
Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Table of Contents
- Abbreviations
- Acknowledgements
- 1 Emerging Civic Urbanisms in Asia: An Introduction
- 2 Walking Tours and Community Heritage in Singapore: Civic Activism in the Making in Queenstown and Geylang
- 3 Resistance and Resilience: A Case Study of Rebuilding the Choi Yuen Village in Hong Kong
- 4 Urban Planning, Public Interest, and Spatial Justice: A Case Study of the Lo-Sheng Sanatorium Preservation Movement in Taipei
- 5 Placemaking as Social Learning: Taipei’s Open Green Programme as Pedagogical Civic Urbanism
- 6 Hong Kong’s Urban Renewal Fund: A Step towards Citizen-driven Placemaking?
- 7 Re-emerging Civic Urbanism: The Evolving State–Civil Society Relations in Community Building in Seoul
- 8 A Shifting Paradigm of Urban Regeneration in Seoul?: A Case Study of Citizen Participation in Haebangchon Urban Regeneration Project
- 9 Building Communities through Neighbourhood-based: Participatory Planning in Singapore
- 10 Beyond the Sunday Spectacle: Foreign Domestic Workers and Emergent Civic Urbanisms in Hong Kong
- 11 Holding Space, Making Place: Nurturing Emergent Solidarities within New Food Systems in Singapore
- 12 Conclusion: Civic Urbanisms and Urban Governance in Asia and Beyond
- Index
- Publications/Global Asia
10 - Beyond the Sunday Spectacle: Foreign DomesticWorkers and Emergent Civic Urbanisms in HongKong
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 19 November 2022
- Frontmatter
- Table of Contents
- Abbreviations
- Acknowledgements
- 1 Emerging Civic Urbanisms in Asia: An Introduction
- 2 Walking Tours and Community Heritage in Singapore: Civic Activism in the Making in Queenstown and Geylang
- 3 Resistance and Resilience: A Case Study of Rebuilding the Choi Yuen Village in Hong Kong
- 4 Urban Planning, Public Interest, and Spatial Justice: A Case Study of the Lo-Sheng Sanatorium Preservation Movement in Taipei
- 5 Placemaking as Social Learning: Taipei’s Open Green Programme as Pedagogical Civic Urbanism
- 6 Hong Kong’s Urban Renewal Fund: A Step towards Citizen-driven Placemaking?
- 7 Re-emerging Civic Urbanism: The Evolving State–Civil Society Relations in Community Building in Seoul
- 8 A Shifting Paradigm of Urban Regeneration in Seoul?: A Case Study of Citizen Participation in Haebangchon Urban Regeneration Project
- 9 Building Communities through Neighbourhood-based: Participatory Planning in Singapore
- 10 Beyond the Sunday Spectacle: Foreign Domestic Workers and Emergent Civic Urbanisms in Hong Kong
- 11 Holding Space, Making Place: Nurturing Emergent Solidarities within New Food Systems in Singapore
- 12 Conclusion: Civic Urbanisms and Urban Governance in Asia and Beyond
- Index
- Publications/Global Asia
Summary
Abstract
This chapter explores practices of civicurbanisms in East Asia by examining theself-organized collective activities of foreigndomestic workers in Hong Kong. Our investigationfocuses on the ‘beauty-styling’ events that enlistthe participation of a large number of Filipinoand Indonesian women on Sundays and publicholidays. By analysing the operation of theseevents and motivations of their organizers andparticipants, we offer a critical interpretationof the ideas of ‘urban commoning’ and ‘bottom-upurbanism’ and consider how such activities havecontributed to the shaping of individual andcollective aspirations of marginalized diasporiccommunities.
Keywords: Urban commoning, bottom-upurbanism, foreign domestic workers, communityempowerment, beauty styling, Hong Kong
Communal organization and collective use of resourceshave long been an integral part of the economic lifeof cities. In recent years, these practices havebeen increasingly associated with the notions of thecommons and ‘commoning’, which refer to analternative self-governing order that contrasts withthe profit-driven development model of a capitalistsystem (Casas- Cortes et al., 2014; Dellenbaugh,2015; Hou, 2017). The conception builds on earlierworks that examine everyday practices of socialreproduction and the ways in which community groupsresist dominant market relations by taking controlover the management of resources (Hardin, 1968;Ostrom, 1990). In more recent writings, scholarshave sought to develop the concept of ‘urbanco-presence and the shared use of space andresources in urban contexts (Borch and Kornberger,2015; Stavrides, 2016; Ferguson, 2014; Dellenbaughet al., 2015). The idea has often been linked to thenotion of ‘bottom-up urbanism’, underpinned byemergent struggles against the acceleratingprivatization of public assets and services amongstgrassroots communities (Harvey, 2012; Casas-Corteset al., 2014; Kickert and Arefi, 2019).
This chapter engages with the idea of ‘urban commoning’by examining the collective activities of HongKong's foreign domestic workers that have allowedthem to build up a set of resource networks withsignificant impacts on their daily lives andprospects in the future. In particular, we focus onthe organization of events relating to beautystyling that enlist the participation of a largenumber of Filipino and Indonesian female workers.These activities were first initiated by localunions as a means to raise political awareness andrecruit new members amongst migrant communities.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Emerging Civic Urbanisms in AsiaHong Kong, Seoul, Singapore, and Taipei beyondDevelopmental Urbanization, pp. 245 - 266Publisher: Amsterdam University PressPrint publication year: 2022