Chapter 14 presents a case study of the reactions of economists to experimental work on preference reversals. In this instance, the profession has not relied on an unacceptably dogmatic view of theory appraisal. Such dogmatism as there has been stems from the commitment of economists to a vision of economics as a separate science. The discussion in this chapter is an illustration rather than an argument for the interpretation of the evolution of economic methodology defended in Chapter 13. As we shall see, the initial reactions of economists to the anomalous results of experiments carried out by psychologists are very different than current attitudes.