Summary
In the previous chapter, we explored the ways in which the scenes of everyday activities which abound on medieval misericords can be seen to have carried a spiritual message for a specifically clerical audience which was attuned to their iconographic significance and by whom, after all, they were commissioned. Without the barrier of such unacknowledged symbolism to distract us, we may expect images which address devotional and doctrinal matters more explicitly to communicate directly with the viewer and, in consequence, to be in some ways more readily understandable to a modern audience no longer steeped in the subtleties of the Christian visual culture of England in the later Middle Ages. Whilst this is often the case, we shall see in the present chapter that even symbols at the heart of Christianity may, depending on the contexts in which they appear, create perplexing puzzles for the viewer. Images, after all, have always had the potential to create disagreements. Writing around the middle of the fifteenth century, Bishop Reginald Pecock was moved to defend the use of images in churches from Lollard criticism in what are essentially commonplace terms:
[T]he iye sight schewith and bringith into the ymaginacioun and into the mynde withynne in the heed of a man myche mater and long mater sooner, and with lasse labour and traueil and peine, than the heering of the eere dooth. And if this now seid is trewe of a man which can rede in bokis stories writun, that myche sooner and in schortir tyme and with lasse labour and pein in his brayn he schal come into remembraunce of a long storie bi sight, than bi the heering of othere mennys reding or bi heering of his owne reding; miche rather this is trewe of alle tho persoones whiche kunnen not rede in bokis, namelich sithen thei schulen not fynde men so redi for to rede a dosen leeuys of a book to hem, as thei schulen fynde redy the wallis of a chirche peintid or a clooth steyned or ymagis sprad abrood in dyuerse placis of the chirche. [Seeing with the eye shows and brings into the imagination and into the mind within a man's head much information, and a great deal of information sooner and with less labour, work and effort, than hearing with the ear does.[…]
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- English Medieval MisericordsThe Margins of Meaning, pp. 44 - 65Publisher: Boydell & BrewerPrint publication year: 2011