Implications
Despite the great growth efficiency of entire male pigs (EM), this production is hampered by the risk of malodorous compounds such as androstenone, skatole and indole in pork. Thus, dietary approaches among others are needed to minimise the incidence of tainted meat. Hydrolysable tannins (HT) can inhibit the activity of the microbial population in the hindgut, which is where a part of the malodourous compounds are generated. This study reveals that at 3% dietary inclusion level, HT reduced the overall level of the relevant compounds in pork but the reduction was not sufficient to be perceived by sensory panel members.
Introduction
Traditional silvopastoral systems for the production of Iberian ham in south-western Spain and Portugal have often relied on acorn-based diets to produce high-quality pork products. These products have been believed as antiquity to have unique flavour such as improved aroma, tenderness and juiciness, as well as a distinctive ‘bitter’ aroma (Cava et al., Reference Cousins, Tanksley, Knabe and Zebrowska2000). Many of these changes are likely attributable to the fatty acid composition of woodland diets, but the presence of tannins in the acorns cannot be discounted.
Tannins have long been considered ‘anti-nutritional’ factors in monogastric nutrition, shown to reduce feed intake and palatability, growth rates and feed efficiencies (Mueller-Harvey, Reference Mueller-Harvey2006). However, tannins form many structurally diverse groups and each structural change may alter their impact and interaction of the feed with the host animal; generalisations about the effects and function of dietary tannins must not be based upon studies with tannins from a single plant species, but should be drawn from studies that address the wide range of available tannin chemistry (Hagerman et al., Reference Hagerman, Robbins, Yohan, Wilson and McArthur1992). Many of the available studies on pigs focussed solely on the impacts of condensed tannins, which are found in a few forage legumes, faba beans (Mariscal-Landín et al., Reference Mariscal-Landín, Lebreton and Sève2002), lupins (Ferguson et al., Reference Ferguson, Gous and Iji2003) and also sorghum grains (Cousins et al., Reference Cava, Ventanas, Florencio Tejeda, Ruiz and Antequera1981). However, woodland diets can also contain HT (Cantos et al., Reference Cantos, Espín, López-Bote, de la Hoz, Ordóñez and Tomás-Barberán2003) and these may have different potencies and modes of actions as compared with condensed tannins. Recent studies have shown that the HT from chestnut have far less impact on growth rates and feed intake in grower and finisher pigs (Antongiovanni et al., Reference Antongiovanni, Minieri and Petacchi2007; Stukelj et al., Reference Stukelj, Valencak, Krsnik and Svete2010).
Interestingly, in vitro incubation of swine caecal inoculum with different concentrations of HT linearly reduced total gas production and the levels of acetic, propionic and n-butyric acid, but not the acetic to propionic acid ratio, suggesting an inhibitory effect on the total activity of caecal bacteria (Biagia et al., Reference Biagia, Cipollini, Paulicks and Roth2010). These findings are of interest especially in the production of EMs where the synthesis of skatole and indole, two compounds responsible for boar taint, could, therefore, be reduced in the colon. Thus, the objectives of this study were to evaluate the potential of dietary HT supplementation to control boar taint-related compounds and to determine their impact on growth performance, carcass characteristics, meat and sensory traits of pork from EMs.
Material and methods
Animals and diets
The Swiss Cantonal Committee for Animal Care and Use approved all procedures involving animals.
The experiment included a total of 36 Swiss Large White EMs originating from 12 litters. From weaning until the start of the experimental period (mean±SE BW=50.4±1.11 kg; age=105±0.3 days), EMs were group-penned and had ad libitum access to a commercial starter (mean±SE BW=10.8±0.44 to 27.2±0.25 kg) and grower diet (mean±SE BW=27.2±0.25 to 50.4±1.11 kg). At the end of the starter period, the littermates were allocated to the three experimental diets according to BW. The three diets consisted of a negative control diet (C) with no added tannins and two diets containing per kg of diet 15 (T15) or 30 g (T30) of supplementary tannins, respectively (Table 1). All diets were formulated to be isonitrogenous and isocaloric and tannin supplement, which originated from chestnut (Silvateam, San Michele Mondovì, Italy), was interchanged by straw meal. The experimental diets were offered ad libitum in a pelleted form. The pigs were reared in the finisher period in group pens, equipped with an automatic feeder and individual pig recognition system (Schauer Maschinenfabrik GmbH & Co. KG, Prambachkirchen, Austria) as described previously by Bee et al. (Reference Bee, Jacot, Guex and Biolley2008), which allowed the determination of individual feed intake in group housed pigs.
Table 1 Feed ingredients (%), nutrient and tannin composition of the experimental diets
DM, dry matter; DE, digestible energy.
1 Control=standard finisher diet without addition of chestnut tannin powder; T15=standard finisher diet with addition of 1.5% of chestnut tannin powder; T30=standard finisher diet with addition of 3% chestnut tannin powder.
2 50% fat from beef and 50% fat from swine.
3 Chestnut powder.
4 Binder that aids in pellet formation.
5 Supplied the following nutrients per kg of diet: 20 000 IU vitamin A, 200 IU vitamin D3, 39 IU vitamin E, 2.9 mg riboflavin, 2.4 mg vitamin B6, 0.010 mg vitamin B12, 0.2 mg vitamin K3, 10 mg pantothenic acid, 1.4 mg niacin, 0.48 mg folic acid, 199 g choline, 0.052 mg biotin, 52 mg Fe as FeSO4, 0.16 mg I as Ca(IO)3, 0.15 mg Se as Na2Se, 5.5 mg Cu as CuSO4, 81 mg Zn as ZnO2, 15 mg Mn as MnO2.
6 The DE coefficients from each feed ingredient were obtained from the Swiss (Agroscope, 2015) database, respectively. Taking into account the relative amount of each feed ingredient in the diet, DE content was calculated.
Slaughter procedure and carcass measurements
One week after pigs reached 100 kg BW, they were selected for slaughter. Feed was withdrawn 16 h before slaughter by negating access to the feeder for the selected pigs. Avoiding all unnecessary stress, the EMs were walked ~100 m to the stunning area, and allowed to rest for 10 min before they were subjected to CO2 stunning for 100 s, after which they were exsanguinated, scalded, mechanically dehaired and eviscerated. At this point the internal organs were removed, and the liver, kidney, testicles, salivary (mandibular) and bulbourethral glands were weighed. Within 2 min after evisceration, liver excisions were rinsed with a phosphate-buffered saline solution and stored at −20°C in RNA-Later solution (1018087; Qiagen, Basel, Switzerland) until RNA extraction. The hot carcasses were then weighed and the pH and temperature of the longissimus dorsi muscle (LD) was measured at the 10th rib location before being refrigerated at 3°C for 1 day. One day postmortem, the left cold carcass sides were weighed and dissected into the major primal cuts (shoulder, loin, ham and belly) and trimmed free of all external fat as previously described (Bee et al., Reference Bee, Chevillon and Bonneau2004).
Feed analysis
Feed samples were milled using a 1.0-mm sieve (Brabender, Duisburg, Germany) before analysis. Dry matter content was determined after samples were dried at 105°C for 3 h and ash content was subsequently determined after incineration at 550°C. Nitrogen was determined using Kjeldahl procedure (Leco FP-2000 analyser; Leco, Mönchengladbach, Germany) and CP calculated by 6.25×N. Crude fibre was analysed after digestion with successively H2SO4 and KOH, washed with acetone, dried at 130°C and finally ashed (EN 71/393, ISO 6865:2000, VDLUFA 6.1.4). Crude fat of diets was determined as petrol ether extract after an acidic hydrolysis (ISO 6492:1999, VDLUFA 5.1.1).
The content of gallic acid and HT in the diets were determined as recently described by Johnson et al. (Reference Johnson, Ives, Ahern and Salminen2014). In brief, phenolic composition of the chestnut tannin extract and the four diet samples were quantified using 20 mg of finely ground powder extracted in 2×1.4 ml of acetone : water (8 : 2, v/v) for 3 h with a Vortex-Genie 2T mixer (Scientific Industries, Bohemia, NY, USA). After 10 min of centrifugation at 16 000×g (Eppendorf centrifuge 5402; Eppendorf AG, Hamburg, Germany), supernatant was stored in a separate vial and the extraction was repeated on the original tissue with fresh solvent. Acetone was removed from the pooled extracts using an Eppendorf concentrator 5301 (Eppendorf AG) and the sample was freeze-dried. Before analysis, sample was dissolved in 2 ml of water and filtered through a 0.20-µm polytetrafluoroethylene filter. Phenolics were analysed from each sample using ultra performance liquid chromatography with diode array and electrospray MS detectors (UPLC-DAD-MS, Waters Acquity UPLC and Waters Xevo TQ triple quadrupole mass spectrometer; Waters Corporation, Milford, MA, USA). We used a Waters Acquity UPLC BEH Phenyl (1.7 ml, 2.1 9100 mm) column with CH3CN (A) and 0.1% HCOOH as eluents (Engström et al., Reference Engström, Pälijärvi and Salminen2015). Individual HTs were identified on the basis of their UV and MS spectra (Moilanen et al., Reference Moilanen, Sinkkonen and Salminen2013). Gallic acid was quantified in gallic acid equivalents, all gallic acid derivatives in pentagalloylglucose equivalents and ellagitannins as tellimagrandin I equivalents.
Analysis of indole, skatole and androstenone concentrations in the adipose tissue
Androstenone, skatole and indole concentrations in the adipose tissue were analysed according to Ampuero Kragten et al. (Reference Ampuero Kragten, Verkuylen, Dahlmans, Hortos, Garcia-Regueiro, Dahl, Andresen, Feitsma, Mathur and Harlizius2011) and based on the method previously described by Hansen-Møller (Reference Hansen-Møller1994). In brief, the adipose tissue samples were liquefied in a microwave oven for 2×2 min at 250 W. The liquefied lipids were centrifuged for 2 min at room temperature. The water was then removed and 0.5 ml of water-free liquid fat, kept at around 47°C, was placed in 2.5-ml Eppendorf tubes in duplicates and an internal standard was added (1 ml methanol containing 0.496 mg/l androstanone and 0.050 mg/l 2-methylindole). After vortexing for 30 s, the tubes were incubated for 5 min at 30°C in an ultrasonic water bath, kept at 0°C in ice-water bath for 20 min and then centrifuged at 11 000×g for 20 min. Finally, the liquid fraction was filtered (0.2-μm filter) and transferred into a vial for androstenone, skatole and indole analysis with an HPLC system. Concentrations were expressed per gram of adipose tissue. The quantification limits were 0.3 μg/g adipose tissue for androstenone and 0.03 μg/g adipose tissue for skatole and indole.
RNA isolation
Total RNA was extracted using a Nucleospin RNA XS kit (740902; Macherey-Nagel, Oensingen, Switzerland) following the procedure provided by the manufacturer. In brief, after thawing, 3 to 4 mg of liver tissue was homogenised in a MiniLys Bertin (Labgene, Chatel-St-Denis, Switzerland) using CK14 Precellys Lysing Kit (KT03961-1-203; Labgene) in 0.3 ml of RA1 buffer of the Nucleospin RNA XS kit. The RNA concentration was determined using a NanoDrop ND 1000 spectrophotometer (Witec AG, Littau, Switzerland). The mean 260/280 absorbance ratio of the samples was 2.13.
Primer design, reverse transcription and quantitative real-time PCR
For reverse transcription with the Quantitect Reverse Transcription kit (205311; Qiagen, Basel, Switzerland), which also includes a DNase I digestion step, 250 ng of RNA were used. The resulting reaction product was diluted 1 : 1 with RNAse-free water before further analysis. Primers for cytochrome P450 (CYP) isoenzyme CYP1A2 and CYP2E1 and CYP2A19 were designed using Primer-Blast service (Ye et al., 2012) offered by the National Institute of Health and verified for specificity using National Center for Biotechnology Information database (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov). Primers for the CYP1A2 gene were the same as used by Rasmussen et al. (2011). The target and housekeeping gene primers and National Center for Biotechnology Information accession numbers are shown in Supplementary Table S1. For each primers pairs, the efficiency of amplification was determined in three independent experiments.
Genes encoding CYP1A2, CYP2E1 and CYP2A19 were evaluated for their expression in pig livers via quantitative real-time PCR, using a KAPA Sybr Fast qPCR Kit (KK 4602m; Kapa Biosystems, Labgene, Chatel-St-Denis, Switzerland) with an Eco Illumina-Real Time PCR System (Labgene). The programme consisted of a pre-incubation step at 95°C for 5 min, followed by 40 cycles of 5 s at 95°C and 20 s at 62°C. The expression of each targeted gene was evaluated using
$$\Delta \Delta ^{{{\minus}C_{t} }} $$
method (with efficiency corrections) and normalised using glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) as housekeeping genes. All the calculations were performed using Eco-Illumina Study software (Labgene).
Sensory analysis
The sensory test aimed to determine differences in intensity of boar taint odour and flavour as well as additional sensorial characteristics of cooked loin chops related to the dietary HT supply. The panel, which consisted of eight judges (five females and three males, from 35 to 62 years of age), was previously trained to determine boar taint as well as juiciness and tenderness. In addition, by using LD samples collected from the experimental animals, judges completed four-training sessions in order to agree on the following three discriminant descriptors: ‘bitter’, ‘gummy’ and ‘astringent’. For the traits juiciness, tenderness, bitter, gummy and astringent a monadic linear scale ranging from 0 to 10 (0=low intensity, weak; 10=great intensity, strong) was used. By contrast, for the boar taint assessment the judges indicated the presence or absence of boar taint odour and flavour using R-index technique (O’Mahony, 1988). The judges could give one of the four following answers regarding boar taint odour and flavour in the test as compared with the control sample: S (the flavour and odour was definitely present), S? (flavour and odour was present but they were not sure), N? (flavour and odour was not present but they were not sure) or N (flavour and odour was not present and they were sure). Samples were offered in a randomised order to ensure that judges did not evaluate the same sample at the same time. The judges were instructed to begin with the first sample on the left side of the plate and follow it clockwise. They were also asked to assess the traits according to a defined sequence. First, they had to smell the meat immediately after removing the glass top and to evaluate boar odour intensity. They were then requested to chew and taste the meat sample and evaluate boar flavour, juiciness, tenderness, bitterness and gumminess intensities and astringent properties. Before starting the sensory evaluation of the following sample, they were asked to eat bread and rinse their mouth with light black tea.
The loin samples from C, T15 and T30 pigs originating from the same litter were served on the same dish, with an extra C sample as a control sample for the R-index test. The litters were randomised between the sessions. In four sessions (n=12, two sessions per week), the LD-strips originating from four EM were offered with a 10-min interval between servings. Data were recorded with the help of the Fizz Network data acquisition system and software (Version 2.0; Biosystems, Couternon, France).
Statistical analysis
Data for growth performance, carcass characteristics and meat quality traits were analysed with the MIXED procedure of SAS. The model used included litter and experimental groups as fixed effects. The individual pig was the experimental unit for analysis of all data. Least-squares means were calculated and considered statistically significant at P⩽0.05 and tendencies were denoted at P⩽0.10 and >0.05. Pearson’s correlations between boar taint compounds and weight of testes, accessory sex glands and CYP gene isoform expression were determined using CORR procedure.
Parametric modelling of the continuous traits of the sensory analysis was performed using MIXED procedure of SAS. As residual diagnostics in the parametric linear mixed models indicated strong deviations from normality in most cases, the R package ‘robustlmm’ (Koller, Reference Koller2013) was used to estimate the model parameters by a robustified REML algorithm (Koller, Reference Koller2014). Inference was based on t-values (normal approximation), non-significant (P>0.05) interactions and (near) zero-valued variance components were step-wise excluded. The full model is given in the following equation:
$$\eqalignno{Y_{{ijklm}} {\,\equals\,} & \mu {\plus}t_{i} {\plus}s_{j} {\plus}r_{k} {\plus}(ts)_{{ij}} {\plus}(tr)_{{ik}} {\plus}A_{l} {\plus}P_{m} \cr &{\plus}(tP)_{{im}} {\plus}(sP)_{{jm}} {\plus}(rP)_{{km}} {\plus}{\itε}_{{ijklm}} $$
μ is the general mean; t i the fixed effect of treatment i; s j the fixed effect of session j; r k the fixed effect of service k; (ts) ij the interaction of treatment i with session j; (tr) ik the interaction of treatment i with service k; A ð the random effect of animal l; P m the random effect of panellist m; (tP) im the interaction of treatment i with panellist m; (sP) jm the interaction of session j with panellist m; (rP) km the interaction of service k with panellist m; ε iklm the residual error.
The R-indices for boar odour and flavour were computed in Excel® according to O’Mahony (Reference O’Mahony1992) on the basis of Thurstonian modelling and signal detection theory of the categorical response values v. treatments. Inference concerning the R-indices was based on tables of critical values as published by Bi and O’Mahony (Reference Bi and O’Mahony2007).
Results
Characterisation of hydrolysable tannin of chestnut
Per kilogram of the chestnut tannin extract consisted of 88.7 g ellagitannins, 450.9 g gallotannins and 37.5 g gallic acid. Gallotannins consisted mainly of nine different types of galloylglucoses having six to 14 galloyl groups, but also smaller levels of di-, tri-, tetra- and pentagalloylglucoses were found. The relatively low levels of ellagitannins consisted mainly of C-glycosidic ellagitannins such as vescalagin, castalagin and castavaloninic acid. In addition, the product contained small amounts of proanthocyanidins (syn. condensed tannins, 3.16 g/kg), consisting of prodelphinidin (48%) and procyanidin (52%) subunits. When included in the pelleted diets, the tannin levels amounted to 0.07% and 0.13% for ellagitannins and 0.46% and 1.01% for gallotannins in the T15 and T30 diets, respectively (Table 1). In addition, the percentage gallic acid amounted to 0.09% and 0.17% in the T15 and T30 diets, respectively. Diet C did not contain any detectable amounts of HT or gallic acid. In all the three experimental diets no condensed tannins were detectable.
Growth performance, morphometric measurements and carcass characteristics
Tannin supplementation had no effect on average daily gain and average daily feed intake (Table 2). Nevertheless, gain-to-feed ratio was lower (P<0.05) in the tannin supplemented compared with the unsupplemented group mainly because of a combination of numerically slower growth and a numerically greater average daily feed intake. Apart from percentage cold loss that tended (P<0.10) to be greater in the T30 compared with the C and T15 groups, hot carcass weight, killing out percentage and carcass characteristics such as percentage lean meat, primal cuts and backfat were not affected by the experimental treatments. Compared with the T15 group, the weight of the salivary and bulbourethral glands was depressed (P<0.05) and that of the kidney tended (P<0.10) to be lower in EM of the T30 group, with reductions of 20%, 18% and 8%, respectively. Except for the kidney, EM of the C group displayed intermediate values.
Table 2 Effect of increasing inclusion levels of hydrolysable tannins in the finisher diet on growth performance, carcass characteristics and organ weights of entire males
a,bValues within a row with different superscript letters differ significantly at P⩽0.05.
x,yValues within a row with different superscript letters tend to differ significantly at P⩽0.10.
1 Control=standard finisher diet without addition of chestnut tannin powder; T15=standard finisher diet with addition of 1.5% of chestnut tannin powder; T30=standard finisher diet with addition of 3% chestnut tannin powder.
2 Weight loss of the hot carcass during cooling at 2°C for 24 h.
3 Sum of denuded shoulder, back and ham weights as percentage of cold carcass weight.
4 Sum of external fat from the shoulder, back and ham expressed as percentage of cold carcass weight.
Meat quality, boar taint compounds and cytochrome P450 isoenzyme gene expression
Thaw losses were greater (P<0.05) in LD chops from EM of the T30 compared with T15 group, whereas other meat quality traits were not affected by the tannin supplementation (Table 3). Skatole and indole tissue levels were lower (P<0.10) in T30 compared with T15 pigs (Table 3). Compared with EM of the C group, only indole but not skatole levels in the adipose tissue were lower (P<0.05) in EM of the T30 group. Although not reaching a tendency (P=0.16), androstenone levels were lowest in the T30, highest in the T15 and intermediate in the C group.
Table 3 Effect of increasing inclusion levels of hydrolysable tannins in the finisher diet of entire males on meat quality traits and boar taint compounds in the adipose tissue
a,bValues within a row with different superscript letters differ significantly at P⩽0.05.
x,yValues within a row with different superscript letters tend to differ significantly at P⩽0.10.
1 Control=standard finisher diet without addition of chestnut tannin powder; T15=standard finisher diet with addition of 1.5% of chestnut tannin powder; T30=standard finisher diet with addition of 3% chestnut tannin powder.
2 L*=lightness (lower values=darker colour; greater values=lighter colour).
The messenger RNA CYP isoenzyme expression in the liver was not affected by the dietary treatments (Table 4). However, expression level of the CYP1A2 and CYP2A19 isoforms were numerically greater in the T30 compared with the T15 treatment.
Table 4 Effect of increasing inclusion levels of hydrolysable tannins in the finisher diet of entire males on hepatic messenger RNA (mRNA) cytochrome P450 (CYP) isoenzyme expressionFootnote 1
1 The mRNA expression of the CYP isoenzymes CYP1A2, CYP2A19 and CYP1E2 are normalised against the mRNA expression of glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase.
2 Control=standard finisher diet without addition of chestnut tannin powder; T15=standard finisher diet with addition of 1.5% of chestnut tannin powder; T30=standard finisher diet with addition of 3% chestnut tannin powder.
The adipose tissue concentration of androstenone, skatole and indole was positively (P<0.05) correlated with the testes, mandibular gland and accessory sex gland weights (Table 5). Furthermore, gene expression of CYP2E1 and CYP1A2, CYP2E1 and CYP2A, and CYP2A decreased (P<0.05) with increasing tissue concentrations of androstenone, skatole and indole, respectively.
Table 5 Correlation coefficients between boar taint compound level in the adipose tissue and weight of testes, bulbourethral and salivary gland as well as on hepatic messenger RNA (mRNA) cytochrome P450 (CYP) isoenzyme expressionFootnote 1
1 The mRNA expression of the CYP isoenzymes CYP1A2, CYP2A19 and CYP1E2 are normalised against the mRNA expression of glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase.
*P<0.05, **P<0.01.
Sensory analysis
Intensity of bitterness tended (P<0.10) to be lower and that of gumminess tended to be greater in the meat of C compared with the T15 and T30 pigs, respectively (Table 6). Presence or absence of boar taint odour and flavour of pork chops from EM was analysed by the R-index procedure (Table 7). In this method, the odour and flavour scores for samples from EM of the T15 and T30 group were compared with those of the C treatment. The R-indices represent the probability of detecting a difference in the presence or absence of boar odour and flavour between EM of a particular treatment and samples of EM of the C group.
Table 6 Effect of increasing inclusion levels of hydrolysable tannins in the finisher diet on sensory scores of loin chops from entire malesFootnote 1
x,yValues within a row with different superscript letters tend to differ significantly at P⩽0.10.
1 Scores are defined as 0=no intensity, weak; 10=very high intensity, strong.
2 Control=standard finisher diet without addition of chestnut tannin powder; T15=standard finisher diet with addition of 1.5% of chestnut tannin powder; T30=standard finisher diet with addition of 3% chestnut tannin powder.
Table 7 Probabilities of detecting the differences in boar taint odour and boar taint flavour by judges (R-index values (%)) between meat from entire male pigs fed the T15 or T30 diet compared with meat from entire male pigs fed the control dietFootnote 1 ,2
*Judges were sure about the presence of boar odour in meat from T15 entire males compared with that of entire males of the control group.
1 Control=standard finisher diet without addition of chestnut tannin powder; T15=standard finisher diet with addition of 1.5% of chestnut tannin powder; T30=standard finisher diet with addition of 3% chestnut tannin powder.
2 The R-indices represent the probability of detecting a difference in the presence or absence of boar odour and flavour between samples of T15 and T30 entire males and samples of C entire males. An R-index of 50% or lower indicates no difference in terms of boar taint odour or flavour between meat from entire males fed the T15 or T30 diets and meat from entire males fed the control diet; a R-index above 50%+the critical value for α =0.05, indicates that judges were sure about the presence of boar odour or flavour in meat from T15 and T30 entire males compared with that of entire males of the control group. The critical value for the R-index was determined to be 7.21% (Bi and O’Mahony, Reference Bi and O’Mahony2007).
The R-index measures the difference between a sample (designated as the ‘signal’ sample) and a control sample (designated as the ‘noise’ sample) during a paired comparison of both. An R-index value of 100% indicates that samples are perfectly distinguishable, whereas a value of 50% indicates that both samples are equal and therefore the null hypothesis cannot be disregarded. A given confidence interval, together with the number of DF, will determine a critical value (R-index – 50%) above which meat from EM fed the HT-supplemented diets present boar taint, either in odour or in flavour, significantly greater than the meat from EM fed diet C. The critical value for the R-index was determined to be 7.21% (Bi and O’Mahony, Reference Bi and O’Mahony2007). Therefore, meat from T15 pigs displayed more (P<0.05) boar odour, but not boar flavour, compared with meat from C pigs. By contrast, meat from T30 and C pigs did not differ regarding boar odour and flavour.
Discussion
Results of in vitro studies from Biagia et al. (Reference Biagia, Cipollini, Paulicks and Roth2010) showed an inhibitory effect of tannins on the total activity of caecal bacteria. The large intestine and colon is the production site of two compounds, skatole and indole. Skatole and androstenone are the main compounds responsible for the incidence of boar taint and indole makes a minor contribution (Xue and Dial, Reference Xue and Dial1997; Wesoly and Weiler, Reference Wesoly and Weiler2012). In several European countries with a large pig sector, there is a clear incentive to switch from barrows to EM production (Bee et al., Reference Bee, Guex and Herzog2015). In light of these facts, it is relevant to evaluate whether tannins might lower or even inhibit the production of indole and skatole and thereby reduce the incidence of boar taint. The major finding of the present study is that compared with the control at the greatest HT inclusion level, the diet rich especially in gallotannins resulted in reduced indole and numerically lower androstenone tissue levels, but the reductions were not sufficient to be perceived by the sensory panel. Puzzling were the findings at 1.5% HT inclusion level as adipose tissue levels of skatole and numerically of androstenone were greatest and accordingly boar odour perception was highest.
Dietary effects on growth performance, carcass characteristics and organ weights
Despite tannin supplementation having no effect on growth rate and feed intake, gain-to-feed ratio was lower in both, the T15 and T30 treatment, compared with the C treatment. However, the lower feed efficiency had no impact on lean tissue and adipose tissue deposition. Recently, Čandek-Potokar et al. (Reference Čandek-Potokar, Škrlep, Batorek Lukač, Zamaratskaia, Prevolnik Povše, Velikonja Bolta, Kubale and Bee2015) observed lower feed intake and only numerically lower growth rate and feed efficiency when EM were offered a diet supplemented with three compared with 2%, 1% or 0% chestnut tannin extract. By contrast, Antongiovanni et al. (Reference Antongiovanni, Minieri and Petacchi2007) reported no differences in feed intake and feed efficiency of finisher pigs fed chestnut tannins at a 0.20% to 0.50% level. These results suggest that there is a dose-dependent effect of gallotannin-rich feed on growth performance.
The lower weights of the mandibular and bulbourethral glands and the numerically lower testes weight of T30 compared with T15 and C pigs partly corroborate the results of Čandek-Potokar et al. (Reference Čandek-Potokar, Škrlep, Batorek Lukač, Zamaratskaia, Prevolnik Povše, Velikonja Bolta, Kubale and Bee2015). In line with its function as a pheromone-secreting gland, the weights of the mandibular glands were positively correlated with androstenone tissue levels. Similar in magnitude, the weights of testes and bulbourethral glands were also positively correlated with androstenone tissue levels. As reviewed by Dias et al. (Reference Dias, Alves, Oliveira and Silva2014), plant extracts rich in tannins and flavonoids can reduce LH and testosterone serum concentrations in male albino rats treated with increasing levels of these extracts over a 60-day period. Similarly, Abarikwu et al. (Reference Abarikwu, Akiri, Durojaiye and Alabi2014) reported that gallic acid directly suppressed steroidogenesis in male Wistar rats by decreasing androgenic enzyme activities. Thus, lower levels of gonadotrophins might decrease the androgenic activity of the testes and in turn understimulate the accessory sex glands, causing their regressive changes. This leads to the hypothesis that were tannins to be introduced into the diets of growing boars at a younger age, before the onset of puberty and the production of sex-related chemicals like androstenone, it is possible that the disruption of the hormone-controlled production of androgenic compounds might act more efficiently, reducing the levels of androstenone in slaughter weight boars.
Dietary effects on skatole, indole and androstenone levels in adipose tissue
One of the main objectives of the present study was to assess the potential of HT to reduce the deposition of skatole and indole in the adipose tissue by affecting the microbial synthesis of these substances in the hindgut. This objective was based on promising results of in vitro and in vivo experiments of Biagia et al. (Reference Biagia, Cipollini, Paulicks and Roth2010) suggesting that dietary HT trigger a shift from a predominantly proteolytic to a predominantly saccharolytic microbial metabolism. In the present study, we observed that with increasing dietary HT inclusion, indole concentration in the adipose tissue linearly decreased. The fact that sensory threshold for indole is 53 times lower than for skatole (Nagata and Takeuchi, Reference Nagata and Takeuchi2003) it is not plausible that the observed decline in indole level was directly associated with the sensory assessment. Surprisingly, skatole tissue levels followed a curvilinear response pattern, as at 1.5% compared with 0% and 3% inclusion levels, skatole tissue concentrations were almost twice as high and way above the acceptance threshold (Meier-Dinkel et al., Reference Meier-Dinkel, Gertheiss, Müller, Wesoly and Mörlein2015). These findings partly corroborate those of Čandek-Potokar et al. (Reference Čandek-Potokar, Škrlep, Batorek Lukač, Zamaratskaia, Prevolnik Povše, Velikonja Bolta, Kubale and Bee2015) who reported also a curvilinear relationship between dietary levels of chestnut tannin extract and the adipose tissue concentration of skatole. At a dietary HT concentration of 3%, 2% and 0% compared with 1%, skatole adipose tissue levels were two-, two- and three-times lower, respectively, and did not follow the concentrations determined in the colon (Čandek-Potokar et al., Reference Čandek-Potokar, Škrlep, Batorek Lukač, Zamaratskaia, Prevolnik Povše, Velikonja Bolta, Kubale and Bee2015). The lack of synchrony between skatole and indole content in the colon and their respective tissue levels is not surprising as absorption and hepatic clearance are, in addition to microbial synthesis, determinant factors for their final tissue concentrations (Wesoly and Weiler, Reference Wesoly and Weiler2012). Knarreborg et al. (Reference Knarreborg, Beck, Jensen, Laue, Agergaard and Jensen2002) concluded from the strong correlation between the concentrations of indolic compounds in the tissue and blood within animals that a proportion of the indolic compounds produced was also absorbed. However, the weak relationships between animals emphasise the importance that individual hepatic clearance rate has on the level of these adipose tissue compounds. In accordance with Čandek-Potokar et al. (Reference Čandek-Potokar, Škrlep, Batorek Lukač, Zamaratskaia, Prevolnik Povše, Velikonja Bolta, Kubale and Bee2015), the significance of liver metabolism is underlined in the present study by the negative relationship between the skatole and indole concentrations in the adipose tissue and the hepatic gene expression of CYP2E1 and CYP2A19. These findings extend those of Čandek-Potokar et al. (Reference Čandek-Potokar, Škrlep, Batorek Lukač, Zamaratskaia, Prevolnik Povše, Velikonja Bolta, Kubale and Bee2015) suggesting a link between dietary HT intake and gene expression and enzyme activity of two major enzymes of the phase 1 metabolism (Wiercinska et al., Reference Wiercinska, Lou and Squires2012). However, based on earlier results not the high molecular weight polyphenols, but their metabolites like the urolithins are responsible for these effects. Espín et al. (Reference Espín, González-Barrio, Cerdá, López-Bote, Rey and Tomás-Barberán2007) showed that ellagic acid released from acorn ellagitannins in the jejunum are metabolised by the intestinal flora to yield urolithin metabolites, which are then absorbed into the bloodstream, conjugated in the liver and either excreted in the urine or undergo active enterohepaticcirculation. What the authors also showed that these metabolites are not stored in the organs like liver, lung, heart, kidney, muscle and adipose tissue. However, as reviewed by Korobkova (Reference Korobkova2015) these metabolites have the potential to alter CYP activity either via direct interactions with the enzymes or by affecting the CYP gene expression. The latter could be one possible mechanism linking the 3% HT intake, adipose tissue skatole and indole concentrations and hepatic gene expression of CYP2E1 and CYP2A19. The reason for the unexpected results in the T15 group remains unclear. Nevertheless, the high skatole level in the T15 group concur with the numerically highest androstenone concentration and numerically lowest CYP2E1 and CYP2A19. It has been shown in isolated pig hepatocytes that excessive concentrations of androstenone prevent CYP2E1 induction by its substrate skatole, resulting in lower hepatic skatole clearance and therefore greater accumulation in the adipose tissue (Doran et al., Reference Doran, Whittington, Wood and McGivan2002).
Dietary effects on meat quality traits and sensory quality
Apart from small differences in thaw losses, being in tendency 1% unit lower in T15 compared with C and T30, meat quality was not affected by the dietary HT supplementation. The lack of HT impact on meat quality is comparable with other dietary approaches that seek to control boar taint with for instance inulin or raw potato starch (Pauly et al., Reference Pauly, Spring, Doherty, Ampuero Kragten and Bee2008; Aluwe et al., Reference Aluwe, Langendries, Bekaert, Tuyttens, De Brabander, De Smet and Millet2013). In line with the higher skatole and androstenone concentrations, members of the sensory panel could detect a stronger boar taint odour but not flavour in cooked loin chops of the T15 compared with the C and T30 groups. The finding that the sensitivity towards odour is stronger than towards flavour is in agreement with a recent study (Bonneau and Chevillon, Reference Bonneau and Chevillon2012). As previously mentioned, skatole levels at T15 were above tolerable thresholds, whereas androstenone levels were rather low (Bonneau and Chevillon, Reference Bonneau and Chevillon2012). This led us to conclude that the adverse reaction of the panellists towards loin from T15 pigs was primarily the result of the greater skatole and not the androstenone concentration. During the training sessions with loin chops from the experimental animals, the members of the panel agreed on the sensory descriptors bitterness, gumminess and astringency. Only two of the three descriptors tended to differ between dietary treatments. Although at very low-score levels, bitterness and gumminess scores tended to be greatest in the T15 and C groups, respectively. Surprisingly, the extent of astringency, which is often associated with tannins did not differ between-treatment groups. All in all, apart from boar taint, the sensory analysis revealed no noticeable concern regarding sensorial properties of loins from pigs fed HT-supplemented diets.
Conclusion
The results of this study confirm that up to 3% HT in a finisher diet of EM has only a marginal impact on growth performance, carcass characteristics and meat quality. It appears that a HT-based diet rich in gallotannins may to some extent be effective at tackling boar taint, but only at the greatest inclusion level. The results obtained at the lower inclusion level are puzzling because they suggest that HT affected either indolic compound production and/or absorption positively in the hindgut or hampered hepatic clearance by reducing CYP isoenzyme expression through unknown mechanisms. Further studies are warranted to unravel the effect of HT on the gut microbiome and liver metabolism, which might lead to additional feeding strategies for EM and to strategies for dealing with boar tainted pork.
Acknowledgements
The authors thank Y. Aeby, C. Biolley, B. Dougoud, S. Dubois, G. Maïkoff, P. Stoll and the panellists from Agroscope Posieux for their support and technical assistance. Furthermore, the authors thank Anne Koivuniemi for running the hydrolysable tannin analysis in the feed and chestnut tannin extract. M. Čandek-Potokar received financing from Slovenian Agency of Research (grant no. P4-0133).
Supplementary Material
To view supplementary material for this article, please visit https://doi.org/10.1017/S1751731116002597
Open access
