Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Contributors
- Preface
- Acknowledgments
- PART I GENERAL STUDIES
- PART II PARTICULAR STUDIES
- 5 ON THE INTERPRETATION OF ‘DONKEY’-SENTENCES
- 6 GENERIC INFORMATION, CONDITIONAL CONTEXTS AND CONSTRAINTS
- 7 DATA SEMANTICS AND THE PRAGMATICS OF INDICATIVE CONDITIONALS
- 8 REMARKS ON THE SEMANTICS AND PRAGMATICS OF CONDITIONALS
- 9 THE USE OF CONDITIONALS IN INDUCEMENTS AND DETERRENTS
- 10 CONDITIONALS AND SPEECH ACTS
- 11 CONSTRAINTS ON THE FORM AND MEANING OF THE PROTASIS
- 12 CONDITIONALS, CONCESSIVE CONDITIONALS AND CONCESSIVES: AREAS OF CONTRAST, OVERLAP AND NEUTRALIZATION
- 13 THE REALIS–IRREALIS CONTINUUM IN THE CLASSICAL GREEK CONDITIONAL
- 14 THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF si-CLAUSES IN ROMANCE
- 15 FIRST STEPS IN ACQUIRING CONDITIONALS
- 16 THE ACQUISITION OF TEMPORALS AND CONDITIONALS
- 17 CONDITIONALS ARE DISCOURSE-BOUND
- 18 CONDITIONALS IN DISCOURSE: A TEXT-BASED STUDY FROM ENGLISH
- Index of names
- Index of languages
- Index of subjects
12 - CONDITIONALS, CONCESSIVE CONDITIONALS AND CONCESSIVES: AREAS OF CONTRAST, OVERLAP AND NEUTRALIZATION
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 04 August 2010
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Contributors
- Preface
- Acknowledgments
- PART I GENERAL STUDIES
- PART II PARTICULAR STUDIES
- 5 ON THE INTERPRETATION OF ‘DONKEY’-SENTENCES
- 6 GENERIC INFORMATION, CONDITIONAL CONTEXTS AND CONSTRAINTS
- 7 DATA SEMANTICS AND THE PRAGMATICS OF INDICATIVE CONDITIONALS
- 8 REMARKS ON THE SEMANTICS AND PRAGMATICS OF CONDITIONALS
- 9 THE USE OF CONDITIONALS IN INDUCEMENTS AND DETERRENTS
- 10 CONDITIONALS AND SPEECH ACTS
- 11 CONSTRAINTS ON THE FORM AND MEANING OF THE PROTASIS
- 12 CONDITIONALS, CONCESSIVE CONDITIONALS AND CONCESSIVES: AREAS OF CONTRAST, OVERLAP AND NEUTRALIZATION
- 13 THE REALIS–IRREALIS CONTINUUM IN THE CLASSICAL GREEK CONDITIONAL
- 14 THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF si-CLAUSES IN ROMANCE
- 15 FIRST STEPS IN ACQUIRING CONDITIONALS
- 16 THE ACQUISITION OF TEMPORALS AND CONDITIONALS
- 17 CONDITIONALS ARE DISCOURSE-BOUND
- 18 CONDITIONALS IN DISCOURSE: A TEXT-BASED STUDY FROM ENGLISH
- Index of names
- Index of languages
- Index of subjects
Summary
Editors' note. König focuses on the interaction of conditionals and concessives, and argues for identifying an intermediate category of concessive conditionals. He also shows how concessives may derive historically from conditionals via concessive conditionals. This chapter is related to Van der Auwera's and Haiman's in addressing concessives, and to Harris's in its historical approach.
INTRODUCTION
Terms like ‘conditional’, ‘temporal’, ‘causal’, ‘concessive’ are part of the terminological inventory that traditional grammar makes available for the characterization of adverbial clauses. The distinctions drawn by these terms seem clear enough until an attempt is made to explicate them in a way that would have crosslinguistic validity, or to apply them in an exhaustive characterization of all kinds of data within a single language. To begin with, there are nonspecific constructions to which several of these terms or none at all seem to be applicable. Examples are nonfinite constructions such as adverbial participles in Russian, the gerundio in Italian, the construction tout en V-ant in French or participial constructions in English. A sentence like the following may have a conditional or a causal interpretation depending on the context:
(1) Lacking that, the movement is dead
Or, to give an example of a different type, the construction Adj as NP be in English merely expresses factuality and is open to both a causal and concessive interpretation:
(2) a. Rich as he is, he spends a lot of money on horses (causal)
b. Poor as he is, he spends a lot of money on horses (concessive)
But even cases where the adverbial relation in question is marked by a conjunction are sometimes difficult to assign to one rather than another category.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- On Conditionals , pp. 229 - 246Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 1986
- 68
- Cited by