7.1 The Current Situation

The number of various taxa recorded so far from southern Africa is considerable (Table 7.1). There is no overall increase with time, but the reasons for this may be somewhat artificial, having to do with not only the number of sites found, which rises from five in the Eocene to 415 in the Holocene, but also with the amount of work done on each epoch. There is, however, a discernible overall pattern in which Orders became essentially stable by the Miocene, families by the Pliocene, genera (though less clearly) by the Pleistocene and species not until the Holocene, when only five species became extinct. Of these, two springboks and the Cape horse became extinct earlier in the Holocene, but the blue antelope and the quagga were only extirpated during the last century by European settlers. There are also a few families and genera that, although not extinct worldwide, no longer occur in southern Africa (Table 7.2). The family Ursidae, represented by the Pliocene Agriotherium africanum from Langebaanweg, tends to be thought of as the most surprising such occurrence but, in fact, the picas (Ochotonidae) are also today restricted to the northern hemisphere (Wilson and Reeder Reference Wilson and Reeder2005), as is the hedgehog genus Erinaceus. However, the absence of Erinaceus and of the carnivore genus Viverra is effectively an artefact of taxonomy. At one time the extant species frontalis and civetta, which still occur in southern Africa, were assigned to Erinaceus and Viverra respectively, whereas they are now considered to belong to Atelerix and Civettictis. The present absence of Gazella is also an artefact of taxonomy. Additionally, there are several taxa that have been introduced by humans, either deliberately as domesticates or accidentally during the Holocene (Table 7.3). The Holocene southern African fauna appears less diverse than that of the Pleistocene, especially in terms of genera and species. When, however, the extinct taxa are removed from consideration, there is very little difference (Table 7.4). In-depth analysis of the temporal relationship between extinct and extant forms will undoubtedly shed light on the relative diversity of the two epochs, but the Pleistocene appears to have been a period of major faunal turnover at the species level.

7.2 The Way Forward

There are two potential shortcomings of any compilation that must be acknowledged: it is both effectively a snap-shot in time and almost certainly incomplete even at the time of its publication. This being the case, to increase or, at least, prolong its usefulness some attempt must be made to offset both failings. In the past this was difficult to do and could only be effected by the publication of periodic updates. There are various major examples such as the taxonomic work Mammal Species of the World, edited by Don E. Wilson and DeeAnn M. Reeder, of which the third edition has so far been published (Wilson and Reeder Reference Wilson and Reeder2005) and a fourth edition is imminent (www.mammalsociety.org/uploads/report_files/Checklist%20Committee_0.pdf). This work is also an example of the explosion in knowledge on mammal taxonomy over the 35 years since the first edition was published. Now, online resources have made it much easier to update content and Mammal Species of the World has taken increasing advantage of this facility (www.departments.bucknell.edu/biology/resources/msw3).

Of course, it is in no way suggested the current work is comparable to this major exercise, but the principle is the same. For one thing, it is hoped that it will be unnecessary for anyone to begin at the beginning again. Instead, what appears here is very much the starting point to what can most usefully be considered a work in progress. The implication of such an approach is that it is not static but will require ongoing input and correction. To do this effectively it will be essential to establish an online database, such as Fossilworks (www.fossilworks.org), which will allow workers (both taxonomists and excavators) to add and/or correct data and keep information current. Other examples of similar databases are The East African Mammals Dentition Database (http://humanorigins.si.edu/education/website/east-african-mammals-dentition-database) and The Copenhagen Database of African Vertebrates (http://macroecology.ku.dk/resources/african-vertebrates). None of these examples is directly comparable to what is proposed here, but each has aspects that could be considered and/or included. For instance, the East African database indicates the importance of adding illustrations of the taxa while the Copenhagen site shows that dedicated software can improve maps considerably. Indeed, use of the latest technology can only improve accuracy and presentation in general. It is also to be hoped that the site could include archived copies of as many relevant publications as possible. This, of course, depends on solving any copyright issues, but it should be possible to archive many of the early, hard-to-access papers. At the least, URLs should be provided so that all can benefit from the searches of others. It is to be hoped that a southern African institution will take up the challenge to provide this service to the community.