In The Tempest, a failed attempt by Caliban to rape Miranda constitutes the event on which a power structure is ratified. For Prospero, who has already taken over control of the island when Caliban was a child, the attempt justifies his enslavement of Caliban. Caliban disagrees: had he succeeded, he “had peopled else / This isle with Calibans” (1.2.150–51). Begetting his own lineage would have legitimized his title to the island and recast his action in a different light. The unrepentant Caliban draws an angry response from Miranda. Calling him an “abhorred slave, / Which any print of goodness wilt not take,” she reminds him that

Miranda sees the failed rape as a sign of Caliban's failed education, but a more complicated picture emerges from the exchange if we notice the implied parallel between rape and education. The reference to education as “print” suggests not just a means of inscription but also a current metaphor for impregnation, the imprinting of a paternal image in the womb. In teaching Caliban her language, then, Miranda's attempt to imprint him with her cultural values and meanings (taught her solely by her father) comes to mirror his fantasy of engendering copies of himself upon her. For Caliban, then, her education of him thus operates as a form of cultural rape, to which his attempted rape of her serves as a symbolic payback.