This article illustrates the use of an empirical method for examining
the perceptual identification of gayness in male speakers. It demonstrates
how, by digitally manipulating the speech of isolated individuals, it is
possible to obtain reliable evidence that pitch range and sibilant
duration may act as indexical of a gay male identity. Further scrutiny of
this result, however, illustrates that linguistic indexicality is not as
straightforward as it originally appears. Subsequent analyses of the data
highlight the ways in which the perceptual evaluation of sexuality is a
highly contingent process, dependent upon a variety of sociolinguistic
factors. An envelope of variation in listeners' affective judgments
of a speaker is shown to exist, and it is argued that research on the
perception of identity must go beyond identification of salient features,
and also consider when and why these features are not salient.I greatly benefited from the insight and
assistance of the following people, whom I would like to thank:
Renée Blake, Lisa Davidson, Penny Eckert, Rudi Gaudio, Ron Butters,
Keith Walters, Barbara Johnstone, and three anonymous reviewers. Earlier
versions of this article were presented at the Linguistic Society of
America Annual Meeting in Oakland, California, in January 2005, and the
72nd Southeastern Conference on Linguistics (SECOL) in Raleigh, North
Carolina in April 2005. I thank the participants at those events for their
questions and comments. All errors are, of course, my own.