Real Problems with Fictional Cases

doi:10.1017/CBO9780511762154.009

SIX - Real Problems with Fictional Cases

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 June 2012

Jon Adams

Edited by

Peter Howlett and

Mary S. Morgan

Show author details

Peter Howlett: Affiliation:
London School of Economics and Political Science
Mary S. Morgan: Affiliation:
London School of Economics and Political Science

Book contents

Get access

Summary

To convey science to a wider non-specialist audience, it is usually necessary to “translate” the content of specialist scientific publications into so-called “popularisations” (e.g., see Royal Society 1986). Popularisations aim to make scientific facts and theories available to audiences who do not have scientific training (see Shinn and Whitley 1985; Burham 1987). Although they are not exclusively written for nor only read by non-specialists, the popularisation is characterised by a more broad-based accessibility than would typically be found within a specialist technical publication. The nominal target audience is not assumed to possess specialist knowledge.

Therefore, popularisations are vehicles by which scientific facts travel to a wider audience. These audiences are not an homogenous mass, but comprise a variety of “publics” with different needs and different levels of scientific training. Scholarship within science studies eschews the notion of a unitary “science” and a unitary “public” in favour of more nuanced, multiple conceptions of both “science” and “public.” As Silverstone states: “There is no such thing as the communication of science; … There is no such thing as the public” (Silverstone 1991, p. 106). This view has become conventional among scholars working within science studies (e.g., Hilgartner 1990; Locke 1999; Yearly 2000; Mellor 2003; Einsiedel 2007).

Type: Chapter
Information: How Well Do Facts Travel?
The Dissemination of Reliable Knowledge
, pp. 167 - 192

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511762154.009 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Book purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Ali, Monica 2004 Brick LaneLondonBlack SwanGoogle Scholar

Amis, Martin 1991 Time’s Arrow: or, The Nature of the OffenceHarmondsworthPenguinGoogle Scholar

Anderson, Mark M. 2007

Banville, John 2001 The Revolutions Trilogy: Doctor Copernicus, Kepler, Newton Letter – An InterludeLondonPicadorGoogle Scholar

Brier, S. 2006 Ficta: Remixing generalized symbolic media in the new scientific novelPublic Understanding of Science 15 153CrossRef Google Scholar

Bryson, Bill 2004 A Short History of Nearly EverythingLondonBlack SwanGoogle Scholar

Burnham, John C. 1987 How Superstition Won and Science Lost: Popularizing Science and Health in the United StatesNew Brunswick, NJRutgers University PressGoogle Scholar

Carroll, Noël 2002 The Wheel of Virtue: Art, Literature, and Moral KnowledgeThe Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism 60 3CrossRef Google Scholar

Crichton, Michael 1990 Jurassic ParkNew YorkBallantine-Random HouseGoogle Scholar

Crichton, Michael 2004 State of FearNew YorkHarperCollinsGoogle Scholar

Crichton, Michael 2006 NextNew YorkHarperCollinsGoogle Scholar

Dawkins, Richard 1976 The Selfish GeneOxfordOxford University PressGoogle Scholar

Dawkins, Richard 1988 The Blind WatchmakerHarmondsworthPenguinGoogle Scholar

Dawkins, Richard 2004 The Ancestor’s Tale: A Pilgrimage to the Dawn of EvolutionNew YorkHoughton MifflinGoogle Scholar

Dos Passos, John 1996 U.S.A.: The 42nd Parallel/1919/The Big MoneyLudington, TownsendNew YorkLibrary of AmericaGoogle Scholar

Dudman, Clare 2003 Wegener’s JigsawLondonSceptreGoogle Scholar

Ehrlich, Paul R. 1968 The Population BombNew YorkBallantineGoogle Scholar

Einsiedel, Edna 2007 EditorialPublic Understanding of Science 16 5CrossRef Google Scholar

Fahnestock, J. 1986 Accommodating Science: The Rhetorical Life of Scientific FactsWritten Communication 3 275CrossRef Google Scholar

Faulkner, William 1991 The Sound and the FuryNew YorkVintageGoogle Scholar

Geertz, Clifford 1973 The Interpretation of Cultures: Selected EssaysNew YorkBasic BooksGoogle Scholar

Gleick, James 1987 Chaos: Making a New ScienceHarmondsworthViking-PenguinGoogle Scholar

Gleick, James 1992 Genius: Richard Feynman and Modern PhysicsLondonAbacus-Little, BrownGoogle Scholar

Govoni, Paola 2005 Historians of Science and the ‘Sobel Effect,’Journal of Science Communication 4 1Google Scholar

Greene, Brian 1999 The Elegant Universe: Superstrings, Hidden Dimensions, and the Quest for the Ultimate TheoryNew YorkNortonGoogle Scholar

Gregory, Jane 2003 The Popularization and Excommunication of Fred Hoyle’s ‘Life-from-Space’ TheoryPublic Understanding of Science 12 25CrossRef Google Scholar

Hawking, Stephen 1996 The Illustrated Brief History of TimeLondonBantam PressGoogle Scholar

Hilgartner, Stephen 1990 The Dominant View of Popularization: Conceptual Problems, Political UsesSocial Studies of Science 20 519CrossRef Google Scholar

Hofstader, Douglas 1979 Godël, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden BraidNew YorkBasic BooksGoogle Scholar

Hosseini, Khalid 2004 The Kite RunnerLondonBloomsburyGoogle Scholar

Kehlmann, Daniel 2007 Measuring the WorldJaneway, Carol BrownNew YorkVintage-Random HouseGoogle Scholar

Kirby, D.A. 2008 Cheng, D.Communicating Science in Social ContextsNew YorkSpringerGoogle Scholar

Kirby, D.A. 2008 Trench, B.Bucchi, M.Handbook of Public Communication of Science and TechnologyNew YorkRoutledgeGoogle Scholar

Koestler, Arthur 1994 Darkness at NoonLondonVintageGoogle Scholar

Krukonis, GregBarr, Tracy 2008 Evolution for DummiesHoboken, NJWiley Publishing, IncGoogle Scholar

Leane, Elizabeth 2007 Reading Popular Physics: Disciplinary Skirmishes and Textual StrategiesAldershotAshgateGoogle Scholar

Levi, Primo 1991 If This Is A Man/The TruceLondonAbacusGoogle Scholar

Lewenstein, Bruce V. 1995 From Fax to Facts: Communication in the Cold Fusion SagaSocial Studies of Science 25.3 403CrossRef Google Scholar

Lewenstein, Bruce V. 2002 Porter, GailCommunicating the Future: Best Practices for Communication of Science and Technology to the PublicGaithersburg, MDNational Institute of Standards and TechnologyGoogle Scholar

Lewis, DavidRodgers, DennisWoolcock, Michael 2008 The Fiction of Development: Literary Representation as a Source of Authoritative KnowledgeJournal of Development Studies 44 198CrossRef Google Scholar

Locke, Simon 1999 Golem science and the public understanding of science: from deficit to dilemmaPublic Understanding Science 8 75CrossRef Google Scholar

Lynch, MichaelCole, Simon 2005 Science and Technology Studies on Trial: Dilemmas of ExpertiseSocial Studies of Science 35 269CrossRef Google Scholar

McEwan, Ian 1999 Enduring Love: A NovelNew YorkAnchor-Random HouseGoogle Scholar

McEwan, Ian 2005 Jonathan, Gottschall, Wilson, David S.The Literary Animal: Evolution and the Nature of NarrativeEvanston, ILNorthwestern University PressGoogle Scholar

Mellor, Felicity 2003 Between fact and fiction: Demarcating science from non-science in popular physics booksSocial Studies of Science 33 509CrossRef Google Scholar

Miller, David P. 2002 The ‘Sobel Effect’: The Amazing Tale of How Multitudes of Popular Writers Pinched All the Best Stories in the History of Science and Became Rich and Famous While Historians Languished in Accustomed Poverty and Obscurity, and How This Transformed the World. A Reflection on a Publishing PhenomenonMetascience 2 185CrossRef Google Scholar

Miller, George A. 1956 The Magical Number Seven, Plus or Minus Two: Some Limits on Our Capacity for Processing InformationThe Psychological Review 63 81CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Mistry, Rohinton 2006 A Fine BalanceLondonFaber and FaberGoogle Scholar

Oreskes, Naomi 2005 ‘Fear’-Mongering Michael Crichton Is WrongThe San Francisco Chronicle 16 B11Google Scholar

Pinker, Steven 2002 The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human NatureHarmondsworthPenguinGoogle Scholar

Powers, Richard 1995 Galatea 2.2New YorkFarrar, Straus and GirouxGoogle Scholar

Pratchett, TerryStewart, IanCohen, Jack S. 1999 The Science of DiscworldLondonEbury PressGoogle Scholar

Pynchon, Thomas 1997 Mason & DixonNew YorkHenry HoltGoogle Scholar

Ramsden, Edmund 2006

Ridley, Matt 1994 The Red Queen: Sex and the Evolution of Human NatureHarmondsworthPenguinGoogle Scholar

Royal Society 1986 Public Understanding of Science: The Royal Society ReportsScience, Technology, and Human Values 11 53CrossRef Google Scholar

Sacks, Oliver 1987 The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a HatLondonPicadorGoogle Scholar

Sacks, Oliver 1991 AwakeningsLondonPicadorGoogle Scholar

Sacks, Oliver 1995 An Anthropologist on MarsLondonPicadorGoogle Scholar

Sacks, Oliver 2002 Uncle Tungsten: Memories of Chemical BoyhoodLondonPicadorGoogle Scholar

Sauer, Rob 1971 Voyages: Scenarios for a Ship Called EarthNew YorkZPG/Ballantine

Shermer, Michael B. 2002 This View of Science: Stephen Jay Gould as Historian of Science and Science Historian, Popular Scientist and Science PopulariserSocial Studies of Science 32 489Google Scholar

Shinn, TerryWhitley, Richard 1985 Expository Science: Forms and Functions of PopularisationDordrechtReidelCrossRef Google Scholar

Simon, Julian 1996 The State of HumanityWiley-BlackwellGoogle Scholar

Silverstone, Roger 1991 Communicating Science to the PublicScience, Technology, & Human Values 16 106CrossRef Google Scholar

Smith, Leonard 2007 Chaos: A Very Short IntroductionOxfordOxford University PressCrossRef Google Scholar

Sobel, Dava 1995 Longitude: The True Story of a Scientific Genius Who Solved the Greatest Scientific Mystery of His TimeHarmondsworthPenguinGoogle Scholar

Solzhenitsyn, Aleksandr 1970 One Day in the Life of Ivan DenisovichHarmondsworthPenguinGoogle Scholar

Strout, Cushing 1992 Border Crossings: History, Fiction, andHistory and Theory 31 153CrossRef Google Scholar

Tallis, Raymond 1995 Newton’s Sleep: Two Cultures and Two KingdomsLondonMacMillanCrossRef Google Scholar

Turner, Stephen 2001 What Is the Problem with Experts?SSS 31 123CrossRef Google Scholar

Tymoczko, Thomas 1998 New Directions in the Philosophy of Mathematics: An AnthologyPrinceton, NJPrinceton University Press

Wason, P. C. 1971 Natural and Contrived Experience in a Reasoning ProblemQuarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 23 63CrossRef Google Scholar

Watt, Ian 1987 The Rise of the Novel: Studies in Defoe, Richardson and FieldingLondonHogarthGoogle Scholar

Wheeler, William Morton 1920 The Termitodoxa, or Biology and SocietyThe Scientific Monthly 10 113Google Scholar

Yearly, Steven 2000 Making Systematic Sense of Public Discontents with Expert Knowledge: Two Analytical Approaches and a Case StudyPublic Understanding of Science 9 105CrossRef Google Scholar