Base assumptions? Racial aspects of US DNA forensics

doi:10.1017/CBO9780511778193.005

4 - Base assumptions? Racial aspects of US DNA forensics

from Section 1 - Key areas in DNA profiling and databasing

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 October 2012

Harriet A. Washington

Edited by

Richard Hindmarsh and

Barbara Prainsack

Show author details

Richard Hindmarsh: Affiliation:
Griffith University, Queensland
Barbara Prainsack: Affiliation:
King's College London

Book contents

Get access

Summary

INTRODUCTION

After two decades of acceptance in US courtrooms, forensic DNA analysis remains plagued with flaws even as its use burgeons. Instead of fomenting a dialogue with the public, US lawmakers have invoked the spectre of violent crime to promulgate the passage of legislation that permits the coercion of DNA samples from ever-expanding segments of society. This leaves US citizens, who prize both privacy and security, to confront momentous policy decisions without the benefit of comprehensive public education or debate.

This chapter largely focuses on events that encapsulate many of these issues, albeit in microcosm: the US conduct of DNA sweeps. Also called DNA dragnets or DNA mass screenings, this method is a species of ‘cold hit’ in which law enforcement essays to match DNA left by an unknown miscreant with the person who left it by obtaining samples from members of the community thought to contain the criminal. The discussion will explore how, via the use of DNA sweeps, local police exploit laws in order to expand the scope of DNA profiling, collection and storage to allow the apprehension of unknown miscreants on the strength of non-specific physical descriptors. However, the ethnically heterogeneous nature of US society and the overwhelming racial disparities in arrest and incarceration present challenges that have been largely ignored.

Type: Chapter
Information: Genetic Suspects
Global Governance of Forensic DNA Profiling and Databasing
, pp. 63 - 84

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511778193.005 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Book purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Allen, J. (ed.), Lewis, J., Litwack, L. F. and Als, H. (2000). Without Sanctuary: Lynching Photography in America. Sante Fe, NM: Twin Palms.Google Scholar

,Amnesty International USA (2004). Threat and Humiliation: Racial Profiling, Domestic Security, and Human Rights in the United States. Ridgefield Park, NJ: US Domestic Human Rights Program.Google Scholar

,Anon. (1993). Court invalidates a decade of blood tests results in criminal casesNew York Times, 12 November, 20A.Google Scholar

,Anon. (2004). Tabletop DNA test lab developed. Lab Business Week, 14 November, 75.Google Scholar

Anton, L. (2008). How far to catch killer?St Petersburg Times (Florida), 1A.Google Scholar

Baker, A. and Vasquez, E. (2007). Police report far more stops and searches. New York Times, 3 February, 1A.Google Scholar

Balaban, E., Alper, J. and Kasamon, Y. (1996). Mean genes and the biology of aggression: a critical review of recent animal and human research. Journal of Neurogenetics, 11, 1–43.CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Beauchamp, T. and Childress, J. (2001). Principles of Biomedical Ethics, 5th edn. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar

Beiser, V. (2001). How we got to two million: How did the land of the free become the world's leading jailer?Mother Jones, 10 July, 2.Google Scholar

Bell, D. (1996). The Foulston & Siefkin lecture: racial libel as American ritual. Washburn Law Journal, 36, 1–7.Google Scholar

Bowman, J. (1977). Genetic screening programs and public policy. Phylon, 38: 117–142.CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Bowman, J. and Murray, R. (1990). Genetic Variation and Disorders in People of African Origin. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar

Brigham, J., Bennett, L., Meissner, C.et al. (2007). The influence of race on face identification. In Handbook of Eyewitness Psychology, Vol. 2, ed. Lindsay, R.. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, pp. 257–282.Google Scholar

Chapin, A. (2005). Arresting DNA: privacy expectations of free citizens versus post-convicted persons and the unconstitutionality of DNA dragnets. Minnesota Law Review, 89, 1842–1874.Google Scholar

Chasnoff, I, Landress, H. and Barrett, M. (1990). The prevalence of illicit-drug or alcohol use during pregnancy and discrepancies in mandatory reporting in Pinellas County, Florida. New England Journal of Medicine, 322, 1202–1206.CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Cherek, D. and Lane, S. (1999). Effects of dl-fenfluramine on aggressive and impulsive responding in adult males with a history of conduct disorder. Psychopharmacology, 146, 473–481.CrossRef Google Scholar

Cho, M. and Sankar, P. (2004). Forensic genetics and ethical, legal and social implications beyond the clinic. Nature Genetics 36, 11(Suppl 36), S8–S12.CrossRef Google Scholar

Cole, S. A. and Dioso-Villa, R. (2007). CSI and its effects: media, juries, and the burden of proof. New England Law Review, 41, 435–470Google Scholar

Duster, T. (2006). Explaining differential trust of DNA forensic technology: grounded assessment or inexplicable paranoia?Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics, 34, 293.CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Esmaili, S. (2007). Student note: searching for a needle in a haystack – the constitutionality of police DNA dragnets, Chicago-Kent Law Review, 82, 495–497.Google Scholar

Finer, J. (2005). Baffled police try DNA sweep: towns men asked to give samples in murder case, Washington Post, 12 January, A03.Google Scholar

Glod, M. (2004). DNA dragnet makes Charlottesville uneasy: race profiling suspected in hunt for rapist. Washington Post, 14 April, A01.Google Scholar

Glover, K. (2005). Racial profiling and the pretextual traffic atop: a critical look at the US Supreme Court's Whren decision. In Proceedings of the American Sociological Association Annual Meeting, Philadelphia, 12 August.Google Scholar

Grand, J. (2002). The blooding of America: privacy and the DNA dragnet. Cardozo Law Review, 23: 2277.Google Scholar PubMed

Gould, S. (1992). The Mismeasure of Man. New York: Norton.Google Scholar

Guthrie, R. (1998). Even the Rat Was White: A Historical View of Psychology, 2nd edn. Boston: Allyn and Bacon.Google Scholar

Harris, D. (1999a). Driving While Black: Racial Profiling on our Nation's Highways. [American Civil Liberties Union Special Report.] New York: American Civil Liberties Unionwww.aclu.org/racialjustice/racialprofiling/15912pub19990607.html (accessed August 2009).Google Scholar

Harris, D. (1999b). The stories, the statistics, and the law: why driving while black matters. Minnesota Law Review, 84, 265–326.Google Scholar

Harris, D. (2005). Good Cops: The Case for Preventive Policing. New York: New Press.Google Scholar

Hefler, J. (2009). N.J. bill would put state in charge of monitoring troopers. Philadelphia Inquirer, July 2, B1.Google Scholar

Henig, R. (2004). The genome in black and white (and gray). New York Times, 10 October, 47.Google Scholar

Hilts, P. (1992). Federal official apologizes for remarks on inner cities. New York Times, 22 February, 6.Google Scholar

,Human Rights Watch (2008). Targeting blacks: drug law enforcement and race in the United States. Washington, DC: United Nations Foundation http://www.hrw.org/en/node/62236/section/1 (accessed August 2009).

,Innocence Project (2009). Website. www.innocenceproject.org/ (accessed 8 January 2009)

John-Hall, A. (2009). Time to stop demonizing ‘black men’. Philadelphia Inquirer, 29 May, A13.Google Scholar

Johnson, C. and Horace, M., (1934). The investigation of racial differences prior to 1910. Journal of Negro Education, 3, 333.CrossRef Google Scholar

Kahn, J. (2004). How a drug becomes ethnic: law, commerce, and the production of racial categories in medicine. Yale Journal of Health Policy, Law and Ethics 4, 1–46.Google Scholar

Katz, J. (1972). Experimentation with Human Beings: The Authority of the Investigator, Subject, Professions, and State in the Human Experimentation Process. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar

Khanna, R. and McVicker, S. (2007). Troubling cases surface in report on HPD crime lab. Houston Chronicle, 17 June, 1.Google Scholar

Leary, W. (1992). Struggle continues over remarks by mental health official. New York Times, 8 March, 34.Google Scholar

Levine, H., Gettman, J., Reinarman, C.et al. (2008). Drug arrests and DNA: building Jim Crow's database. GeneWatch, 21, 9–11.Google Scholar

Lombroso, C. (1911). Crime, Its Causes and Remedies. [Trans. Horton, Henry P..] Boston, MA: Little, Brown, pp. 428, 447–448.Google Scholar

Lowe, A., Urquhart, A., Foreman, L.et al. (2001). Inferring ethnic origin by means of an STR profile. Forensic Science International, 119, 17–22.CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Marks, J. (1995). Human Biodiversity: Genes, Race, and History. New York: Aldine Transactions.Google Scholar

Matejik, L. (2008). DNA sampling: privacy and police investigation in a suspect society. Arkansas Law Review, 61, 53–58.Google Scholar

McGeehan, P. (2007). Spitzer wants DNA sampling in most crimes. The New York Times 14 May, 1.Google Scholar

M'charek, A. (2008). Contrasts and comparisons: three practices of forensic investigation. Comparative Sociology, 7, 387–412.CrossRef Google Scholar

,MSNBC (2007). Black, Latino drivers fare worse in traffic stops. MSNBC.COM, April 29, http://74.125.113.132/search?q=cache:rhY_WIURuo4J:www.msnbc.msn.com/id/18383182/+MSNBC+driving+while+black+2007&-cd=1 &hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us&client=firefox-a (accessed 5 March 2010).

Neufeld, P. and Scheck, B. (2007). CSI isn't like real-world crime labs. Los Angeles Times, 2 February, 18.Google Scholar

,Open Society Justice Initiative (2006). Ethnic profiling in the Moscow metro. New York: Open Society Institute http://www.soros.org/initiatives/justice/focus/equality_citizenship/articles_publications/publications/profiling_20060613 (accessed 15 March 2010).

Page, L. (2008). Scotland Yard criminologist: DNA-print troublemaker kids Give me the child, I'll lock-up the man. London Observer, 17 March, 1.Google Scholar

Peterson, R. (2000). DNA databases: when fear goes too far. American Criminal Law Review, 37, 1219–1230.Google Scholar PubMed

Philipkoski, K. (1998). A crime sniffing network. Wired News, 11 August www.wired.com/news/technology/0,282,14231,00.html (accessed July 2002).

Randerson, J. (2006). DNA of 37% of black men held by police: Home Office denies racial bias. Guardian, 7 January www.guardian.co.uk/world/2006/jan/05/race.ukcrime (accessed August 2009).

Roberts, D. (1997). Killing the Black Body: Race, Reproduction and the Meaning of Liberty. New York: Vintage Books.Google Scholar

Ross, A. and Castelle, G. (1993). In the Matter of an Investigation of the West Virginia State Police Crime Laboratory, Serology Division (Report No.21973) In the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia.

Rutledge, J. (2001). They all look alike: the inaccuracy of cross-racial identifications. American Journal of Criminal Law, 28, 207–228.Google Scholar

Rushlow, J. (2007). Rapid DNA database expansion and disparate minority impact. GeneWatch 20, 3–11.

Sampson, R. and Lauritsen, J. (1997). Racial and ethnic disparities in crime and criminal justice in the United States. Crime and Justice, 21, 311- 326.CrossRef Google Scholar

Sachs, J. (2004). DNA and a new kind of racial profiling. Popular Science 21 April, 16–20.Google Scholar

Secko, D., Preto, N., Niemeyer, S.et al. (2009). Informed consent in biobank research: a deliberative approach to the debate. [Paper No. GE3LS, W. Maurice Young Centre for Applied Ethics.]Social Science Medicine, 68, 781–789.CrossRef Google Scholar

Sellers-Diamond, A. (1994). Disposable children in black faces: the violence initiative as inner-city containment policy. University of Missouri Kansas Law Review, 62, 423–428.Google Scholar

Simoncelli, T. and Steinhardt, B. (2006). California's Proposition 69: a dangerous precedent for criminal DNA databases. Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics, 34, 199–213.CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Safir, H. (2007). DNA technology as an effective tool in reducing crime. Forensic Magazine, October/November www.forensicmag.com/articles.asp?pid=168 (accessed August 2009).

Scheck, B. and Neufeld, P. (2001). Junk science, junk evidence. New York Times, 11 May, 35.Google Scholar

Silver, J. (2004). DNA technology advancing to produce more information faster for police. Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 12 December, A3.Google Scholar

Smith, B. and Dailard, C. (2003). Black women's health in custody. In National Colloquium on Black Womens' Health. Washington, DC: Black Womens' Health Imperative, pp. 97–108.Google Scholar

Smith, G. (2007). Cash ties that bind: possible violation of city bidding rules for DNA lab linked to Safir. New York Daily News, 20 August www.nydailynews.com/news/2007/08/20/2007–08-20_cash_ties_that_bind-2.html (accessed August 2009).

Sosnowski, R. (2006). A Chip-Based Genetic Detector for Rapid Identification of Individuals. [Document No. 213911.] Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.Google Scholar

Terry, D. (1994). A woman's false accusation pains many blacks. New York Times, 6 November, 32.Google Scholar

Tolson, M. and Khanna, R. (2007). Mix-up on DNA deals HPD lab another blow: man exonerated 14 years after rape conviction. Houston Chronicle, 4 October, 1.Google Scholar

Ungvarsky, E, (2007). What does one in a trillion mean?GeneWatch, 20, 1.Google Scholar

Walker, S. (2004). Police DNA Sweeps Extremely Unproductive: A National Survey of Police DNA Sweeps. Omaha, NE: University of Nebraska Police Professionalism Initiative, Department of Criminal Justice.Google Scholar

Washington, H. A. (2001). Gene blues. Essence, 32, 88.Google Scholar

Washington, H. A. (2004). Born for evil? Stereotyping the karyotype: a case history in the genetics of aggression. In Twentieth Century Ethics of Human Subjects Research: Historical Perspectives on Values, Practices and Regulations, eds. Roelcke, V. and Maio, G.. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner, pp. 319–334.Google Scholar

Washington, H. A. (2007). Medical Apartheid: The Dark History of Medical Experimentation on Black Americans from Colonial Times to the Present. New York: Doubleday.Google Scholar

Philip, A. Ward v. George Trent (1999). Appeal from the United States District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia at Huntington 9No. 98–7267). Robert C. Chambers, District Judge. (CA-97–1107) Decided April 23, 1999.

State v. Soto (1996) 734 A.2d 350 N.J. Super. Ct. Law Div.