Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Figures and Tables
- Acknowledgments
- 1 NATIONAL GOVERNMENTS AND GLOBAL CAPITAL: A RECASTING
- 2 FINANCIAL MARKET INFLUENCE ON GOVERNMENT POLICY: THEORY AND HYPOTHESES
- 3 FINANCIAL MARKET INFLUENCE IN DEVELOPED NATIONS: AN EMPIRICAL ASSESSMENT
- 4 FINANCIAL MARKET–GOVERNMENT RELATIONS IN EMERGING MARKETS
- 5 POLITICS MEETS MARKETS: DOMESTIC RESPONSES TO FINANCIAL MARKET PRESSURES
- 6 ALTERNATIVE DOMESTIC RESPONSES: CHANGES TO FINANCIAL MARKET–GOVERNMENT RELATIONS
- 7 HISTORY REPEATING ITSELF? FINANCIAL MARKETS AND NATIONAL GOVERNMENT POLICIES BEFORE THE FIRST WORLD WAR
- 8 FINANCIAL MARKET–GOVERNMENT RELATIONS IN THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY
- APPENDIX 2.1 FINANCIAL MARKET INTERVIEWS
- APPENDIX 3.1 DATA DEFINITIONS AND SOURCES
- APPENDIX 3.2 FULL RESULTS FOR MACROINDICATORS MODEL
- APPENDIX 4.1 THE COMPONENTS OF THE SDDS
- APPENDIX 4.2 RATING AGENCY METHODOLOGIES
- APPENDIX 4.3 RATING AGENCY OUTCOMES, 1997
- APPENDIX 6.1 NATIONS IN CAPITAL CONTROLS DATA SET
- References
- Index
- Titles in the series
7 - HISTORY REPEATING ITSELF? FINANCIAL MARKETS AND NATIONAL GOVERNMENT POLICIES BEFORE THE FIRST WORLD WAR
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 14 January 2010
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Figures and Tables
- Acknowledgments
- 1 NATIONAL GOVERNMENTS AND GLOBAL CAPITAL: A RECASTING
- 2 FINANCIAL MARKET INFLUENCE ON GOVERNMENT POLICY: THEORY AND HYPOTHESES
- 3 FINANCIAL MARKET INFLUENCE IN DEVELOPED NATIONS: AN EMPIRICAL ASSESSMENT
- 4 FINANCIAL MARKET–GOVERNMENT RELATIONS IN EMERGING MARKETS
- 5 POLITICS MEETS MARKETS: DOMESTIC RESPONSES TO FINANCIAL MARKET PRESSURES
- 6 ALTERNATIVE DOMESTIC RESPONSES: CHANGES TO FINANCIAL MARKET–GOVERNMENT RELATIONS
- 7 HISTORY REPEATING ITSELF? FINANCIAL MARKETS AND NATIONAL GOVERNMENT POLICIES BEFORE THE FIRST WORLD WAR
- 8 FINANCIAL MARKET–GOVERNMENT RELATIONS IN THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY
- APPENDIX 2.1 FINANCIAL MARKET INTERVIEWS
- APPENDIX 3.1 DATA DEFINITIONS AND SOURCES
- APPENDIX 3.2 FULL RESULTS FOR MACROINDICATORS MODEL
- APPENDIX 4.1 THE COMPONENTS OF THE SDDS
- APPENDIX 4.2 RATING AGENCY METHODOLOGIES
- APPENDIX 4.3 RATING AGENCY OUTCOMES, 1997
- APPENDIX 6.1 NATIONS IN CAPITAL CONTROLS DATA SET
- References
- Index
- Titles in the series
Summary
Globalization is not a new phenomenon. Governments always have been constrained. Globalization really is a catch-word. … Domestic constraints still matter, and international constraints are not much different than they were during the 19th century.
In its international methods, as in these internal methods, nineteenth century society was constricted by economics. The realm of fixed foreign exchanges was coincident with civilization. … Though, as a rule, such considerations [the need for balanced budgets] were not consciously present in the minds of statesmen, this was the case only because the requirements of the gold standard ranked as axiomatic. The uniform world pattern of monetary and representative institutions was the result of the rigid economy of the period.
Polanyi's 1944 account of the collapse of the gold standard regime, and the international economic openness required and facilitated by that regime, implicates the primacy of market forces. Although economic integration was not, in and of itself, detrimental to the functioning of democratic societies, economic integration without an accompanying system of social protection was doomed to failure. Leaders gave priority to the maintenance of external balance over all other goals, but their publics ultimately rejected the notion that currency values were the penultimate policy achievement. If the gold standard's rules – coupled with the evolving domestic political ambitions of governments – sowed the seeds of its demise, can the same be said for contemporary financial globalization? To what extent are Polanyi's criticisms of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries relevant today?
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Global Capital and National Governments , pp. 249 - 303Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2003