THE ROOTS OF INCIVILITY

The contributions of constitutional initiatives and civilian peace efforts to the vast project of democratising the means of governmental violence are important. In the age of triangulated violence, they warn against defeatism by forcing us to rethink the old objection that democracy always degenerates into violence. One of the first versions of that celebrated dogma appeared in the eighth book of Plato's Republic, where democracy is described not as the government of the people but of the poor against the rich. The guiding principle of democracy is said to be liberty, which is quickly transformed into licence due to democrats' lack of public and private restraint. Such licentiousness of the people is reinforced by their indulgence of superfluous needs and immodest desires, their lack of respect for law and their general tendency to question authority, so that the old condescend to the young, parents fear their children, ‘the master fears and flatters his scholars and the scholars despise their masters and tutors’. Polybius repeated this later famous line of attack: