Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Contributors
- Preface
- Acknowledgments
- PART I GENERAL STUDIES
- PART II PARTICULAR STUDIES
- 5 ON THE INTERPRETATION OF ‘DONKEY’-SENTENCES
- 6 GENERIC INFORMATION, CONDITIONAL CONTEXTS AND CONSTRAINTS
- 7 DATA SEMANTICS AND THE PRAGMATICS OF INDICATIVE CONDITIONALS
- 8 REMARKS ON THE SEMANTICS AND PRAGMATICS OF CONDITIONALS
- 9 THE USE OF CONDITIONALS IN INDUCEMENTS AND DETERRENTS
- 10 CONDITIONALS AND SPEECH ACTS
- 11 CONSTRAINTS ON THE FORM AND MEANING OF THE PROTASIS
- 12 CONDITIONALS, CONCESSIVE CONDITIONALS AND CONCESSIVES: AREAS OF CONTRAST, OVERLAP AND NEUTRALIZATION
- 13 THE REALIS–IRREALIS CONTINUUM IN THE CLASSICAL GREEK CONDITIONAL
- 14 THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF si-CLAUSES IN ROMANCE
- 15 FIRST STEPS IN ACQUIRING CONDITIONALS
- 16 THE ACQUISITION OF TEMPORALS AND CONDITIONALS
- 17 CONDITIONALS ARE DISCOURSE-BOUND
- 18 CONDITIONALS IN DISCOURSE: A TEXT-BASED STUDY FROM ENGLISH
- Index of names
- Index of languages
- Index of subjects
11 - CONSTRAINTS ON THE FORM AND MEANING OF THE PROTASIS
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 04 August 2010
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Contributors
- Preface
- Acknowledgments
- PART I GENERAL STUDIES
- PART II PARTICULAR STUDIES
- 5 ON THE INTERPRETATION OF ‘DONKEY’-SENTENCES
- 6 GENERIC INFORMATION, CONDITIONAL CONTEXTS AND CONSTRAINTS
- 7 DATA SEMANTICS AND THE PRAGMATICS OF INDICATIVE CONDITIONALS
- 8 REMARKS ON THE SEMANTICS AND PRAGMATICS OF CONDITIONALS
- 9 THE USE OF CONDITIONALS IN INDUCEMENTS AND DETERRENTS
- 10 CONDITIONALS AND SPEECH ACTS
- 11 CONSTRAINTS ON THE FORM AND MEANING OF THE PROTASIS
- 12 CONDITIONALS, CONCESSIVE CONDITIONALS AND CONCESSIVES: AREAS OF CONTRAST, OVERLAP AND NEUTRALIZATION
- 13 THE REALIS–IRREALIS CONTINUUM IN THE CLASSICAL GREEK CONDITIONAL
- 14 THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF si-CLAUSES IN ROMANCE
- 15 FIRST STEPS IN ACQUIRING CONDITIONALS
- 16 THE ACQUISITION OF TEMPORALS AND CONDITIONALS
- 17 CONDITIONALS ARE DISCOURSE-BOUND
- 18 CONDITIONALS IN DISCOURSE: A TEXT-BASED STUDY FROM ENGLISH
- Index of names
- Index of languages
- Index of subjects
Summary
Editors' note. Of central importance in defining conditionals is a full understanding of the constraints on (i) which structures can be interpreted as conditionals, and (ii) when conditionals can be interpreted as nonconditionals. Haiman focuses on the circumstances under which conjoined clauses can be interpreted as conditionals and conditionals as concessives, so providing a direct link to the papers by Van der Auwera and König. Using extensive crosslinguistic data, Haiman argues that an explanation for the constraints lies in the nature of the diagrammatic iconicity of S1 S2 constructions, thereby also showing that semantic change is not arbitrary.
INTRODUCTION
The recurrent interchangeability or identity of conditional and interrogative markers has been noted in a number of unrelated languages, among them the members of the Uralic family (Beke 1919), Germanic, French and Greek (Havers 1931: 21) and Chinese (Chao 1968: 81–2). The phenomenon is explained on the assumption that conditional protases are the topics of the sentences in which they occur (Haiman 1978; for further discussion, see Akatsuka, Ford and Thompson in this volume). As topics constitute information whose validity is (perhaps only provisionally) agreed upon by all parties to the discourse, it is natural for a speaker to establish their given status by asking for assent or recognition from his interlocutor. In some languages, the semantic equivalence of protasis and topic is directly reflected by the identical morphology and syntax of these two categories: representative examples are Turkish (Lewis 1967: 217), Tagalog (Schachter 1976: 496), Tabasaran (Magometov 1965: 271), Korean (Martin and Lee 1969: 146, 159), Vietnamese (Hoa 1974: 103, 341), Middle Egyptian (Gardiner 1957: 125) and, once again, Chinese (Chao 1968: 81–110).
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- On Conditionals , pp. 215 - 228Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 1986
- 14
- Cited by