Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Illustrations
- Preface
- Notes on Contributors
- 1 Introduction
- PART I ANCIENT KEYNOTES: FROM HOMER TO LUCIAN
- PART II ANCIENT MODELS, BYZANTINE COLLECTIONS: EPIGRAMS, RIDDLES AND JOKES
- PART III BYZANTINE PERSPECTIVES: TEARS AND LAUGHTER, THEORY AND PRAXIS
- PART IV LAUGHTER, POWER AND SUBVERSION
- PART V GENDER, GENRE AND LANGUAGE: LOSS AND SURVIVAL
- 17 Comforting Tears and Suggestive Smiles: To Laugh and Cry in the Komnenian Novel
- 18 Do Brothers Weep? Male Grief, Mourning, Lament and Tears in Eleventh- and Twelfth-Century Byzantium
- 19 Laments by Nicetas Choniates and Others for the Fall of Constantinople in 1204
- 20 ‘Words Filled With Tears’: Amorous Discourse as Lamentation in the Palaiologan Romances
- 21 The Tragic, the Comic and the Tragicomic in Cretan Renaissance Literature
- 22 Belisarius in the Shadow Theatre: The Private Calvary of a Legendary General
- 23 Afterword
- Appendix: CHYROGLES, or The Girl With Two Husbands
- Bibliography
- Index Locorum
- Index Rerum
23 - Afterword
from PART V - GENDER, GENRE AND LANGUAGE: LOSS AND SURVIVAL
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 20 December 2017
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Illustrations
- Preface
- Notes on Contributors
- 1 Introduction
- PART I ANCIENT KEYNOTES: FROM HOMER TO LUCIAN
- PART II ANCIENT MODELS, BYZANTINE COLLECTIONS: EPIGRAMS, RIDDLES AND JOKES
- PART III BYZANTINE PERSPECTIVES: TEARS AND LAUGHTER, THEORY AND PRAXIS
- PART IV LAUGHTER, POWER AND SUBVERSION
- PART V GENDER, GENRE AND LANGUAGE: LOSS AND SURVIVAL
- 17 Comforting Tears and Suggestive Smiles: To Laugh and Cry in the Komnenian Novel
- 18 Do Brothers Weep? Male Grief, Mourning, Lament and Tears in Eleventh- and Twelfth-Century Byzantium
- 19 Laments by Nicetas Choniates and Others for the Fall of Constantinople in 1204
- 20 ‘Words Filled With Tears’: Amorous Discourse as Lamentation in the Palaiologan Romances
- 21 The Tragic, the Comic and the Tragicomic in Cretan Renaissance Literature
- 22 Belisarius in the Shadow Theatre: The Private Calvary of a Legendary General
- 23 Afterword
- Appendix: CHYROGLES, or The Girl With Two Husbands
- Bibliography
- Index Locorum
- Index Rerum
Summary
The violence of either grief or joy
Their own enactures with themselves destroy;
Where joy most revels, grief doth most lament;
Grief joys, joy grieves, on slender accident.
Shakespeare, Hamlet, Act 3, scene 2, 202–5Laughter and tears can be dangerous things – especially when juxtaposed, as they are throughout this book, and also in the lines that serve as the epigraph to this brief epilogue. Shakespeare's lines have a bearing on the range of ambiguity explored in the foregoing chapters: they are spoken by the Player King in the play-within-a-play that (perhaps) proves the guilt of Hamlet's uncle. They are doubly part of a performance; the whole episode is a send-up in which not only Hamlet and the fictional audience but also the real audience in the theatre are encouraged to be complicit: Shakespeare parodies the cliches and conventions that were the inheritance of the late sixteenth century from the Renaissance and its Graeco-Roman hinterland. Within that parodied context, the cliche can still be dangerous. The purpose of the character played by the Player King is to seduce the character played by the Player Queen, as a prelude to the murder of her husband. The speech continues:
This world is not for aye, nor ‘tis strange
That even our loves should with our fortunes change …
The lines about grief and joy turn out to have been part of a rhetorical (and hardly logical) argument that even the most intense feelings are subject to change and perhaps were never sincere in the first place:
Our wills and fates do so contrary run
That our devices still are overthrown;
Our thoughts are ours, their ends none of our own.
(217–19)As the editors of this book set out clearly near the start of their Introduction, neither laughter nor weeping is an emotion in itself. Tears or laughter may constitute either the spontaneous, physiological manifestation of that emotion, or its performance, or ‘the enactment of elaborate social processes’ (see p. 5) – or indeed all three together.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Greek Laughter and TearsAntiquity and After, pp. 403 - 412Publisher: Edinburgh University PressPrint publication year: 2017