Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t8hqh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T00:22:38.416Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Urban planning by obliteration of both waterways and opponents: the infilling of canals during the 1950s reconstruction of central Tokyo

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 December 2014

JUNICHI HASEGAWA
JUNICHI HASEGAWA*
Affiliation:
Faculty of Economics, Keio University, 2–15–45 Mita, Minato-ku, Tokyo 108 – 8345, Japan
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article examines the infilling of canals constructed in early modern times and subsequent development on newly created land in central Tokyo in the 1950s, following the curtailment of official war-damage reconstruction after World War II. New developments included a high-rise central station building, a four-storey amusement complex, an underground entertainment street and an elevated motorway. The Tokyo Metropolitan Government and Japanese National Railways were driving forces in infilling and development, which resulted in enormous political and social reactions in the local communities, newspapers and the National Diet (Parliament).

Type
Research Article
Information
Urban History , Volume 42 , Issue 3 , August 2015 , pp. 483 - 506
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2014 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Diefendorf, J.M. (ed.), Europe's Bombed Cities (Basingstoke, 1990)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; idem, In the Wake of War (Oxford, 1993); Tiratsoo, N., Reconstruction, Affluence and Labour Politics (London, 1990)Google Scholar; Tiratsoo, N., Hasegawa, J., Mason, T. and Matsumura, T., Urban Reconstruction in Britain and Japan, 1945–1955 (Luton, 2002), chs. 2–5Google Scholar; Hasegawa, J., Replanning the Blitzed City Centre (Buckingham, 1992)Google Scholar; Larkham, P.J. and Lilley, K.D., Planning the ‘City of Tomorrow’ (Pickering, 2001)Google Scholar. Also see P.J. Larkham (ed.), ‘Virtual special issue: replanning and rebuilding the blitzed city’, Planning Perspectives (2013), http://explore.tandfonline.com/page/pgas/rppe-vsi, containing 11 articles on blitz reconstruction in European countries that appeared in that journal between 1993 and 2008.

2 In English, Tiratsoo et al., Urban Reconstruction in Britain and Japan, chs. 6–9; C. Hein, J.M. Diefendorf and Ishida, Y. (eds.), Rebuilding Urban Japan after 1945 (Basingstoke and New York, 2003)Google Scholar.

3 Land readjustment had long been a principal method of Japanese urban planning. It entailed taking portions of individually owned plots in order to realize plans for roads, open spaces and other purposes. It was predicated on a premise that land values would rise sufficiently in areas covered by readjustment projects to compensate affected owners. See, e.g., Minerbi, L.et al. (eds.), Land Readjustment: The Japanese System (Boston, MA, 1986)Google Scholar.

4 For statistical details, see Kensetsusho (Ministry of Construction) (ed.), Sensaifukkoshi (Records of War Damage Reconstruction), vol. I (Tokyo, 1959)Google Scholar.

5 Seidensticker, E., Tokyo Rising: The City since the Great Earthquake (New York, 1990), 147Google Scholar.

6 Before the war, there were several underground shopping streets that used passages of the stations of the underground railway; the first at Ueno opened in 1930, although none of them exist now. See Asahi Shimbun (Asahi), 13 Jan. 1976, 20 Jan. 1983 and 8 Nov. 1988.

7 Tokyo Statistical Yearbook (Tokyoshitokeinenpyo or Tokyototokeisho) for 1935, 669; for 1955, 172 and 179; and for 1960, 23, 252 and 268. Full-scale motorization arrived in the late 1960s, as the number of registered motor vehicles in the Tokyo metropolitan area increased from 854,000 in 1965 to 1,712,000 in 1970. See Tokyo Statistical Yearbook for 1970, 188. In this connection, see Gunn, S., ‘People and the car: the expansion of automobility in urban Britain, c. 1955–70’, Social History, 38 (2013), 220–37CrossRefGoogle Scholar, which shows that post-war motorization in Britain was a more limited, gradual and ambiguous process than is generally perceived.

8 Suzuki, M., Edo no Kawa Tokyo no Kawa (Tokyo, 1989), 239Google Scholar.

9 Seidensticker, Tokyo Rising, 149.

10 Not until 1968 was the new planning legislation referring to a public inquiry finally enacted. For this enactment, see Hasegawa, J., ‘Drafting of the 1968 Japanese city planning law’, Planning Perspectives, 29 (2014), 231–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 ‘Japan: an overview’ and ‘Tokyo’, in Tiratsoo et al., Urban Reconstruction in Britain and Japan, and Y. Ishida, ‘Japanese cities and planning in the reconstruction period: 1945–55’, in Hein et al. (eds.), Rebuilding Urban Japan after 1945.

12 Smith, H.D., ‘Tokyo as an idea: an exploration of Japanese urban thought until 1945’, Journal of Japanese Studies, 4 (1978), 45–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar, quotations on 63.

13 B. Bognar, Tokyo (Chichester, 1997), quotations on 47.

14 Sorensen, A., The Making of Urban Japan. Cities and Planning from Edo to the Twenty-First Century (London, 2002)Google Scholar.

15 Jackson, N., ‘Tradition and modernity: architecture in Japan after Hiroshima’, in Clapson, M. and Larkham, P. (eds.), The Blitz and its Legacy (Farnham and Burlington, 2013)Google Scholar.

16 Amin, A. and Thrift, N., Cities (Cambridge, 2002), esp. ch. 6Google Scholar.

17 Minutes of the Tokyo Metropolitan Assembly meetings are held at the Tokyo Metropolitan Assembly Library; minutes and related documents of Chogi are held at the Tokyo Metropolitan Archives. Minutes of the National Diet meetings and the newspapers are held at the National Diet Library but the former may also be accessed on the Internet. The photographs in this study are selected from those taken by Chuo ward and kept at its Kyobashi Library.

18 Tokyoto (ed.), Tokyo Sensaishi (Tokyo, 1953), 533–7Google Scholar.

19 Letter to Tokyo Shimbun, 11 Jan. 1948.

20 Letter to Tokyo Shimbun, 13 Jan. 1948.

21 Tokyo Shimbun, 23 Mar. 1948.

22 Asahi, 14 Oct. 1945.

23 Asahi, 28 Nov. 1946. The designation was authorized in February 1947. Asahi, 6 Feb. 1947.

24 In June 1949, the Japanese National Railways, a public corporation responsible for national railways, was inaugurated and took over the reconstruction of the national railway's stations.

25 S. Yasui, Tokyoshiki (Tokyo, 1961), 50.

26 Tokyo Shimbun, 23 Mar. 1948.

27 Minutes of the Metropolitan Assembly meeting, 30 Mar. 1948, 974–5.

28 Tokyoto (ed.), Tokyo Sensaishi, 536–7.

29 Tokyo Shimbun, Hissen, 30 Aug. 1948.

30 Ginmekai (ed.), Ginza wagamachi (Tokyo, 1975), 184–5Google Scholar.

31 Asahi, 2 Apr. 1948.

32 Tokyo Shimbun, 17 May 1948.

33 Minutes of the Metropolitan Assembly meeting, 10 Mar. 1949, 369–70 and 374.

34 Minutes of the House of Representatives’ Construction Committee, 7 Apr. 1949, 7.

35 Minutes of the House of Representatives’ Construction Committee, 12 Apr. 1949, 3–4.

36 Yomiuri Shimbun (Yomiuri), 19 Mar. 1949.

37 Tokyoto (ed.), Tokyo Sensaishi, 536.

38 Shinso, 5 Jan. 1951, 28–9. Also see Konomi's biography, Maki, H., Tokumukikancho Konomi Ujitoshi (Tokyo, 2010), ch. 9Google Scholar.

39 Yomiuri, 2 Nov. 1951.

40 Yomiuri, 8 Nov. 1951.

41 Minutes of the House of Councillors’ Budget Committee, 13 Nov. 1951, 12.

42 Reported in Yomiuri, 1 Dec. 1951.

43 Shukan Shincho, 2 Feb. 1959, 26–32.

44 Tosei Shinpo, 9 Oct. 1953 and 2 Jul. 1954.

45 Asahi, Tokyoban (the page for Tokyo), 31 Mar. 1953.

46 Minutes of the Metropolitan Assembly meeting, 27 Jul. 1954, 38.

47 Yomiuri, 30 Oct. 1954.

48 Minutes of the House of Representatives’ Local Government Committee, 10 Nov. 1954, 2.

49 Yomiuri, Henshu Techo, 9 Apr. 1949.

50 Asahi, 22 Oct. 1949.

51 Asahi, evening edition, 30 Dec. 1951.

52 Asahi, 28 May 1952.

53 Asahi, evening edition, 18 Aug. 1952.

54 Asahi, 15 Nov. 1946.

55 Senpachi Suzuki, in his role as a member of the House of the Representatives’ Transport Committee, introduced the project at its meeting on 25 Jun. 1953. Minutes of the Committee, 25 Jun. 1953, 7.

56 Minutes of the House of Representatives’ Transport Committee, 9 Jul. and 1 Aug. 1953.

57 Minutes of the House of Representatives’ Audit Committee, 4 Sep. 1953, 4–16.

58 Minutes of the House of Representatives’ Audit Committee, 2 Nov. 1953, 12–15.

59 Asahi, 20 Nov. 1953.

60 Asahi, evening edition, 28 Nov. 1953.

61 Asahi, 3 and 30 Mar., 4 and 10 Apr. 1954; Asahi, evening edition, 20 Mar. and 1 Apr. 1954.

62 Yomiuri, Shitamachiban, 1 May 1954.

63 Yomiuri, Shitamachiban, 14 May 1954.

64 Yomiuri, Shitamachiban, 9 Jun. 1954.

65 Yomiuri, evening edition, 21 Oct. 1954.

66 Yomiuri, 22 Oct. 1954.

67 Asahi, Tokyoban, 1 Aug. 1956.

68 Yomiuri, Chuoban, 21 Jan. 1957.

69 Stated by Higuchi himself and by Tatsuya Takio, head of the construction bureau of the Metropolitan Government; see minutes of the House of Representatives’ Construction Committee, 7 Dec. 1953, 1.

70 Summary of the sky building and skyway, no. 1, in Chogi, vol. 3, 33–19–48 to 33–19–60.

71 Minutes of the Metropolitan Assembly meeting, 6 Oct. 1955, 190.

72 Ishikawa, H., ‘Dai Tokyo Chihokeikaku to Kosokudojidoshadoro’ (Regional plan for Greater Tokyo and expressways), Doro (Road), 2, 8 (Aug. 1940), 36–40Google Scholar, and Doro, 2, 9 (Sep. 1940), 9–14.

73 Stated by Higuchi and Takio, minutes of the House of Representatives’ Construction Committee, 7 Dec. 1953, 1.

74 Agenda no. 102, discussed at the meeting on 5 Mar. 1951, in Chogi, vol. 4, 33–19–226. Also see a case history of the Tokyo Expressway project submitted for the meeting of Metropolitan Government officials on 4 Aug. 1953, in Chogi, vol. 18, 33–23–138.

75 Tokyo Shimbun, 18 Sep. 1951.

76 Case history of the Tokyo Expressway project, in Chogi, vol. 18, 33–23–138.

77 Agenda no. 30, discussed at the meeting on 4 Aug. 1953, in Chogi, vol. 18, 33–23–179.

78 Memo on infilling of Sotobori in connection with the construction of elevated road, in Chogi, vol. 18, 33–23–181.

79 Minutes of the Metropolitan Assembly meeting, 25 May 1954, 135–44.

80 Minutes of the Metropolitan Assembly meeting, 30 Jun. 1954, 341.

81 Minutes of the House of Representatives’ Construction Committee, 4 Dec. 1953, 8.

82 Minutes of the House of Representatives’ Construction Committee, 9 Nov. 1953, 6.

83 Minutes of the House of Representatives’ Construction Committee, 11 Dec. 1953, 3.

84 Minutes of the House of Representatives’ Construction Committee, 31 May 1954, 2–4.

85 Minutes of the House of Representatives’ Construction Committee, 3 Jun. 1954, 3 and 6.

86 Minutes of the Metropolitan Assembly meeting, 30 Jun. 1954, 334–5.

87 Yomiuri, Shitamachiban, 7 Sep. 1954.

88 Marunouchi Times, 14 Jul., 4 and 18 Aug. 1954.

89 Yomiuri, 6 Aug. 1954.

90 Asahi and Yomiuri, evening edition, 2 Oct. 1954.

91 Marunouchi Times, 20 Oct. 1954.

92 Minutes of the House of Representatives’ Local Government Committee, 10 Nov. 1954, 1–4.

93 Shinso, 5 Jan. 1951, 29.

94 Tosei Shinpo, 9 Oct. 1953.

95 Tosei Shinpo, 27 Nov. 1953.

96 Asahi, 11 Jun. 1959.

97 Minutes of the House of Representatives’ Construction Committee, 4 Dec. 1953, 8.

98 Minutes of the House of Representatives’ Construction Committee, 7 Apr. 1949, 9–10.

99 Minutes of the Subcommittee on State-owned Property of the House of Representatives’ Audit Committee, 7 May and 6 and 9 Sep. 1956; minutes of the House of Representatives’ Construction Committee, 6 Apr. 1959.

100 Mainichi Shimbun, Tonaichuoban, 8 Feb. 1954.

101 Tosei Shinpo, 25 Mar. 1955.

102 Asahi, evening edition, 9 Dec. 1968.

103 Sensaifukkoshihenshuiinkai (ed.), Sensaifukkoshi (Nagoya, 1984), 36 and 40.

104 J. Tabuchi, ‘Eidan ga unda Shin Nagoya’ (Resolution that produced a new Nagoya), Bungei Shunju (Apr. 1961), 144 and 147.

105 For recent studies, see Brayshay, M. and Essex, S., ‘Boldness diminished?’ Urban History, 35 (2008), 437–61Google Scholar; Hasegawa, J., ‘The attitudes of the Ministry of Town and Country Planning towards blitzed cities in 1940s Britain’, Planning Perspectives, 28 (2013), 271–89CrossRefGoogle Scholar.