Hostname: page-component-5c6d5d7d68-qks25 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-08-26T11:09:57.490Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Robert Mylne, Thomas Telford and the architecture of improvement: the planned villages of the British Fisheries Society, 1786–1817

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 December 2007

DANIEL MAUDLIN
DANIEL MAUDLIN*
Affiliation:
School of Architecture and Design, University of Plymouth, Plymouth, PL4 8AA
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article examines the architecture and design of the pioneering planned fishing villages established by the British Fisheries Society across the Highlands of Scotland in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. The Society established a utilitarian planning model which fundamentally influenced the subsequent planned village boom that remains so evident in the historic landscape of the Scottish Highlands today. The British Fisheries Society also made a significant contribution to urban history with Thomas Telford's innovative plan for its last development of Pulteneytown. Pulteneytown remains the most complete example of Telford's work as a town planner.

Type
Research Article
Information
Urban History , Volume 34 , Issue 3 , December 2007 , pp. 453 - 480
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2007

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The primary documentary sources for the British Fisheries Society are the British Fisheries Society Papers (NAS/GD9) held by the National Archives of Scotland (gifted by the dukes of Argyll). A particular debt of gratitude is owed to Jean Dunlop's pioneering account of the political and economic history of the Society, The British Fisheries Society, 1786–1893 (Edinburgh, 1978). This paper is an architectural history and I direct anyone seeking a detailed account of the political and economic history of the British Fisheries Society towards her excellent book, reissued by Birlinn under the John Donald imprint in 2005.

2 Coull, J.R., The Sea Fisheries of Scotland: A Historical Geography (Edinburgh, 1996), 3Google Scholar.

3 Ibid., 69.

4 Dunlop, J., The British Fisheries Society, 1786–1893 (Edinburgh, 1978), 20–4Google Scholar.

5 Coull, The Sea Fisheries of Scotland, 75.

6 Devine, T.M., Clanship to Crofters' War (Manchester, 1994), 32Google Scholar; Macinnes, A., Clanship, Commerce and the House of Stewart, 1603–1788 (East Linton, 1996), 14Google Scholar.

7 Devine, Clanship to Crofters' War, 17.

8 Ibid., 34.

9 Richards, Eric, The Highland Clearances: People, Landlords and Rural Turmoil (Edinburgh, 2000), 108Google Scholar.

10 Such was the resistance to depopulation and emigration that Scottish landowners lobbied Henry Dundas, secretary of state for Scotland, to introduce a ban on emigration from Scottish ports in 1775, though the legislation had little practical effect. R.A. Dodgshon, From Chiefs to Landlords: Social and Economic Change in the Western Highlands, c. 1493–1820 (Edinburgh, 1998), 240.

11 Richards, Highland Clearances, 48.

12 Devine, Clanship to Crofters' War, 37; A. Mackillop, More Fruitful than the Soil: Army, Empire and the Scottish Highlands, 1715–1830 (East Linton, 2000), 83.

13 Richards, Highland Clearances, 43.

14 Youngson, A.J., After the '45 (Edinburgh, 1973), 37Google Scholar.

15 Turnock, D., The Making of the Scottish Rural Landscape (Aldershot, 1995), 229Google Scholar.

16 D. Lockhart, ‘Planned villages in north east Scotland, 1750–1860’, in J. Frew and D. Jones (eds.), The New Town Phenomenon: The Second Generation, St Andrews Studies in the History of Scottish Architecture and Design IV (St Andrews, 2000), 25.

17 Lockhart, D., ‘Planned village development in Scotland and Ireland, 1700–1800’, in Devine, T.M. and Dickson, D. (eds.), Ireland and Scotland 1600–1850 (Edinburgh, 1983), 133Google Scholar.

18 Royal Commission on Ancient and Historic Monuments of Scotland (RCAHMS), Inventory of Argyll, 7 (Edinburgh, 1994), 440.

19 McWilliam, C., Scottish Townscape (London, 1975), 92Google Scholar.

20 Reid, R., The Georgian House and its Details (Bath, 1989), 75Google Scholar.

21 Macinnes, Clanship, Commerce and the House of Stewart, 211.

22 Lockhart, ‘Planned villages in north east Scotland’, 25–7.

23 Kostof, S., The City Shaped: Urban Patterns and Meanings through History (London, 1991), 15Google Scholar.

24 Adams, I.H., Peter May, Land Surveyor, 1749–1793 (Edinburgh, 1979), 12–37Google Scholar.

25 NAS/GD248/242; Woolmer, H., ‘Grantown-on-Spey: an eighteenth century New Town’, Town Planning Review, 41 (1970), 239CrossRefGoogle Scholar. There were also many smaller villages such as Joseph Cumine of Auchry's Cuminestown, Aberdeenshire, 1765; Urquhart, Morayshire; Longmanhill, Banffshire; Fetterangus, Longside; and New Deer, St Fergus and Mintlaw, Aberdeenshire. See Lockhart, ‘Planned villages in north east Scotland’, 30–1.

26 Adams, Peter May, Land Surveyor, 12–37.

27 Macinnes, Clanship, Commerce and the House of Stewart, 217–19.

28 Clyde, R., From Rebel to Hero: The Image of the Highlander, 1745–1830 (East Linton, 1995), 23Google Scholar.

29 NAS/E730/32. Papers of the Board of Commissioners of Annexed and Forfeited Estates, 1771.

30 McWilliam, Scottish Townscape, 99; Allen, N., ‘Highland planned villages’, Highland Vernacular Building, SVBWG (Edinburgh, 1989), 28Google Scholar.

31 Smith, A., Jacobite Estates of the Forty-Five (Edinburgh, 1982), 145Google Scholar.

32 Ibid., 148.

33 Ibid., 154.

34 NAS/RHP/2312; NAS/E777/313/290; McWilliam, Scottish Townscape, 99.

35 Macinnes, Clanship, Commerce and the House of Stewart, 218–20; John Knox, A Discourse on the Expediency of Establishing Fishing Stations in the Highlands of Scotland, 1786 (NAS: GD9/1/1).

36 Mackillop, More Fruitful than the Soil, 190–5.

37 Clyde, From Rebel to Hero, 22.

38 Macinnes, Clanship, Commerce and the House of Stewart, 195.

39 NAS/GD9/3/49.

40 NAS/GD9/3/28–30.

41 Dunlop, The British Fisheries Society, 89.

42 NAS/GD9/3/32.

43 NAS/GD9/3/200.

44 Survey and Report on the Coasts and Central Highlands of Scotland. Made by the Command of the Right Honourable the Lords Commissioners of His Majesty's Treasury, in the Autumn of 1802, Thomas Telford, civil engineer, Edin. FRS. Cited in Smiles, S., The Life of Thomas Telford by Smiles (London, 1867), 144Google Scholar.

45 NAS/GD9/3/20; Mull Museum Archive (MMA); Edinburgh Evening Courant, 20 Feb. and 6 Mar. 1787; Edinburgh Evening Courant, Caledonian Mercury and Glasgow Mercury, Feb. and Mar. 1788.

46 NAS/GD9/3/95. Sir James Grant of Grant in a letter to the British Fisheries Society. Further information regarding the improving works of Sir James at Grantown-on-Spey can be found in Woolmer, ‘Grantown-on-Spey’, 238–45.

47 Beaton, E., ‘Building practices in Loch Broom and Gairloch parishes’, in Baldwin, J.R. (ed.), People and Settlements in North West Ross (Galloway, 1994), 159–93Google Scholar; Munro, J., ‘Ullapool and the British Fisheries Society’, in Baldwin (ed.), People and Settlements in North West Ross, 244–70Google Scholar; Beaton, E. and Stell, G., ‘Local building traditions in Ross and Cromarty’, in Omand, D. (ed.), The Ross and Cromarty Book (Golspie, 1984), 207Google Scholar; Beaton, E., Caithness: An Architectural Guide (Edinburgh, 1996), 36–44Google Scholar; Munro, J., ‘Pulteneytown and the planned villages of Caithness’, in Baldwin, J.R. (ed.), Caithness: A Cultural Crossroads (Edinburgh, 1982)Google Scholar; RCAHMS, Inventory of Argyll, 3 (Edinburgh, 1980), 236; A. Whitaker, ‘A walk around Tobermory’, Oban Times (1988), 20.

48 The fifth duke was chairman of the Society until 1800 but was relatively inactive after 1790 following the completion of the first two settlements.

49 Colvin, H.M., Autobiographical Dictionary of British Architects, 1600–1840, 3rd edn (London, 1995), 684Google Scholar.

50 Currie, J., Mull: The Island and its People (Edinburgh, 2000), 189Google Scholar.

51 Smiles, The Life of Thomas Telford, 101.

52 Kostof, The City Shaped, 240.

53 NAS/GD9/3/95; Woolmer, ‘Grantown-on-Spey’, 239.

54 NAS/GD9/3/38; NAS/GD9/4/213; MMA/3/2/7.

55 MMA/3/2/2; RCAHMS, Inventory of Argyll, 3 (Edinburgh, 1980), 236.

56 Adams, Peter May, Land Surveyor, 18. Aitken rejected May's plan for Ullapool drawn up for the Annexed Estates Commission (NAS/RHP/3400), A Survey and Design for a Village at Ullapool, Peter May for the Annexed Estates Commission, 1756.

57 NAS/GD9/3/616.

58 NAS/GD9/3/617.

59 Allen, ‘Highland planned villages’, 40–9.

60 Other examples: Plockton, Lochalsh, Ross-shire, founded by Mackenzie of Seaforth, 1801, plan by William Cumming; Poolewe, Gairloch, Ross-shire, founded by Mackenzie of Gairloch, 1808; Golspie, Sutherland, duke of Sutherland, plan by David Wilson, 1805; and Helmsdale, Sutherland, duke of Sutherland, plan by William Forbes, 1816.

61 NAS/GD9/3/448; NAS/GD9/3/553.

62 Telford, T., Atlas to the Life of Thomas Telford by Himself (London, 1838)CrossRefGoogle Scholar. None of Telford's subsequent biographies shed any light upon Telford's urban design and design influences. Smiles, The Life of Thomas Telford; Alexander Gibbs, The Story of Telford (London, 1935); and Rolt, L.T.C., Thomas Telford (London, 1958)Google Scholar. It has to be concluded that neither Telford in later life nor his biographers considered his town planning to be of much significance when set against his great civil engineering works.

63 King, D., The Complete Works of Robert and James Adam (Oxford, 1991), 385Google Scholar. Planned villages incorporating crescents and semicircles had also been attempted in Scotland, such as Lord Garlies' crescent-plan for Garliestown, Wigtownshire, 1760.

64 Smiles, The Life of Thomas Telford, 113.

65 Stilman, D., English Neo-Classical Architecture (London, 1988), 236Google Scholar.

66 Downes, K., The Georgian Cities of Britain (Oxford, 1979), 120Google Scholar.

67 NAS/GD9/7/264.

68 NAS/GD9/14/128/9/11/10.

69 Colvin, Biographical Dictionary, 97.

70 Smiles, The Life of Thomas Telford, 113.

71 Thomas Telford, letter to Andrew Little, 10 Mar. 1793. Cited in Rolt, Thomas Telford, 24–5.

72 The industrial theme was lost when later changed to Saltoune Terrace, Telford St, and Burn St.

73 Thomas Telford, Thomas Telford by Himself (London, 1838), 115–20.

74 NAS/GD9/59; NAS/GD9/248/29/4/89; NAS/GD9/334/16/11/91.

75 NAS/GD9/3/183; NAS/GD9/8/119. Robert Melville was a bankrupt fishing agent from Dunbar, East Lothian, who persuaded the Board of Directors to grant him the majority of the contracts for Ullapool. Melville employed James Miller, a minor Edinburgh architect, to produce the plans for his various contracted buildings at Ullapool. Anon., Plan of Harbour and Breakwater, 1854 (NAS/RHP/4286).

76 NAS/GD9/10, 45; NAS/GD9/1/164; NAS/GD9/21/28.5.92; NAS/GD9/9/13; NAS/GD9/22/9.5.01. William Mackenzie, Sketch of the Pier at Stein in the Island of Skye, 1807 (NAS/RHP/11800).

77 NAS/GD9/21/18.7.91.

78 Smiles, The Life of Thomas Telford, 154.

79 Telford, ‘Harbours, wharfs and piers’, in Telford, Thomas Telford by Himself; RCAMHS/NMRS/XSD/158/1. Other examples of Highland Road and Bridge Commission harbours include: Avoch Harbour, Ballintraed Harbour, Banff Harbour, Burgh-Head Harbour, Channery Point Ferry Pier, Corran Ferry Pier, Cullen Harbour, Dornie Ferry, East Tarbet Harbour, Feoline Harbour, Fortrose Harbour, Fraserburgh Harbour, Gordon Harbour, Inverfarigaig Landing Pier, Invergordon Ferry Pier, Kirkwall Harbour, Kyle Ferry Pier, Nairn Harbour, Peterhead Harbour, Portmahomack Harbour, Portree Harbour, Small Isles Harbour, St Catherine's Ferry Pier and Tobermory Harbour Pier.

80 NAS/GD9/3/144.

81 RCAHMS, Inventory of Argyll, 7 (Edinburgh, 1994), 443.

82 Samuel, Johnson, A Journey to the Western Islands of Scotland (London, 1775), 140Google Scholar.

83 Maudlin, D., ‘Robert Mylne at Pitlour House’, Architectural Heritage, 12 (2001), 27–37CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

84 NAS/GD9/3/553; NAS/GD9/4/248; NAS/GD9/162; RCAHMS, Inventory of Argyll, 3 (Edinburgh, 1980), 237. An 1812 sketch of the harbour front at Tobermory by William Daniel shows the inn completed according to Mylne's design. However, the inn was subsequently extended and latterly converted into a supermarket.

85 Gaskell, P., Morvern Transformed: A Highland Parish in the Nineteenth Century (Cambridge, 1968), 244CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Maudlin, D., ‘Tradition and change: a study of Argyll tacksmen's houses in Morvern’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland, 133 (Edinburgh, 2004), 1–16Google Scholar.

86 NAS/SRO/GD9/4/76.

87 NAS/GD9/3/140–7.

88 NAS/GD9/3/593; NAS/SRO/GD9/3/627.

89 NAS/GD9/3/144.

90 NAS/GD9/289/21.5.08.

91 NAS/GD9/289/14/05/08.

92 Several of the merchants and curers that took up leases at Pulteneytown were from Leith.

93 NAS/GD9/4/113.

94 NAS/GD9/3/177.

95 NAS/GD9/3/441.

96 NAS/GD9/3/57; NAS/GD9/3/553.

97 NAS/GD9/3/607.

98 Hume, J., The Industrial Archaeology of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1967), 33Google Scholar.

99 Girouard, M., The English Town (London, 1990), 94Google Scholar.

100 Maudlin, D., ‘Regulating the vernacular: the impact of building regulations in the eighteenth century planned village’, Vernacular Architecture, 35 (2004), 40–9CrossRefGoogle Scholar

101 Colvin, Biographical Dictionary, 1072–5.

102 NAS/GD9/100/1/7/91.

103 King, Complete Works of Robert and James Adam, 385.

104 NAS/RHP/11798.