Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Introduction
- 1 To Benefit the Poor and Advance Medical Science: Hospitals and Hospital Care in Germany, 1820-1870
- 2 From Traditional Individualism to Collective Professionalism: State, Patient, Compulsory Health Insurance, and the Panel Doctor Question in Germany, 1883—1931
- 3 In Search of German Social Darwinism: The History and Historiography of a Concept
- 4 Modern German Doctors: A Failure of Professionalization?
- 5 The Mentally Ill Patient Caught between the State's Demands and the Professional Interests of Psychiatrists
- 6 Rationalizing the Therapeutic Arsenal: German Neuropsychiatry in World War I
- 7 Sterilization and “Medical” Massacres in National Socialist Germany: Ethics, Politics, and the Law
- 8 The Old as New: The Nuremberg Doctors' Trial and Medicine in Modern Germany
- 9 The Debate that Will Not End: The Politics of Abortion in Germany from Weimar to National Socialism and the Postwar Period
- 10 The Sewering Scandal of 1993 and the German Medical Establishment
- Index
3 - In Search of German Social Darwinism: The History and Historiography of a Concept
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 January 2013
- Frontmatter
- Introduction
- 1 To Benefit the Poor and Advance Medical Science: Hospitals and Hospital Care in Germany, 1820-1870
- 2 From Traditional Individualism to Collective Professionalism: State, Patient, Compulsory Health Insurance, and the Panel Doctor Question in Germany, 1883—1931
- 3 In Search of German Social Darwinism: The History and Historiography of a Concept
- 4 Modern German Doctors: A Failure of Professionalization?
- 5 The Mentally Ill Patient Caught between the State's Demands and the Professional Interests of Psychiatrists
- 6 Rationalizing the Therapeutic Arsenal: German Neuropsychiatry in World War I
- 7 Sterilization and “Medical” Massacres in National Socialist Germany: Ethics, Politics, and the Law
- 8 The Old as New: The Nuremberg Doctors' Trial and Medicine in Modern Germany
- 9 The Debate that Will Not End: The Politics of Abortion in Germany from Weimar to National Socialism and the Postwar Period
- 10 The Sewering Scandal of 1993 and the German Medical Establishment
- Index
Summary
At a lunchtime meeting held on August 20,1942, to mark the occasion of the appointment of Otto-Georg Thierack as Reich justice minister and Roland Freisler as president of the “People's Court,” Hitler launched into one of his characteristic monologues. The judicial system, he said, was soft. Criminals were being allowed to get away with far too much on the home front. Looting and petty crime were being punished with mere prison sentences instead of death. The results of this in the longer term would be disastrous:
Every war leads to a negative selection. The positive elements die in masses. The choice of the most dangerous military service is already a selection: the really brave ones become airmen, or join the U-boats. And even in these services there is always the call: who wants to volunteer? And it's always the best men who then get killed. All this time, the absolute ne'er-do-well is cared for lovingly in body and spirit. Anyone who ever enters a prison knows with absolute certainty that nothing more is going to happen to him. If you can imagine this going on for another three or four years, then you can see a gradual shift in the balance of the nation taking place: an over-exploitation on the one side; absolute conservation on the other.
In order to reestablish the balance, Hitler declared, the “negative” elements in the German population had to be killed in much larger numbers. In the following months, Thierack and his officials redefined the role of penal policy to achieve this end. Punishment, the new Reich minister of justice told German judges on June 1, 1943, “in our time has to carry out the popular-hygienic task of continually cleansing the body of the race by the ruthless elimination of criminals unworthy of life.”
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Medicine and ModernityPublic Health and Medical Care in Nineteenth- and Twentieth-Century Germany, pp. 55 - 80Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 1997
- 7
- Cited by