1970s to Present – A Time of Convergence?

Steven A. Bank

doi:10.1017/CBO9781139013284.008

7 - 1970s to Present – A Time of Convergence?

from Part III - Conclusion

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 07 October 2011

Steven A. Bank

Show author details

Steven A. Bank: Affiliation:
University of California, Los Angeles

Book contents

Get access

Summary

The three themes discussed in the previous chapters – profits, power, and politics – have each continued to influence the modern debate over corporate tax reform in the United Kingdom and the United States during the last twenty years. American politicians have maintained their focus on the paucity of dividends and the actions of managers while their British counterparts revived their concern about shareholder expropriation and inadequate retained earnings. Moreover, political changes have ushered in dramatic reforms in both countries, although in the case of the USA the modification to the tax treatment of dividends that was ultimately enacted in 2003 was once again less radical than the original proposal and fell short of the goal of full integration. In the latest round of reforms, these common themes seem to be pushing the two systems toward convergence rather than divergence, which seems predictable in light of the growth of multinational corporations and the globalization of commerce. What is uncertain, however, is the effect of developments outside of each country, such as the growing power of the European Union, the European Court of Justice, and other countries, in dictating whether convergence is inevitable or even possible.

United Kingdom

In the mid 1990s, the UK once again became concerned with dividends and firm investment. A 1995 study published by the Institute for Fiscal Studies (“IFS”) announced that there had been a dramatic rise in the percentage of profits paid out as dividends during the previous decade. In a press release accompanying this announcement, the IFS noted that “[t]he dividend payout ratio . . . is higher in the UK than in any other major economy. There is a danger that these high dividend payouts are having an adverse effect on business investment.” Other studies reached similar conclusions regarding the dangers of increased dividends. By 1997, with dividends continuing to rise and Labour poised to retake power for the first time in eighteen years, the corporate tax system appeared to be headed for another revision.

Type: Chapter
Information: Anglo-American Corporate Taxation
Tracing the Common Roots of Divergent Approaches
, pp. 223 - 249

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139013284.008 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Bond, StephenCompany Dividends and Taxes in the UKFiscal Studies 16 1996 3Google Scholar

Gammie, MalcolmThe End of Imputation: Changes in UK Dividend TaxationIntertax 25 1997 333Google Scholar

Riley, BarryReaping Tory dividendsFinancial TimesLondon 1997 1Google Scholar

Peston, RobertBrown may scrap dividend creditFinancial TimesLondon 1997 1Google Scholar

Kelly, JimUnder fire for ‘victimless’ tax increase: Brown may defy critics over dividend creditsFinancial TimesLondon 1997 11Google Scholar

Column, LexTaxing timesFinancial TimesLondon 1997 22Google Scholar

Coggan, PhilipNot the easy optionFinancial TimesLondon 1997 8Google Scholar

Brown’s first Budget – business and market reactionFinancial TimesLondon 1997 3

Casson, PeterInternational Aspects of the UK Imputation System of Corporate TaxationBritish Tax Review 5 1998 493Google Scholar

Avi-Yonah, ReuvenBack to the 1930s? The Shaky Case for Exempting DividendsTax Notes 97 2002 1599Google Scholar

Tontsch, AndreasCorporation Tax Systems and Fiscal Neutrality: The UK and German Systems and their Recent ChangesIntertax 30 2002 178CrossRef Google Scholar

Tiley, JohnThe United KingdomComparative Income Taxation: A Structural AnalysisAult, Hugh J.Arnold, Brian J.New YorkAspen Publishers 2010 147Google Scholar

Mitchell, CarolineTreasury urged to reprieve tax credit for poorThe TimesLondon 1998Google Scholar

Lumsden, GavinDismay over refusal to restore tax creditsThe TimesLondon 1998Google Scholar

Charles, JamesWhere the manifestos hit our walletsThe TimesLondon 2010 82Google Scholar

Bell, LeonieJenkinson, TimNew Evidence of the Impact of Dividend Taxation and on the Identity of the Marginal InvestorJournal of Finance 57 2002 1321CrossRef Google Scholar

Searjeant, GrahamSeven years on, Brown’s swoop on pensions looks less cleverThe TimesLondon 2004 58Google Scholar

Kaletsky, AnatoleRegulations killed the pensions industryThe TimesLondon 2006 35Google Scholar

Webster, PhilipHurst, GregBrown slaps down claim that he wiped £1bn from pensionsThe TimesLondon 2007 22Google Scholar

Rozenberg, GabrielSeib, ChristineTories may restore tax credit for pensionsThe TimesLondon 2005 41Google Scholar

Severiens, Jacob T.Does a Dividend Tax Credit WorkTaxes 54 1976 17Google Scholar

Cox, John H.The Corporate Income Tax and Integration: A Summary of Positions and the Prospects for ChangeTaxes 58 1980 10Google Scholar

Hickman, Frederic W.Tax Equity and the Need for CapitalNational Tax Journal 28 1975 282Google Scholar

Art PineCarter’s dividend tax proposal is in troubleWashington Post 1977 D7Google Scholar

Sullivan, Martin A.Dividend : Will Double Tax Relief Get Canned – AgainTax Notes 98 2003 647Google Scholar

Lawrence Fox, H.Washington Tax WatchJournal of Corporate Taxation 2 1975 360Google Scholar

Lawrence Fox, H.Jackson, James K.Washington Tax WatchJournal of Corporate Taxation 3 1976 176Google Scholar

Stratton, SherylLubick Looks at Treasury Past and Treasury PresentTax Notes 84 1999 1702Google Scholar

Smith, James E.The Dividend and Interest Exclusions: A Changing SceneTaxes 60 1982 240Google Scholar

Eustice, James S.The Tax Reform Act of 1986: Analysis and CommentaryBostonWarren, Gorham & Lamont 1987 2Google Scholar

Leonard, Robert J.A Pragmatic View of Corporate IntegrationTax Notes 35 1987 889Google Scholar

Staff of the Joint Committee on TaxationGeneral Explanation of the Tax Reform Act of 1986 1987 336

Richardson, JoannaIntegration Faces ‘Marketing Problem,’ Says Treasury’s HubbardTax Notes Today 92 1992 193Google Scholar

Lahart, JustinCash-rich firms urged to spendWall Street Journal 2005 C1Google Scholar

Glassman, James K.Numbers you can trustWashington Post 2002 H1Google Scholar

Gompers, PaulMetrick, AndrewSiegel, JeremyThis tax cut will pay dividendsWall Street Journal 2002 A20Google Scholar

McCaffery, Edward J.Remove a major incentive to cheatWall Street Journal 2002 B2Google Scholar

Garrett, ElizabethAccounting for the Federal Budget and its ReformHarvard Journal on Legislation 41 2004 187Google Scholar

Murray, ShailaghMcKinnon, John D.Democrats’ confidence grows about shrinking Bush tax cutWall Street Journal 2002Google Scholar

Krim, JonathanTech companies see Bush plan on dividends as troublesomeWashington Post 2003 E1Google Scholar

Hook, JanetBush plan to end dividend tax in for changesLos Angeles Times 2003 A30Google Scholar

Norris, FloydBush’s plan taxes certain dividends, fine print revealsNew York Times 2003 A1Google Scholar

Weisman, JonathanAllen, MikeBush seeks to enlist economists’ support; growth plan has gathered considerable oppositionWashington Post 2003 A7Google Scholar

Mohr, PattiRojas, WarrenInterest Groups Test Bush Idea of ‘Single Tax’ on DividendsTax Notes 98 2003 1471Google Scholar

Desai, Mihir A.The Decentering of the Global FirmThe World EconomyOxfordBlackwell Publishing 2009 1271Google Scholar

Barry, FrankTax Policy, FDI and the Irish Economic Boom of the 1990sEconomic Analysis & Policy 33 2003 221CrossRef Google Scholar

Darby, Joseph B.Lemaster, KelseyDouble Irish More Than Doubles the Tax SavingsPractical US/International Tax Strategies 11 2007 2Google Scholar

Craig, AlistairEU Law and British Tax: Which Comes FirstLondonThe Chameleon Press 2003 11Google Scholar

Graetz, Michael J.Warren, Jr Alvin C.Income Tax Discrimination and the Political and Economic Integration of EuropeYale Law Journal 115 2006 1186CrossRef Google Scholar

Graetz, Michael J.Warren, Jr Alvin C.Dividend Taxation in Europe: When the ECJ Makes Tax PolicyCommon Market Law Review 44 2007 1577Google Scholar

Gammie, MalcolmUK Imputation, Past, Present and FutureBulletin for International Fiscal Documentation 52 1998 429Google Scholar

Harris, PeterOliver, DavidInternational Commercial TaxCambridge University Press 2010 294CrossRef Google Scholar

Duncan, GaryChancellor accused of losing control of corporate tax to EUThe TimesLondon 2003 41Google Scholar

Rozenberg, GabrielCorporate tax review eyes return of poundThe TimesLondon 2007 62Google Scholar

McLure, Jr Charles E.Harmonizing Corporate Income Taxes in the European Community: Rationale and ImplicationsTax Policy & Economics 22 2008 151CrossRef Google Scholar

Betterndorf, LeonCorporate Tax Harmonization in EuropeEconomic Policy 2010 539Google Scholar

Judge, ElizabethSingle European tax could cost UK business £4 bn, academics warnThe TimesLondon 2007 55Google Scholar

Searjeant, GrahamEU has company tax in its sightsThe TimesLondon 2005 61Google Scholar

Killian, SheilaWhere’s the Harm in Tax Competition? Lessons from US Multinationals in IrelandCritical Perspectives on Accounting 17 2006 1067CrossRef Google Scholar

Kingson, Charles I.The Great American Jobs Act CaperTax Law Review 58 2005 327Google Scholar

Duncan, GaryChancellor told to cut Corporation TaxThe TimesLondon 2006 56Google Scholar

Buckley, ChristineCut tax or lose more business, says CBIThe TimesLondon 2006 52Google Scholar

Buckley, ChristineEmployers and unions lobby over corporate tax rates and non domsThe TimesLondon 2008 44Google Scholar

Jagger, SuzyCorporation Tax cuts make us global players, say business leadersThe TimesLondon 2010 14Google Scholar

Jagger, SuzyCorporate tax will be the lowest in G20, Osborne promises CBIThe TimesLondon 2010 39Google Scholar

Gilmore, GrainneTaxman will be deprived of millions of pounds in the great dividend payoutThe TimesLondon 2010 58Google Scholar

Merrill, Peter R.Corporate Tax Policy for the 21st CenturyNational Tax Journal 63 2010 623CrossRef Google Scholar

Gravelle, Jane G.Hungerford, Thomas L.Corporate Tax Reform: Issues for CongressCongressional Research Service Report for Congress 2010Google Scholar

US Department of the TreasuryTreasury Conference on Business Taxation and Global CompetitivenessBackground Paper 2007Google Scholar

Congressional Budget OfficeCorporate Income Tax Rates: International ComparisonsComparisons 2005Google Scholar

Book contents

7 - 1970s to Present – A Time of Convergence?

Summary

Access options

References

Save book to Kindle

Save book to Dropbox

Save book to Google Drive