Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-p9bg8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-29T18:49:51.064Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

ANTARCTIC PILOT: COMPRISING THE COASTS OF ANTARCTICA AND ALL ISLANDS SOUTH OF THE USUAL ROUTE OF VESSELS. S.J. Lawrence (compiler). 2009. Taunton: United Kingdom Hydrographic Office. 7th edition. xviii + 489p., illustrated, hard cover. ISBN: 978-0-70-774-2014. £50.10.

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 December 2009

Ian R. Stone*
Affiliation:
Scott Polar Research Institute, University of Cambridge, Lensfield Road, Cambridge CB2 1ER
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Type
Book Review
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2009

The very subtitle of this latest edition of the Antarctic Pilot referring to ‘all islands south of the usual route of vessels’ is likely to engender a quickening of the pulse in the reader even before perusal of the volume starts. One has long suspected that deep in the bowels of the Hydrographic Office in Taunton there exists some person, who perhaps rarely sees the light of day, whose task it is to insert in these ostensibly most functional and prosaic of books an element of poetry, a desire to bid farewell to normal cares and to embark on a voyage . . . it matters little where. A much more distinguished writer than the present reviewer made a similar point. Somerset Maugham at the start of his famous story The vessel of wrath, written in 1931, enlarges on the merits of the series of works of which the Antarctic Pilot is representative. ‘There are few books in the world that contain more meat than the Sailing Directions published by the Hydrographic Department. . . .’. He devotes more than a page of the story to a description of the series in question especially noting their ‘matter-of-fact style, the admirable order, the concision with which the material is set before you, the stern sense of the practical that informs every line’ but which cannot ‘dim the poetry’ contained therein. He mentions also the variety of incidental information provided, availability of supplies at various anchorages and so forth, and concludes ‘[c]an the imagination want more material than this to go on a journey through time and space?’ (Maugham Reference Maugham1951). The answer, surely, is a resounding negative.

The Antarctic Pilot has long been the essential vade mecum of mariners in the far south and the latest edition, compiled by Captain S.J. Lawrence, is even more valuable than its distant predecessors in that it includes a stunning set of colour photographs. But apart from this welcome innovation, the format is traditional. After a glossary, which contains such esoteric material as the Cyrillic morse code, chapter 1 is introductory but it still comprises 102 pages. Here we are straight back to Maugham since we are immediately advised of the fairly obvious point that ‘as a result of the lack of landmass. . .and the frequency of cyclones in the area, very heavy seas and high swells are frequently encountered.’ This constitutes the first of the warnings to mariners mentioned frequently throughout the book including, for example, the possibility of encountering mines (from World War II) in Kerguelen, and ‘explosives scattered’ around close to the former Wilkes Station. Indeed it seems that the only ocean going hazard that sailors are unlikely to encounter in the area is piracy. This chapter is wonderfully comprehensive and as well as the sort of information one might reasonably expect to appear, ice concentrations and so forth, there is a full account of the wildlife, with excellent photographs. More essential is a statement of ‘principal harbours and anchorages’. Readers will not be surprised to learn that fewer than 100 of these are listed. There is also an excellent map of bases operated by the National Antarctic Programmes (lamentably spelt ‘programs’) after which the chapter goes on to consider in full detail the weather, of which, as was once jocularly observed, there is rather a lot beyond 60°S.

But this is a mere introduction to what follows, and chapter 2 affords an excellent example of the way the book is structured. This is upon the sub-Antarctic islands of Bouvetøya, Prince Edward Islands, Îles Crozet, Îles Kerguelen, Heard Island and the McDonald Islands and Macquarie Island. As an example of the comprehensive information set forth, in the ‘General Information’ section we are warned of the ‘doubtful’ existence of a ‘rock’, reported by SS Truls in 1929, 46 m high at 56° 07′S, 23° 39′E, some 720 miles east of Bouvetøya. The information on that territory itself covers some two pages and is exhaustive. There is a full description of the island that we are advised may be safely circumnavigated if one is ‘remaining at least 2 miles off the coast’. One of the excellent points of the Antarctic Pilot is that there is no stint in the amount of space devoted to the history of the various territories under consideration and this indicates the desire of the compilers of the different editions to educate as well as to inform their readers. For Bouvetøya this covers more than a column and lists the various visits by vessels noting that they were usually frustrated with regard to landing. Full details of the circumnavigation of the island are stated including an ominous ‘dangerous rock’ and there is a note of anchorages and ‘harbours’, of which there are none of the latter at Bouvet.

The rest of the book continues in the same vein. In the section on the Antarctic Peninsula for example we find the most detailed possible description of all the passages and bays in that complex area. There can be few if any members of expedition cruise staff, who may have landed at some of their favourites very many times, for example Paradise Harbour, who would not find something that they did not know. Moreover there are clear colour photographs (from where did the photographers obtain the weather in which they were taken?) of beacons, refuge huts and so forth. For example in the case of Dorian Bay we have half page photographs of the beacon and of both huts, the latter clearly showing the flagpole up which this reviewer hoisted the Union Flag, which he found neatly folded on a shelf inside the hut, the last time he was there. It was replaced on the shelf at the end of the visit, one hopes with equal neatness! Dorian Bay is followed by Port Lockroy, that most visited site, with full information for approaching the harbour with the rather surprising note that this ‘can be entered at night with the assistance of radar or searchlights.’ There is, of course, an excellent photograph of Bransfield House.

The whole of the accessible part of the Antarctic coastline is covered with the same exhaustive attention to detail and the descriptions of the less frequented parts are full of advice reflecting the imperfect state of charting, difficult conditions etc. In describing the Australian Antarctic Territory the compiler permits himself the observation (unattributed) that this is the ‘home of the blizzard’ and for George VI Land mariners are ‘warned not to place any reliance on their magnetic compass’ due to the proximity of the South Magnetic Pole.

The volume concludes with a full statement of the Antarctic Treaty and of the environmental protocol to it. There are also lists of facilities and refuges, the supplies in which ‘may be extremely basic’, Antarctic specially protected areas, historic sites and monuments, other protected areas, and statements of guidance for visitors. The index is as comprehensive as one would expect in a volume of this authority.

The book would have benefited by a thorough third reading by a third party to iron out a few slips. For example we have merely Bellingshausen on page 14 but he has been ennobled by page 178, there is a picture of the ‘Accommadation’ block at Halley on page 385, and Dr R. von Drygalski appears on page 426.

As might be expected the volume is substantially bound ready to survive much anxious thumbing on the bridges of vessels as they venture into the seas in question. The Antarctic Pilot is not cheap but in terms of value for money it is unsurpassed. In Maugham's day 4 shillings was considered reasonable for the Yangtse Kiang Pilot; nowadays £50 is not excessive for this latest edition of the Antarctic Pilot.

References

Maugham, W.S. 1951. The vessel of wrath. In: Maugham, W.S. The complete short stories vol 2. London: William Heinemann.Google Scholar