Evolutionary arguments against the <span class='italic'>de facto</span> re-pathologising of homosexuality

doi:10.1017/CBO9780511980381.022

14 - Evolutionary arguments against the de facto re-pathologising of homosexuality

from Part VI - Evolution and Society

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 April 2012

Aldo Poiani

Edited by

Aldo Poiani

Show author details

Aldo Poiani: Affiliation:
Monash University, Victoria

Book contents

Get access

Summary

Homosexuality or same-sex sexual orientation has a very long history in the medical field as pathology of sexuality, starting from the nineteenth century (Bullough, 1974; Adams and Sturgis, 1977; Coleman, 1982; Beckstead 2001; Conrad and Angell, 2004). Officially, however, homosexuality was removed from the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-III) in 1973. This change notwithstanding, the current version of the DSM (DSM-IV-TR), in place since the year 2000, still includes the categories of Gender Identity Disorder (GID) and Sexual Disorder Not Otherwise Specified and its subcategory, Persistent and Marked Distress about Sexual Orientation (Throckmorton, 1998; McCommon, 2009), that leave a door open for the persistence of psychotherapeutic practices that aim at either changing the sexual orientation of homosexuals to heterosexuality, or to maintain the homosexual orientation but eliminate homosexual behaviours. These practices are variably known as conversion therapies, reparative therapies (e.g. Grace, 2008), or re-orientation therapies (Masters and Johnson, 1979).

In this chapter I start with the main issues section, where I briefly review the historical background of ‘homosexuality as pathology’, the emergence of conversion therapies, especially those that have a religious motivation; the criticisms that such therapies have received, including the establishment of alternative gay/lesbian affirmative therapies, and the current approaches that aim at integrating the various dimensions that are relevant to the life of homosexuals. In the ‘Looking forward’ section, I propose an evolutionary view of homosexuality as an adaptive expression of sexuality, not as pathology, and endeavour to establish some evolutionarily inspired criteria that may help both therapists and counsellors in their approaches to homosexual clients, especially in cases where those clients feel the necessity to seek consistency between their sexuality and their strongly held religious beliefs.

Type: Chapter
Information: Pragmatic Evolution
Applications of Evolutionary Theory
, pp. 261 - 280

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511980381.022 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Book purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Adams, H. E.Sturgis, E. T. 1977 Status of behavioral reorientation techniques in the modification of homosexuality: a reviewPsychological Bulletin 84 1171CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Bailey, J. M. 1999 Homosexuality and mental illnessArchives of General Psychiatry 56 883CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Bancroft, J. 1975 Homosexuality and the medical profession: a behaviourist's viewJournal of Medical Ethics 1 176CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Barbosa, P.Torres, H.Silva, M. A. 2010 Agapé Christian reconciliation conversations: exploring the intersections of culture, religiousness, and homosexual identity in Latino and European AmericansJournal of Homosexuality 57 98CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Bartlett, A.Smith, G.King, M. 2009 The response of mental health professionals to clients seeking help to change or redirect same-sex sexual orientationBMC Psychiatry 9 11CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Beckstead, A. L. 2001 Cures versus choices: agendas in sexual reorientation therapyJournal of Gay and Lesbian Psychotherapy 5 87CrossRef Google Scholar

Beckstead, A. L.Morrow, S. L. 2004 Mormon clients' experiences of conversion therapy: the need for a new treatment approachThe Counseling Psychologist 32 651CrossRef Google Scholar

Bullough, V. L. 1974 Homosexuality and the medical modelJournal of Homosexuality 1 99CrossRef Google Scholar

Burch, B. 1993 Heterosexuality, bisexuality, and lesbianism: rethinking psychoanalytic views of women's sexual object choicePsychoanalytic Review 80 83Google Scholar PubMed

Byrd, A. D.Nicolosi, J. 2002 A meta-analytic review of treatment of homosexualityPsychological Reports 90 1139CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Carpenter, E. 1908 The Intermediate SexGeorge Allen and Unwin LtdLondonGoogle Scholar

Chivers, M. L. 2005 A brief review and discussion of sex differences in the specificity of sexual arousalSexual and Relationship Therapy 20 377CrossRef Google Scholar

Coleman, E. 1982 Changing approaches to the treatment of homosexuality: a reviewAmerican Behavioral Scientist 25 397CrossRef Google Scholar

Conrad, P.Angell, A. 2004 Homosexuality and remedicalizationSociety 41 32CrossRef Google Scholar

Davison, G. C. 1976 Homosexuality: the ethical challengeJournal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 44 157CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Diamond, L. M. 2003 Reconsidering ‘sexual desire’ in the context of reparative therapyArchives of Sexual Behavior 32 429Google Scholar

Diamond, L. M. 2008 Sexual Fluidity: Understanding Women's Love and DesireHarvard University PressCambridge, MAGoogle Scholar

Dixson, A. 2010 Homosexual behaviour in primatesPoiani, AAnimal Homosexuality: A Biosocial PerspectiveCambridge University PressCambridge381CrossRef Google Scholar

Drescher, J. 1998 Contemporary psychoanalytic psychotherapy with gay men with a commentary on reparative therapy of homosexualityJournal of Gay and Lesbian Psychotherapy 2 51CrossRef Google Scholar

Drescher, J. 2001 I'm your handyman: a history of reparative therapiesJournal of Gay and Lesbian Psychotherapy 5 5CrossRef Google Scholar

Drescher, J. 2001 Ethical concerns raised when patients seek to change same-sex attractionsJournal of Gay and Lesbian Psychotherapy 5 181CrossRef Google Scholar

Drescher, J. 2004 Homosexuality and its vicissitudes: the ‘homosexual other’ in psychoanalytic theory and praxis,CSISPGoogle Scholar PubMed

Drescher, J. 2009 http://www.anglicancommunion.org/listening/book_resources/docs/Dreshcher%20Sexual%20Conversion%20Therapies.pdf

Ellis, M. L. 2008 Homophobia is the patientPsychodynamic Practice 14 313CrossRef Google Scholar

Fergusson, D. M.Horwood, L. J.Beautrais, A. L. 1999 Is sexual orientation related to mental health problems and suicidality in young people?Archives of General Psychiatry 56 876CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Ford, J. G. 2001 Healing homosexuals: a psychologist's journey through the ex-gay movement and the pseudo-science of reparative therapyJournal of Gay and Lesbian Psychotherapy 5 69CrossRef Google Scholar

Forstein, M. 2001 Overview of ethical and research issues in sexual orientation therapyJournal of Gay and Lesbian Psychotherapy 5 167CrossRef Google Scholar

Friedman, R. C.Downey, J. I. 2002 Sexual Orientation and Psychoanalysis: Sexual Science and Clinical PracticeColumbia University PressNew York, NYGoogle Scholar

Friedman, R. M. 1986 The psychoanalytic model of male homosexuality: a historical and theoretical critiquePsychoanalytic Review 73D 79Google Scholar

Gonsiorek, J. C. 1982 Results of psychological testing on homosexual populationsAmerican Behavioral Scientist 25 385CrossRef Google Scholar

Gonsiorek, J. C. 1991 The empirical basis for the demise of the illness model of homosexualityGonsiorek, J. C.Weinrich, J. D.Homosexuality: Research Implications for Public PolicySage PublicationsThousand Oaks, CA115CrossRef Google Scholar

Gonsiorek, J. C. 2004 Reflections from the conversion therapy battlefieldThe Counseling Psychologist 32 750CrossRef Google Scholar

Grace, A. P. 2008 The charisma and deception of reparative therapies: when medical science beds religionJournal of Homosexuality 55 545CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Haldeman, D. C. 1991 Sexual orientation conversion therapy for gay men and lesbians: a scientific examinationGonsiorek, J. C.Weinrich, J. D.Homosexuality: Research Implications for Public PolicySage Publications, IncThousand Oaks, CA149CrossRef Google Scholar

Haldeman, D. C. 1994 The practice and ethics of sexual orientation conversion therapyJournal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 62 221CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Haldeman, D. C. 2001 Therapeutic antidotes: helping gay and bisexual men recover from conversion therapiesJournal of Gay and Lesbian Psychotherapy 5 117CrossRef Google Scholar

Haldeman, D. C. 2002 Gay rights, patient rights: the implications of sexual orientation conversion therapyProfessional Psychology: Research and Practice 33 260CrossRef Google Scholar

Haldeman, D. C. 2004 When sexual and religious orientation collide: considerations in working with conflicted same-sex attracted male clientsThe Counseling Psychologist 32 691CrossRef Google Scholar

Halpert, S. C. 2000 ‘If it ain't broke, don't fix it’: ethical considerations regarding conversion therapiesInternational Journal of Sexuality and Gender Studies 5 19CrossRef Google Scholar

Herek, G. M.Garnets, L. D. 2007 Sexual orientation and mental healthAnnual Review of Clinical Psychology 3 353CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Herrell, R.Goldberg, J.True, W. R. 1999 Sexual orientation and suicidality: a co-twin control study in adult menArchives of General Psychiatry 56 867CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Hertzman, C. 1999 The biological embedding of early experience and its effects on health in adulthoodAnnals of the New York Academy of Science 896 85CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Hooker, E. A. 1957 The adjustment of the male overt homosexualJournal of Projective Techniques 21 18CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Isay, R. A. 1989 Being Homosexual: Gay Men and their DevelopmentFarrar Straus GirouxNew York, NYGoogle Scholar

Karten, E. Y.Wade, J. C. 2010 Sexual orientation change efforts in men: a client perspectiveJournal of Men's Studies 18 84CrossRef Google Scholar

King, M. 2003 Dropping the diagnosis of homosexuality: did it change the lot of gays and lesbians in Britain?Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 37 684CrossRef Google Scholar

King, M.Smith, G.Bartlett, A. 2004 Treatments of homosexuality in Britain since the 1950s – an oral history: the experience of professionalsBMJ 328 429Google Scholar PubMed

Maccio, E. M. 2010 Influence of family, religion, and social conformity on client participation in sexual reorientation therapyJournal of Homosexuality 57 441CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Masters, W. H.Johnson, V. E. 1979 Homosexuality in PerspectiveLittle, Brown and CompanyBoston, MAGoogle Scholar

McCommon, B. 2009 Sexual orientation and psychiatric diagnosis: Issues to consider for DSM-V and beyondJournal of Gay and Lesbian Mental Health 13 94CrossRef Google Scholar

Mitchell, S. A. 2002 Psychodynamics, homosexuality, and the question of pathologyStudies in Gender and Sexuality 3 3CrossRef Google Scholar

Moberly, E. R. 1985 New perspectives on homosexualityJournal of the Royal Society for the Promotion of Health 105 206CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Morrow, S. L.Beckstead, A. L. 2004 Conversion therapies for same-sex attracted clients in religious conflict: context, predisposing factors, experiences, and implications for therapyThe Counseling Psychologist 32 641CrossRef Google Scholar

Morrow, S. L.Beckstead, A. L.Hayes, J. A. 2004 Impossible dreams, impossible choices, and thoughts about depolarizing the debateThe Counseling Psychologist 32 778CrossRef Google Scholar

Murphy, T. F. 1992 Redirecting sexual orientation: techniques and justificationsJournal of Sex Research 29 501CrossRef Google Scholar

Nicolosi, J. 1994 Objections to AAP Statement on Homosexuality and AdolescencePediatrics 93 696Google Scholar PubMed

Nicolosi, J. 2001 The removal of homosexuality from the psychiatric manualCatholic Social Science Review 6 71CrossRef Google Scholar

Nicolosi, J. 2001 A developmental model for effective treatment of male homosexualityAmerican Journal of Pastoral Counseling 3 87CrossRef Google Scholar

Nicolosi, J.Byrd, A. D. 2002 A critique of Bem's ‘exotic becomes erotic’ theory of sexual orientation developmentPsychological Reports 90 931CrossRef Google Scholar

Nicolosi, J.Byrd, A. D.Potts, R. W. 2000 Beliefs and practices of therapists who practice sexual reorientation psychotherapyPsychological Reports 86 689CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Nicolosi, J.Byrd, A. D.Potts, R. W. 2000 Retrospective self-reports of changes in homosexual orientation: a consumer survey of conversion therapy clientsPsychological Reports 86 1071CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Pattison, E. M.Pattison, M. L. 1980 ‘Ex-gays’: religiously mediated change in homosexualsAmerican Journal of Psychiatry 137 1553Google Scholar

Peplau, L. A.Spalding, L. R.Conley, T. D. 1999 The development of sexual orientation in womenAnnual Review of Sex Research 10 70Google Scholar PubMed

Pitt, R. N. 2010 ‘Still looking for my Jonathan’: gay black men's management of religious and sexual identity conflictsJournal of Homosexuality 57 39CrossRef Google Scholar

Poiani, A. 2010 Animal Homosexuality: A Biosocial PerspectiveCambridge University PressCambridgeCrossRef Google Scholar

Rodríguez, E. M. 2010 At the intersection of church and gay: a review of the psychological research on gay and lesbian ChristiansJournal of Homosexuality 57 5CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Rodríguez Rust, P. C. 2003 Reparative science and social responsibility: the concept of a malleable core as theoretical challenge and psychological comfortArchives of Sexual Behavior 32 449Google Scholar

Rosser, B. R. S.Bockting, W. O.Ross, M. W. 2008 The relationship between homosexuality, internalized homo-negativity, and mental health in men who have sex with menJournal of Homosexuality 55 185CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Schroeder, M.Shidlo, A. 2001 Ethical issues in sexual orientation conversion therapies: an empirical study of consumersJournal of Gay and Lesbian Psychotherapy 5 131CrossRef Google Scholar

Serovich, J. M.Craft, S. M.Toviessi, P. 2008 A systematic review of the research base on sexual reorientation therapiesJournal of Marital and Family Therapy 34 227CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Shidlo, A.Schroeder, M. 2002 Changing sexual orientation: a consumers' reportProfessional Psychology: Research and Practice 33 249CrossRef Google Scholar

Shidlo, A.Schroeder, M.Drescher, J. 2001 What needs fixing? An introductionJournal of Gay and Lesbian Psychotherapy 5 1CrossRef Google Scholar

Spitzer, R. L. 2003 Can some gay men and lesbians change their sexual orientation? 200 participants reporting a change from homosexual to heterosexual orientationArchives of Sexual Behavior 32 403CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Strassberg, D. S.Roback, H.Cunningham, J. 1979 Psychopathology in self-identified female-to-male transsexuals, homosexuals, and heterosexualsArchives of Sexual Behavior 8 491CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Throckmorton, W. 1998 Attempts to modify sexual orientation: a review of outcome literature and ethical issuesJournal of Mental Health Counseling 20 283Google Scholar

Throckmorton, W. 2002 Initial empirical and clinical findings concerning the change process for ex-gaysProfessional Psychology: Research and Practice 33 242CrossRef Google Scholar

Tozer, E. E.McClanahan, M. K. 1999 Treating the purple menace: ethical considerations of conversion therapy and affirmative alternativesThe Counseling Psychologist 27 722CrossRef Google Scholar

Tozer, E. E.Hayes, J. A. 2004 Why do individuals seek conversion therapy? The role of religiosity, internalized homonegativity, and identity developmentThe Counseling Psychologist 32 716CrossRef Google Scholar

Tye, M. C. 2003 Spitzer's oversight: ethical–philosophical underpinnings of ‘reparative therapy’Archives of Sexual Behavior 32 452Google Scholar

Vasey, P. L.Pocock, D. S.VanderLaan, D. P. 2007 Kin selection and male androphilia in Samoan Evolution and Human Behavior 28 159CrossRef Google Scholar

Wilde, W. 2004 Letter to the Editor: Repairing homophobicsArchives of Sexual Behavior 33 325CrossRef Google Scholar

Worthington, R. L. 2004 Sexual identity, sexual orientation, religious identity, and change: is it possible to depolarize the debate?The Counseling Psychologist 32 741CrossRef Google Scholar

Yarhouse, M. A. 1998 When clients seek treatment for same-sex attraction: ethical issues in the ‘right to choose’ debatePsychotherapy 35 248CrossRef Google Scholar

Yarhouse, M. A.Burkett, L. A.Kreeft, E. M. 2002 Paraprofessional Christian ministries for sexual behavior and same-sex identity concernsJournal of Psychology and Theology 30 209CrossRef Google Scholar