Google Scholar
Tordoff, W. 1994. ‘Decentralisation: comparative experience in Commonwealth Africa’, Journal of Modern African Studies 32 (4), 555–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
UNOHAC. 1994. Província de Manica, Sector da Educaçāo. Inventārio de instalaçōes e pessoal (EP1). Chimoio: UNOHAC.Google Scholar
Vines, A. 1991. Renamo: terrorism in Mozambique. London: James Currey.Google Scholar
Young, T. 1990. ‘The MNR/Renamo: external and internal dynamics’, African Affairs 89 (357), 491509.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Xadreque, A. and Americo, M. 1990. ‘As Autoridades Gentílicas de Beira: segundo relatório provisório de investigaçāo’. Beira: Núcleo de Projecto ARPAC (Ministry of Culture) de Sofala.Google Scholar