Nasca is a region of the Andes considered coastal in terms of both geography and culture. However, highland relationships and influences were critical in the development, expansion, and collapse of ancient societies in the area. Highland–coastal connections are well documented in the Andes; they began with the earliest occupants and continued through Inca rule. In Nasca, highland relationships were complex and varied, consisting of the exchange of goods, sharing of ideas, migration, and political dominance. One defining factor of coastal–highland connections is that they were bilateral, with influence and people moving in both directions. Highland contacts were more pronounced in some periods than in others. This article focuses on the period AD 500–1450, which encompasses the end of the Early Intermediate period (EIP), the Middle Horizon, and the Late Intermediate period (LIP), all times of intensified highland influence and population movement that resulted in significant societal change.
Interactions, Population Movements, and Cultural Change
Many types of interactions occur between groups of people, some of which have a great potential to cause cultural change. In the Andes, highland–coastal relationships were particularly important in the development and expansion of complex societies. The geography and resources of the region influenced the type and frequencies of interactions. From the Andes mountains a series of valleys extend to the coast, and many have stacked vertical environments in which large changes in elevation are covered in short distances (Murra Reference Murra and Murra1972; Pulgar Vidal Reference Pulgar Vidal1996). This creates a situation where the procurement of resources from diverse environmental zones and interaction among different groups can occur more easily than the difficult terrain would indicate.
For many years, the dominant model of economic organization and exchange in the Andes centered on verticality and reciprocal exchange. Based on the work by Murra (Reference Murra and Murra1972), verticality is the practice in which highland communities established colonies or directly controlled areas and resources outside their home base to obtain agricultural or other goods not available in the high elevations. This system allowed communities to be self-sufficient and not rely on external exchange relationships, merchants, or markets. People were dependent on their ethnic group whose leaders redistributed goods. On the coast, by the Inca period specialization and commercial exchange were the bases of the economy, and not verticality (Rostworowski Reference Rostworowski de Diez Canseco and Benson1977). Today scholars propose that the situation was more complex and that verticality was not always the primary organization in the highlands. Sometimes it occurred along with other strategies, such as barter or exchange, and only involved certain segments of the population or particular commodities (Goldstein Reference Goldstein2005; Stanish Reference Stanish1992; Van Buren Reference Van Buren1996). The variability in how items were obtained and exchanged dates back to the earliest periods in the Andes and is evident over time in Nasca (Burger and Asaro Reference Burger and Asaro1977; Eerkens et al. Reference Eerkens, Vaughn, Linares-Grados, Conlee, Schreiber, Glascock and Tripcevich2010; Mader Reference Mader2019; Reindel and Isla Reference Reindel and Isla2018; Van Gijseghem Reference Van Gijseghem2006; Vaughn Reference Vaughn2009; Whalen Reference Whalen2014).
The exchange of ideas was just as important as the exchange of goods. Archaeologists have long documented time periods, called horizons, in which art styles spread across broad areas of the Andes (Rowe Reference Rowe1962). In many cases, these styles were connected to influential religions that brought new beliefs and ritual practices, and their dissemination was often facilitated by powerful states as they expanded their political and economic dominance (e.g., Burger Reference Burger1992; Isbell Reference Isbell, Isbell and Silverman2008; Menzel Reference Menzel1964). The impact of these ideas was variable, but they were often a catalyst for change.
The movement of people between the highlands and coast is another important factor in the rise and fall of complex societies in the Andes. Resettlement of people was an extensively used strategy by the Inca, who moved communities into areas where they would be more productive, less of a threat, or both (e.g., Cieza de León Reference Cieza de León1984 [1553]; Garcilaso de la Vega Reference Garcilaso de la Vega and Livermore1966 [1609]); it was a strategy possibly used by earlier civilizations, such as the Wari. Other types of population movements—including the large-scale abandonment of regions and smaller, more sporadic movements of people—likely were also important factors in cultural change.
From the beginnings of archaeological research, migration has been proposed as a causal factor in changes evident in the archaeological record. This hypothesis was particularly prominent in the early and mid-twentieth century when the dominant paradigm was culture history that focused on the diffusion of traits through migration (e.g., Anthony Reference Anthony1990). Migration as an explanatory mechanism fell out of favor beginning in the 1960s with the spread of processual archaeology. A recent resurgence in the study of population movements has focused on how they affected societies in many areas, including the Andes (e.g., Beresford-Jones and Heggarty Reference Beresford-Jones, Heggarty and Bellwood2014; Goldstein Reference Goldstein2015; Knudson Reference Knudson2008; Tung Reference Tung, Silverman and Isbell2008). The renewed focus is partly due to archaeologists’ more common use of newer techniques, including strontium and oxygen isotopic analysis, that can tell us where individuals were born and where they lived in adulthood, and of DNA that can elucidate broader population movements. In addition, today we vividly see the effect of migration and how it is related to broader political, economic, and environmental factors.
Nasca–Highland Relationships
Nasca is located along the desert plain of the west coast of Peru in a region called the south coast, although geographically it is the south-central coast. It is part of the hyper-arid far northern Atacama Desert, with a mean annual precipitation of 10 mm (Mächtel et al. Reference Mächtel, Eitel, Schukraft, Ross, Reindel and Wagner2009:39). The Nasca drainage consists of a series of rivers that run from the highlands, merge into the Grande River, and then into the Pacific Ocean (Figure 1). This positions much of the drainage away from the coastline; the focus of habitation was inland along the rivers in the middle valleys, where it was easier to access water and agricultural land. From this inland position people had quick access to higher environmental zones and their resources.
Figure 1. Map with modern towns on the south coast, the obsidian source Quispisisa, and the archaeological site of Wari.
One difficulty in examining coastal–highland relationships in Nasca is distinguishing the coastal area from the highlands. Schreiber and Lancho Rojas (Reference Schreiber and Rojas2003:30–31) subdivided the Nasca valleys based on hydrology, because water is the most critical resource in the desert. They developed the following zones: Lower Valley (below 400 m asl), Middle Valley (400–800 m asl), Zone of Infiltration (800–1,200 m asl), Upper Valley (1,200–2,000 m asl), and Sierra (above 2,000 m asl). The Nasca cultural area is most closely associated with the Middle Valley (the lower elevations and foothills of the Andes), although the cultural area extends to the Zone of Infiltration. A noticeable change occurs in the elevations of 2,000 to 3,000–4,000 m asl near the headwaters of the rivers, where the valleys are steep and narrow except for pockets of open land known as cabezadas (McCool Reference McCool2017; Sossna Reference Sossna2014). In many time periods this zone had a mix of influences from the lower elevations and societies to the east. The puna regions (high-elevation grasslands) are at around 4,000 m asl; farther to the east and lower in elevation lay the central Andean valleys of the province of Ayacucho. I define the coastal Nasca cultural area as being between zero and 2,000 m asl, an intermediate area focused on the cabezadas from 2,000 to 3,000–4,000 m asl, and a highland cultural area that includes the puna and regions to the east.
This article focuses on the period from AD 500 to 1450, but highland–coastal connections have their roots in the Preceramic period (9000–1800 BC). A central line of evidence for these contacts is the procurement of obsidian, because its sources are not present on the coast. The primary source used by Nasca people was Quispisisa in central Ayacucho, located 100 km from the town of Nasca (Burger and Glascock Reference Burger and Glascock2000; Eerkens et al. Reference Eerkens, Vaughn, Linares-Grados, Conlee, Schreiber, Glascock and Tripcevich2010). One of the most direct routes from Quispisisa to the coast is through Nasca, and from early on, the highland–coastal movement of obsidian affected cultural developments (Burger and Glascock Reference Burger, Glascock, Isbell and Silverman2002:360). During all phases of the Preceramic, obsidian is present, and by the end of the period camelid bones are present at lowland sites, indicating the widespread use of these highland animals (Conlee Reference Conlee2016; Engel Reference Engel1981; Gorbahn Reference Gorbahn2013; Isla Reference Isla Cuadrado1990; Vaughn and Linares Grado Reference Vaughn and Grados2006). During the Early Horizon (800 BC–AD 1), highland–coastal links became well established. In the northern drainage many sites were in high elevation zones, some of which were production centers that provided coastal sites with goods (Mader Reference Mader2019; Reindel and Isla Reference Reindel and Isla2018; Sossna Reference Sossna2014). Highland products (obsidian and camelids) were found in large amounts in the lowlands, whereas coastal products (shell) were rare in the highlands, indicating that coastal people spurred this interaction (Mader Reference Mader2019).
Late Early Intermediate Period (AD 500–650)
The EIP, beginning around AD 1, marks the rise of the Nasca culture, the first large complex society centered in the drainage. Best known for the Nasca Lines (geoglyphs), the people of the Nasca culture also produced fine polychrome pottery, built the large center of Cahuachi, and spread the practice of making trophy heads (e.g., Orefici Reference Orefici2012; Proulx Reference Proulx2006; Reiche Reference Reiche1968). Highland relationships are not particularly evident, and few settlements were located in high elevations compared to the Early Horizon (Reindel and Isla Reference Reindel and Isla2018; Sossna Reference Sossna2014). As in earlier periods, obsidian is a crucial indicator of highland connections, and its distribution was variable, suggesting different procurement strategies. It is proposed that people living in the puna above Nasca brought obsidian to the lower elevations to trade for products such as maize and ají peppers (Burger and Asaro Reference Burger and Asaro1977; Vaughn Reference Vaughn2009). Vaughn (Reference Vaughn2009:146) concludes that this was small-scale reciprocal exchange among households and not redistribution by elites. However, at larger settlements in lower elevations, like La Tiza, the quantity of the material was greater, and reduction patterns and artifact types indicate more availability than previously found (Conlee Reference Conlee2014). There, a more organized and frequent type of trade is indicated that possibly involved elites. Generally, long-distance exotic goods were not the focus of the economy, exchange, or status building. Instead, Nasca goods, particularly pottery and textiles, are found as far away as the Moquegua Valley (Goldstein Reference Goldstein2000). This attests to the prestigious position held by the Nasca culture: it was not a society that looked externally for legitimation or prestige.
Critical shifts in highland–coastal relationships began in Late Nasca, when links with the Huarpa (the pre-Wari people) of highland Ayacucho become evident. Huarpa potters adopted aspects of Nasca iconography and ceramic technology, practices that continued during the subsequent Middle Horizon (e.g., Benavides Reference Benavides Calle1971; Knobloch Reference Knobloch1983; Leoni Reference Leoni, Isbell and Silverman2006; Menzel Reference Menzel1964). Some researchers have argued that people from Nasca moved up into the highlands because of increased aridity on the coast, and possibly artisans made their way to the Huarpa heartland where they directly influenced the pottery style (Eitel and Mächtle Reference Eitel, Mächtle, Reindel and Wagner2009; Schreiber Reference Schreiber and Stein2005; Valdez and Valdez Reference Valdez, Valdez, Patton and Manion2016). Genetic data support this hypothesis: mitochondrial DNA of northern Nasca populations suggests migrations into the highlands occurred around AD 640 (Fehren-Schmitz et al. Reference Fehren-Schmitz, Haakc, Mächtle, Masch, Llamas, Cagigao, Sossna, Schittek, Cuadrado, Eitel and Reindel2014).
During the Late Nasca, shifts in obsidian procurement occurred, at least in the upper elevations of the southern drainage. At the site of Cocahuischo, obsidian was mostly in the form of finished tools with little debitage, indicating that objects were imported as preforms or finished tools (Whalen Reference Whalen2014:306–309). This contrasts with the pattern at earlier sites where the full sequence of reduction was found and the material was likely imported as nodules. Whalen (Reference Whalen2014:332) suggests that Huarpa people controlled Quispisisa obsidian and produced complete artifacts carried by llama caravans into Nasca.
Late Nasca architecture also had highland influences. At the site of Huaca del Loro in the Las Trancas Valley, Strong (Reference Strong1957:36) excavated a large round structure (connected to a multiroom rectangular compound) that was constructed of stone and rubble, with a plastered floor and painted red walls. Paulsen (Reference Paulsen and Sandweiss1983:100) proposes it was a highland-style temple built by the Huarpa people. The structure is similar to a round ceremonial building at Ñawinpukyo in Ayacucho, dating to the late Huarpa (Leoni Reference Leoni, Isbell and Silverman2006), and to a large round funeral structure with a central square chamber at Huayuncalla in northern Nasca (Sossna Reference Sossna2014:47). Cook (Reference Cook and Bray2015) identifies round structures in the midst of rectilinear architecture as a Huarpa tradition, which morph into D-shaped temples during the Wari period. Overall, the evidence indicates an important shift in the Late Nasca, when relationships between the highlands and coast expanded with the movement of ideas, goods, and people.
Middle Horizon (AD 650–1000)
During the Middle Horizon coastal–highland relationships were transformed, and Nasca became directly enmeshed with the highland Wari, who expanded their influence and power to the coast. Whereas the exchange of goods and ideas, as well as some migration, occurred earlier between Nasca and the highlands, during the Middle Horizon the coast experienced highland political dominance and colonization. Nasca people had variable relationships and responses to the Wari (Figure 2). In the lowland areas of the northern valleys, the number and size of local settlements decreased (Reindel Reference Reindel, Reindel and Wagner2009; Silverman Reference Silverman2002; Sossna Reference Sossna2014). Wari-related tombs with multiple burials and high-status grave goods are documented at several sites, and Lambrasniyoq has small Wari-style rectangular compounds and a D-shaped temple (Isla Reference Isla Cuadrado, Kaulicke and Isbell2001, Reference Isla Cuadrado, Reindel and Wagner2009; Isla and Reindel Reference Isla Cuadrado and Reindel2014; Sossna Reference Sossna2014). In the cabezadas between 2,000 and 4,000 m asl, Proyecto Nasca-Palpa identified more than 40 sites with a Wari affiliation (Isla and Reindel Reference Isla Cuadrado and Reindel2014; Sossna Reference Sossna2014). One of the largest sites, Huayuncalla, has Wari-style rectangular compounds. None had defensive walls, slingstones, or other evidence of conflict (Sossna Reference Sossna2014:196). Late Nasca (Nasca 7), local Middle Horizon (Loro), and Wari (Chakipampa) ceramics are present, sometimes in the same stratigraphic contexts. Sossna (Reference Sossna2014:192) proposes that in the late seventh century “conservative locals” using Nasca 7 pottery lived alongside local people using Loro pottery, who adopted some elements of Ayacucho pottery styles, as well as a small group of immigrants using Wari imperial styles. This mixing of people and cultures is a hallmark of the Middle Horizon in Nasca.
Figure 2. Map of the region showing the Middle Horizon sites discussed in the text.
In the southern drainage, Wari sites include Pacheco in the lower Nasca Valley, Huaca del Loro in the middle valley, Pataraya in the upper valley, and Incawasi in the cabezadas (Conlee et al. Reference Conlee, Kellner, Walker and Gutiérrez2021; Edwards and Schreiber Reference Edwards and Schreiber2014; Menzel Reference Menzel1964; Tello Reference Tello2002). All contain Wari rectangular compounds and imperial- and local-style pottery, and Huaca del Loro has at least one D-shaped temple. Incawasi and Pataraya are connected by roads that originate in the sierra and continue down to the middle and lower Nasca Valley (Edwards and Schreiber Reference Edwards and Schreiber2014), indicating the importance and frequency of travel between the areas.
Huaca del Loro was a Wari colony at the southern edge of Nasca. The settlement spans approximately 20 ha and contains cemetery, ritual, and domestic areas (Conlee et al. Reference Conlee, Kellner, Walker and Gutiérrez2021; Strong Reference Strong1957; Tello Reference Tello2002). Recent excavations uncovered a rectilinear Wari compound and a D-shaped temple in the western part of the site (Figure 3; Conlee et al. Reference Conlee, Kellner, Walker and Gutiérrez2021). Ground-penetrating radar documented the presence of several other rectilinear compounds, indicating that the Wari sector was substantial. The eastern half of the settlement contains local architecture and may have housed local support personnel for the Wari installation. Local Loro-style pottery predominates, but imperial styles Chakipampa and Viñaque are present in small quantities (Figure 4). Similar pottery assemblages are found at all Wari sites in Nasca: Loro appears to be a widespread style used by Wari and local communities and was not developed solely in resistance to the Wari. The association between Wari and Loro pottery and Loro influence outside the region requires additional investigation. Future excavations at Huaca del Loro will further clarify the nature of the site and the relationship between the Wari and Nasca peoples.
Figure 3. Map of Huaca del Loro showing the excavated units and the rectilinear compound (Structure 1) and D-shaped temple (Structure 2) (drawn by Zach Lindsey).
Figure 4. Pottery from Huaca del Loro: (a) Wari imperial Viñaque style and (b) the local Loro style. (Color online)
La Tiza in the middle Aja Valley is not a colony, but several lines of evidence indicate strong Wari ties. Obsidian was procured and used in greater quantity than earlier and exclusively came from Quispisisa, which was likely under Wari control (Conlee Reference Conlee2016). New copper alloys were developed in the Middle Horizon, and bronze objects are common at Wari sites (Jennings et al. Reference Jennings, Valarde, Mora and Álvarez2015; Lechtman Reference Lechtman1991, Reference Lechtman and McEwan2005). At La Tiza bronze objects were used for the first time; tupus (shawl pins) were the most numerous. The tupus are similar to those found at Pataraya (Edwards Reference Edwards2010:376–377), in tombs in the northern drainage (Reindel et al. Reference Reindel, Stöllner, Gräfingholt, Tripcevich and Vaughn2013:304), and in the Wari heartland. Tupus were widespread in the Middle Horizon probably because of Wari influence. The Middle Horizon La Tiza textiles contain a higher quantity of camelid fiber than earlier, indicating that fiber or yarn was being increasingly traded from the highlands (Mills and Conlee Reference Mills and Conlee2019). Certain kinds of fabrics, such as interlocked tapestries, were probably introduced by the Wari (Rowe Reference Rowe, Rowe, Benson and Schaffer1979:186), and those that combined highland designs and coastal techniques indicate new highland links. As at other contemporary sites, the pottery consisted mostly of the local Loro style, with a few pieces of Chakipampa and Viñaque.
At La Tiza, Wari-style family mausoleums, similar to those documented in the northern drainage, were used and contained elite grave goods of Spondylus shell, fine pottery, textiles, and copper artifacts that were also common in Wari tombs. The new burial practices represent a stimulus from the Wari heartland where multiple burials were common and replaced the individual graves used previously (Isbell Reference Isbell2004; Ochatoma and Cabrera Reference Ochatoma Paravicino and Romero2001). Foreigners were identified in the mausoleums through oxygen and strontium isotopic analysis (Buzon et al. Reference Buzon, Conlee and Bowen2011; Conlee et al. Reference Conlee, Buzon, Gutierrez, Simonetti and Creaser2009). Two women in their early twenties had signatures similar to highland regions and may have married into the community to create ties between local high-ranking people and the Wari.
Nasca–highland relationships in the Middle Horizon were not unilateral. Various aspects of Nasca culture, most notably the Nasca pottery style, were adapted by the Wari. The Wari incorporation of Nasca religious and cultural images reflects the prestige of Nasca (Menzel Reference Menzel1964) and likely some aspects of a shared ideology. Trophy heads were possibly popularized through Nasca influence, although differences occurred in their use and who they were obtained from (Conlee et al. Reference Conlee, Buzon, Gutierrez, Simonetti and Creaser2009; Kellner Reference Kellner and Bonogofsky2006; Knudson et al. Reference Knudson, Williams, Osborn, Forgey and Williams2009; Tung Reference Tung2012). The Wari also perhaps incorporated the Nasca tradition of burying the dead in a flexed, seated position (Valdez et al. Reference Valdez, Bettcher, Ochatoma and Valdez2006:684).
In sum, the Wari and Nasca were very enmeshed. In Nasca, for the first time, archaeological evidence indicates the political, social, and economic dominance of highland people and institutions. This dominance is found archaeologically in the establishment of Wari colonies, an increase in highland goods such as obsidian and copper alloys, new mortuary practices, and the presence of foreigners. Nasca's influence in the highlands is reflected in Wari people's incorporation of Nasca ceramic technology and iconography and possibly in the increased use of flexed burial positions and trophy heads.
A major disruption occurred at the end of the Middle Horizon that resulted in the collapse of Wari and Nasca. Much of Nasca was abandoned by AD 1000, and it was not reoccupied until at least AD 1200 (Conlee Reference Conlee2016; Edwards Reference Edwards2010; Reindel and Wagner Reference Reindel, Wagner, Reindel and Wagner2009; Sossna Reference Sossna2014). In the middle of the tenth century, the Wari colony Pataraya was ceremonially closed in an event during which corridors were sealed, ceramics vessels smashed, fires lit in the corners, and a fine layer of sand placed on the surface, indicating a purposeful and quick abandonment (Edwards Reference Edwards, Rosenfeld and Bautista2017). At Huaca del Loro the D-shaped temple was filled in and offerings of cotton were left, although the timing and exact nature of this event are yet to be established. At La Tiza, the collapse was more gradual, with abandonment of domestic areas before burial areas. It is unclear where people moved, although it is suspected they migrated to higher elevations or to coastal areas to the north that had more regular access to water.
Wari collapse and Nasca abandonment were caused by multiple factors. Wari was an expansive state that encompassed a vast area of the Andes; when the political system weakened, it would have been difficult to support administrative centers and economic activities in the colonies. Climatic change, particularly drought, potentially caused instability as decreasing agricultural yields led to stress and weakened the power of the rulers (McEwan Reference McEwan, Schwartz and Nichols2006; Shimada et al. Reference Shimada, Schaaf, Thompson and Mosley-Thompson1991; Thompson et al. Reference Thompson, Mosley-Thompson, Bolzan and Koci1985; Williams Reference Williams2002). Other potential factors include internal rebellion or epidemic diseases that affected people or crops (Schreiber Reference Schreiber and Bergh2012).
In Nasca, drought conditions are evident. Geoarchaeological data from desert loess indicate the desert shifted east (limiting agricultural land), and a more arid period began around AD 600 that extended until the fourteenth century in some areas (Eitel et al. Reference Eitel, Hecht, Mächtle, Schukraf, Kadereit, Wagner, Kromer and Unkel2005). Lake cores from Laguna Pumacocha document a period of marked aridity from AD 900 to 1100 (Bird et al. Reference Bird, Abbott, Vuille, Rodbell, Stansell and Rosenmeier2011:8587), and analysis of marine sediments near Lima indicates extreme drought from AD 800 to 1250 (Rein et al. Reference Rein, Lückge and Sirocko2004). However, Nasca had faced drought before that did not lead to large-scale abandonment (Eitel and Machtle Reference Eitel, Mächtle, Reindel and Wagner2009; Eitel et al. Reference Eitel, Hecht, Mächtle, Schukraf, Kadereit, Wagner, Kromer and Unkel2005; Reindel and Isla Reference Reindel and Isla2013); therefore, other factors contributed to its instability. During the EIP, the puquios, a system of underground aqueducts, were built in the southern valleys—a major investment that helped stabilize the water supply (Schreiber and Lancho Rojas Reference Schreiber and Rojas2003). Large-scale irrigation systems anchor people to locations and can generate vulnerabilities because fields and communities are not easily moved when water availability decreases (Hegmon et al. Reference Hegmon, Peeples, Kinzig, Kulow, Meegan and Nelson2008; Nelson et al. Reference Nelson, Kintigh, Abbott and Anderies2010). The puquios may not have been effective during a drought that lasted many years and severely limited the subterranean water supply (Conlee Reference Conlee and Faulseit2015). Additionally, irrigation systems may increase water availability or stability for some while causing shortages or instability for others (Nelson et al. Reference Nelson, Kintigh, Abbott and Anderies2010:4). It is possible that the Wari fundamentally changed local communities’ control over irrigation and water, which created greater disparities in the water supply and generated more social inequality, which was a factor in people leaving (Conlee Reference Conlee and Faulseit2015).
Late Intermediate Period (AD 1000–1450)
The Nasca drainage was reoccupied around AD 1200, a period that coincided with improved climatic conditions. Evidence from loess and related deposits suggests increased humidity, and the period is classified as semiarid with more reliable rainfall (Eitel et al. Reference Eitel, Hecht, Mächtle, Schukraf, Kadereit, Wagner, Kromer and Unkel2005:153). A period of monsoonal precipitation occurred between AD 1320 and 1440, with more water in the Nasca rivers (Unkel et al. Reference Unkel, Kadereit, Mächtle, Eitel, Kromer, Wagner and Wacker2007:23). The improved conditions may have spurred populations to settle in the region, although other factors were likely important as well.
The society in the LIP was profoundly different from earlier ones in Nasca. Throughout the middle valleys and foothills, the population increased, and large agglutinated villages and towns dominated the settlement hierarchy; many ranged from 8 to 30 ha (Conlee Reference Conlee2003; Lambers et al. Reference Lambers, Eisenbeiss, Sauerbier, Kupferschmidt, Gaisecker, Sotoodeh and Hanusch2007; Reindel Reference Reindel, Reindel and Wagner2009; Schreiber and Lancho Rojas Reference Schreiber and Rojas2003; Siveroni Reference Siveroni2017; Sossna Reference Sossna2014; Figure 5). Settlements were more varied in size, location, architectural layout, and construction material. Many sites, such as La Tiza, were in defensive locations and contained large walls and piles of slingstones, indicating increased conflict and a greater concern with defense. (Figure 6). However, a few sites such as the village of Pajonal Alto were located on the valley bottoms without any defensive features.
Figure 5. Map of the Nasca region showing the LIP sites discussed in the text.
Figure 6. Large wall at La Tiza with an inset of typical domestic terrace architecture at the site.
Sites in the cabezadas were unlike those in the coastal region. In the northern drainage they consisted primarily of round structures, whereas in the lower elevation, houses were square and rectangular and often agglutinated in compounds (Sossna Reference Sossna2014). Despite the architectural differences, the pottery was similar. Sossna (Reference Sossna2014:201) suggests that a cultural or political border existed between the two and names the group living in the foothills Nanasca, and the one in the cabezadas Rucanas, names that come from historic sources. He proposes that similar pottery in both areas and the presence of highland products such as camelids and tubers in the lower elevations indicate a close economic relationship. Both areas have defensive sites and evidence of conflict indicating a threat from groups in neighboring valleys or populations in the highlands east of the puna. A similar pattern is found in the cabezadas in the southern tributaries, where Weston McCool (Reference McCool2017, personal communication 2020) has documented 17 sites with round residential architecture and chullpa burial towers, which resemble those of the Lucanas region to the east (Abraham Reference Abraham2010; Schreiber Reference Schreiber1992). This pattern contrasts with settlements in the lower elevations where rectangular and square architecture is the norm and burials were in simple pits. The settlements in the southern cabezadas are described as hillforts with nucleated residences, multiple large walls, and ditches, indicating endemic warfare and conflict (McCool Reference McCool2017). The ceramics are similar to those in lower elevations (Weston McCool, personal communication 2020). These patterns indicate that the cabezadas were a well-demarcated intermediate zone during this period.
New economic activities and relationships developed, with production focused on utilitarian goods such as plain pottery and textiles, contrasting with the fine pottery and textiles of earlier periods (Conlee Reference Conlee2003, Reference Conlee, Schwartz and Nichols2006, Reference Conlee2016). Pottery changed dramatically to simple geometric designs and less skillful manufacture, suggesting a loss or rejection of the previous practices. Chemical compositional analysis (INAA) of pottery from the small village of Pajonal Alto and the large town of La Tiza identified a variety of clay sources and many communities producing pottery (Conlee et al. Reference Conlee, Boulanger, Glascock, Glascock, Neff and Vaughn2019; Vaughn et al. Reference Vaughn, Conlee, Neff and Schreiber2006). People continued to obtain obsidian primarily from Quispisisa, but Jampatilla (located 18 km farther away) was a source of lower-quality material that was also used (Conlee Reference Conlee2016; Eerkens et al. Reference Eerkens, Vaughn, Linares-Grados, Conlee, Schreiber, Glascock and Tripcevich2010). Metal objects are not reported, suggesting that people could no longer obtain these items or that they were no longer important in demarcating social identity and status. Subsistence activities were similar to those at earlier settlements, with a focus on farming and possibly an increase in camelid herding (Conlee Reference Conlee2003, Reference Conlee2016). Overall, the evidence for production, exchange, and subsistence practices suggests substantial regional interaction and continued ties to the highlands.
Religious and burial practices were markedly changed. In the burial practices of the middle valleys and foothills, individuals were placed in pits with few grave goods, and infants and children were interred in large ceramic pots or with large pieces of pottery (Conlee Reference Conlee2016). The mausoleum tombs of the Middle Horizon were absent, as were elaborate grave goods. No longer were supernatural beings depicted in the art, and trophy heads are not documented. The geoglyphs that were a hallmark of the Nasca culture, and continued to be constructed in the Middle Horizon, were not used in the same way. Many long paths with an abundance of associated LIP pottery cross the desert plateaus where large concentrations of geoglyphs are found (Lambers Reference Lambers2006; Sakai et al. Reference Sakai, Jorge Olano and Takahashi2010). However, LIP buildings were constructed on top of geoglyphs, indicating they were no longer sacred (Lambers Reference Lambers2006), and much of the religious system centered on the geoglyphs appears to have been abandoned. Rituals were also no longer conducted on a regional scale and instead were community or family based. At Pajonal Alto a small mound and plaza were associated with an elite compound (Conlee Reference Conlee2003). In contrast, at La Tiza small hilltop structures were used for rituals, indicating diversity in ritual locations (Conlee Reference Conlee2016). People maintained Pan Andean religious ideas, which included mountain and water worship, animal and plant offerings, and the use of chicha, antaras, and Spondylus in rituals. Religious practices associated specifically with the Nasca and Wari cultures were absent.
The political and social nature of society was substantially different. Given the complexity of regional settlement patterns and the diversity of architecture, it appears that the number and kinds of social statuses increased (Conlee Reference Conlee, Vaughn, Ogburn and Conlee2005, Reference Conlee2016). The hierarchy expanded but also diffused, with resources of power becoming more variable and resulting in a more segmented and horizontally complex society. With religion no longer playing an important centralizing role, expanded economic relationships and regional trade—along with new political structures—worked to integrate the region. Evidence of conflict suggests that violence and the threat of violence were common and that leadership was based in part on the ability to defend settlements or lead attacks.
These major changes may be attributed to the long period that the region was abandoned. When people resettled, they brought different ideas and practices, which resulted in a different material culture. Another consideration is that the new immigrants (or at least a large percentage of them) were not genetically related to those who lived there previously. Mitochondrial and Y-chromosomal DNA research by Lars Fehren-Schmitz and colleagues suggests major changes in the Nasca population based on samples from the northern Nasca drainage. Genetic distinction between coast and highland populations was very marked during the EIP and the Middle Horizon, but not in the LIP (Fehren-Schmitz et al. Reference Fehren-Schmitz, Reindel, Cagigao, Hummel and Hermann2010, Reference Fehren-Schmitz, Warnberg, Reindel, Seidenberg, Cagigao, Isla Cuadrado, Hummel and Herrmann2011, Reference Fehren-Schmitz, Haakc, Mächtle, Masch, Llamas, Cagigao, Sossna, Schittek, Cuadrado, Eitel and Reindel2014). Mitochondrial DNA studies indicate genetic discontinuity between the Middle Horizon and the LIP, and that LIP coastal populations were similar genetically to those of the highlands (Frehren-Schmitz et al. Reference Fehren-Schmitz, Haakc, Mächtle, Masch, Llamas, Cagigao, Sossna, Schittek, Cuadrado, Eitel and Reindel2014:9445). It is proposed that a substantial influx of highland people to the coast occurred around AD 1150, coinciding with increased humidity on the coast and increased aridity in the highlands (Frehren-Schmitz et al. Reference Fehren-Schmitz, Haakc, Mächtle, Masch, Llamas, Cagigao, Sossna, Schittek, Cuadrado, Eitel and Reindel2014:9447). The genetic data suggest that many of the people who resettled Nasca were not the direct descendants of the previous occupants, which would help explain the major differences in society.
At La Tiza four individuals were buried near each other in a large domestic structure. They included one possible female aged 25–33, one possible male aged 14–15, and two infants aged 1.0–1.5 years. All four were born and lived in the local region, based on oxygen and strontium isotopic analysis (Buzon et al. Reference Buzon, Conlee, Simonetti and Bowen2012; Conlee et al. Reference Conlee, Buzon, Gutierrez, Simonetti and Creaser2009). A radiocarbon date of AD 1315–1435 came from charcoal associated with the adult female. Radiocarbon dates from other LIP contexts at the settlement span AD 1212–1455. These data suggest that, if emigration from the highlands occurred and some people settled at La Tiza, by 1300 a new generation was being born and raised at the settlement. It is also possible that these individuals represent a small local population who did not move out of the region at the end of the Middle Horizon.
In addition to the use of DNA and isotopic analysis, connecting highland people to the new type of society in the LIP can be done by the comparison of material culture. However, this comparison is difficult, given the sparsity of information about groups in the highland regions adjacent to Nasca. In particular, little is known about early LIP sites in coastal Nasca (where they are missing), in the intermediate area, or in the highlands. More information is known from the later part of the LIP and the Late Horizon. Historic and archaeological evidence indicate that the Lucanas ethnic group occupied the upper areas of the Nasca drainage, including the puna regions such as the Pampa Galeras (Meddens and Schreiber Reference Meddens and Schreiber2010:134). Preliminary reconnaissance, including around the town of Puquio, identified a substantial population at the time of Inca conquest. The site of Pulapuco, located at 3,450 m asl near the town of Lucanas, was an LIP settlement and then an Inca administrative center. The settlement has round residential architecture, fortification walls, and tombs constructed at the base of boulders or outcrops that contain multiple individuals (Abraham Reference Abraham2010). The pottery is highland in style, with only one piece with the dot-and-band motif common in Nasca (Abraham Reference Abraham2010:233). Two sherds—one with a raised oval appliqué with deep impressions and one with a round circle appliqué that forms a flower (Abraham Reference Abraham2010:Figures 7.16 and 7.17)—are similar to single examples found at Pajonal Alto. These styles have not been identified at other coastal settlements and are likely highland imports. In contrast, the red slip and other types of appliqué pottery common at Pulapuco are found at many sites in the surrounding Lucanas region, the Andamarca Lucanas region to the east, and the Soras region to the northeast (Abraham Reference Abraham2010; Meddens and Schreiber Reference Meddens and Schreiber2010; Schreiber Reference Schreiber and Malpass1993). Pulapuco architecture is similar to that in Andamarca Lucanas and Soras, and in the cabezadas, but has nothing in common with sites in coastal Nasca. Historical information indicates the Lucanas people traded camelid meat and wool for coca and aji pepper with populations in the lower elevations (Monzón Reference Monzón1965). Overall, the Lucanas people, as represented by those who lived at Pulapuco, had some shared cultural traditions with the Andamarca Lucanas and Soras groups, as well as the cabezadas people, but not with people of the lower elevations of Nasca.
In the northern Nasca drainage, Sossna (Reference Sossna2014:236) proposes that people living in the middle valleys and foothills were immigrants from the northern valleys of Ica, Pisco, and Chincha, and that those living in the cabezadas emigrated from the southern or central highlands. However, isotopic and genetic data do not indicate influxes of northern coastal populations at this time. Additional samples from lowland Nasca settlements and from the northern south coast valleys are needed to fully assess this proposal. In the southern drainage, one potential scenario is that in the early part of the LIP people from eastern Lucanas began moving across the puna and settled at the site of Pulapuco and around Puquio. By the middle of the LIP, they had established settlements in the cabezadas, and possibly large numbers of them moved down to the foothills and middle valleys. There they may have mixed with remnant coastal populations. Radiocarbon dating and excavations at cabezada sites, as well as additional DNA analysis of individuals from the highlands, cabezadas, and lowlands, will help address this scenario.
Discussion and Conclusions
Archaeological evidence reveals a long and dynamic history of Nasca–highland relationships. By the EIP interactions between the highlands and coast were well established. Consumption of highland obsidian had increased in some but not all Nasca communities, suggesting a differential access to goods based on community location and status. By the Late EIP, substantial changes occurred as connections between the Nasca and the Huarpa people of Ayacucho strengthened. DNA evidence indicates the movement of coastal Nasca people into the highlands, and Huarpa-style architecture on the coast suggests that highlanders moved to Nasca. This dynamic period led to the development and expansion of the Wari Empire.
Highland relationships were transformed in the Middle Horizon as the Wari came to govern Nasca. However, questions remain about the relationship between the two. When did the Wari conquest begin? Evidence suggests the presence of substantial Huarpa influence and connections in the late EIP. Did the movement of people, ideas, and goods occur before domination by the Wari, or did political conquest begin in the Huarpa period? What did conquest involve? The lack of defensive sites or other evidence of conflict indicates that large-scale warfare did not occur. How then, did the Wari establish itself in the region? The Wari colonies found in the cabezadas imply direct control of that area, but the Wari people's relationship with settlements in the middle valleys and foothills is more complex, involving both the establishment of colonies such as Huaca del Loro and government through local elites and marriage alliances at La Tiza.
The end of the Middle Horizon and beginning of the LIP was a time of great disruption as people left Nasca. A better understanding of the impact of changing environmental conditions on people, farming, and irrigation is necessary to understand what led to collapse and migration. It is informative to compare this period in Nasca with that in the Ica Valley to the north: in the lower valley, abandonment did not occur, indicating different political, social, and environmental conditions (Cadwallader et al. Reference Cadwallader, Torres, O'Connell, Pullen and Beresford-Jones2015). Information is lacking on this period in the Acarí Valley to the south, but this would be a productive area of future investigation. Other issues that need to be further addressed are the extent of highland people in Nasca in the LIP, where in the highland these individuals came from, and what aspects of culture they brought with them. The hillfort settlements in the cabezadas resemble those to the east in the sierra in Lucanas and have little in common with settlements in the lower drainage; however, the ceramic styles are similar to those in the lowlands. What does this disparity in material culture represent? These settlements may be key to understanding population dynamics in this period.
If LIP populations consisted primarily of highlanders, then the Nasca culture of the EIP may have been the last primarily coastal society in the region. The Middle Horizon was a time when the cultures of Nasca and Wari mixed and coastal–highland dichotomies became less pronounced. If, in the LIP, new people settled the region and brought different ideas and traditions, when the Inca conquered Nasca they may have encountered a society that had many aspects of highland religious beliefs, sociopolitical organization, and perhaps even language. This history of the Nasca region highlights the close connections between coastal and highland regions over several hundred years that involved substantial population movements, intensified in the Middle Horizon, and transformed local society by the time of Inca conquest.
Acknowledgments
Many thanks to project codirector Aldo Noriega and all participants in the Pajonal Alto, La Tiza, and Huaca del Loro projects. Research at Huaca del Loro was funded by a National Science Foundation Grant BCS-1758084, a grant from the Curtiss T. Brennan and Mary G. Brennan Foundation, and the Research Enhancement Program at Texas State University. Funding for La Tiza was provided by a National Science Foundation Grant BCS-0314273, a National Geographic Society Committee for Research and Exploration Grant, the H. John Heinz III Fund Grant Program for Latin American Archaeology, and the Research Enhancement Program at Texas State University. Support for work at Pajonal Alto was provided by a National Science Foundation Dissertation Improvement Grant. Permission to excavate at all sites was granted by the Ministerio de Cultura del Perú.
Data Availability Statement
Data can be obtained by contacting the author Christina Conlee ([email protected]).
Open access
