Book contents
- The Everyday Makers of International Law
- Cambridge Studies in International and Comparative Law: 170
- The Everyday Makers of International Law
- Copyright page
- Dedication
- Epigraph
- Contents
- Preface
- Abbreviations
- 1 Carnegieplein 2, 10:00 am
- 2 Coffee, Cigarettes, and International Judicial Practices
- 3 A New Generation of Litigators
- 4 Telling a Story
- 5 The Invisible Army
- 6 The Three Wise Monkeys
- 7 The Lyophilization of Life
- 8 The Memo
- 9 To Capture the World
- 10 Bricolage
- 11 The Explorer
- 12 A Four-Letter Word
- 13 What Does It Mean…
- 14 The Stage
- 15 The Moment of (Constructed) Truth
- 16 Truth Woven Together
- 17 Spijkermakersstraat 9, 8:00 pm
- Index
- Cambridge Studies in International and Comparative Law
10 - Bricolage
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 03 November 2022
- The Everyday Makers of International Law
- Cambridge Studies in International and Comparative Law: 170
- The Everyday Makers of International Law
- Copyright page
- Dedication
- Epigraph
- Contents
- Preface
- Abbreviations
- 1 Carnegieplein 2, 10:00 am
- 2 Coffee, Cigarettes, and International Judicial Practices
- 3 A New Generation of Litigators
- 4 Telling a Story
- 5 The Invisible Army
- 6 The Three Wise Monkeys
- 7 The Lyophilization of Life
- 8 The Memo
- 9 To Capture the World
- 10 Bricolage
- 11 The Explorer
- 12 A Four-Letter Word
- 13 What Does It Mean…
- 14 The Stage
- 15 The Moment of (Constructed) Truth
- 16 Truth Woven Together
- 17 Spijkermakersstraat 9, 8:00 pm
- Index
- Cambridge Studies in International and Comparative Law
Summary
This chapter turns to the judicial bureaucrats’ review of the facts and evidence on the record. As all soon discover, it is impossible to reconstruct the historical or objective truth behind a case, but only to come up with a persuasive factual narrative that obscures as much as it reveals. What may appear a structured and logical task proves more akin to bricolage. As they parse through the record, bureaucrats are bound to select the facts they deem most salient, ascribe varying weight to the scraps of information they come across, and use whatever is at hand to stitch up an assessment able to withstand scrutiny. Things get even trickier – and more uncertain – where technical or scientific evidence is involved. Some courts are better equipped to engage in extensive factual review than others. These differences notwithstanding, most international judges tend to have little patience for complex evidentiary issues, which they happily delegate to their legal assistants.
Keywords
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- The Everyday Makers of International LawFrom Great Halls to Back Rooms, pp. 185 - 200Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2022