2 - Sixteenth-Century Food Wars
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 13 May 2022
Summary
Abstract
A complex debate about diet, morals, and health occupied the Italian Renaissance literary imagination, ranging widely. Some writers advocated the appreciation of sensory pleasure and linked discernment even to peasants; others made furious attacks on foodstuffs like sausages and melons. Literary discussions over temptation and restraint; discipline and the pleasure of eating turned on a group of suspect foods in a cultural battle that involved medical prohibitions, religious associations of eating with lust, and popular lore. While a moral and disciplinary vision sought to control food discourse in medical and dietetic treatises, a counterargument advanced playfully by sixteenth-century literature put forward a new appreciation for taste and the legitimization of the idea of pleasure in eating.
Keywords: health, morals, taste, pleasure in eating, temptation, discipline
Introduction
The first chapter demonstrated that a powerful yet contested vision of social distinction implicit in food culture changed dramatically over the course of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, when the role of personal taste and pleasure in eating – in literary and non-literary representations – began to balance out traditional links between food, status, and class. In particular, the pleasures of eating two traditionally luxury foods – fresh fruit and roasted fowl – appear in literature of this period as not only possible but desirable items to consume for the lower classes. This shift took place alongside a new emphasis on refined manners at the table and a growing importance of the sense of gusto. Chapter One also focused on how Italian cuisine and culture, from the sixteenth century on, upgraded the status of greens and vegetables from their initially low place on the alimentary hierarchy virtually to the heights of aristocratic delicacies. This new appreciation for greens and vegetables, which were championed by many genres of literary works, contributed to a change that was already underway in cookbooks and dietary tracts, as well as on menus, which together fomented a significant refashioning of contemporary food culture.
But conceptions about food were not only influenced by status and class issues or by re-evaluations of traditional foodstuffs. Instead, they were also encouraged by the sixteenth-century revival of Galen and concomitant obsessions about a healthy diet and moderation in eating.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Food Culture and Literary Imagination in Early Modern ItalyThe Renaissance of Taste, pp. 87 - 148Publisher: Amsterdam University PressPrint publication year: 2022