Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Special Section on Goethe and Idealism
- Introduction—Goethe and Idealism: Points of Intersection
- Goethe and Spinoza: A Reconsideration
- Goethean Intuitions
- Goethe's Notion of an Intuitive Power of Judgment
- “Idealism is nothing but genuine empiricism”: Novalis, Goethe, and the Ideal of Romantic Science
- The Quest for the Seeds of Eternal Growth: Goethe and Humboldt's Presentation of Nature
- Hegel's Faust
- Goethe contra Hegel: The Question of the End of Art
- Goethean Morphology, Hegelian Science: Affinities and Transformations
- Die Gretchenfrage: Goethe and Philosophies of Religion around 1800
- Civic Attachments & Sibling Attractions: The Shadows of Fraternity
- Margarete-Ariadne: Faust's Labyrinth
- Save the Prinz: Schiller's Geisterseher and the Lure of Entertainment
- Walsers Trilogie der Leidenschaft: Eine Analyse seines Goethe-Romans Ein liebender Mann im Kontext der Tradition der Ulrike-Romane
- Review Essay: What's New in the New Economic Criticism
- Book Reviews
Goethe contra Hegel: The Question of the End of Art
from Special Section on Goethe and Idealism
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 February 2013
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Special Section on Goethe and Idealism
- Introduction—Goethe and Idealism: Points of Intersection
- Goethe and Spinoza: A Reconsideration
- Goethean Intuitions
- Goethe's Notion of an Intuitive Power of Judgment
- “Idealism is nothing but genuine empiricism”: Novalis, Goethe, and the Ideal of Romantic Science
- The Quest for the Seeds of Eternal Growth: Goethe and Humboldt's Presentation of Nature
- Hegel's Faust
- Goethe contra Hegel: The Question of the End of Art
- Goethean Morphology, Hegelian Science: Affinities and Transformations
- Die Gretchenfrage: Goethe and Philosophies of Religion around 1800
- Civic Attachments & Sibling Attractions: The Shadows of Fraternity
- Margarete-Ariadne: Faust's Labyrinth
- Save the Prinz: Schiller's Geisterseher and the Lure of Entertainment
- Walsers Trilogie der Leidenschaft: Eine Analyse seines Goethe-Romans Ein liebender Mann im Kontext der Tradition der Ulrike-Romane
- Review Essay: What's New in the New Economic Criticism
- Book Reviews
Summary
Kein Mensch will begreifen, daß die höchste und einzige Operation der Natur u. Kunst die Gestaltung sei.…
(MA 20.1:197)[No one is prepared to grasp that, both in nature and in art, the sole and supreme process is the creation of form.…]
—Goethe, letter to Zelter, October 30, 1808IN THIS ESSAY I OUTLINE the basic ideas of Goethe's mature aesthetics (from the time of his Italian journey and later) and argue that Goethe's conception of art offers important alternatives and resistance to the Hegelian thesis of the “end of art.” My contribution is divided into three main parts. The first part consists of two sections devoted to articulating Goethe's aesthetics; due to the intimate connection between nature (in particular, metamorphosis) and art in Goethe, one section sketches Goethe's view of nature and scientific knowledge, while the second section articulates Goethe's conception of art as a higher metamorphosis of nature. The second main part outlines the place of art in Hegel as a moment of Absolute Spirit. I argue that Hegel's aesthetics is primarily a content aesthetics according to which art is basically a form of knowledge that is inferior to philosophy, as opposed to Goethe's, which emphasizes the significance of the unique form of art's sensual appearance. Given this difference, contrary to Goethe, Hegel does not envisage a truly unique vocation for art (for Goethe knowledge and art have two very distinct, though related, tasks).
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Goethe Yearbook 18 , pp. 127 - 158Publisher: Boydell & BrewerPrint publication year: 2011