Speculative grammar

doi:10.1017/CHOL9780521226059.015

13 - Speculative grammar

from IV - Logic in the high middle ages: semantic theory

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 28 March 2008

Edited by

Jan Pinborg and

Get access

Summary

Grammar in the early Middle Ages

Medieval speculative grammar grew out of the schoolmens' work with ancient Latin grammar as it had been transmitted in the canonical works of Donatus and Priscian. The efforts of early medieval glossators were directed towards explaining the authoritative texts, towards systematising the descriptional apparatus used by the authors, and towards harmonising the apparent or real contradictions which arose in a comparison of the grammatical and logical traditions. The results of their combined efforts were summarised in the famous Summa super Priscianum compiled about 1140 by Peter Helias. The grammarians' discussions, which had been influenced by the logicians, in their turn influenced and refined logical doctrine and played an important role in the emergence of the specifically medieval logical doctrines known collectively as terminist logic. The grammatical discussions about the meaning of substantive words, for instance, were crucial to the development of the theory of supposition. The twelfth-century grammarians emphasised the importance of explaining linguistic features causally, instead of just describing them as Priscian had done, and in this way attained a high degree of linguistic sophistication. But it would perhaps be too much to say that their efforts already inaugurated a new paradigm of linguistic description.

The general nature of ‘modistic’ grammar

Around 1270, however, a new theoretical framework was established. The phases of the development which brought this about are not yet known in detail, but the first representatives of the new doctrine seem to be Boethius of Dacia and Martin of Dacia.

Type: Chapter
Information: The Cambridge History of Later Medieval Philosophy
From the Rediscovery of Aristotle to the Disintegration of Scholasticism, 1100–1600
, pp. 254 - 270

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CHOL9780521226059.015 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 1982

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Book purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Boethius, Dacia (1969). Quaestiones super Priscianum maiorem ed. Pinborg, J. and Roos, H. (Corpus Philosophorum Danicorum Medii Aevi 4), GadGoogle Scholar

Boethius, Dacia (1976). De aeternitate mundi, ed. Green-Pedersen, N.J. in Boethii Daci Opera (Corpus Philosophorum Danicorum Medii Aevi, 6), GadGoogle Scholar

Boethius, Dacia (1976). Quaestiones super librum Topicorum, ed. Green-Pedersen, N.J. and Pinborg, J. (Corpus Philosophorum Danicorum Medii Aevi VI, 1), GadGoogle Scholar

Brown, Stephen F. (1973) ‘Walter Burleigh's Middle Commentary on Aristotle's Perihermeneias’, Franciscan Studies 33 :Google Scholar

Bursill-Hall, G. L. (1971). Speculative Grammars of the Middle Ages (Approaches to Semantics, II), MoutonCrossRef Google Scholar

Ebbesen, S. (1972). ‘Anonymi Bodleiani in Sophisticos Elenchos Aristotelis Commentarii fragmentum’, CIMAGL 8 :Google Scholar

Ebbesen, S. ed. (1977a). Incertorum auctorum Quaestiones super Sophisticos Elenchos (Corpus Philosophorum Danicorum Medii Aevi, 7), GadGoogle Scholar

Ebbesen, S. (1977c). ‘Can Equivocation Be Eliminated?’, Studia Mediewistyczne 18:.Google Scholar

Ebbesen, S. (1979). ‘The Dead Man is Alive’, Synthese 40:.CrossRef Google Scholar

Ebbesen, S. and Pinborg, J. (1970). ‘Studies in the Logical Writings Attributed to Boethius de Dacia’, CIMAGL 3:.Google Scholar

Fredborg, K. M. (1977) ‘tractatus glosarum prisciani in ms vat. lat. 1486’, cimagl 21:.Google Scholar

Fredborg, K. M., Nielsen, L. and Pinborg, J. (1978). ‘an unedited part of roger bacon's opus maius: de signis’, traditio 34:.Google Scholar

Heath, Terrence (1971). ‘Logical Grammar, Grammatical Logic, and Humanism in Three German Universities’, Studies in the Renaissance 18:.CrossRef Google Scholar

Hunt, R. W. (1949–50). ‘Studies on Priscian in the Twelfth Century’, Mediaeval and Renaissance Studies 1 : ; 2:Google Scholar

John, Dacia (1955). Opera, ed. Otto, A. (Corpus Philosophorum Danicorum Medii Aevi, 1), GadGoogle Scholar

Kneepkens, C. H. (1977). ‘The Relatio simplex in the Grammatical Tracts of the Late Twelfth and Early Thirteenth Century’, Vivarium 15:.CrossRef Google Scholar

Kneepkens, C. H. (1978). ‘Master Guido and his View on Government: On Twelfth Century Linguistic Thought’, Vivarium 16:.CrossRef Google Scholar

Kretzmann, Norman (1970). ‘Medieval Logicians on the Meaning of the Propositio’, Journal of Philosophy 67:CrossRef Google Scholar

Lyons, J. (1977). Semantics I–II, Cambridge University PressGoogle Scholar

Manin, Dacia (1961). Opera, ed. Roos, H. (Corpus Philosophorum Danicorum Medii Aevi, 2), GadGoogle Scholar

Pinborg, Jan (1967a). Die Entwicklung der Sprachtheorie im Mittelalter (BGPM XLII, 2), AschendorffGoogle Scholar

Pinborg, Jan (1971a). ‘Bezeichnung in der Logik des Mittelalters’ in Der Begriff der Repraesentatio im Mittelalter (Miscellanea Mediaevalia, 8), De GruyterGoogle Scholar

Pinborg, Jan (1971b). ‘Simon of Faversham's Sophisma: Universale est Intentio: A Supplementary Note’, Mediaeval Studies 33:.CrossRef Google Scholar

Pinborg, Jan (1972). Logik und Semantik im Mittelalter — Ein Überblick (Problemata, 10), Frommann-HolzboogGoogle Scholar

Pinborg, Jan (1973a). ‘Petrus de Alvernia on Porphyry’, CIMAGL 9:.Google Scholar

Pinborg, Jan (1973b). ‘A New Ms. of the Questions on the Post. Anal. Attributed to Petrus de Alvernia with the Transcription of some Questions Related to Problems of Meaning’, CIMAGL 10:.Google Scholar

Pinborg, Jan (1975a). ‘Die Logik der Modistae’, Studia Mediewistyczne 16:.Google Scholar

Pinborg, Jan (1975b). ‘Radulphus Brito's Sophism on Second Intentions’, Vivarium 13:.CrossRef Google Scholar

Pinborg, Jan (1975c). ‘A Note on Some Theoretical Concepts of [Medieval] Logic and Grammar’, ‘Grabmann’, Revue Internationale de Philosophie, 29e année, 113:Google Scholar

Pinborg, Jan (1976a). ‘Some Problems of Semantic Representations in Medieval Logic’ in Parrett, H. (ed.) History of Linguistic Thought and Contemporary Linguistics, De GruyterGoogle Scholar

Priscian, (1855–9). Institutionsgrammaticae, ed. Hertz, Martin (Grammatici Latini), Teubner (Reprinted Georg Olms 1961)Google Scholar

Radulphus, Brito (1980). Quaestiones super Priscianum minorem, ed. Enders, Heinz W. and Pinborg, Jan (Grammatica Speculativa, 3), Frommann-Holzboog.Google Scholar

Rijk, L. M. ed. (1962–7). Logica modernorum: A contribution to the History of Early Terminist Logic. I: On the Twelfth Century Theories of Fallacy (1962); II, 1: The Origin and Early Development of the Theory of Supposition; II, 2: Texts and Indices (1967), Van GorcumGoogle Scholar

Robert, Kilwardby (1975). ‘The Commentary on Priscianus maior Ascribed to Robert Kilwardby’, ed. Pinborg, J. et al., CIMAGL 15:Google Scholar

Roger, Bacon (1902). The Greek Grammar of Roger Bacon and a Fragment of his Hebrew Grammar, ed. Nolan, E. and Hirsch, S. A., Cambridge University PressGoogle Scholar

Roger, Bacon (1978). De signis, ed. Fredborg, K. M. et al., in Fredborg, et al. 1978Google Scholar

Roos, H. (1977). ‘Henrici Roos in Memoriam. Nachgelassene Papiere’, CIMAGL 24:.Google Scholar

Siger, Courtrai (1978). Summa Modorum Significandi – Sophismata, ed. Pinborg, J. (Amsterdam Studies in the Theory and History of Linguistic Science, III: Studies in the History of Linguistics, 14), BenjaminsGoogle Scholar

Simon, Faversham (1957). Opera omnia, vol. 1; Opera logica, tomus prior: Quaestiones super libro Porphyrii, Quaestiones super libro Praedicamentorum, Quaestiones super libro Perihermeneias, ed. Mazzarella, P., CedamGoogle Scholar

Thurot, Charles (1868). Extraits de divers manuscrits latins pour servir à I'histoire des doctrines grammatical au moyen-âge, Imprimerie impérialeGoogle Scholar

Trentman, J. A. (1975). ‘Speculative Grammar and Transformational Grammar; A Comparison of Philosophical Presuppositions’, in Parret, Herman (ed.) History of Linguistic Thought and Contemporary Linguistics, De GruyterGoogle Scholar

William, Ockham (1957b). Expositio super viii libros Physicorum, Prologus in Ockham, William 1957aGoogle Scholar

William, Ockham (1974a). Opera philosophica [OP] I: Summa logicae, ed. Boehner, P., Gál, G., and Brown, S., in Ockham, William 1967–Google Scholar

William, Ockham (1977a). OT III: Scriptum in librum primum Sententiarum, Ordinatio; Distinctiones IV–XVII, ed. Etzkorn, G. I. in Ockham, William 1967–Google Scholar