Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of contributors
- Preface
- Acknowledgments
- 1 Introduction: inferences from verbal material
- PART I GENERAL ISSUES
- PART II CONTENT ANALYSIS SYSTEMS
- 9 The achievement motive
- 10 A scoring manual for the achievement motive
- 11 The motive to avoid success
- 12 A revised scoring manual for the motive to avoid success
- 13 The affiliation motive
- 14 A scoring manual for the affiliation motive
- 15 The intimacy motive
- 16 The intimacy motivation scoring system
- 17 Affiliative trust–mistrust
- 18 A scoring system for affiliative trust–mistrust
- 19 Power motivation
- 20 A scoring manual for the power motive
- 21 Power motivation revisited
- 22 A revised scoring system for the power motive
- 23 Personal causation and the origin concept
- 24 The origin scoring system
- 25 Explanatory style
- 26 The explanatory style scoring manual
- 27 Conceptual/integrative complexity
- 28 The conceptual/integrative complexity scoring manual
- 29 Uncertainty orientation
- 30 A manual for scoring need for uncertainty
- 31 Assessing adaptation to life changes in terms of psychological stances toward the environment
- 32 Scoring manual for psychological stances toward the environment
- 33 Self-definition and social definition: personal styles reflected in narrative style
- 34 Revised scoring manual for self-definition and social definition
- 35 Responsibility
- 36 Scoring system for responsibility
- PART III METHODOLOGY, SCORER TRAINING, DATA COLLECTION
- Appendix I Practice materials for learning the scoring systems
- Appendix II Pictures used to elicit thematic apperceptive stories
- Appendix III How to order additional practice materials
- References
- Name Index
- Subject Index
33 - Self-definition and social definition: personal styles reflected in narrative style
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 16 October 2009
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of contributors
- Preface
- Acknowledgments
- 1 Introduction: inferences from verbal material
- PART I GENERAL ISSUES
- PART II CONTENT ANALYSIS SYSTEMS
- 9 The achievement motive
- 10 A scoring manual for the achievement motive
- 11 The motive to avoid success
- 12 A revised scoring manual for the motive to avoid success
- 13 The affiliation motive
- 14 A scoring manual for the affiliation motive
- 15 The intimacy motive
- 16 The intimacy motivation scoring system
- 17 Affiliative trust–mistrust
- 18 A scoring system for affiliative trust–mistrust
- 19 Power motivation
- 20 A scoring manual for the power motive
- 21 Power motivation revisited
- 22 A revised scoring system for the power motive
- 23 Personal causation and the origin concept
- 24 The origin scoring system
- 25 Explanatory style
- 26 The explanatory style scoring manual
- 27 Conceptual/integrative complexity
- 28 The conceptual/integrative complexity scoring manual
- 29 Uncertainty orientation
- 30 A manual for scoring need for uncertainty
- 31 Assessing adaptation to life changes in terms of psychological stances toward the environment
- 32 Scoring manual for psychological stances toward the environment
- 33 Self-definition and social definition: personal styles reflected in narrative style
- 34 Revised scoring manual for self-definition and social definition
- 35 Responsibility
- 36 Scoring system for responsibility
- PART III METHODOLOGY, SCORER TRAINING, DATA COLLECTION
- Appendix I Practice materials for learning the scoring systems
- Appendix II Pictures used to elicit thematic apperceptive stories
- Appendix III How to order additional practice materials
- References
- Name Index
- Subject Index
Summary
Most of the measures described in this book assess the content in verbal material. In contrast, the measure to be described here assesses aspects of the narrative style, under the assumption that the way in which an individual tells a story reflects a broader “personal style.” Stylistic characteristics of personality have been considered a part of both normal and abnormal personality from the beginning (see, e.g., Allport, 1961; Allport & Vernon, 1933; D. Shapiro, 1965), but they have captured the interest of psychologists less consistently than have thematic or content characteristics. Perhaps one reason for this is that exploration of content-based characteristics and stylistic characteristics requires completely different strategies. A researcher seeking to establish the validity of a content-based measure is usually in a position to choose a relatively narrow domain of human activities, and assess correlates in that domain. In contrast, a researcher seeking to establish the validity of a stylistic measure generally hopes to establish that the style unifies behavior in many different domains. The research strategy must be to cast a relatively wide net, and to identify stylistic similarities underlying substantive, or domain, differences.
Self- and social definition are concepts derived from Sartre's (1946/1965) analysis of the problem of identity formation for Jews in the context of anti-Semitism, and de Beauvoir's (1949/1953) application of the same reasoning to the problem of identity formation in women in the context of constraining social definitions of women.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Motivation and PersonalityHandbook of Thematic Content Analysis, pp. 481 - 488Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 1992
- 3
- Cited by