Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Acknowledgments
- Introduction to the Second Edition – The Prisoner of Aura: The Lost World of Woody Allen
- 1 Reconstruction and Revision in Woody Allen's Films
- 2 Desire and Narrativity in Annie Hall
- 3 Manhattan
- 4 The Purple Rose of Cairo – Poststructural Anxiety Comes to New Jersey
- 5 Hannah and Her Sisters
- 6 The Eyes of God
- Conclusion to the Second Edition – Allen's Fall: Mind, Morals, and Meaning in Deconstructing Harry
- Filmography
- Selected bibliography
- Index
6 - The Eyes of God
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 14 January 2010
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Acknowledgments
- Introduction to the Second Edition – The Prisoner of Aura: The Lost World of Woody Allen
- 1 Reconstruction and Revision in Woody Allen's Films
- 2 Desire and Narrativity in Annie Hall
- 3 Manhattan
- 4 The Purple Rose of Cairo – Poststructural Anxiety Comes to New Jersey
- 5 Hannah and Her Sisters
- 6 The Eyes of God
- Conclusion to the Second Edition – Allen's Fall: Mind, Morals, and Meaning in Deconstructing Harry
- Filmography
- Selected bibliography
- Index
Summary
Many critics and writers did not overlook Woody Allen's use – or abuse – of vision as a metaphor for moral insight and blindness in Crimes and Misdemeanors. As Mary Erler, associate professor of English at Fordham University, wrote in the Sunday New York Times:
In the movie's opening scene, a testimonial dinner, the ophthalmologist Judah Rosenthal tells us he has always remembered his father's warning that God's eyes see everything – and in fact that may be why he became an eye doctor. Our hearts sink, as we see that the movie intends to link the largest of moral questions – Is there a God? Is there a moral order? Is right action in the world rewarded and evil punished? – with the exhausted metaphor of vision as moral understanding. With an ophthalmologist as hero, will it be possible to escape a certain heavy-handedness in pursuit of these themes?
Allen's oversimplification of such profound moral and philosophical questions certainly deserves some of Erler's criticism. Nevertheless, in spite of Allen's questionable development of this metaphor, the treatment of moral vision in Crimes and Misdemeanors requires further comment. Fortunately, Allen's directorial ingenuity and visual creativity in this film are not restricted to this cliché of vision and moral prescience and blindness. Allen goes beyond this metaphor to make another breakthrough movie, a film that includes humor but successfully emphasizes interior consciousness and moral ambiguity.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- The Films of Woody Allen , pp. 129 - 147Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2002