Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Contributors
- 1 Introduction
- 2 Teachers Unions in the United States: The Politics of Blocking
- 3 Teacher Unions in England: The End is Nigh?
- 4 Teacher Unionism in France: Making Fundamental Reform an Impossible Quest?
- 5 Teacher Unionism in Germany: Fragmented Competitors
- 6 Teachers Unions in the Nordic Countries: Solidarity and the Politics of Self- Interest
- 7 Teachers' Unions in Japan: The Frustration of Permanent Opposition
- 8 Teachers' Unions in Mexico: The Politics of Patronage
- 9 Teacher Unions in India: Diverse and Powerful
- 10 The Comparative Politics of Education: Teachers Unions and Education Systems Around the World
- Index
- References
6 - Teachers Unions in the Nordic Countries: Solidarity and the Politics of Self- Interest
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 December 2016
Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Contributors
- 1 Introduction
- 2 Teachers Unions in the United States: The Politics of Blocking
- 3 Teacher Unions in England: The End is Nigh?
- 4 Teacher Unionism in France: Making Fundamental Reform an Impossible Quest?
- 5 Teacher Unionism in Germany: Fragmented Competitors
- 6 Teachers Unions in the Nordic Countries: Solidarity and the Politics of Self- Interest
- 7 Teachers' Unions in Japan: The Frustration of Permanent Opposition
- 8 Teachers' Unions in Mexico: The Politics of Patronage
- 9 Teacher Unions in India: Diverse and Powerful
- 10 The Comparative Politics of Education: Teachers Unions and Education Systems Around the World
- Index
- References
Summary
Introduction
Teacher unions in the Scandinavian countries (Denmark, Norway and Sweden) were once exceptionally powerful, a situation facilitated by the corporatist political system and the social democrats – the largest political party. However, corporatist governance and social democracy have weakened over the last three decades, which has reduced teacher unions’ influence on national policy formulation and diminished their bargaining power. Nevertheless, teacher unions have proved resilient as they have found new allies and avenues, especially at local level, to exercise their power. The diminution of teacher union power across the Scandinavian states has varied considerably – the Swedish teacher unions have experienced greater reduction of power than their counterparts in Norway and Denmark. In striking contrast to Scandinavia, the single teacher union in Finland has remained immensely influential and therefore is a bit of an outlier.
Research on teacher unions in the Nordic countries is sparse, particularly in Finland, and tends to be conducted by researchers commissioned by teacher unions. There are no studies on how the teacher unions as political actors have exercised power through a corporatist tradition that makes the unions part of the political system and the civil administration. The close involvement of organised interests in public policy-making – which makes such interests an integral part of the political structure of the Nordic countries – is evidenced in numerous studies that place Scandinavia, but not Finland, at the upper end of scales measuring the degree of interest integration (Lijphart and Crepaz 1991; Rommetvedt 2003: 134). The corporate system affords teacher unions a number of opportunities to exercise influence over policy initiatives, legislative decision-making and policy implementation. In order to understand the extent to which teacher unions are enabled to influence policy, it is crucial to investigate this system of corporatism and how it has changed in recent years. Corporatism can be understood as an ‘institutional arrangement whereby important political-economic decisions are reached via negotiations between or in consultation with peak-level representation of employees and employers (or other interest groups and the state)’ (Kenworthy 2003: 11).
The first part of the chapter will analyse how and why corporatism and social democracy were propitious for the rise of teacher union power, and in which ways the unions’ interests played out in education politics and collective bargaining from the interwar period until the 1980s.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- The Comparative Politics of EducationTeachers Unions and Education Systems around the World, pp. 144 - 191Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2016
References
(2002) From an industrial to a post-industrial society: Changing conceptions of equality in education. Educational Review
54(2): 173–81.Google Scholar
(2010) Bounded Rationality in Finnish Education Policy. In , , and , eds, Education in Political Science. Discovering a Neglected Field. New York: Routledge.
(1989) Öppna karteller och sociale inhägnader. In , ed., Kampen om yrkesutövning, status och kunskap: professionaliseringens sociala grunder.
Lund: Studentlitteratu.
(2006) Between Growth and Security: Swedish Social Democracy From a Strong Society to a Third Way.
Manchester: Manchester University Press.
, and (2009) Party competition and the resilience of corporatism. Government and Opposition
44(2): 167–87.Google Scholar
, , and (2010) Social democrats, unions and corporatism: Denmark and Sweden compared. Party Politics
17(1): 118–34.Google Scholar
(2011) Privatisation of public education? The emergence of independent upper secondary schools in Sweden. Journal of Education Policy
26(2): 225–43.Google Scholar
(1999) Party system change in Scandinavia since 1970: ‘Restricted change’ or ‘general change’?
West European Politics
22(3): 139–58.Google Scholar
(2007) The end of the social democratic hegemony? The March 2007 Finnish general election. West European Politics
30: 1148–57.Google Scholar
(2009) From a contingent party system to party system convergence? Mapping party system change in postwar Finland. Scandinavian Political Studies
32(2): 221–39.Google Scholar
(2003) Party politics and the common good in Swedish local government. Scandinavian Political Studies
26(2): 93–123.Google Scholar
(2000) Still corporatism in Scandinavia? A survey of recent empirical findings. Scandinavian Political Studies
23(2): 157–81.Google Scholar
(2001) Organized interest and the state: A disintegrating relationship? Evidence from Denmark.
European Journal of Political Research 39(3): 391–416.Google Scholar
(1971) Kampen om skolelovene af 1958. En studie i interesseorganisationers politiske aktivitet. Odense University Press.
et al. (1974) Lærerne og folkeskolen gennem 100 år. København: Danmarks Lærerforening.
(1966) Lærerinteresser of læreruddannelse. Aarbog for dansk skolehistorie. Copenhagen: Selskabet for Skole- og Uddannelseshistorie.
(1998) Institutioner, politikere og brugere. In , ed., Offentligt og effektivt? Institutionelle valg i den offentlige sektor.
Copenhagen: Gyldendal.
(2000) Governance and Devolution in the Danish School System. In , and , eds, The Governance of Schooling: comparative studies of devolved management. London: Routledge.
, and (1999) From corporatism to lobbyism? Parliaments, executives, and organized interests in Denmark and Norway. Scandinavian Political Studies
22.Google Scholar
., and (2006) Power and democracy in Denmark: Still a viable democracy?
Scandinavian Political Studies
29(1): 1–24.Google Scholar
, and (2005) State, market, and civil forces in the governance of education: The case of Sweden, France, Germany, the Czech Republic. European Education 37(1): 26–45.Google Scholar
., ., and (2001) Reasons for school choice in the Netherlands and in Finland. Occational Paper No. 24. National Center for the Study of Privatization in Education, Teachers College, Columbia University.
(2014) Explaining change and inertia in Swedish and French education: A tale of two corporatisms?
Policy Studies
35(3): 282–302.Google Scholar
, and (1987) Fra Lokalkreds til fagforening. De lokale fagforeningers tilblivelsesproces i Danmarks lærerforening. Første rapport i forskningsprojektet fremtidens skole/fremtidens lærerforening.
København: Institut for Kultursociologi.
(2007) In search of an identity: Finland's Left Alliance and the experience of coalition government. Contemporary Politics
13(1): 37–55.Google Scholar
(1983) The nation-building process and the development of the secondary school system in Finland, Norway and Sweden at the end of the 19th century. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research
27(1): 1–14.Google Scholar
(2002) The new Swedish regime for collective bargaining and conflict resolution: A comparative perspective. European Journal of Industrial Relations
8(2): 197–216.Google Scholar
(1985) Politics Against Markets: The Social Democratic Road to Power. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
and (2008) Comparative Study of Teachers’ Pay in Europe.
Brussels: EI/ETUCE joint research project.
(1999) The Danish welfare state under bourgeois reign. The dilemma of popular entrenchment and economic constraints. Scandinavian Political Studies
22(3): 243–60.Google Scholar
(2002) New management reforms of the Danish and Swedish welfare states: The role of different social democratic responses. Governance: An International Journal of Policy, Administration, and Institutions
15(2): 271–94.Google Scholar
, and (2005) Bloc politics vs. broad cooperation? The functioning of Danish minority parliamentarism. Journal of Legislative Studies
11(2): 153–69.Google Scholar
, and (2007) Towards a new professionalism in school? A comparative study of teacher autonomy in Norway and Sweden. European Educational Research Journal
6(3): 232–48.Google Scholar
(2006) Uddannelserne i årets løb. Folketingsåret 2005–2006. Uddannelseshistorie. København: Selskabet for Skole-og Uddannelseshistorie.
(2010) Hvorfra – hvorhen? Tendenser og lovændringer mv. i dansk uddannelsespolitik 1998–2010. Uddannelseshistorie. København: Selskabet for Skole-og Uddannelseshistorie.
(2013) Lærerlockout, lektiecafeer og lavere SU – uddannelserne i folketingsåret 2012–2013. Uddannelseshistorie. København: Selskabet for Skole-og Uddannelseshistorie.
, Larsen, T.P., Madsen, J.S., and J. Due (2011) Challenging Scandinavian employment relations: The effects of new public management reforms. The International Journal of Human Resource Management
22(11): 2295–310.Google Scholar
(1990) Education as a discipline in Finland. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research 34(4): 271–84.Google Scholar
(2003) Teacher Education in Finland: Current Models and New Developments. In , L. Vlasceanau, and L.C. Barrows, eds, Institutional Approaches to Teacher Education within Higher Education in Europe. Bucharest: UNESCO Studies on Higher Education.
(2003) Quantitative indicators of corporatism. International Journal of Sociology 33(3): 10–44.Google Scholar
(2001) The Nordic welfare state in Finland. Scandinavian Journal of History
26(3): 225–47.Google Scholar
(2006) A Concise History of Finland. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
, and (1990) The university, the state and the professional interest groups: A Finnish lesson in university development policy. Higher Education Policy
3(3): 15–18.Google Scholar
, and (1994) The thirst for learning, or protecting one's niche? The shaping of teacher training in Finland during the 19th and 20th centuries. British Journal of Sociology of Education
15(4): 515–27.Google Scholar
, Floris, T.S., Granberg, M., Montin, S, Rieper, O., and S.I. Valo (2000) Renewal of local government in Scandinavia: Effects for local politicians. Local Government Studies
26(2): 93–116.Google Scholar
(2007) Why are they doing it? Social democracy and market-oriented welfare state reforms. West European Politics
30(1): 172–94.Google Scholar
(1976) Interest Groups in Norwegian Politics. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget.
(2009) The Municipal Takeover of the School System. SSE/EFI Working Paper Series in Business Administration No. 2011: 2.
(2008) Finnish Strategy for High-Level Education for All. In and , eds, Governance and Performance of Education Systems: 305–24. Springer.
(1999) Local school choice policies in Sweden. Scandinavian Political Studies
22: 137–156.Google Scholar
, and M.M.L. Crepaz (1991) Corporatism and consensus democracy in eighteen countries. British Journal of Political Science. 21(1): 235–46.Google Scholar
, , , and (2002) Educating for the New Sweden?
Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research 46(3): 283–303.Google Scholar
, and (2005) Policy reform and the decline of corporatism in Sweden. West European Politics
28(5): 1057–74.Google Scholar
(2002) Sweden: Decentralization, deregulation, quasi-markets – and then what?
Journal of Education Policy 17(6): 687–97.Google Scholar
(2006) Education politics and teachers: Sweden and some comparisons with Great Britain. Hitotsubshi Journal of Social Studies 38 (1): 63–78.Google Scholar
, , , and (2010) Setting things right? Swedish upper secondary school reform in a 40-year perspective. Journal of Education 45(1): 46–59.Google Scholar
, and (2002) Government formation in the Nordic countries: The electoral connection. Scandinavian Political Studies
25(3): 259–80.Google Scholar
, and (2012) Contested discourses of teacher professionalism: Current tensions between education policy and teachers unions. Journal of Education Policy 27(6): 815–33.Google Scholar
(2006) Welfare-ideological change in Scandinavia: A comparative analysis of partisan welfare state positions in four Nordic countries, 1970–2003. Scandinavian Political Studies 29(4): 356–85.Google Scholar
, , , , , and (2011) Disrupted exchange and declining corporatism: Government authority and interest group capability in Scandinavia. Government and Opposition. 46(3): 365–91.Google Scholar
OECD (1994) Quality in Teaching. OECD (Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development): Paris.
(2002) Divided Government in Finland. From a Semi-Presidential to a Parliamentary Democracy. In , ed., Divided Government in Comparative Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
., ., and (2006) Education Policy and Intergenerational Income Mobility: Evidence from the Finnish Comprehensive School Reform. IZA Discussion Paper No. 2204. http://ssrn.com/abstract=920645
. (2008) Lärayrkets uppkomst och förändring: en sociologisk studie av lärares villkor, organisering och yrkesprojekt inom den grunläggende utbildningen i Sverige ca. 1800-2000. Akademisk avhandling. Göteborg: Sociologiska institutionen, universitetet.
(2014). Counter from the Catheda. Democratic School Workers Association redefining teachers’ political agency in Finland, 1973–1989. Pedagogica Historica 50(4): 533–53.Google Scholar
(2008). Private school diversity in Denmark's national voucher system. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research
52(4): 331–54.Google Scholar
, and (2007) The curse of success: The impact of the OECD's Programme for International Student Assessment on the discourses of the teaching profession in Finland. European Educational Research Journal
6: 438–63.Google Scholar
, and (2009) The uses of the national PISA results by Finnish officials in central government. Journal of Education Policy. 24(5): 539–56.Google Scholar
(1988) The Formation and Professionalization of the Popular Teachers in Finland in the 20th Century. In , and , eds, Läraren i 1900-talets kultur och samhälle. Turun yliopiston kasvatustieteiden tiedekunnan julkaisuja, B26: 106–48.
(2000) The globalisation of education: Finnish education at the doorstep of the new millennium. Educational Review. 52(2): 131–42.Google Scholar
, , and (2002) Shoots of revisionist education policy or just slow readjustment? The Finnish case of educational reconstruction. Journal of educational policy
17(6): 643–58.Google Scholar
(2003) The Rise of the Norwegian Parliament. London: Frank Cass.
(2005) Norway: Resources count, but votes decide? From neo-corporatist representation to neo-pluralist parliamentarism. West European Politics. 28(4): 740–63.Google Scholar
(1992a) Den korporative staten: intresseorganisationer och statsförvaltning i svensk politik. Stockholm: Nordstedts juridik: Allmänna förlaget.
(1992b) Explaining Swedish corporatism: The formative moment. Scandinavian Political Studies. 15(3): 173–91.Google Scholar
(1997) Den svenska modellens institutionella arv. In: , ed., Fackliga organisationsstrategier. Solna: Arbetslivsinstitutet. Stockholm: TCO.
(2004) Vegar til samling. Norsk lærarlags historie 1966–2006. [Roads to unification. The history of Norwegian teacher unions 1966–2006]. Oslo: Det Norske Samlaget.
(2011) Schooling for money: Swedish education reforms and the role of the profit motive. Economic Affairs (October). Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.Google Scholar
(2015) Real Finnish Lessons. The True Story of an Education Superpower. Surrey: Centre for Policy Studies.
, and (2011) Is traditional teaching all that bad? A within-student between-subject approach. Economics of Education Review. 30(2): 365–79.Google Scholar
(2006) The Age of Social Democracy. Norway and Sweden in the Twentieth Century. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
(1993) Educational Science, the State, and Teachers. Forming the Corporate Regulation of Teacher Education in Finland. In , ed., Changing Pattern of Power, Self Regulation and Teacher Education Reform. New York: State University of New York.
(1998) Decontextulizing teachers’ knowedge: Finnish didactics and teacher education curricula during the 1980s and 1990s. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research
42(4): 325–38.Google Scholar
(2005) The Finnish miracle of PISA: Historical and sociological remarks on teaching and teacher education. Comparative Education
41(4): 455–70.Google Scholar
, , and (1997) Didactics closure: Professionalization and pedagogic knowledge in Finnish teacher education. Teaching and Teacher Education
13(8): 887–91.Google Scholar
, , and (2002) Abdication of the education state or just shifting responsibilities? The appearance of a new system of reason in constructing educational governance and social exclusion/inclusion in Finland. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research
46(3): 247–64.Google Scholar
, , , , and (2009) Quality assurance and evaluation (QAE) in Finnish compulsory schooling: A national model or just unintended effects of radical decentralisation?
Journal of Education Policy
42(2): 163–78.Google Scholar
(2010) Wage scales and centralized bargaining: A binding constraint on the wage-setting?
Applied Economics Letters
17(3): 247–50.Google Scholar
(2002) Conflict resolution in the Nordic countries. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research
8: 670–87.Google Scholar
(2004) Teacher Policy Reforms in Sweden: The Case of Individualised Pay. International Institute for Educational Planning, UNESCO.
, and (2002) Labour market organisations’ participation in Swedish public policy-making. Scandinavian Political Studies
25(4): 295–315.Google Scholar
(1993) Et typisk Hernes-år. In Skolen 1993–1994. Årbok for norsk utdanninghistorie. Selskapet for norsk skolehistorie.
(2005) Kunnskapsløftet – Ny eller gammel skole. Beskrivelse og analyse av Kristin Clemets reformer i grunnoplæringen. Oslo: Cappelen Akademisk Forlag.
., ., and (2004) From collectivism to individualism? Education as nation building in a Scandinavian perspective. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research 48(2): 141–58.Google Scholar
(2000) New organisational solutions in Norwegian local councils: Leaving a puzzling role for local politicians?
Scandinavian Political Studies
23(4): 343–72.Google Scholar
(2011) Friskölor i förandring. In J. Hartman, ed., Konkurrencens konsekvenser. Vad händer med svensk velfärd. Stockholm: SNS Förlag.
(2008). Knowledge and solidarity: The Norwegian social-democratic school project in a period of change, 1945–2000. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research
52(1): 1–15.Google Scholar
, and (2010) Market-oriented school reform in England and Finland: School choice, finance and governance. Educational Studies 36(1): 1–12.Google Scholar
(2009) Education and Social Integration. The Development of Comprehensive Schooling in Europe. New York: Palgrave MacMillan.
(2013) Neo-liberalism and universal state education: The cases of Denmark, Norway and Sweden 1980–2011. Comparative Education
48(2): 407–23.Google Scholar
(2015) Privatizing education: Free school policy in Sweden and England. Comparative Education Review
59(3): 473–97.Google Scholar
, and (2017) Why school choice reforms in Denmark fail: The blocking power of the teacher union. European Journal of Education.Google Scholar
- 6
- Cited by