Introduction
Schistosomiasis is considered a neglected tropical disease that affects millions of people worldwide (Neves et al., Reference Neves, Braga, Bezerra, Cravo and Andrade2015). Human infection is caused by flatworms of the genus Schistosoma: Schistosoma mansoni, S. haematobium and S. japonicum. The parasite usually causes a chronic debilitating disease that impairs human development and productivity (Colley et al., Reference Colley, Bustinduy, Secor and King2014).
Schistosomiasis presents clinically in acute, subacute and chronic stages. Many cases present with late complications. The acute stage is species-independent and occurs early during invasion and migration of the parasite. The subacute stage occurs after parasitic maturity and settlement in the target organs. Granulomata are formed around eggs or around the dead worms in the colon and rectum in S. mansoni infection. The chronic stage occurs due to healing of the granulomas by fibrosis and calcification around trapped eggs. Malignancy may develop in the colon as a complication of the chronic stage, according to the infective species (Barsoum et al., Reference Barsoum, Esmat and El-Baz2013).
Fibrosed granulomatous liver parenchyma in cases of S. mansoni infection causes compression and destruction of portal blood vessels, leading to portal hypertension with disabling sequelae. Unfortunately, praziquantel (PZQ) in therapeutic doses cannot reverse such damage. Thus, researchers were encouraged to develop new drugs that could protect the liver. Plant therapy played an important role in the research of schistosomiasis treatment (El Ridi & Tallima, Reference El Ridi and Tallima2013). Praziquantel is the only drug recommended by the World Health Organization (WHO) for treating and controlling human schistosomiasis. However, resistance to the drug has already been identified, indicating the need for new compounds to treat such disease (Neves et al., Reference Neves, Braga, Bezerra, Cravo and Andrade2015). In addition, PZQ has been ineffective in killing immature stages of the parasite during recent bilharzial infections, leading to reduced cure rates and failure to abort early infection (Gundamaraju, Reference Gundamaraju2014). Schistosomiasis control over the past 40 years has depended mainly on PZQ, and there is an urgent need to develop new anthelmintics to be used in combination with PZQ in order to increase its efficacy and reduce resistance to PZQ (Bergquist et al., Reference Bergquist, Utzinger and Keiser2017). Efforts are focused on natural plant extracts that may have effective schistosomicidal activity. However, few studies have focused on isolation, identification and evaluation of these natural extracts (Ndjonka et al., Reference Ndjonka, Rapado, Silber, Liebau and Wrenger2013).
Callistemon citrinus is a plant of great medicinal importance. Numerous bacterial, fungal, viral and parasitic diseases have traditionally been treated with this plant (Radulovića et al., Reference Radulovića, Randjelović, Stojanović, Cakić, Bogdanović and Živanoviće2015). Callistemon species are widely encountered in the wet tropics, particularly in Australia, South America and tropical Asia, although they are now available worldwide (Shinde et al., Reference Shinde, Patil and Bairagi2012). Previous studies and reports have shown that C. citrinus possesses a wide range of biological activities, including wound healing, hepatoprotective, cardioprotective, anti-inflammatory, antidiabetic, hypolipidemic, antioxidant and antithrombotic effects. In addition, it inhibits cholinesterase and elastase enzymes (Goyal et al., Reference Goyal, Jain, Jain and Sharma2012) and shows analgesic and antidiarrhoeal effects (Ahmed et al., Reference Ahmed, Khan, Choudhury and Rashid2015). It also exerts antimicrobial, nematocidal, larvicidal, pupicidal and insecticidal activities (Ali et al., Reference Ali, Shah and Ahmad2011; Palanikumar et al., Reference Palanikumar, Pravin, Navaneethan, Mahendren, Mohanraj and Dhanakkodi2017). The anthelmintic effects of various extracts of C. citrinus leaves on the adult Indian earthworm (Pheretima posthuma) were assessed by Pal & Pathak (Reference Pal and Pathak2007). The study showed a dose-dependent lethal effect, with paralysis of Pheretima posthuma worms. Moreover, Ammar et al. (Reference Ammar, El Hefnawy, Mahmoud, Sabry, Gawish, Aly and Refahy2016) recorded death of all S. mansoni cercariae and miracidia after 30 minutes of exposure to the methanolic extract of C. citrinus leaves. They also proved a direct marked lethal effect on adult S. mansoni worms in vitro. Aqueous extracts from C. citrinus, Allium sativum and Moringa stenopetala were also proven to have anti-leishmanial activities against both promastigotes and amastigotes of Leishmania major (Kinuthia et al., Reference Kinuthia, Anjili, Gikonyo, Kigondu, Ingonga and Kabiru2013). The present study was designed to assess the effects of C. citrinus extract in mice experimentally infected with S. mansoni in both prepatent (juvenile worms) and patent phases (adult worms) of infection by parasitological, histopathological and biochemical studies.
Materials and methods
Experimental mice and S. mansoni infection
The study included 80 male BALB/c albino mice (10–12 weeks old and 20 ± 2 g). The mice were kept in an air-conditioned animal house at the Theodor Bilharz Research Institute (TBRI), Giza, Egypt, and fed a standard pellet diet and water ad libitum. Freshly shed cercariae were obtained from laboratory-bred Biomphalaria alexandrina snails infected with miracidia of the Egyptian strain of S. mansoni, reared and maintained at the Schistosome Biological Supply Program Unit, TBRI. The shed cercariae were counted using a stereomicroscope (Mohamed et al., Reference Mohamed, Sharaf El-Din, Mohamed and Habib2010). Infection was achieved by subcutaneous injection of mice with about 100 Schistosoma cercariae per mouse (Holanda et al., Reference Holanda, Pellegrino and Gazzinelli1974).
Drugs and doses
Praziquantel was provided by the Egyptian International Pharmaceutical Industries Company, Egypt (E.I.P.C.O.) and was suspended in 2% cremophore (Sigma Aldrich, USA). It was given orally at a dose of 500 mg/kg for two consecutive days, according to El-Lakkany et al. (Reference El-Lakkany, Hammam, El-Maadawy, Badawy, Ain-Shoka and Ebeid2012), on the 14th day post infection to groups IV and V and on the 45th day post infection to groups VII and VIII.
Callistemon citrinus leaves were provided by a plant taxonomist from the Faculty of Agriculture, Menoufia University, Egypt. Leaves were washed with tap water, air dried and ground into fine particles. Aqueous extract of C. citrinus was prepared according to Kinuthia et al. (Reference Kinuthia, Anjili, Kabiru, Kigondu, Ingonga and Gikonyo2015). Briefly, the obtained fine particles (100 g) were added to distilled water (600 ml) and placed in a 70°C water bath for 1.5 hours. The mixture was filtered using Whatman filter paper. Aqueous extract of C. citrinus was freshly prepared on the 13th and 44th days post infection, preserved at 4°C and given to the mice the next days as follows: 14th day post infection to groups III and V and 45th day post infection to groups IV and VIII. The extract was given orally at a dose of 200 mg/kg according to Ahmed et al. (Reference Ahmed, Khan, Choudhury and Rashid2015).
Experiment design
The mice were divided into eight groups of 10 mice each:
Group I (GI): non-infected non-treated mice (negative control)
Group II (GII): infected non-treated mice (positive control)
Group III (GIII): infected mice treated with C. citrinus on the 14th day post infection
Group IV (GIV): infected mice treated with PZQ on the 14th day post infection
Group V (GV): infected mice treated with C. citrinus and PZQ on the 14th day post infection
Group VI (GVI): infected mice treated with C. citrinus on the 45th day post infection
Group VII (GVII): infected mice treated with PZQ on the 45th day post infection
Group VIII (GVIII): infected mice treated with C. citrinus and PZQ on the 45th day post infection
In the 7th week post infection, all mice were anaesthetized with ether and euthanized by decapitation. After worm counting, parts of liver and ileum were taken from each mouse to calculate egg load and oogram pattern. Liver specimens were taken for histopathological studies. Blood samples were collected and sera were separated for biochemical studies.
Porto-mesenteric worm burden and reduction %
Saline perfusion of S. mansoni adult worms from the portal vein and porto-mesenteric vessels was performed. Counting of males, females and couples was carried out according to Smithers & Terry (Reference Smithers and Terry1965). The percentage reduction of adult worms after treatment was calculated according to Tendler et al. (Reference Tendler, Pinto, Oliveira, Gebara and Katz1986) using the formula R = C−V/C × 100, where R = reduction %, C = mean number of adult worms from infected non-treated mice, and V = mean number of parasites from treated mice.
Tissue egg load/g intestine and liver
The number of eggs per gram of tissue was calculated. Samples of ileum and liver were weighed and 0.5 g of each sample was placed in a test tube containing 5% KOH (5 ml) solution for 16 hours at 37°C. Eggs were counted under a light microscope at ×40 magnification (Herbert et al., Reference Herbert, Orekov and Roloson2010).
Oogram pattern
Three fragments (1 cm each) were cut longitudinally from the ileum of each mouse, rinsed with saline and dried gently using Whatman filter paper. They were examined microscopically and the percentages of various developmental stages of eggs (immature, mature and dead) were determined (Pellegrino et al., Reference Pellegrino, Oliveira, Faria and Cunha1962).
Hepatic granuloma number and size
Liver tissues from the euthanized mice were fixed in 10% formalin, dehydrated in ascending grades of alcohol and paraffin embedded. Tissues were cut into 4 μm sections and stained with haematoxylin and eosin (H&E). Hepatic granulomas per section were counted and measured digitally at ×10 using a multi-head Olympus SC100 microscope and the analySIS getIT software (Olympus, Tokyo, Japan) at the Pathology Department, Faculty of Medicine, Menoufia Governorate. The mean number of granulomas per section was calculated for each group. To assess granuloma size, circular shaped granulomas with a single egg in the centre were measured. The diameters of the largest ten granulomas in each section were measured and the mean diameter was calculated for each studied group (El-kott et al., Reference El-kott, Mohammed and Ismail2011).
Estimation of liver function
Serum samples were separated by centrifugation at 3000 rpm for ten minutes. Liver function tests (aspartate transaminase (AST), alanine transaminase (ALT) and total bilirubin (TB)) were performed using an Integra 400 auto analyser (Roche, Germany). Quantitative determination of AST and ALT was carried out by the Warburg method with pyridoxal-5-phosphate at a wavelength of 340 nm according to the International Federation of Clinical Chemistry (IFCC) protocol (Bergmeyer et al., Reference Bergmeyer, Horder and Rej1986). Total bilirubin concentration (mg/dl) was measured by photometry according to a diazo method as described by Malloy & Evelyn (Reference Malloy and Evelyn1937).
Statistical analysis
The data collected were tabulated and processed using SPSS version 22.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, Illinois, USA) on an IBM-compatible computer. Normality of data was assessed by visual methods as well as a Shapiro–Wilk test. Continuous parametric variables were presented as means ± SD. The difference between groups regarding parametric variables (tissue egg load, oogram pattern, mean hepatic granuloma pattern, AST, ALT and total bilirubin) was analysed by the one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) test, and then the Tukey honest significant difference post-hoc test was used to identify the groups that were significantly different from each other. The Kruskal–Wallis test was applied to study the difference between the groups having non-parametric variables (worm burden).
Results
The highest reduction of total S. mansoni worm burden was seen in both groups that received C. citrinus either combined with PZQ (GV) or alone (GIII) early during the prepatent period of infection (89.3% and 85.2%, respectively). Callistemon citrinus administered on the 45th day post infection either alone (GVI) or combined with PZQ (GVIII) induced a higher reduction of total worm count (79.1%), with significant differences between all groups (P < 0.0001). PZQ administered early in the course of infection induced a negligible effect on the adult worm burden (6.63%) (table 1).
Callistemon citrinus administered early during the course of infection achieved the highest reduction in egg load in GV (combined therapy) (96.2% intestine and 93.1% liver) and in GIII (C. citrinus alone) (91.8% intestine and 90.6% liver), with no significant difference between the two groups (p8 = 0.9624 and 0.999 in intestine and liver, respectively) (table 2).
p1: Group II vs Group III.
p2: Group II vs Group IV.
p3: Group II vs Group V.
p4: Group II vs Group VI.
p5: Group II vs Group VII.
p6: Group II vs Group VIII.
p7: Group III vs Group IV.
p8: Group III vs Group V.
p9: Group III vs Group VI.
p10: Group IV vs Group V.
p11: Group IV vs Group VII.
p12: Group V vs Group VIII.
p13: Group VI vs Group VII.
p14: Group VI vs Group VIII.
p15: Group VII vs Group VIII.
*Groups sharing the same letter are not statistically different.
Callistemon citrinus administered late in the infection achieved 84.5% reduction in intestinal egg load and 78.9% reduction in hepatic egg load when given alone (GVI), and 87.6% intestinal reduction and 82.5% hepatic reduction when combined with PZQ (GVIII), with no significant difference between the two groups (p14 = 0.9940 and 0.995 in intestine and liver, respectively) (table 2).
The schistosomal oogram pattern showed a massive increase in the percentage of dead eggs in groups V (C. citrinus + PZQ 14 days post infection) and III (C. citrinus 14 days post infection), to 95.8% and 91.6%, respectively, with a highly significant difference in comparison to the control positive group (p3 and p1: 0.0000). This was followed by both groups that received C. citrinus late (45th day post infection) either combined with PZQ (GVIII) or alone (GV), where dead eggs increased to 84.8% and 82.3%, respectively, with a highly significant difference compared to the positive control group (p6 and p4: 0.0000) (table 3).
Haematoxylin and eosin sections of liver tissue showed that C. citrinus given early during prepatency reduced both the number and size of granulomas, either when combined with PZQ (GV; 90.7% and 93.4% for the number and size, respectively) or when administered as monotherapy (GIII; 87.2% and 90% for the number and size, respectively). Callistemon citrinus given on the 45th day post infection was associated with improvement in number and size of granulomas, although to a lesser extent, when combined with PZQ (GVIII; 81.3% and 64.2% for the number and size, respectively) or alone (GVI; 74.4% and 49% for the number and size, respectively). All showed a significant decrease compared to the control positive group (GII) (p3, p1, p6 and p4: 0.0000, respectively) (table 4 and fig. 1).
AST, ALT and TB serum levels were measured to assess liver function. The highest levels were detected in both the positive control group (GII) and the group administered solely PZQ early, on the 14th day post infection (GIV), with no significant difference between them. On the other hand, the highest improvement was detected in groups administered C. citrinus early, on the 14th day post infection, either alone (GIII) or combined with PZQ (GV), with no significant difference when compared to the negative control group (GI) (figs 2, 3 and 4)
p1: Group II vs Group III.
p2: Group II vs Group IV.
p3: Group II vs Group V.
p4: Group II vs Group VI.
p5: Group II vs Group VII.
p6: Group II vs Group VIII.
p7: Group III vs Group IV.
p8: Group III vs Group V.
p9: Group III vs Group VI.
p10: Group IV vs Group V.
p11: Group IV vs Group VII.
p12: Group V vs Group VIII.
p13: Group VI vs Group VII.
p14: Group VI vs Group VIII.
p15: Group VII vs Group VIII.
*Groups sharing the same letter are not statistically different.
p1: Group II vs Group III.
p2: Group II vs Group IV.
p3: Group II vs Group V.
p4: Group II vs Group VI.
p5: Group II vs Group VII.
p6: Group II vs Group VIII.
p7: Group III vs Group IV.
p8: Group III vs Group V.
p9: Group III vs Group VI.
p10: Group IV vs Group V.
p11: Group IV vs Group VII.
p12: Group V vs Group VIII.
p13: Group VI vs Group VII.
p14: Group VI vs Group VIII.
p15: Group VII vs Group VIII.
*Groups sharing the same letter are not statistically different.
Discussion
With the increasing popularity of treatments based on natural medicinal plant extracts, the current study was designed to assess the anthelmintic effects of aqueous extract of C. citrinus in mice experimentally infected with S. mansoni in comparison with the currently used PZQ in prepatent and patent phases of infection. Aqueous extract of Callistemon (200 mg/kg) was selected because water is a safe, non-toxic universal solvent and avoids the high toxicity of organic solvents (such as methanol, acetone, chloroform and dichloromethane) to living cells. Previous results for aqueous extract of C. citrinus (Kinuthia et al., Reference Kinuthia, Anjili, Kabiru, Kigondu, Ingonga and Gikonyo2015) are encouraging. Also, Bhushan et al. (Reference Bhushan, Sardana and Bansal2014) recorded the best yield of C. citrinus when water was used as a solvent in comparison to petroleum ether, ethyl acetate, chloroform and ethanol. The dose selected (200 mg/kg) is one fourth of the maximum therapeutic dose calculated by Bhushan et al. (Reference Bhushan, Sardana and Bansal2014), as recommended by toxicologists (Festing & Altman, Reference Festing and Altman2014).
Vimieiro et al. (Reference Vimieiro, Araújo, Katz, Kusel and Coelho2013) described efficient treatment of schistosomiasis during the initial phase of infection as an important challenge. An ideal treatment would inhibit egg production and consequently granuloma formation, which is the main cause of the pathology of this disease (Coelho et al., Reference Coelho, Enk and Katz2009).
All the anti-parasitic parameters assessed in this work, including the percentage reduction of the adult worm burden perfused from the portal vein and porto-mesenteric vessels, the percentage reduction of the ileal and hepatic tissue egg load and the ileal oogram pattern, indicated that early treatment with C. citrinus either alone or combined with PZQ was more effective compared to treatment received late during the course of infection. These results are supported by a number of studies on other anti-schistosomal therapeutic agents. When juvenile S. mansoni worms are treated early, they fail to produce eggs due to the inhibitory effect of anti-schistosomals on their sexual maturation, causing atrophy of their testes and ovaries, hence confirming the advantage of early treatment (Hamza et al., Reference Hamza, Metwaly and Abo El-Maaty2012; Vimieiro et al., Reference Vimieiro, Araújo, Katz, Kusel and Coelho2013). In context, several studies have demonstrated that immature worms are less susceptible to PZQ (Botros et al., Reference Botros, Pica-Mattoccia, William, El-Lakkani and Cioli2005; Grandière-Pérez et al., Reference Grandière-Pérez, Ansart and Paris2006; Vimieiro et al., Reference Vimieiro, Araújo, Katz, Kusel and Coelho2013).
Regarding late treatment during the patent period of infection, C. citrinus either alone or combined with PZQ exhibited considerable anti-schistosomal effects, with remarkable improvement of all parasitological parameters, comparable to, if not better than, treatment solely by PZQ. To date, no data have been published regarding the in vivo anti-schistosomal effects of C. citrinus. However, many herbal and plant-based medicines have been used to treat S. mansoni infection and have achieved comparable results to those obtained with PZQ; e.g. Schitozim, Tanacetum vulgare, Artemisia absinthium and Tanacetum parthenium (Muya et al., Reference Muya, Allan, Kutima, Ayonga and Yole2014; de Almeida et al., Reference de Almeida, de Carvalho, Gazolla, Pinto, da Silva, de Moraes and Da Silva Filho2016). Interestingly, previous studies have proved that C. citrinus fruits have calcium channel blocking effects (Ali et al., Reference Ali, Shah and Ahmad2011). Many studies have demonstrated that voltage-operated calcium channels of Schistosoma represent prime targets for chemotherapy (Redman et al., Reference Redman, Robertson, Fallon, Modha, Kusel, Doenhoff and Martin1996). These channels play an important role in regulating intracellular calcium levels and are essential for multiple parasite cellular events, muscular contractions, release of various neurotransmitters, as well as gene expression (Salvador-Recatalà et al., Reference Salvador-Recatalà, Schneider and Greenberg2008). Nifedipine (a calcium channel blocker) was tested for anti-schistosomal effects on both schistosomula and adult worms. It was found to be effective against S. mansoni schistosomula, as it significantly reduced their viability. It also caused impaired motility, several tegumental lesions and intense contractions in adult worms. Nifedipine also impaired egg production by S. mansoni females, decreasing S. mansoni fecundity (Silva-Moraes et al., Reference Silva-Moraes, Couto, Vasconcelos, Araújo, Coelho, Katz and Grenfell2013).
Histopathological assessment of the number and diameter of S. mansoni induced hepatic granulomas in this work showed that C. citrinus, either as sole therapy or combined with PZQ, significantly reduced the number of hepatic granulomas in all groups compared to both positive control and sole PZQ groups, indicating a marked effect of C. citrinus. As regards the size of granulomas, C. citrinus significantly decreased the granuloma diameter in all groups compared to the positive control group. It also showed comparable effect to that of PZQ, as it significantly reduced the size in all C. citrinus treated groups except for the sole late C. citrinus treated group, for which no significant difference was reported when compared to the sole PZQ late group. Improvement of both number and size of granulomas in C. citrinus treated groups can be explained by the calcium channel blocking effect of the extract, as reported previously for verapamil (a calcium channel blocker), which was found to interrupt egg production. This is valuable, as eggs are responsible for the development of granulomatous lesions (Bonn, Reference Bonn2004).
In this study, a hepatic shift phenomenon was observed, as few adult worms were found inside the hepatic parenchyma in some sections of the PZQ late monotherapy group. Hepatic shift was reported by Meister et al. (Reference Meister, Ingram-Sieber, Cowan, Todd, Robertson, Meli, Patra, Gasser and Keiser2014), who attributed it to racemate PZQ or its R-enantiomers treatment, which killed the majority of adult worms, while treatment with S-enantiomers of PZQ killed only a few adults. Worms migrate to the hepatic parenchyma mostly because of the loss of grip on the wall of the mesenteric blood vessels induced by the drug, allowing them to migrate back to the mesenteric veins. Meister et al. (Reference Meister, Ingram-Sieber, Cowan, Todd, Robertson, Meli, Patra, Gasser and Keiser2014) assumed that the hepatic shift phenomenon detected in their study in association with using S-enantiomers of PZQ was evidence of inefficacy.
Some of the multiple enzymatic systems in hepatocytes are markers for cell organelle activities. Hence, injury to such organelles is reflected by the serum levels of those enzymes, which can be used in assessing different therapies for S. mansoni infection (Hamed & Hetta, Reference Hamed and Hetta2005; El-Kott et al., Reference El-kott, Mohammed and Ismail2011). In this study, AST, ALT and TB serum levels were measured as indicators of hepatic tissue injury. They were significantly increased in the positive control group, reflecting hepatic injury, as previously reported (El-Kott et al., Reference El-kott, Mohammed and Ismail2011). The highest improvement of hepatic functions was recorded in mice administered C. citrinus early in the prepatent phase of infection (alone or combined with PZQ). Callistemon citrinus administered late resulted in improved liver function, although to a lesser extent, which was significantly different from the positive control group. Hepatoprotective effects of dried leaf extract of Callistemon lanceolatus – the old synonym of C. citrinus – were reported by Jain et al. (Reference Jain, Dubey, Sikarwar and Jain2007), who detected significant improvement in AST, ALT, alkaline phosphatase and total bilirubin levels in Callistemon-treated mice after carbon tetrachloride induced hepatic damage.
Financial support
This research received no specific grant from any funding agency, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
Conflict of interest
None.
Ethical standards
The authors assert that all procedures contributing to this work comply with the ethical standards of the relevant national and institutional guides on the care and use of laboratory animals.