Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-j824f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-05T15:25:56.378Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Suburban growth in Adelaide, South Australia, 1850–1930: speculation and economic opportunity

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 August 2016

MICHAEL MCGREEVY
MICHAEL MCGREEVY*
Affiliation:
6/13 St Annes Terrace, Glenelg North SA 5045, Australia
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Suburbs are significant to any understanding of Australian urbanization as they have been the dominant organizational element in the morphology of metropolitan areas. A case-study of suburban growth in Adelaide, South Australia, in the period from 1850 to 1930 suggests that dominant accounts of Australian suburbs of the era, as places of tranquillity, leisure, home and family, whose growth was driven by aspiration and social mobility, are largely illusory. Suburban growth was instead driven by speculation and economic opportunity. Accounts of commercial, recreational and industrial activity in Adelaide's suburban municipalities of the time suggests economically and socially diverse communities. Whereas the desire for the quarter or half acre block in the suburbs was most often due to its productive potential rather than bourgeois aspirations for seclusion and semi-rural tranquillity.

Type
Research Article
Information
Urban History , Volume 44 , Issue 2 , May 2017 , pp. 208 - 230
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2016 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Davison, G., ‘Australia: the first suburban nation?’ Journal of Urban History, 22 (1995), 40–74 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Alonso, W., Problems, Purposes and Implicit Policies for a National Strategy of Urbanization (Berkeley, 1971), 1–33 Google Scholar.

3 Fishman, R., Bourgeois Utopias: The Rise of Suburbia (New York, 1987), 3–17 Google Scholar; Jackson, K.T., The Crabgrass Frontier (New York, 1985), 20–44 Google Scholar.

4 Fishman, Bourgeois Utopias, 134–54; Jackson, The Crabgrass Frontier, 87–137; Warner, S.B., The Urban Wilderness: A History of the American City (New York, 1972), 199–222 Google Scholar.

5 Fishman, Bourgeois Utopias, 182–207.

6 Ibid ., 3–17; Reiger, K., The Disenchantment of the Home (Melbourne, 1985), 56–82 Google Scholar.

7 Jackson, The Crabgrass Frontier, 45–86; Marsh, M., ‘Suburban men and masculine domesticity, 1870–1915’, in Nicolaides, B. and Wiese, A. (eds.), The Suburb Reader (New York, 2006), 63–8Google Scholar.

8 Fishman, Bourgeois Utopias, 3–17.

9 Harris, R. and Lewis, R., ‘The geography of North American cities and suburbs, 1900–1950: a new synthesis’, Journal of Urban History, 27 (2001), 262–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar; McManus, R. and Ethington, P., ‘Suburbs in transition: new approaches to suburban history’, Urban History, 34 (2007), 317–37CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

10 Harris, R. and Lewis, R., ‘Constructing a faulty zone: misrepresentations of American cities and suburbs, 1900–1950’, Annals of American Geographers, 88 (1998), 622–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 Gordon, D., ‘Capitalist development and the history of American cities’, in Tabb, W. and Sawers, L. (eds.), Marxism and the Metropolis: New Perspectives in Urban Political Economy (New York, 1978), 25–63 Google Scholar; Harris and Lewis, ‘Constructing a faulty zone’, 622–39.

12 Fogleson, R., Bourgeois Nightmares: Suburbia 1870–1930 (New Haven, 2005), 26–33 Google Scholar.

13 Davison, G., ‘Colonial origins of the Australian home’, in Troy, P. (ed.), European Housing in Australia (Melbourne, 2000), 6–18 Google Scholar.

14 Davison, G., ‘The past and future of the Australian suburb’, in Johnson, L. (ed.), Suburban Dreaming: An Interdisciplinary Approach to Australian Cities (Geelong, 1994), 99–113 Google Scholar; Frost, L., Australian Cities in Comparative View (Melbourne, 1990)Google Scholar; Archer, J., The Great Australian Dream: The History of the Australian House (Melbourne, 1996)Google Scholar; Leach, R., Whatever Happened to Urban Policy? A Comparative Study of Urban Policy in Australia, Canada and the United States (Canberra, 1985)Google Scholar; Glynn, S., Urbanisation in Australian History (Melbourne, 1970)Google Scholar; McCarty, J., ‘Introduction’, in McCarty, J. and Schedvin, C. (eds.), Australian Capital Cities: Historical Essays (Sydney, 1978), 1–9 Google Scholar; Maher, C., Australian Cities in Transition (Melbourne, 1982), 2–22 Google Scholar.

15 Cannon, M., Australia in the Victorian Age: Life in the Cities (Melbourne, 1975), 264–70Google Scholar; Mayne, A., ‘A just war: the language of slum representation in twentieth-century Australia’, Journal of Urban History, 22 (1995), 7–99 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Sumerling, P., ‘Adelaide's West End’, in Dickey, B. (ed.), William Shakespeare's Adelaide 1860–1930 (Adelaide, 1992), 27–34 Google Scholar.

16 Howe, R., ‘Inner suburbs: from slums to gentrification’, in Johnson (ed.), Suburban Dreaming, 152–3Google Scholar; McCalman, J., ‘Private life in the garden suburbs between the wars or what will people say’, in Davison, G., Dingle, A. and O'Hanlon, S. (eds.), The Cream Brick Frontier: Histories of Australian Suburbia (Melbourne, 1995), 51–61 Google Scholar; Cannon, Australia in the Victorian Age, 218–20.

17 Frost, L. and O'Hanlon, S., ‘Urban history and the future of Australian cities’, Australian Economic History Review, 49 (2009), 1–18 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

18 Davison, ‘The past and future of the Australian suburb’, 99–113.

19 Davison, ‘Australia: the first suburban nation?’, 40–74.

20 Mullins, P., ‘Is Australian urbanization different’, in Najman, J. and Western, J. (eds.), A Sociology of Australian Society: Introductory Readings (Melbourne, 1991), 142 Google Scholar.

21 Howe, ‘Inner suburbs’, 142.

22 G. Mitchell, ‘The industry time forgot’, in Troy (ed.), European Housing in Australia, 77–85; P. Spearitt, ‘Suburban cathedrals: the rise of the drive in shopping centre’, in Davison, Dingle and O'Hanlon (eds.), The Cream Brick Frontier, 88–107; Spearitt, P. and Young, J., ‘Life and death on the strip’, in Dingle, A. (ed.), The Australian City: Future, Past, Proceedings of the 3rd Annual Planning and Urban History, Conference (Adelaide, 1996), 251–7Google Scholar; M. Williams, ‘The making of Adelaide’, in McCarty and Schedvin (eds.), Australian Capital Cities, 112–43; Morrow, D., ‘“Forging ahead”: industry and environmental transformation in a Melbourne suburb 1906–85’, Australian Economic History Review, 52 (2012), 148–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Burnley, I., The Australian Urban System: Growth, Change and Differentiation (Melbourne, 1980), 20–66 Google Scholar; I. Turner, ‘The growth of Melbourne’, in McCarty and Schedvin (eds.), Australian Capital Cities, 62–81.

23 Davison, G., ‘The suburban idea and its enemies’, Journal of Urban History, 39 (2013), 842 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

24 Mullins, ‘Is Australian urbanization different’; O'Hanlon, S., ‘Cities, suburbs and communities’, in Lyons, M. and Russell, P. (eds.), Australian History: Themes and Debates (Sydney, 2005), 172–89Google Scholar.

25 Frost, Australian Cities in Comparative View, 30–57.

26 Ibid ., 40–57.

27 Frost, L., The New Urban Frontier: Urbanization and City Building in Australia and the American West (Sydney, 1991), 22–35 Google Scholar.

28 P. Mullins and C. Kynaston, ‘The household production of subsistence: the urban peasantry thesis reassessed’, in Troy (ed.), European Housing in Australia, 142–63; Mullins, ‘Is Australian urbanization different’, 172–89.

29 Frost, Australian Cities in Comparative View, 49–50.

30 Whitelock, D., Adelaide 1836–1976: A History of Difference (Queensland, 1977), 22–4Google Scholar.

31 Williams, ‘The making of Adelaide’, 112–43.

32 Sinclair, W., ‘Urban booms in nineteenth-century Australia: Adelaide and Melbourne’, Journal of the Historical Society of South Australia, 10 (1982), 3–15 Google Scholar.

33 Ibid ., 3–15; Williams, M., The Making of the South Australian Landscape: A Study in the Historical Geography of South Australia (London, 1974), 450–7Google Scholar.

34 The Mail, land price data gathered from numerous editions, Adelaide (1910–28); the Advertiser, land price data gathered from various editions, Adelaide (1880 to 1931); Whitelock, Adelaide 1836–1976, 173–4; Donovan, P., Between the City and the Sea: A History of West Torrens from Settlement to the Present Day (Netley, 1986), 41–50 Google Scholar; Blackett, J., History of Unley and Goodwood (Adelaide, 1934), 20–30 Google Scholar.

35 L. Frost, ‘Connections’, in Troy (ed.), European Housing in Australia, 182–7.

36 Australian Bureau of Statistics, Census: Census: Part XXI, South Australia: Dwellings in Local Government Areas (Canberra, 1921), 1636–8; Australian Bureau of Statistics, Census: Part XXIII, Analysis of Dwellings in Local Government Areas, South Australia (Canberra, 1947), 1806–7.

37 Linn, R., Those Turbulent Years: A History of the City of Adelaide 1929–79 (Adelaide, 2006), 98 Google Scholar.

38 Sumerling, ‘Adelaide's West End’, 33–4; Whitelock, Adelaide 1836–1976, 159–230; Government of South Australia 1986, Atlas of South Australia, Adelaide, www.atlas.sa.gov.au/resources/atlas-of-south-australia-1986/the-course-of-settlement/adelaide, accessed Oct. 2015.

39 Pikusa, S., The Adelaide House 1836–1901 (Adelaide, 1986), 55–8Google Scholar.

40 Blackett, History of Unley and Goodwood; Blackburn, M., The Hundred Years History of Kensington and Norwood (Adelaide, 1953)Google Scholar; Brown, T., Glenelg: An Urban Village 1836–1972 (Adelaide 1973)Google Scholar; City of Hindmarsh, Hindmarsh Oral History Project (Adelaide, 1980); City of Prospect, Recollections of Prospect: Oral History of the Early Decades of the Twentieth Century (Adelaide, 1986); Couper-Smartt, J., Walk around Corners: Port Adelaide (Adelaide, 2005)Google Scholar; Gooden, G. and Moore, T., Fifty Years History of the Town of Kensington and Norwood (Adelaide, 1903)Google Scholar; Davey, I., ‘Growing up in South Australia’, in Richards, Eric (ed.), The Flinders History of South Australia (Adelaide, 1982), 371–402 Google Scholar; Donovan, Between the City and the Sea; Lewis, J., Enfield and the Northern Villages (Adelaide, 1985)Google Scholar; Lamshed, M., Prospect 1872–1972: A Portrait of a City (Adelaide, 1972)Google Scholar; Marles, M., A Pictorial History of West Torrens (Adelaide, 1980)Google Scholar; S. Marsden, ‘Oral history in South Australia’, in Richards (ed.), The Flinders History of South Australia, 475–83; Marsden, S., A History of Woodville (Adelaide, 1977)Google Scholar; Murphy, C., Starrs, J. and Bruce, S., Of Ships, Strikes, and Summer Nights: Oral Histories from the Port Adelaide Community (Adelaide, 1991)Google Scholar; Naughan, J. and Praite, R., Whistler's Unley Then and Now (Adelaide, 1988)Google Scholar; Parsons, R., Hindmarsh Town (Adelaide, 1974)Google Scholar; Pascoe, J., History of Adelaide and Vicinity (Adelaide, 1901)Google Scholar; Payne, P., Thebarton Old and New (Adelaide, 1996)Google Scholar; Payne, P., History of Unley 1871–1971 (Adelaide, 1972)Google Scholar; Payne, P. ‘Living in Prospect’, in Richards (ed.), The Flinders History of South Australia, 177–82Google Scholar; Perry, D., The Place of the Waters: A Story of Glenelg's First Fifty Years (Adelaide, 1985)Google Scholar; Scales, M., John Walkers Village (Adelaide, 1974)Google Scholar; Warburton, E., Speaking of the Past: Voices of the Past (Adelaide, 1986)Google Scholar; Warburton, E., St Peters: A Suburban Town (Adelaide, 1983)Google Scholar.

41 Scales, John Walkers Village, 109–15.

42 Warburton, St Peters: A Suburban Town, 100–51.

43 Blackburn, The Hundred Years History of Kensington and Norwood, 42–50.

44 Warburton, Speaking of the Past: Voices of the Past, 11–46.

45 Blackburn, The Hundred Years History of Kensington and Norwood, 42–50; Blackett, History of Unley and Goodwood, 20–30; Brown, Glenelg, 29–61; City of Prospect, Recollections of Prospect; Couper-Smartt, Walk around Corners, 13–130; Davey, ‘Growing up in South Australia’, 371–402; Donovan, Between the City and the Sea, 105–36; Lamshed, Prospect 1872–1972, 33–60; Marsden, A History of Woodville, 106–18; Murphy, Starrs and Bruce, Of Ships, Strikes, and Summer Nights, 1–65; Parsons, Hindmarsh Town, 216; Payne, History of Unley 1871–1971, 344–60; Payne, ‘Living in Prospect’, 177–82; Payne, Thebarton Old and New, 63–154; Perry, The Place of the Waters, 51–72; Scales, John Walkers Village, 109–21; Warburton, St Peters: A Suburban Town, 100–36; Warburton, Speaking of the Past: Voices of the Past, 11–46.

46 Blackburn, The Hundred Years History of Kensington and Norwood, 42–50; Payne, Thebarton Old and New, 138.

47 Couper-Smartt, Walk around Corners, 13–20.

48 Town Planning Committee, Report on the Metropolitan Area of Adelaide (Adelaide, 1962), 165–6.

49 Vamplew, W., ‘Sport: more than fun and games’, in Richards (ed.), The Flinders History of South Australia, 439 Google Scholar; Rafferty, J., ‘God's gift or demon drink: churches and alcohol in South Australia between the two world wars’, Journal of the Historical Society of South Australia, 15 (1987), 16–41 Google Scholar; Payne, History of Unley 1871–1971, 344–60; Payne, ‘Living in Prospect’, 177–82; Payne, Thebarton Old and New, 63–154; Scales, John Walkers Village, 56–71; Murphy, Starrs and Bruce, Of Ships, Strikes, and Summer Nights, 1–65; Painter, A., ‘Hotels and drinking’, in Dickey (ed.), William Shakespeare's Adelaide, 87–105 Google Scholar; Hilliard, D., ‘The city of churches’, in Dickey (ed.), William Shakespeare's Adelaide, 61–86 Google Scholar.

50 T. Smith, ‘Sport and pastimes’, in Richards (ed.), The Centenary History of South Australia, 369–77.

51 Frost, The New Urban Frontier, 96.

52 Appendix A, in Richards (ed.), The Centenary History of South Australia, 395.

53 Williams, The Making of the South Australian Landscape, 427.

54 Frost, Australian Cities in Comparative View, 40–57.

55 Australian Bureau of Statistics, Census: Part IV, South Australia: Analysis of Population in Local Government Areas (Canberra, 1933), 421–7.

56 Whitelock, Adelaide 1836–1976, 199–201; Pikusa, The Adelaide House 1836–1901, 55–8.

57 Advertiser, data gathered from various editions, Adelaide (1880–1931); Whitelock, Adelaide 1836–1976, 173–4.

58 Australian Bureau of Statistics, Census: Part XXI, South Australia: Dwellings in Local Government Areas (Canberra, 1921), 1636–8.

59 Advertiser, comparative data gathered from various editions from Adelaide (1880–1931); Mail, comparative data gathered from various editions Adelaide (1920–31).

60 Blackett, History of Unley and Goodwood, 20–30.

61 Pikusa, The Adelaide House 1836–1901, 55–91; Whitelock, Adelaide 1836–1976, 178–80.

62 Anthony Dingle, ‘Necessity the mother of invention, or do it yourself’, in Troy (ed.), European Housing in Australia, 57–66.

63 M. Lewis, ‘Making do’, in Troy (ed.), European Housing in Australia, 41–57; Davison, ‘Colonial origins of the Australian home’, 6–18.

64 Advertiser, comparative data gathered from various editions, Adelaide (1880–1931); Mail, comparative data gathered various editions, Adelaide (1920–31).

65 de Vries, J., The Industrious Revolution (New York, 2008), 218–37CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

66 Nicolaides, B., My Blue Heaven (Chicago, 2002), 18 Google Scholar.

67 Parr, J., Gender of Breadwinners (Toronto, 1990), 190–2Google Scholar.

68 De Vries, The Industrious Revolution, 218–20.

69 Gaynor, A., Harvest of the Suburbs (Perth, 2006), 1–67 Google Scholar.

70 Mullins and Kynaston, ‘The household production of subsistence’, 142–3.

71 Frost, ‘Connections’, 182–7.

72 Australian Bureau of Statistics, Census: Part XIII, South Australia Population of Local Government Areas (Canberra, 1921), 996–1003.

73 Strawhan, P., ‘Growing up in Playford's South Australia: a personal reminisce’, in O'Neil, B., Raferty, J. and Round, K. (eds.), Playford's South Australia: Essays on the History of South Australia, 1933–1968 (Adelaide, 1992), 7–13 Google Scholar; Marsden, A History of Woodville, 160.

74 Whitelock, Adelaide 1836–1976, 173–4.

75 Marsden, ‘Oral history in South Australia’.

76 Blackburn, The Hundred Years History of Kensington and Norwood, 42–50; Blackett, History of Unley and Goodwood, 20–30; Brown, Glenelg, 29–61; Lamshed, Prospect 1872–1972, 33–60; Marsden, A History of Woodville, 106–18; Murphy, Starrs and Bruce, Of Ships, Strikes, and Summer Nights, 1–65; Parsons, Hindmarsh Town, 115–269; Payne, History of Unley 1871–1971, 344–60; Payne, ‘Living in Prospect’, 177–82; Payne, Thebarton Old and New, 63–154; Perry, The Place of the Waters, 51–72; Scales, John Walkers Village, 56–71; Warburton, St Peters: A Suburban Town, 97–8; Warburton, Speaking of the Past: Voices of the Past, 11–46; City of Hindmarsh, Hindmarsh Oral History Project.

77 ‘Central Board of Health’, Advertiser, Adelaide, 20 Aug. 1891, 7: Perry, The Place of the Waters, 51–72.

78 ‘The helpful hen’, Advertiser, Adelaide, 16 Nov. 1923, 11.

79 ‘Metropolitan milk supply’, Advertiser, Adelaide, 5 Jul. 1907, 9.

80 Warburton, St Peters: A Suburban Town, 118.

81 Observer, Adelaide, 15 Nov. 1884, 12.

82 ‘Unley dairies’, Advertiser, Adelaide, 29 Apr. 1930, 16; ‘In the dirty dairies, milk and mud, filthy conditions prevailing’, Advertiser, Adelaide, 24 Dec. 1907, 9; ‘Central Board of Health’, Advertiser, Adelaide, 20 Aug. 1891, 7.

83 ‘The suburban half acre’, Mail, all editions, Adelaide (1901–31).

84 Blackburn, The Hundred Years History of Kensington and Norwood, 42–50; Blackett, History of Unley and Goodwood, 20–30; City of Prospect, Recollections of Prospect; Couper-Smartt, Walk around Corners, 13–130; Lamshed, Prospect 1872–1972, 33–60; Marsden, A History of Woodville, 106–18; Marsden, ‘Oral histories in South Australia’, 475–83; Murphy, Starrs and Bruce, Of Ships, Strikes, and Summer Nights, 1–65; Parsons, Hindmarsh Town, 115–69; Payne, History of Unley 1871–1971, 344–60; Payne, ‘Living in Prospect’, 177–82; Payne, Thebarton Old and New, 63–154; Perry, The Place of the Waters, 105–36; Scales, John Walkers Village, 56–71; Warburton; Speaking of the Past: Voices of the Past, 34–46; City of Hindmarsh, Hindmarsh Oral History Project.

85 ‘Backyard gardening: does it pay?’, Mail, Adelaide, 12 Apr. 1913, 10.

86 Parsons, Hindmarsh Town, 250–2.

87 Blackburn, The Hundred Years History of Kensington and Norwood, 42–50; Warburton, St Peters: A Suburban Town, 80–98; City of Hindmarsh, Hindmarsh Oral History Project.

88 Blackburn, The Hundred Years History of Kensington and Norwood, 42–50; Blackett, History of Unley and Goodwood, 20–30; City of Prospect, Recollections of Prospect; Couper-Smartt, Walk around Corners; Davey, ‘Growing up in South Australia’, 371–402; Lamshed, Prospect 1872–1972, 33–60; Marsden, A History of Woodville, 106–18; Marsden, ‘Oral histories in South Australia’, 475–83; Murphy, Starrs and Bruce, Of Ships, Strikes, and Summer Nights, 1–65; Parsons, Hindmarsh Town; Payne, History of Unley 1871–1971, 344–60; Payne, ‘Living in Prospect’, 177–82; Payne, Thebarton Old and New, 63–154; Perry, The Place of the Waters; Scales, John Walkers Village; Warburton, Speaking of the Past: Voices of the Past, 134–46; City of Hindmarsh, Hindmarsh Oral History Project; Painter, ‘Hotels and drinking’, 97.

89 ‘Carriage and wagon builders: meeting of the Association’, Advertiser, Adelaide, 15 Sep. 1913, 17.

90 B. Nicolaides ‘Introduction’, in Nicolaides and Wiese (eds.), The Suburb Reader, 99.