Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Dedication
- Editors and Advisers
- Contents
- Polin: Studies in Polish Jewry
- Polin
- Statement From the Editors
- SYMPOSIUM: JEWS AND THE EMERGENCE OF AN INDEPENDENT POLISH STATE
- ARTICLES
- The Basic Privileges of the Jews of Great Poland as Reflected in Polish Historiography
- The Decline of the Polish-Lithuanian Kahal
- A Mobile Class. The Subjective Element in the Social Perception of Jews: The Example of Eighteenth Century Poland
- Polish Synagogues in the Nineteenth Century
- The image of the Jew in Polish Narrative Prose of the Romantic Period
- The Polish-Jewish Daily Press
- From ‘Numerus Clausus’ to ‘Numerus Nullus’
- DOCUMENTS
- COMMENTARY
- REVIEW ESSAYS
- BOOK REVIEWS
- Leiter to the Editors
- Contributors
- Obituaries
The image of the Jew in Polish Narrative Prose of the Romantic Period
from ARTICLES
- Frontmatter
- Dedication
- Editors and Advisers
- Contents
- Polin: Studies in Polish Jewry
- Polin
- Statement From the Editors
- SYMPOSIUM: JEWS AND THE EMERGENCE OF AN INDEPENDENT POLISH STATE
- ARTICLES
- The Basic Privileges of the Jews of Great Poland as Reflected in Polish Historiography
- The Decline of the Polish-Lithuanian Kahal
- A Mobile Class. The Subjective Element in the Social Perception of Jews: The Example of Eighteenth Century Poland
- Polish Synagogues in the Nineteenth Century
- The image of the Jew in Polish Narrative Prose of the Romantic Period
- The Polish-Jewish Daily Press
- From ‘Numerus Clausus’ to ‘Numerus Nullus’
- DOCUMENTS
- COMMENTARY
- REVIEW ESSAYS
- BOOK REVIEWS
- Leiter to the Editors
- Contributors
- Obituaries
Summary
Anyone attempting to present an image of the Jew in Polish narrative prose of the period 1822-63 has to consider, at the outset, factors that conditioned this image. First of all one must mention the social and psychological environment and the stereotype of the Jew which emerged from it. As Alexander Hertz recalls:
An image of one social group reflected in the consciousness of every member of another social group is one of the most interesting and important problems of sociology and cultural anthropology. The investigation of this image and how it evolved is of the utmost importance for understanding the relations of groups and individuals. In our relations with people belonging to different groups we use definitions derived from images drawn from our own collective experience about other groups and their members. These images and the definitions stemming from them are never the results of sober thought and do not correspond to reality. They are an inadequate representation of it. And it cannot be otherwise. They come from our everyday experiences which have nothing to do with the detailed and scrupulous search for truth of the scientist. These experiences are merely based on casual meetings and incidental judgements where emotion outweighs reflections. Consequently stereotypes are constructed which are a part of ‘knowledge based on supposition’ and ideas about others.
Hertz's comments apply to the stereotype, in other words to several clear and characteristic traits of the model which have both an emotional and cognitive character. Pierre Reboul introduced, in his work with the rather misleading title Le Mythe Anglais dans la Littirature Francaise sous la Restauration (Lille 1962), the similar concept of images illusoires. The title is misleading because in Reboul's work myth has nothing to do with the constructions of religious consciousness in primitive societies: like the stereotype, it is an idea for expressing ‘false consciousness’. Reboul, however, emphasized the important role of literature in the formation of the myth. ‘The leading and most important writers were always influenced by collective thoughts, although they sometimes escaped them and tried to shape them. The myth existed more vigorously among writers than among other people of other professions. ‘
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Jews and the Emerging Polish State (Polin Volume Two) , pp. 199 - 218Publisher: Liverpool University PressPrint publication year: 2008