Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gxg78 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T09:29:05.309Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Where do goals of care conversations belong? A case for the emergency department

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 July 2019

Brittany Cameron*
Affiliation:
University of Toronto, Family Medicine, Toronto, ON
Andreas Laupacis
Affiliation:
St. Michael's Hospital, Department of Palliative Care, Li Ka Shing Knowledge Institute, Toronto, ON
*
Correspondence to: Dr. Brittany Cameron, 2707-126 Simcoe St., Toronto, ON M5H 4E6; Email: [email protected].

Abstract

Type
Commentary
Copyright
Copyright © Canadian Association of Emergency Physicians 2019 

INTRODUCTION

Emergency medicine developed as a specialty to provide life-sustaining and disease-oriented care for patients with acute illness.Reference Grudzen, Corita and Stone1 However, some life prolonging measures offered in emergency departments (EDs) to patients with advanced disease may not be in keeping with patients’ goals or wishes at the end of life. We commonly define goals-of-care conversations to involve both a discussion about resuscitation preferences or “code status,” in addition to making decisions about treatment, the intensity of care, and planning for future care needs. An encounter I had during my first year of residency allowed me to reflect upon the importance of engaging in goals-of-care conversations early in presentation to hospital – most often in the setting of the ED.

A 91-year-old female with advanced dementia presented to the ED with fever, bilious, non-bloody emesis, and diffuse abdominal pain. She had not had a bowel movement in 48 hours, with decreased oral intake and urine output. The patient lived with her appointed power of attorney (POA), her daughter, and was dependent for both basic and instrumental activities of daily living. When assessed in the ED, the patient was febrile, alert, however disoriented to person, place, and time, which was representative of her baseline level of confusion. Her abdomen was soft, with diffuse tenderness, greatest in the right lower quadrant. The patient had a lymphocytosis with a white blood cell count of 12, elevated lactate of 2.1, hemoglobin of 104. A computed tomography (CT) scan revealed a closed loop, small bowel obstruction, and the acute surgical service was consulted.

Admitted under surgery, the patient was monitored over the course of the weekend with nasogastric tube insertion. Due to comorbidities, advanced cognitive disease, and high surgical risk, conservative medical management later became the definitive plan. Early in her admission, the patient became more acutely confused, frequently removing the nasogastric tube in agitation. Subsequently 48 hours following, with no signs of clinical improvement, the surgical team met with the patient's daughter and POA to address Do-Not-Resuscitate status. As POA, the daughter expressed that her mother's primary request was to be made comfortable and allow for a natural death, with minimal interventions. At this stage, a consultation to the palliative care team was made for optimization of pain management and fulfillment of the patient's original care goals. The patient succumbed to her illness on the Palliative Care Unity in the days shortly thereafter.

Working with the palliative care team, I had the benefit of analysing this case in the rear-view mirror. I could appreciate how a case like this could slip through the cracks: a common surgical complaint referred to surgery and lost in the shuffle over the course of a busy weekend with multiple attending physicians. Despite this, it remains clear that the patient's course in the hospital could have been altered had a conversation surrounding goals of care been had in the ED.

GOALS OF CARE IN THE ED

Although not typically seen as an ideal environment to discuss goals of care, the ED represents an important point at which healthcare providers can guide patients in navigating their further management and personal goals related to care.Reference Grudzen, Corita and Stone1 In Canada, the experience of dying most often occurs in the hospital, commonly involving a substantial number of interventions and investigations.Reference You, Dodek and Lamontagne2 One fifth of deaths occur in an intensive care unitReference Cook, Rocker and Marshall3 while rates of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) prior to death continue to increase among the elderly population.Reference Ehlenbach, Barnato and Curtis4

QUALITY OF LIFE OVER QUANTITY

Because patients presenting to EDs are increasingly advanced in age and more medically complex, greater clinical skill is required of the ED physician in symptom management and end-of-life care. While hardwired to provide heroic measures in an efficient manner, emergency physicians must also recognize and respect illness presentations where further efforts may not be futile or in keeping with a patient's goals of care. A recent Canadian study found that 80% of older adult patients in the hospital with a serious illness prefer a less aggressive and more comfort-oriented end-of-life care plan that does not include CPR.Reference Heyland, Barwich and Pichora5 For many patients, the focus will shift towards maximizing general well-being and comfort, with the value of quality of life outweighing that of quantity.Reference Smith, White and Arnold6

Patients with dementia are at a heightened risk for in-hospital death, and an increasing proportion of the population is dying from advanced dementia. Physicians often under-recognize the terminal nature of the gradual loss of cognition and function seen in dementia, as research demonstrates that dementia patients frequently receive suboptimal end-of-life care, and often burdensome interventions.Reference Ouchi, Wu and Medairos7

Early palliative care can benefit both patients and healthcare systems. At a systems level, incorporation of palliative care into EDs can limit healthcare spending without compromising quality of care. Recent evidence demonstrates that early integration into palliative care can reduce ED visits and hospitalizations by up to 50%.Reference Wang8

Initiating a palliative care consultation directly from the ED shortens length of stay by an average of 4 days, resulting in fewer in-hospital deaths (Wu et al., 2013) while significantly increasing quality of life without reducing overall survival (Grudzen et al., 2016).Reference Wu, Newman, Lasher and Brody9,Reference Grudzen, Emlet, Kuntz, Shreves, Zimny, Gang, Schaulis, Schmidt, Isaacs and Arnold10

USING EFFECTIVE COMMUNICATION STRATEGIES

A number of barriers make engaging in goals-of-care conversations with patients challenging for emergency physicians. Limited time, privacy, and a lack of an established therapeutic relationship compound an already difficult conversation.Reference Rogers and Lukin11 Research indicates that emergency physicians also cite challenges in predicting illness trajectory during a brief encounter in the ED.Reference Argintaru, Quinn and Chartier12 Despite some prognostic uncertainty, emergency physicians can rely upon effective communication strategies to convey important messages to patients and their families about disease outlook and viable symptom management options. Wang et al.Reference Rogers and Lukin11 highlight a method to approach a brief goals-of-care conversation in the ED setting (Table 1).

Table 1. A systematic, 5-minute approach to ED goals-of-care conversations.

Palliative care in emergency medicine offers patients and families support along the entire continuum of care and is best if instituted as early as possible.Reference Rogers and Lukin11 Using a simple framework to engage in goals-of-care conversations can make the process more accessible for emergency physicians. Often deferred and addressed later during an admission, it's important to recognize that palliative care can begin in the ED and successfully bridge into inpatient and outpatient services. It can radically improve the way that patients interact with the healthcare system, while enhancing comfort and dignity at the end of life.

Acknowledgments

Dr. Brittany Cameron would like to acknowledge the support of Dr. Nicholas Pimlott and the Case Report Writing Group at Women's College Hospital.

Competing interests

None declared.

References

REFERENCES

1.Grudzen, S, Corita, R, Stone, R. The palliative care model for emergency department patients with advanced illness. J Palliat Med 2011;14(8):945–50.Google Scholar
2.You, J, Dodek, P, Lamontagne, F, et al. What really matters in end-of-life discussions? Perspectives of patients in hospital with serious illness and their families. CMAJ 2014;186(18):E679–87.Google Scholar
3.Cook, D, Rocker, G, Marshall, J, et al. ; Level of Care Study Investigators and the Canadian Critical Care Trials Group. Withdrawal of mechanical ventilation in anticipation of death in the intensive care unit. N Engl J Med 2003;349:1123–32.Google Scholar
4.Ehlenbach, WJ, Barnato, AE, Curtis, JR, et al. Epidemiologic study of in-hospital cardiopulmonary resuscitation in the elderly. N Engl J Med 2009;361:2231.Google Scholar
5.Heyland, DK, Barwich, D, Pichora, D, et al. ; ACCEPT (Advance Care Planning Evaluation in Elderly Patients) Study Team; Canadian Researchers at the End of Life Network (CARENET). Failure to engage seriously ill hospitalized patients and their families in advance care planning: results of a multicenter prospective study. JAMA Intern Med 2013;173:778–87.Google Scholar
6.Smith, AK, White, DB, Arnold, RM. Uncertainty: the other side of prognosis. N Engl J Med 2013;368(26):2448–50.Google Scholar
7.Ouchi, K, Wu, M, Medairos, R, et al. Initiating palliative care consults for advanced dementia patients in the emergency department. J Palliat Med 2014;17(3):349.Google Scholar
8.Wang, D. Beyond code status: palliative care begins in the emergency department. Ann Emerg Med 2017;69(4):437–43.Google Scholar
9.Wu, F, Newman, J, Lasher, A, Brody, A. Effects of initiating palliative care consultation in the emergency department on inpatient length of stay. J Palliat Med 2013;16(11):1362–7.Google Scholar
10.Grudzen, C, Emlet, L, Kuntz, J, Shreves, A, Zimny, E, Gang, M, Schaulis, M, Schmidt, S, Isaacs, E, Arnold, R. EM Talk: communication skills training for emergency medicine patients with serious illness. BMJ Supportive & Palliative Care 2016;6(2):219–24.Google Scholar
11.Rogers, I, Lukin, B. Applying palliative care principles and practice to emergency medicine. Emerg Med Australas 2015;27(6):612–5.Google Scholar
12.Argintaru, N, Quinn, K, Chartier, L, et al. Perceived barriers and facilitators to goals of care discussions in the emergency department: a descriptive analysis of the views of emergency medicine physicians and residents. CJEM 2019;21(2):211–8.Google Scholar
Figure 0

Table 1. A systematic, 5-minute approach to ED goals-of-care conversations.