GM maize is one of the major GM crops grown worldwide. In comparison to 2010, the field area of GM maize planted increased by 11 % to just under 51 million hectares in 2011, occupying 32 % of the total global maize cultivation area(1). It is becoming increasingly difficult to obtain non-GM maize. Various maize products are used in commercial diets for farmed fishes. The carbohydrate in whole-kernel meal is an energy source and the starch serves as a feed binder. As a result of the increasing production of salmon and other fish species and decreasing availability of fishmeal, which has been the main dietary protein source, especially for piscivorous fish, plant protein sources are increasingly being used in diets to obtain a cost-efficient, sustainable aquaculture industry. Maize gluten meal, a by-product of starch extraction containing approximately 60 % protein, has increased in importance as a protein source in fish feeds. The wet-milling process used to extract starch and provide maize gluten meal as a by-product is carried out by steeping the maize kernels in water at 50°C, mildly acidified with sulphur dioxide (0·01 %) to prevent microbial growth, with subsequent grinding and mechanical separation of the starch and gluten. This mild treatment is not expected to denature the maize proteins, including any transgenic proteins (see later), although specific studies investigating this are apparently absent from the scientific literature. If they remain intact and biologically active, maize gluten meal would contain higher concentrations of any transgenic proteins than whole-kernel meal. Effects of maize gluten meal derived from GM maize as a feed ingredient for cultured fish have apparently not been investigated.
GM Bt-maize (MON810) expresses Cry1Ab protein, by transfer of a gene found in Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) bacteria, which confers resistance to the European corn borer, Ostrinia nubilalis. The Cry proteins are endotoxins produced by the soil bacterium Bt, and each has putative species-specific toxicity against insects(Reference Knowles2, Reference Bravo, Gill and Soberón3). The high specificity of the three-domain crystal proteins towards target insects arises due to the need for alkaline pH (>9·5) for solubilisation, presence of serine proteases in the midgut for processing and presence of specific receptors in the insect midgut epithelial cells for binding(Reference Bravo, Gill and Soberón3). The Cry protoxins are considered non-toxic to higher animals(Reference Betz, Hammond and Fuchs4), putatively due to differing pH and enzymatic and binding conditions in the gastrointestinal tract. In one study, the Cry1Ab protein was reported to be rapidly digested in simulated gastric and intestinal fluids, as immune reactive bands were not identified(Reference Xu, Cao and He5), whereas another study concluded that under more physiologically relevant in vitro conditions (pH 2·5, pepsin-to-substrate ratio 1:20 and in the presence of phosphatidylcholine) Cry1Ab was stable(Reference Guimaraes, Drumare and Lereclus6). Furthermore, at least some studies indicate that ingested Cry1A toxins may elicit humoral and mucosal immune responses in mice(Reference Adel-Patient, Guimaraes and Paris7–Reference Vázquez-Padrón, Moreno-Fierros and Neri-Bazán9), suggesting that even fragments of the protein may be immunogenic, although this remains to be specifically investigated. Marked histological changes in rat liver and kidney by Bt-maize have been observed(Reference Kiliç and Akay10). A review of rat feeding studies with three different commercialised GM maizes (NK603, MON810 and MON863) suggested sex- and often dose-dependent side effects, mostly affecting kidneys and liver. The effects differed between GM types. Moreover, effects on heart, adrenals, spleen and blood cells were also frequently identified(Reference de Vendômois, Roullier and Cellier11).
Concerns regarding possible allergenicity of GM plant crops have also been raised(Reference Prescott and Hogan12, Reference Prescott, Campbell and Moore13). Transgenic proteins have been suggested to be potentially antigenic or allergenic, possibly due to differences in post-translational modifications following integration of the transgenic DNA into a foreign organism's genome. It is not known whether Atlantic salmon or other fish have the ability to elicit a type I hypersensitivity reaction (classic allergic response), as they do not appear to have an IgE-analogue and their mast cells are devoid of histamine(Reference Reite and Evensen14). However, the putative T-cell-mediated type IV hypersensitivity reaction in the distal intestine (DI), caused by as little as 5–10 % inclusion of both full-fat and extracted soyabean meal (SBM)(Reference Baeverfjord and Krogdahl15–Reference Lilleeng, Penn and Haugland17), appears to have similar histopathological and immunological characteristics to that of coeliac disease (gluten intolerance) or other inflammatory bowel diseases in human subjects. It may serve as a comparative model for studying intestinal pathophysiological and immunological responses in general, as well as investigating whether a pre-existing hypersensitivity reaction alters the fish's response to a potential antigen in the GM plant ingredient.
The purpose of the present study was to assess whether responses in Atlantic salmon to dietary inclusion of Bt-maize expressing Cry1Ab differed from the near-isogenic maternal line of maize and also when the fish were sensitised with 15 % SBM inclusion in diet (SBM-induced enteropathy). Initially, the intention was to test maize gluten meal made from the Bt-maize, as this is a more commonly used maize product in salmon diets. However, we were unable to locate a mill that could process the small quantities of Bt-maize and control non-GM maize that we had at our disposal within the financial and time restraints of the project. Thus, the feeding experiment was carried out with 20 % inclusion level of whole-kernel maize meal. Samples were taken from fish exposed to the diets following an initial 33 d period, as well as a longer period of 97 d. A wide range of physiological responses were assessed in an attempt to identify any changes that may serve as biomarkers for Bt-maize exposure, including (1) growth performance and feed utilisation; (2) health parameters such as haematology, plasma clinical chemistry and relative weights and histomorphology of main organs; (3) Cry1Ab protein and specific antibodies in plasma; (4) digestive and intestinal function and (5) distal intestinal cell proliferation, oxidative stress and immune responses.
Materials and methods
Feed ingredients and experimental diet
Two maize types, Bt-maize (MON810) and its near-isogenic maternal line (non-GM (nGM) maize), were derived from planted seed varieties PR34N44 and PR34N43, respectively, provided by Pioneer. They were grown simultaneously in neighbouring fields in Spain. All the maize grains were dried and ground just prior to diet preparation to obtain whole-maize meal. Feeds were prepared by Nofima AS. Diet formulations are given in Table 1. Yttrium oxide was added as a biological marker for apparent digestibility determinations. All diets were balanced regarding vitamins and minerals according to estimated requirements(18). Protein, lipid and energy levels were kept as similar as possible and were comparable between each nGM diet and GM counterpart with and without SBM, respectively. The diets were extruded with a feed particle (pellet) size of 3·5 mm. Salmon feed production using extrusion is a common practice in Norwegian aquaculture. Rausell et al. (Reference Rausell, Pardo-López and Sánchez19) reported that heat up to 60°C did not denature the pore-forming domain of the Cry1Ab protein, although the receptor-recognising domains may be more heat sensitive, and Xu et al. (Reference Xu, Cao and He5) reported anti-Cry1Ab binding to Cry1Ab protein treated at 100°C for up to 60 min. Hence, Cry1Ab protein integrity is expected to be at least partially intact following extrusion.
Table 1 Formulation and proximate composition of the experimental diets on an as-fed basis
nGM, non-GM; Bt, Bacillus thuringiensis; SBM, soyabean meal.
* Residue = DM–(protein+lipids+starch+ash).
† Gross energy was calculated using the energy concentrations of 39·5 for lipid, 23·6 for protein and 17·2 kJ/g for starch.
Experimental design and facilities
The experiment was carried out using a 2 × 2 factorial design with four diet groups. The factors GM and SBM inclusion were tested separately and in combination. The feeding trial was conducted at the aquaculture research facilities of Nofima AS following the institutional and national guidelines for the care and use of animals, and approved by the National Animal Research Authority in Norway. Post-smolt Atlantic salmon of the Sunndalsøra breed with an initial average weight of 93·8 (se 0·3) g were randomly allocated, 100 fish per tank, to twelve tanks. Triplicate tanks of fish were fed one of the four experimental diets. Water surface area in the tanks was 1 m2 and water depth 50 cm. The tanks contained filtered running seawater with a temperature of 8·0 ± 0·5°C and salinity between 31 and 32‰. Fish were continuously fed by automatic disc feeders. During the trial, fish were subjected to a 24 h light photoperiod.
Sampling
Sampling was conducted following 33 and 97 d of dietary exposure to the experimental diets. The fish were not fasted before the samplings, as this reduces potential diet-induced inflammatory changes in the intestine(Reference Baeverfjord and Krogdahl15) as well as changes in physiological parameters(Reference Krogdahl and Bakke-McKellep20). A total of ten randomly selected fish per tank were anaesthetised, individually weighed and body (fork) length measured. Blood was collected from the caudal vein by means of a heparinised medical syringe. Organs including liver, spleen, head kidney, gonads (the latter only large enough to be weighed at 97 d) and the different regions of the intestine were removed and weighed for calculation of organosomatic indices. Prior to weighing, the intestinal tract was cleared of visceral fat and luminal content, and then divided into proximal intestine (PI), mid intestine (MI) and DI, as described earlier(Reference Nordrum, Krogdahl and Røsjø21). From four of the ten fish per tank, samples from the PI, MI, DI, spleen, head kidney and liver for histological examination were collected, fixed in 4 % buffered formaldehyde solution for 24 h and subsequently stored in 70 % ethanol until further processing. For mRNA expression investigations, DI tissue samples were rinsed in sterile PBS, transferred to RNA later for 24 h and stored at − 20°C. Head kidney, spleen and intestinal samples for protein expression and/or digestive enzyme analyses were frozen in liquid N2 and stored at − 80°C. Intestinal contents of MI (at 97 d only) and DI (at both 33 and 97 d) were gathered from ten fish, weighed and freeze-dried. Faeces were collected from thirty fish by stripping from the DI, pooled and frozen on dry ice for digestibility measurements. For composition analyses, whole fish and livers from an additional five fish per tank at the 97 d sampling time were pooled, frozen in liquid N2 and stored at − 80°C.
Chemical composition analyses
Diets and faeces were analysed for DM, crude protein, crude lipid, starch, ash (mineral) and yttrium oxide (Y2O3), the latter by inductivity coupled plasma mass spectroscopy, as previously described(Reference Refstie, Helland and Storebakken22). Whole fish and livers were analysed for DM, crude protein and crude lipid. Liver glycogen was also analysed. DM was measured by drying at 103°C for 24 h with the exception of faeces, which were freeze-dried. For ash, samples were weighed before and after burning at 540°C. Fat in liver and whole body was determined gravimetrically after ethyl-acetate extraction and the fat in feed and faeces after acid hydrolysis and extraction with diethyl ether. N was measured with a nitrogen determinator (LECO FP-428; Väsby) according to Association of Official Analytical Chemists (AOAC) official methods of analysis(Reference Soderberg and Cunniff23) and crude protein calculated as N × 6·25. Starch and glycogen were measured by enzymatic degradation(Reference Hemre, Lie and Lied24).
Haematology, plasma clinical chemistry and detection of plasma Cry1Ab protein and specific antibodies
Blood smears of whole blood on microscope slides were prepared for differential blood cell counts using standard techniques. Haematocrit was immediately measured using microhaematocrit tubes centrifuged at 13 000 rpm for 5 min. Erythrocyte counts and Hb were measured on a Cell-Dyn 400 (Sequoia-Turner) according to the manufacturer's instructions, using Para 12 control blood (Streck) for calibration.
The rest of the whole blood was centrifuged at 3000 g for 10 min to obtain the plasma fraction. Plasma clinical chemistry was performed at the Central Laboratory of the Norwegian School of Veterinary Science using Advia® 1650 (Bayer Healthcare), an automated analysis system for clinical chemistry. Total protein, globulins, albumin, alanine aminotransferase, aspartate aminotransferase, alkaline phosphatase, amylase, lipase, TAG, total bilirubin, total bile acids, NEFA and cholesterol were analysed using standard techniques.
Cry1Ab protein levels and specific antibodies in plasma were determined as previously described(Reference Walsh, Buzoianu and Gardiner25) and modified for salmon. Briefly, plasma Cry1Ab protein levels were analysed by ‘sandwich’ ELISA using a commercially available kit QuantiPlate for Cry1Ab/Cry1Ac (Envirologix) following manufacturer's instructions. A standard curve was prepared by using purified Cry1Ab protein standards (0–5 μg/ml) provided in the kit. The mean absorbance read at 450 nm against reference wavelength 630 nm was calculated and used to determine sample concentrations. Positive and negative controls were prepared with the kit Cry1Ab-positive control solution as internal standards. The matrix-specific limit of detection of the adapted kit was determined by interpolation at optical density units (ODmatrix) from the Cry1Ab standard curve. ODmatrix units were determined to be 3 sd from the mean of a population of negative samples measured for a specific matrix. The criteria for positive samples was to exceed the matrix-specific limit of detection.
For detection of specific antibodies against Cry1Ab in plasma, ELISA plates were coated overnight at 4°C with 1 mg/ml of purified Cry1Ab toxin (a fermentation product of B. thuringiensis var. Kurstaki from Dipel, produced by Valent BioSciences Corporation) in 0·05 m-carbonate–bicarbonate buffer (pH 9·6). The plates were blocked for 1 h at 37°C with 0·01 m-PBS (pH 7·4), containing 1 % gelatine. PBS alone or serial dilutions (from 1:5 to 1:78 125) of fish plasma were added to the plates and incubated for 1 h at 37°C. Plates were then incubated with anti-fish IgM mouse IgG1 (1:16 000) antibodies for 1 h at 37°C. Following this, biotin-labelled anti-mouse IgG1 antibody conjugate (1:5000) was added to the wells and the plates were incubated for 1 h at 37°C. Horse-radish peroxidise-labelled avidin conjugate was subsequently added and the incubation step was repeated. For colour development, H2O2/o-phenylenediamine-containing substrate solution (pH 5) was added and the plates were developed for 5 min in the dark. The enzyme reaction was stopped by the addition of 4 m-H2SO4. The absorbance was read at 492/630 nm. Samples were analysed in duplicate and the washing procedure repeated after each step involved manually washing the plates twice with PBS containing 1 % gelatine and decanting. Antibody titre was defined as the maximum serum dilution with an absorbance measurement higher than the blank signal plus three times the standard deviation.
Histology
All formalin-fixed tissues were routinely dehydrated in ethanol, equilibrated in xylene and embedded in paraffin according to standard histological procedures. Sections of 5 μm were stained with haematoxylin and eosin and blindly evaluated under a light microscope. Distal intestinal morphology was scored according to the criteria previously described in Atlantic salmon with SBM-induced enteritis(Reference Baeverfjord and Krogdahl15): (1) widening and shortening of the intestinal folds; (2) loss of the supranuclear vacuolisation in the absorptive cells (enterocytes) in the intestinal epithelium; and (3) cellular infiltration of a mixed leucocyte population in the central lamina propria within the intestinal folds as well as in the submucosa. The degree of histological changes was assessed as normal, mild, moderate or severe.
Digestive enzyme activities and bile acid concentrations
Leucine aminopeptidase activity in the PI, MI and DI tissue was analysed to assess intestinal function following the method described previously(Reference Krogdahl, Bakke-McKellep and Baeverfjord26). Activities are related to mmol substrate hydrolysed per unit time in the whole tissue per kg body weight (enzymatic capacity) and per mg protein (specific activity). Protein was analysed using the Bio-Rad Protein Assay (Bio-Rad Laboratories).
For trypsin activity analysis, 50 mg freeze-dried intestinal content was homogenised and suspended in 2 ml dH2O. Trypsin activity was measured colorimetrically according to Kakade et al. (Reference Kakade, Hoffa and Liener27), using the substrate benzoyl-arginine-p-nitroanilide (Sigma-Aldrich). The trypsin activity is expressed as the change in optical density units (U) and related to mg DM. The bile acid concentrations in the intestinal contents were analysed using the Enzabile® kit from Nycomed Pharma AS Diagnostics.
Quantitative real-time PCR
RNA purification and quality control, DNase treatment, complementary DNA synthesis, primer optimisation and quantitative PCR assays were performed as described in detail elsewhere(Reference Kortner, Valen and Kortner28). Quantitative PCR primers were obtained from the literature or designed using Primer3 software (http://frodo.wi.mit.edu/primer3). See Table 2 for details. β-Actin (ACTB), RNA polymerase II (RNAPOLII), hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase 1 (HPRT1) and glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) were evaluated for use as reference genes by ranking relative gene expression according to their stability, as described previously(Reference Kortner, Valen and Kortner28). A combination of GAPDH and RNAPOLII was used as normalisation factor. Distal intestinal mean normalised expression of the target genes was calculated from raw C q values using a plate calibrator-normalised relative quantification(Reference Muller, Janovjak and Miserez29).
Table 2 Primer pair sequences, amplicon size (AS), annealing temperature (AT), efficiency (E) and Genbank accession number for genes used for quantitative real-time PCR
CD4, cluster of differentiation 4; TGF-β, transforming growth factor β; IFN-γ, interferon-γ; PCNA, proliferating cell nuclear antigen; HSP70, heat shock protein 70; CAT, catalase; SOD, superoxide dismutase; PEPT, peptide transporter; SGLT, sodium-dependent glucose transporter; ACTB, β-actin; RNA-POLII, RNA polymerase II; HPRT1, hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase 1; GAPDH, glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase.
Western blot analysis
A measure of 50 mg tissues samples from DI, head kidney and spleen were homogenised with 400 μl cold radioimmunoprecipitation assay lysis buffer (50 mm-Tris–HCl (pH 8·0), 150 mm-NaCl, 0·1 % SDS, 1 % Igepal CA-630, 0·5 % sodium deoxycholate, 2·5 mm-phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride (PMSF), 2·5 mm-EGTA, 4 mm-ethylene glycol tetraacetic acid (EGTA), 5 mm-sodium orthovanadate, 5 μg/ml aprotinin, 50 μg/ml leupeptin, 2 μg/ml pepstatin, 0·2 mg/ml benzamidine and 10 mm-sodium fluoride). The homogenates were centrifuged at 16 000 g at 4°C for 20 min and supernatants were collected. Protein content was quantified using the Bradford assay (Bio-Rad) with bovine serum albumin (BSA) as a standard.
Samples of 10 μg protein were prepared for SDS-PAGE and transferred to a nitrocellulose membrane (Invitrogen). Membranes were incubated with primary antibodies: rabbit polyclonal anti-GAPDH (1:250; Abcam); mouse monoclonal anti-CD4 (1:50; provided by Karsten Skjødt, University of Southern Denmark); and mouse monoclonal anti-proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) (1:2000; Dako) in 1 × Tris-buffered saline with Tween-20 (TBST) (50 mm-Tris–HCl (pH 7·5), 150 mm-NaCl, 0·1 % Tween 20) with 5 % non-fat dry milk and subsequently incubated with the alkaline phosphatase-conjugated secondary antibodies. The targeted proteins were visualised with fluorescence by ECF™ Western Blotting reagent Pack (GE Healthcare) and Typhoon 9200 imager system (Amersham Biosciences). ImageQuant software (Amersham Biosciences) was applied to quantify the band intensities. GAPDH was used as a reference for normalisation of the target protein expressions.
Calculations
$$\begin{eqnarray} Condition\,factor\,( K ) = (body\,weight/fork\,length^{3})\times 100. \end{eqnarray}$$
$$\begin{eqnarray} Organosomatic\,index = (organ\,weight/body\,weight)\times 100. \end{eqnarray}$$
$$\begin{eqnarray} Specific\,growth\,rate = ((ln\,final\,weight - ln\,initial\,weight)\times 100)/ t ;\, t = time\,in\,d. \end{eqnarray}$$
$$\begin{eqnarray} Feed\,efficiency = weight\,gain\,(g)/feed\,intake\,(g). \end{eqnarray}$$
$$\begin{eqnarray} Apparent\,digestibility\,coefficient\,(\%) = 100 - (100\times (nutrient\,in\,faeces/yttrium\,oxide\,in\,faeces)\times (yttrium\,oxide\,in\,feed/nutrient\,in\,feed)). \end{eqnarray}$$
$$\begin{eqnarray} Nutrient\,retention\,efficiency = 100\times nutrient\,gain/nutrient\,intake. \end{eqnarray}$$
$$\begin{eqnarray} Mean\,corpuscular\,volume = (haematocrit/erythrocytes)\times 10. \end{eqnarray}$$
$$\begin{eqnarray} Mean\,corpuscular\,Hb = (Hb/erythrocytes)\times 10;\,Hb = Hb\,(g/100\hairsp ml). \end{eqnarray}$$
$$\begin{eqnarray} Mean\,corpuscular\,Hb\,concentration = (Hb/haematocrit)\times 100. \end{eqnarray}$$
Statistics
The data were statistically evaluated using JMP version 9.0 (2010) Statistical Discovery™ (SAS Institute, Inc.). Normal distribution of data was tested using a plot of actual v. predicted residuals and the Shapiro–Wilk W-statistic on the residuals. The results were subjected to two-way ANOVA, with GM and SBM inclusion as the class variables. The data for mRNA expression (n 7 or 8) and protein levels (n 3) were analysed based on individual fish, while for other data tank means (n 3) were used. For the histological evaluation, results were compared using the χ2 test. All reported P values are two-sided and significance was set at P< 0·05.
Results
Proximate composition, as well as pesticide and mycotoxin levels in the two maize types are reported in Walsh et al. (Reference Walsh, Buzoianu and Gardiner30). Cry1Ab protein levels in the Bt MON810 maize was 0·6 parts per million (0·00 006 %), while the non-GM counterpart did not contain detectable levels of Cry1Ab. Analysed proximate compositions of the experimental diets (Table 1) were similar to calculated compositions. All diets were close to equivalent in composition, similar in protein, starch and ash. However, SBM-containing diets were slightly lower in lipid and gross energy and higher in residue levels.
During the entire feeding trial, all the fish appeared normal and no mortalities were observed. The fish fed the 15 % SBM inclusion diets were successfully sensitised (see Effects of soyabean meal section).
Effects of Bt-maize and interactions between GM and soyabean meal inclusion
Growth performance and feed utilisation
No differences in initial or final body weight, body weight gain, body length, specific growth rate, condition factor, feed intake or feed efficiency were observed between nGM maize- and Bt-maize-fed fish (Table 3). Nor were interactions between Bt-maize and SBM observed.
Table 3 Mean growth performance and feed utilisation of Atlantic salmon (initial body weight 93·8 (se 0·3) g) fed non-GM (nGM) maize or GM Bt-maize without or with soyabean meal (SBM) for 33 and 97 d†
nSBM, non-SBM; Bt, Bacillus thuringiensis; BW, body weight; BL, body length; BWG, body weight gain; SGR, specific growth rate; CF, condition factor; FI, feed intake; FE, feed efficiency. *P< 0·05.
† The P values are given for nGM/GM and nSBM/SBM inclusion, respectively, as well as for interactions between Bt-maize and SBM inclusion by two-way ANOVA analysis.
Proximate composition of whole body and liver
Bt-maize caused lower crude lipid deposition (Table 4). No effects on whole-body crude protein or DM, or on liver crude lipid, glycogen or DM were observed in Bt-maize-fed fish. No interactions between Bt-maize and SBM were observed.
Table 4 Mean composition of whole body and liver of Atlantic salmon fed non-GM (nGM) maize or GM Bt-maize without or with soyabean meal (SBM) for 97 d†
nSBM, non-SBM; Bt, Bacillus thuringiensis. *P< 0·05.
† The P values are given for nGM/GM and nSBM/SBM inclusion, respectively, as well as for interactions between Bt-maize and SBM inclusion by two-way ANOVA analysis.
Apparent nutrient digestibilities, faecal DM and nutrient retention efficiencies
Crude protein and mineral digestibility of the Bt-maize diets were reduced (P= 0·0456 and 0·0261, respectively; Fig. 1). Decreased crude lipid retention (P= 0·0203) and a tendency toward decreased energy retention (P= 0·0550) were observed in the fish fed Bt-maize (Fig. 2). No interactions between Bt-maize and SBM were found in any of these parameters.
Fig. 1 Apparent digestibility coefficients (ADC (%)) of crude protein, crude lipid, starch and mineral, as well as faecal DM (FDM) in fish fed the four experimental diets for 97 d. Values are means, with their pooled standard errors represented by vertical bars (n 3). *, **Significant effect of GM inclusion (two-way ANOVA). a,bSignificant effect of soyabean meal (SBM) inclusion (P< 0.05; two-way ANOVA). □, non-GM maize; 
, GM Bt-maize; 
, non-GM maize+SBM; 
, GM Bt-maize+SBM.
Fig. 2 Nutrient retention efficiencies (%) of DM, crude protein, crude lipid and energy in fish fed the four experimental diets for 97 d. Values are means, with their pooled standard errors represented by vertical bars (n 3). *, **Significant effect of GM inclusion (two-way ANOVA). a,bSignificant effect of soyabean meal (SBM) inclusion (P< 0.05; two-way ANOVA). □, non-GM maize; , GM Bt-maize; , non-GM maize+SBM; , GM Bt-maize+SBM.
Organosomatic indices
A transient (detected at 33 but not at 97 d) trend (P< 0·10) towards higher relative weights of whole intestine (P= 0·0924) and PI (P= 0·0752) were observed in fish fed Bt-maize diets (Table 5). Moreover, an interaction, albeit not significant (P= 0·0936), indicated that Bt-maize tended to increase PI weight reduced by SBM at 33 d. At 97 d, no differences were observed, nor were interactions between Bt-maize and SBM observed.
Table 5 Mean organosomatic indices (g/kg body mass) of head kidney (HKSI), spleen (SPSI), liver (LISI), whole intestine (ISI), proximal intestine (PISI), mid intestine (MISI), distal intestine (DISI) and gonad (GSI) of Atlantic salmon fed non-GM (nGM) maize or GM Bt-maize without or with soyabean meal (SBM) for 33 and 97 d†
nSBM, non-SBM; Bt, Bacillus thuringiensis.*P< 0·05.
† The P values are given for nGM/GM and nSBM/SBM inclusion, respectively, as well as for interactions between Bt-maize and SBM inclusion by two-way ANOVA analysis.
Haematology, leucocyte counts, plasma clinical chemistry and Cry1Ab-specific antibodies and protein in plasma
The Bt-maize did not cause any differences in haematological values or differential leucocyte counts (Table 6), or in plasma clinical chemistry (Table 7) at either 33 or 97 d. Nor were interactions between Bt-maize and SBM observed. Cry1Ab protein plasma concentrations were below detection limits and no specific antibodies (IgM) against Cry1Ab could be detected (data not shown).
Table 6 Mean haematological parameters including haematocrit (Hct), erythrocyte count, Hb, mean corpuscular volume (MCV), mean corpuscular Hb (MCH) and MCH concentration (MCHC) and differential leucocyte counts including lymphocytes, granulocytes and monocytes of Atlantic salmon fed non-GM (nGM) maize or GM Bt-maize without or with soyabean meal (SBM) for 33 and 97 d†
nSBM, non-SBM; Bt, Bacillus thuringiensis. *P< 0·05
† The P values are given for nGM/GM and nSBM/SBM inclusion, respectively, as well as for interactions between Bt-maize and SBM inclusion by two-way ANOVA analysis.
Table 7 Mean plasma clinical chemistry including total protein (Tprot), globulins, albumin, alanine aminotransferase (ALT), aspartate aminotransferase (AST), alkaline phosphatase (AP), amylase, lipase, TAG, total bilirubin, total bile acids, NEFA and cholesterol in Atlantic salmon fed non-GM (nGM) maize or GM Bt-maize without or with soyabean meal (SBM) for 33 and 97 d†
nSBM, non-SBM; Bt, Bacillus thuringiensis. *P< 0·05.
† The P values are given for nGM/GM and nSBM/SBM inclusion, respectively, as well as for interactions between Bt-maize and SBM inclusion by two-way ANOVA analysis.
Histology
The histomorphology of head kidney, spleen, liver, PI, MI (data not shown) and DI (Fig. 3 and Table 8; see also Effects of soyabean meal section), as assessed by light microscopy, did not differ between nGM maize- and Bt-maize-fed fish, nor were any interactions between Bt-maize and SBM observed.
Fig. 3 Histological details of distal intestinal simple folds of Atlantic salmon fed (A and E) non-GM (nGM)-maize, (B and F) GM Bt-maize, (C and G) GM Bt-maize with soyabean meal (SBM) and (D and H) Bt-maize with SBM diets for 33 and 97 d (haematoxylin and eosin; × 400). No differences between nGM and Bt-maize-fed fish were observed. The SBM-fed fish, however, showed reduced supranuclear vacuolisation (v) in enterocytes, widened lamina propria (lp) due to cellular infiltration and increased numbers of intra-epithelial lymphocytes (
) and goblet cells (
). The SBM-induced changes became exacerbated with time. (A colour version of this figure can be found online at http://www.journals.cambridge.org/bjn).
nGM, non-GM; nSBM, non-soyabean meal; SBM, soyabean meal; Bt, Bacillus thuringiensis. *P< 0·05
† The values signify the number of Atlantic salmon per dietary treatment that displayed the various degrees of morphological changes (n 12) following 33 and 97 d of feeding nGM maize or GM Bt-maize without or with soyabean meal (SBM). The changes were classified according to the criteria previously described(Reference Reite and Evensen14).
‡ The P values are given for nGM/GM and nSBM/SBM inclusion, respectively, as well as for interactions between Bt-maize and SBM inclusion.
Digestive enzyme activities and bile acid concentration
Bt-maize significantly decreased leucine aminopeptidase-specific activity (P= 0·0368; Fig. 4(B)) and tended to decrease enzymatic capacity (P= 0·0724; Fig. 4(A)) of PI tissue at 97 d. No differences in either trypsin activity or bile acid concentration in MI and/or DI content were caused by Bt-maize (Table 9). No interactions between Bt-maize and SBM were observed for any of these parameters.
Fig. 4 Activities of leucine aminopeptidase in intestinal tissue, as related to mmol substrate hydrolysed per unit time in the whole tissue per kg body weight (capacity; A) and per mg protein (specific activity; B), in proximal intestine (PI), mid intestine (MI) and distal intestine (DI) of Atlantic salmon fed the four experimental diets for 33 and 97 d. Values are means, with their pooled standard errors represented by vertical bars (n 3). *,** Significant effect of GM inclusion (two-way ANOVA). a,bSignificant effect of soyabean meal (SBM) inclusion (P< 0.05; two-way ANOVA). □, non-GM maize; , GM Bt-maize; , non-GM maize+SBM; , GM Bt-maize+SBM.
Table 9 Mean activities of trypsin (change in optical density units/mg DM) and concentration of bile acid (mg/g DM) in content of mid intestine (MI) and distal intestine (DI) of Atlantic salmon fed non-GM (nGM) maize or GM Bt-maize without or with soyabean meal (SBM) for 33 and 97 d†
nSBM, non-SBM; Bt, Bacillus thuringiensis. *P< 0·05
† The P values are given for nGM/GM and nSBM/SBM inclusion, respectively, as well as for interactions between Bt-maize and SBM inclusion by two-way ANOVA analysis.
mRNA expression in distal intestine tissue
Real-time quantitative PCR analyses were limited to the DI, where possible interactions in immune-sensitised salmon would be expected. The relative mRNA expression analyses of CD4, IL-1β, IL-17a, transforming growth factor-β, IFN-γ, PCNA, heat shock protein 70 (HSP70), catalase, superoxide dismutase (SOD), peptide transporter and sodium-dependent glucose transporter (SGLT) in DI are shown in Fig. 5(A)–(K), respectively.
Fig. 5 Normalised ratio of relative mRNA expression levels (quantitative real-time PCR) of genes in the distal intestine of salmon fed the four diets for 33 and 97 d: (A) cluster of differentiation 4 (CD4), (B) IL-1β, (C) IL-17a, (D) transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β), (E) interferon-γ (IFN-γ), (F) proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), (G) heat shock protein 70 (HSP70), (H) catalase (CAT), (I) superoxide dismutase (SOD), (J) proton-coupled peptide transporter (PEPT) and (K) sodium-dependent GLUT (SGLT). Values are means, with their pooled standard errors represented by vertical bars (n 7–8). *,** Significant effect of GM inclusion (two-way ANOVA). a,bSignificant effect of the soyabean meal (SBM) inclusion (P< 0.05; two-way ANOVA). y,zSignificant interaction between GM and SBM inclusion (P< 0.05; two-way ANOVA). □, non-GM maize; , GM Bt-maize; , non-GM maize+SBM; , GM Bt-maize+SBM.
Significant interactions between Bt-maize and SBM inclusion were observed for SOD (P= 0·0271) at 33 d (Fig. 5(I)), as well as IFN-γ (P= 0·0340; Fig. 5(E)), HSP70 (P= 0·0366; Fig. 5(G)) and SGLT (P= 0·0070; Fig. 5(K)) at 97 d. Bt-maize caused increased SOD (Fig. 5(I)) at 33 d and HSP70 (Fig. 5(G)) at 97 d only in SBM-fed fish. At 97 d, increased IFN-γ (Fig. 5(E)) was caused by Bt-maize feeding in normal fish, but this response appeared to be abolished or masked with SBM inclusion in the diet. For SGLT, the Bt-maize decreased its expression in normal fish, but not in fish fed SBM inclusion diets (Fig. 5(K)).
Western blot analyses of cluster of differentiation 4 and proliferating cell nuclear antigen
Western blot analyses of protein isolated from DI were analysed for CD4 and PCNA as local immune and toxicity indicators, respectively. Furthermore, protein isolated from head kidney and spleen were analysed for PCNA as an indicator of toxicity that may have escaped detection by plasma clinical chemistry, organosomatic indices or histological evaluation.
Single immunoreactive CD4 bands at approximately 51 kDa in DI (Fig. 6) and PCNA bands at approximately 31 kDa in head kidney, spleen and DI (Fig. 7) were detected. An increase in CD4 protein was transiently caused by Bt-maize at 33 d (P= 0·0436; Fig. 6). PCNA expression was transiently decreased in DI by Bt-maize at 33 d (P= 0·0330), but not at 97 d. The Bt-maize did not have any effect on PCNA protein levels in either HK (Fig. 7(A) and (B)) or spleen (Fig. 7(C) and (D)). No interactions between Bt-maize and SBM were observed for any of these parameters.
Fig. 6 Western blot analysis of cluster of differentiation 4 (CD4) protein in distal intestinal (DI) tissue of fish fed the four diets for 33 and 97 d. (A) Representative immunoblots including glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) control: lane 1 – non-GM (nGM) maize; lane 2 – GM Bt-maize; lane 3 – nGM maize+soyabean meal (SBM); and lane 4 – GM Bt-maize+SBM. Values are means, with their pooled standard errors represented by vertical bars (n 3). The respective relative immunostaining intensities (B) are also shown. *,** Significant effect of GM inclusion (two-way ANOVA). □, nGM maize; , GM Bt-maize; , nGM maize+SBM; , GM Bt-maize+SBM.
Fig. 7 Western blot analysis of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) protein in (A and B) head kidney (HK), (C and D) spleen (SP) and (E and F) distal intestine (DI) of fish fed the four experimental diets for 33 and 97 d. Representative immunoblots (A, C and E) including glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) control: lane 1 – non-GM (nGM)-maize; lane 2 – GM Bt-maize; lane 3 – nGM maize+ Soyabean meal (SBM) and lane 4 – GM Bt-maize+SBM. The respective relative immunostaining intensities are also shown (B, D and F). Values are means, with their pooled standard errors represented by vertical bars (n 3). *,** Significant effect of GM inclusion (two-way ANOVA). a,bSignificant effect of the soyabean meal (SBM) inclusion (P< 0.05; two-way ANOVA). □, nGM maize; , GM Bt-maize; , nGM maize+SBM; , GM Bt-maize+SBM.
Effects of soyabean meal
The fish fed 15 % SBM inclusion diets were sensitised, as indicated by mild-to-moderate histopathological signs of inflammation in DI (Fig. 3 and Table 8). These were characterised by increased width of the lamina propria and submucosa, infiltration of inflammatory cells, decreased enterocyte vacuolisation, increased goblet cell frequency and a shift of enterocyte nuclei from basal to a more apical position. With time, the inflammation became exacerbated and fusion of mucosal folds was also observed. Moreover, the SBM-fed fish also showed reduced faecal DM (diarrhoea; Fig. 1), decreased intestinal and liver weights (Table 5), increased trypsin activity in DI content (Table 9) and increased CD4 mRNA levels in the DI at 97 d (Fig. 5(A)).
Other results also indicated reduced performance and organ malfunction associated with the hypersensitivity reactions, such as decreased growth performance and feed and nutrient utilisation and retention (Tables 3 and 4; Fig. 1), erythrocyte mean corpuscular volume (Table 6) at 33 d and plasma alkaline phosphatase, bile acid, cholesterol and NEFA concentrations (Table 7), despite no difference in feed intake (Table 3). The fish exhibited maldigestion, as indicated by lower macronutrient digestibilities (Fig. 1), digestive enzyme activities (Fig. 3) and nutrient transporter mRNA levels (peptide transporter and SGLT; Fig. 5(J) and (K), respectively), as well as changes in trypsin activity and bile acid concentration in the intestinal content (Table 9). Increased PCNA mRNA and protein (Figs. 5, respectively), HSP70 mRNA (Fig. 5(G)) and decreased catalase mRNA (Fig. 5(H)) in DI are also indicative of malfunction of the inflamed tissue.
Discussion
Despite somewhat lower protein and mineral digestibility of the Bt-maize containing diets, growth and feed efficiency after 97 d of feeding did not differ between fish fed Bt-maize or nGM maize. However, Bt-maize appeared to cause changes in nutrient metabolism, either locally in the intestine or systemically, as indicated by the reduced whole-body lipid content and lipid retention efficiency, a response not previously observed in Bt-maize-fed salmon(Reference Hemre, Sagstad and Bakke-McKellep31). The battery of analyses conducted did not reveal any remarkable differences that unequivocally explain this finding, although tendencies of higher intestinal weights and increased CD4 protein, albeit transient, as well as relative mRNA expression of IFN-γ in DI may indicate that local changes in tissue growth and immune responses in the intestinal tissue may have had a metabolic cost. Maintenance of the intestine has been estimated to require as much as 20–25 % of an organism's daily nutrient and energy requirements(Reference Ferrell32), and changes in intestinal growth may therefore account for reduced body lipid stores. The Bt (Cry) protein has been characterised as lectin-like(Reference Burton, Ellar and Li33–Reference Knowles, Thomas and Ellar35) and the data suggest that this protein or other components in the Bt-maize may act as growth factor(s) in the intestine of salmon, leading to an increase in relative intestinal weights. Some lectins, such as phytohaemagglutinin, have been demonstrated to function as growth factors for the intestinal mucosa(Reference Linderoth, Prykhod'ko and Ahrén36–Reference Bardocz, Grant and Ewen38). Correspondingly, lower activity of the brush-border enzyme leucine aminopeptidase in PI may indicate that the growth led to an increase in immature epithelial cells that had not developed full functionality(Reference Bakke-McKellep, Penn and Salas39). This again may explain the lower nutrient digestibility in fish fed Bt-maize-containing diets.
The histological evaluation indicated that the presence of Bt-maize in diets neither caused damage to any organs or tissues, nor did it appear to change the SBM-induced hypersensitivity reaction in salmon DI. This was supported by the general lack of differences in haematological and plasma clinical chemistry values. This is in agreement with results of earlier studies in salmon(Reference Sanden, Berntssen and Krogdahl40, Reference Bakke-McKellep, Sanden and Danieli41). Similarly, light microscopy investigation in liver and pancreas of sheep following oral exposure to Bt176-maize did not reveal histological changes. However, at higher magnification with electron microscopy, smaller, irregularly shaped cell nuclei containing increased amounts of granules in hepatocytes and pancreatic acinar cells were caused by Bt176-maize(Reference Trabalza-Marinucci, Brandi and Rondini42). Moreover, electron microscopy also revealed that nuclei in pancreatic acinar cells, hepatocytes and testes cells were modified by GM soyabean(Reference Malatesta, Caporaloni and Gavaudan43–Reference Vecchio, Cisterna and Malatesta45). Thus, electron microscopy analysis may be necessary for further investigation of Bt-maize effects on subcellular structures in salmon tissues.
The transient increase in CD4 mRNA expression and protein level in DI caused by Bt-maize indicated presence of CD4+ T effector cell. The reason for the transient nature of these responses is unknown. It does, however, imply development of tolerance to the Bt-maize following a period of oral exposure. Cry1Ab protein immunoreactivity may be conserved as it passed through the digestive tract, as indicated by in vitro digestion trials, in which the protein was only slightly degraded at pH 2 even at high pepsin-to-substrate ratio(Reference Guimaraes, Drumare and Lereclus6). The protein or immunoreactive fragments of the protein was also found in the digesta of pigs(Reference Walsh, Buzoianu and Gardiner25) fed the same batch of Bt-maize as the salmon in the present study. The pH range along the gastrointestinal tracts of Atlantic salmon is 4·5–8·6(Reference Nordrum, Krogdahl and Røsjø21, Reference Nordrum, Olli and Røsjø46), thus higher than most monogastric mammals. Therefore, it is likely that the Cry1Ab protein escapes full digestion also in the salmon gastrointestinal tract. The elevated DI IFN-γ expression observed in the Bt-maize-fed fish is an indication that a local immune response is elicited following more than 3 months of dietary exposure. The cytokine is produced by CD4 and CD8 effector T cells once antigen-specific immunity develops(Reference Schoenborn and Wilson47). It has been reported that IFN-γ and other cytokines, such as IL-12, IL-10 and IL-4, were induced in cultured mice spleen cells by Cry1A protein(Reference Guerrero, Russell and Moreno-Fierros8). Thus, the CD4 and IFN-γ transcriptional responses merit further investigations as biomarker candidates for exposure to GM maize.
With few exceptions, responses to Bt-maize exposure were generally not influenced by the SBM-induced hypersensitivity reaction. The only significant interactions detected were with quantitative PCR analyses from the DI. SBM-inclusion in the diets appeared to increase the DI response to Bt-maize regarding HSP70, SOD (transient effect) and possibly SGLT mRNA levels. For the latter, IFN-γ has been shown to decrease ion transporter presence or activity in intestinal epithelium in higher vertebrates(Reference Bertelsen, Eckmann and Barrett48–Reference Woo, Gildea and Tack50) and result in malabsorption of ions(Reference Woo, Gildea and Tack50, Reference Musch, Clarke and Mamah51). Thus, the elevated IFN-γ expression in DI may explain the tendency of decreased SGLT mRNA expression, and also help explain the reduced mineral digestibility observed in Bt-maize-fed salmon. For HSP70 and SOD, the dependency of the Bt-maize effects on sensitised fish indicates a potentiating effect on cellular stress responses. On the other hand, the opposite was seen with IFN-γ, in which SBM appeared to ameliorate the increase caused by Bt-maize alone. However, the dependency of the Bt-maize effects on sensitised fish for all these genes were generally low, so that the implications for the general health of the fish appeared to be marginal, as confirmed by other findings in the fish following 97 d of exposure to the Bt-maize.
Other responses to Bt-maize observed in the present study may be of lower value as biomarkers, as they are quite unspecific and differed from results in earlier studies in salmon and other animals fed the same GM-event maize or other crop plants. For example, the lack of effects on feed intake and growth was not in agreement with the earlier studies in salmon, in which the same GM-event maize significantly decreased both(Reference Hemre, Sagstad and Bakke-McKellep31). Nor were the significantly decreased protein and ash digestibilities, lipid retention, lipid content in filet and unchanged starch digestibility observed in the present study in line with results reported by Hemre et al. (Reference Hemre, Sagstad and Bakke-McKellep31). A 3-year study on sheep, however, reported decreased plasma potassium levels caused by Bt-maize(Reference Bakke-McKellep, Sanden and Danieli41). It has been reported earlier that Bt-maize induced increased liver and DI weights and decreased spleen and head kidney weights in Atlantic salmon(Reference Hemre, Sagstad and Bakke-McKellep31) and enlarged spleen in rats(Reference de Vendômois, Roullier and Cellier11). However, no effects of Bt-maize on these organs were currently observed in salmon. Nor were unchanged peptide transporter 1 mRNA in DI in agreement with an earlier study(Reference Frøystad-Saugen, Lilleeng and Bakke-McKellep52). Previous studies showed that plasma total protein or albumin tended to decrease in rats and broiler chickens fed Bt-rice, Bt-maize or Bt-cottonseed meal(Reference Kiliç and Akay10, Reference Schroder, Poulsen and Wilcks53–Reference Elangovan, Tyagi and Shrivastav55). However, Bt-maize did not cause any changes in plasma protein level or osmolality in the present study, which indicate that the decreased protein and mineral digestibilities of the Bt-maize diets were not enough to negatively influence salmon health during the timespan encompassed by this feeding trial.
Furthermore, changes in cellular proliferation (PCNA) in DI, spleen or head kidney do not appear to be of value as biomarkers for Bt-maize exposure. Changes in normal intestinal cell renewal have been suggested as early indicators for abnormal or toxic conditions in the gastrointestinal tract(Reference Bakke-McKellep, Penn and Salas39, Reference Ortego, Hawkins and Walker56–Reference Hemre, Deng and Wilson60). It has been reported that Cry1A can bind to the intestinal mucosal surfaces, influencing some epithelial cell functions(Reference Vázquez-Padrón, Moreno-Fierros and Neri-Bazán61). The expression of a proliferation marker, Ki-67, was significantly higher in the basal cells of the ruminal epithelium of sheep fed Bt-maize(Reference Bakke-McKellep, Sanden and Danieli41). As the DI was the main region showing histomorphological changes in the present study, PCNA mRNA and protein expression were determined in this tissue as well as in the immunologically important tissues, spleen and head kidney. PCNA was increased both at gene and protein expression level in the DI of fish with SBM-induced hypersensitivity, as reported in other studies(Reference Bakke-McKellep, Penn and Salas39, Reference Sanden, Berntssen and Krogdahl40). Analyses in more proximal intestinal regions, where tendencies of increased tissue weights were observed in the Bt-maize-fed fish, would be useful in future studies to assess PCNA as a potential biomarker for Bt-maize exposure.
Conclusions
In the present study, an overall evaluation of health and growth performance indicated that Bt-maize (MON810) in diets for normal and SBM-sensitised Atlantic salmon resulted in lower protein and mineral digestibility as well as lipid and energy retention, indicating that these fish utilised and metabolised feed less efficiently compared to those fed the nGM maize. The increased IFN-γ associated with the tendency of decreased SGLT expression may partly explain the lower nutrient and mineral digestibilities in Bt-maize-fed salmon. Metabolic costs associated with higher intestinal growth and immune responses, as indicated by elevated distal intestinal IFN-γ mRNA expression levels and transient CD4 protein level, may explain lower lipid retention. Furthermore, Bt-maize may potentiate oxidative cellular stress in the DI of fish afflicted with an intestinal hypersensitivity reaction, as indicated by increases in SOD mRNA and HSP70 mRNA. The increases in CD4 protein and IFN-γ mRNA in the DI of Bt-maize-fed fish suggest that Cry1Ab protein or other antigens produced due to genetic modification have potential local immunogenic effects in the gastrointestinal tract and may function as biomarkers for MON810-event maize exposure for this species. However, long-term observations and more in-depth studies on immune responses and nutrient utilisation may be needed to confirm these results. Testing maize gluten meal derived from GM maize, a more commonly used, protein-rich maize product in salmonid diets, would also be of practical value for the aquaculture industry.
Acknowledgements
The study was supported by a European Union Seventh Framework Programme grant (GMSAFOOD, grant no. 211820). The authors wish to thank Asbjørn Valset at Nofima Marine research station at Sunndalsøra, Norway for skilled animal care, and Ellen K. Hage, Elin C. Valen and Gunn C. Østby in our lab in Oslo for excellent technical assistance. Å. K., E. G. and A. M. B. helped secured the funding for the research. A. M. B. and Å. K. designed the study. J. G., Å. K., N. H. S., G.-I. H. and A. M. B. participated in the sampling. J. G., N. H. S., T. M. K. and E. G. conducted the laboratory analyses. J. G. performed the histological evaluation. J. G., T. M. K. and A. M. B. wrote the manuscript and all authors have read and approved the final manuscript. The authors have declared no conflicts of interest.
