Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Preface
- Acknowledgements
- Table of cases
- Table of statutes
- Table of statutory instruments
- Table of international instruments
- Part One Theoretical perspectives and international sources
- Part Two Promoting consultation and decision-making
- Part Three Children's rights and parents' powers
- 9 Children's rights versus family privacy – physical punishment and financial support
- 10 Parents' decisions and children's health rights
- 11 Educational rights for children in minority groups
- 12 Educational rights for children with disabilities
- 13 Children's right to know their parents – the significance of the blood tie
- 14 Children's right to know and be brought up by their parents
- 15 An abused child's right to state protection
- 16 Right to protection in state care and to state accountability
- 17 The right of abused children to protection by the criminal law
- 18 Protecting the rights of young offenders
- 19 Conclusion – themes and the way ahead
- Appendix I UN Convention on the Rights of the Child
- Appendix II Human Rights Act 1998
- Index
- References
9 - Children's rights versus family privacy – physical punishment and financial support
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 June 2012
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Preface
- Acknowledgements
- Table of cases
- Table of statutes
- Table of statutory instruments
- Table of international instruments
- Part One Theoretical perspectives and international sources
- Part Two Promoting consultation and decision-making
- Part Three Children's rights and parents' powers
- 9 Children's rights versus family privacy – physical punishment and financial support
- 10 Parents' decisions and children's health rights
- 11 Educational rights for children in minority groups
- 12 Educational rights for children with disabilities
- 13 Children's right to know their parents – the significance of the blood tie
- 14 Children's right to know and be brought up by their parents
- 15 An abused child's right to state protection
- 16 Right to protection in state care and to state accountability
- 17 The right of abused children to protection by the criminal law
- 18 Protecting the rights of young offenders
- 19 Conclusion – themes and the way ahead
- Appendix I UN Convention on the Rights of the Child
- Appendix II Human Rights Act 1998
- Index
- References
Summary
Introduction
Parents are best placed to protect and promote their children's rights and the vast majority of them do so very happily. Nevertheless, the privacy of family life ensures that parents can also tyrannise and abuse their children. Indeed, the physical dependence of young children makes an imbalance in power between them and their parents inevitable. It is clear that the law could do more to ensure that parents paid greater attention to their children's rights, if it took a more interventionist role. But social policy, strongly influenced by common assumptions about family privacy and parental autonomy, reflects a distinct lack of sympathy for the view that the law should attempt to interfere with family life.
This chapter starts by assessing the extent to which the assumption that the family should be free from legal regulation underlies current legislation governing the relationship between children and their parents. It then considers two areas which, despite being very different in content, demonstrate well the law's reluctance to intervene in order to promote children's rights. It assesses first the legal principles governing parents' right to control and discipline their children as they think fit. Second, it considers the law's treatment of the child's right to financial support and to be brought up with a reasonable standard of living. Both areas of law reflect how the concept of ‘private ordering’ dominates policies in these fields.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Children's Rights and the Developing Law , pp. 321 - 362Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2009