The destruction of tropical forests is one of the main threats to primate survival at both local and global scales (Butti et al., Reference Butti, Pacca, Santos, Alonso, Buss and Ludwig2002; Estrada et al., Reference Estrada, Garber, Rylands, Roos, Fernandez-Duque and Di Fiore2017, Reference Estrada, Garber, Mittermeier, Wich, Gouveia and Dobrovolski2018; Fernández et al., Reference Fernández, Kerhoas, Dempsey, Billany, McCabe and Argirova2022). Habitat loss and fragmentation result in small, isolated populations that will become inviable in the near future (Shaffer, Reference Shaffer1981; Brito, Reference Brito2009). In these cases, management programmes involving translocations and reintroductions of individuals or groups are needed to establish the genetic and demographic variation necessary for populations to persist (Kierulff et al., Reference Kierulff, Procópio-de-Oliveira, Martins, Valladares-Pádua, Porfírio, Oliveira and Bicca-Marques2007).
Here we describe a conservation management initiative for the northern muriqui Brachyteles hypoxanthus, a Critically Endangered primate endemic to the Atlantic Forest of south-eastern Brazil. Approximately 1,000 individuals are known to occur in 12 populations, only half of which comprise > 100 individuals (Strier et al., Reference Strier, Possamai, Tabacow, Pissinatti, Lanna and Melo2017; Melo et al., Reference Melo, Boubli, Mittermeier, Jerusalinsky, Tabacow and Ferraz2021). The other, smaller populations vary in size, with the smallest in the Mata dos Luna, a forest remnant of c. 40 ha at Ibitipoca in Lima Duarte, Minas Gerais, Brazil (Fig. 1).
In 2002 there were 10 individuals in a mixed-sex group in the northern muriqui population in the Ibitipoca forest (Oliveira, Reference Oliveira2003; Nogueira et al., Reference Nogueira, Ferraz, Oliveira, Tabacow, Amâncio and Melo2010). By 2015 only two adult males remained. Northern muriquis can be individually identified by their natural markings, and the Ibitipoca males were assigned unique codenames (BER-IB, LUN-IB) to distinguish them and their population of origin. The isolation of this population from other northern muriqui populations precluded any possibility of female recruitment without intervention. Thus, following the Brazilian National Action Plan for the Conservation of Muriquis (Jerusalinsky et al., Reference Jerusalinsky, Talebi and Melo2011), we started a management project with both in situ and ex situ management components, to preserve what remained of the genetic diversity of this population.
Northern muriquis typically live in multi-male, multi-female groups in which males are philopatric and females disperse from their natal groups prior to the onset of puberty (Strier & Ziegler, Reference Strier and Ziegler2000; Strier et al., Reference Strier, Possamai, Mendes, Furuichi, Aureli and Yamagiwa2015). This information, along with many other insights about the demographics, diet and feeding, ranging and social and reproductive behaviour of muriquis, comes from the long-term Muriqui Project of Caratinga (Strier, Reference Strier2021). Whenever appropriate we used this knowledge about wild northern muriquis to inform our conservation management decisions.
Females born in isolated populations that support only a single social group either remain in their natal groups, where they risk breeding with close relatives, or disperse into other forest fragments, where they spend their lives alone (Tabacow et al., Reference Tabacow, Nery, Melo, Ferreira, Lessa and Strier2021). Solitary females have been translocated into other small populations, where they successfully reproduced with resident males (Mendes et al., Reference Mendes, Santos and Carmo2005; Tabacow et al., Reference Tabacow, Nery, Melo, Ferreira, Lessa and Strier2021). We initially employed a similar approach in the Ibitipoca population.
In January 2017 we translocated a solitary female (ESM-FE) from a forest fragment in Ferros, Minas Gerais, 285 km north of the Mata dos Luna. We initially released the female into a 5 × 3 m, 5 m high, outdoor wire mesh enclosure constructed for this purpose in a clearing within the forested home range of the two males. The intention was to give her time to habituate to her new location and to permit observers to monitor her health and adaptation after the translocation. We also hoped that her presence would attract the males and subsequently facilitate her integration into their group.
We released her 3 days later, but she did not interact with the males, nor did they approach or follow her. She travelled instead to a distant patch of forest, where observers were able to follow her movements until she disappeared 9 months later.
It is possible that ESM-FE's history of living alone for at least the previous 2 years, combined with the absence of female associates for the two Ibitipoca males over at least 8 years, could have inhibited them from engaging in social interactions, as has occurred in other populations in which solitary females were translocated and released into established mixed-sex groups (Tabacow et al., Reference Tabacow, Nery, Melo, Ferreira, Lessa and Strier2021). We concluded that more controlled conditions of captivity would be necessary to increase the opportunities for social interactions that would lead to the formation of a group with reproductive potential.
We implemented a new approach, bringing the animals into an open-air 20 × 8 m, 9 m high, wire enclosure constructed adjacent to a 1.84 ha patch of native secondary forest vegetation 11 km from Mata dos Luna. The enclosure, the adjacent forested area and the surrounding open area bounded by electric fencing form a complex that we named Muriqui House.
The enclosure part of Muriqui House has two sections separated by a wire mesh window and wooden door that can be opened or closed whenever it is necessary to separate any of the animals. There are hatches that open into each section for offering food and four platforms for resting. Within this enclosure a variety of wooden supports and some remnant native trees permit the northern muriquis to engage in their typical suspensory mode of locomotion. In addition, there are sheltered areas that provide protection from poor weather conditions. At each end there are passages that can be opened to permit access to the forest adjacent to the enclosure (Plate 1).
A total of 146 native plant species have been identified in this forested area within the Muriqui House complex, 30 of which are known to be eaten by wild northern muriquis elsewhere (Strier, Reference Strier1991). Four supplemental feeding platforms (1 × 1 m) were constructed 3 m above the forest floor. The entire Muriqui House complex (enclosure plus forest and an open area under restoration) is surrounded by 3.83 ha of cleared habitat, where 2,500 plants of various native species have been planted for vegetation restoration. The perimeter is surrounded by nets and electrical wires to protect the northern muriquis from predators and to prevent escapes (Fig. 1).
We captured the two adult males, BER-IB and LUN-IB, and released them into the Muriqui House enclosure in May and August 2019, respectively, where they joined a solitary female (ECO-S) known to be c. 9 years of age. She had been translocated from the area surrounding the Reserva Particular do Patrimônio Natural (Private Natural Heritage Reserve) Mata do Sossego in Simonésia, Minas Gerais, Brazil, and we released her into the enclosure in March 2019 (Tabacow et al., Reference Tabacow, Nery, Melo, Ferreira, Lessa and Strier2021). We translocated a second solitary female (SOC-S), estimated to be c. 20 years of age, from the same area as ECO-S and introduced her into the enclosure in October 2019, completing what became the four-member founder group.
We carried out all captures in accordance with previous recommendations (Oliveira et al., Reference Oliveira, Tabacow, Gasparotto, Procópio, Frasson and Teixeira2020; Teixeira et al., Reference Teixeira, Bernal-Valle, Ramos, Santos, Abreu and Santos2022). Veterinarians monitored the animals closely following pre-established protocols for sedation during capture through to their transport and release into the enclosure (Valença-Montenegro et al., Reference Valença-Montenegro, Melo and Jerusalinsky2021).
From the outset we provisioned the occupants of Muriqui House with a diet that resembled the leaves and fruits that northern muriquis are known to eat in the wild, supplemented with flowers, nectar and seeds (Strier, Reference Strier1991). We experimented by adjusting food quantities and substituting items whilst striving to maintain an appropriate nutritional balance rich in fibre, protein and carbohydrates. The acceptance of the northern muriquis of green, leafy vegetables, including collard greens, broccoli and cabbage, was important as these items contributed significant quantities of fibre to their diets. We developed a diet composed of four menus offered on alternating days, with the food provided at different times and locations in the enclosure to stimulate natural foraging practices of the northern muriqui. We offered leaves on all menus. We mostly offered foods high in protein, energy, fat, vitamins and minerals in the morning, and mostly offered vegetables in the afternoons. The northern muriquis also supplemented their diets by sampling the plants growing in the enclosure.
We used environmental enrichments to maintain the health, quality of life and behavioural repertoire of the northern muriquis. These enrichments included providing natural food items for their menus, which we collected from the surrounding forests, constructing support structures to encourage their natural suspensory locomotion, and attaching provisioned fruit below branches to stimulate natural foraging postures (Iurck et al., Reference Iurck, Nowak, Costa, Mendes, Ford and Strier2013).
Throughout daylight hours, trained observers monitored the northern muriquis, collecting behavioural data using scan and focal animal samples following the ethogram and sampling protocols established from long-term field studies of the behaviour and ecology of a wild northern muriqui population (Strier, Reference Strier1999). The northern muriquis engaged in affiliative behaviours and vocalizations typical of this species in the wild, including extended, intense affiliative embracing between the two males. Thus, as anticipated, the enclosure facilitated social interactions not only amongst the two males, who were already familiar with one another, but also amongst the females and between the males and females. During November 2019–February 2020 we observed BER-IB copulating twice with each of the two females.
In February 2020 we released the northern muriquis into the forested area of the Muriqui House complex, where we maintained their provisioned diet but where they also foraged on naturally occurring plants. Once released into the forest of Muriqui House we observed BER-IB copulating with ECO-S during 8–19 March 2020. ECO-S gave birth to her first infant, ELI-IB, on 3 November 2020, 229 days after her last observed copulation (Plate 1). This is longer than the median 216 days gestation length (range: 214.5–218.5 days) described from faecal steroid analyses of a larger sample of wild females (Strier & Ziegler, Reference Strier and Ziegler1997), suggesting that at least one subsequent copulation, which was responsible for the conception, had been missed by observers.
On 12 November 2020 we translocated a third solitary female (NEN-PNC), estimated to be c. 5 years of age, from the Caparaó region, in Espírito Santo State, Brazil, where one of the largest northern muriqui populations is located (Clyvia et al., Reference Clyvia, Ferraz, Novaes, Moura, Lacerda and Alves2020). As with the other northern muriquis, we initially released NEN-PNC into the enclosure to acclimatize, and on 18 January 2021 we released her into the forested part of the Muriqui House complex. Consistent with the pattern of social integration observed amongst immigrant female northern muriquis in the wild (Strier et al., Reference Strier, Possamai, Mendes, Furuichi, Aureli and Yamagiwa2015), NEN-PNC initially associated with the males, avoided the females and engaged in playful interactions with the infant. There are now six northern muriquis in this newly established group.
There are many difficulties intrinsic to a project of this size, such as the availability of specialized personnel and the construction and maintenance of structures. There are also challenges inherent in artificially manipulating the formation of a group of animals with a complex social system. Nonetheless, we have shown the feasibility of managing male northern muriquis from the same natal group with females from different locations to establish a new social group with demonstrated reproductive potential. Our success was based on promoting social interactions consistent with the natural behaviour of the species in a setting that permits us to monitor their behaviour, nutrition and health. The consolidation of this new social group offers hope for the repopulation of northern muriquis in the forests of Ibitipoca and for the maintenance of their genetic diversity. The experiences obtained from this approach could also be useful for similar initiatives for the conservation of other reduced populations of northern muriquis and other primates.
Author contributions
Study design: FRdM, FPT, MSN, MV-M, LSM, KBS, LJ; fieldwork: FRdM, FPT, PMP, MSN, EPTT, DS-T; data analysis, writing: FRdM, FPT, PMP, MSN, EPTT, DS-T, MV-M, KBS, LJ; funding acquisition: FRdM, FPT, MSN, KBS.
Acknowledgements
We thank Renato Machado, Beto Nardelli, Raquel Pazos and the Ibiti Projeto (SISBIO License No. 64.438-6) for permissions and financial support; the Mohamed bin Zayed Conservation Fund and Fundação Grupo Boticário for financial support to FRdM; the Taxon Advisory Group of the American Association of Zoos and Aquariums for financial support to KBS; the Instituto Estadual de Florestas de Minas Gerais and Instituto Chico Mendes de Conservação da Biodiversidade for logistical support; the Universidade Federal de Viçosa for logistical support and scholarships for Uslaine Cunha and Priscila Oliveira, who helped with data collection; the Muriqui Institute of Biodiversity for logistical and administrative support; the Parque Estadual do Ibitipoca (Clarice Silva) for technical support; NGO Eco-Diversa (Mariane Kaizer, Aryanne Clyvia and Daniel Ferraz) for their support and help with Nena's capture; Adriana Milagres, Aline Barbosa, Brittany Berger, Daniel Vilela, Eutálio Pimenta, Izabela Secco, José Vicente, Júlio César, Junior Reis (Juninho), Lara Mendes, Larissa Calais, Laura Castro, Mikaelly Frasson, Paulo Mangini, Reginaldo Fagundes, Tatiane Vivian, Theo Anderson, Thiago Barros, Thiago Gomide, Valéria Ribeiro, Vinícius Gasparotto and Viviane Sodré for technical support; Luciana Pacca (ICMBio/CPB) for Fig. 1; Pedro Lima and Nilson Menezes Almeida for help collecting botanical samples; André L. Pereira for identifying plant species; Murilo Maia for support with the diet and nutrition of the northern muriquis; and Fabiana C.S.A. de Melo for advising the undergraduate students who worked on the project.
Conflicts of interest
None.
Ethical standards
This research complied with all ethical requirements in Brazil (Process SISBIO License no. 64.438-6; CEUA UFMG 163/2020) and abided by the Oryx guidelines on ethical standards.
Data availability
Data available upon request to the authors.