Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-fbnjt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-18T02:22:15.009Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The political motivations for the reform of urban policy during the rapid economic growth period in Japan: a closer look

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 December 2019

Junichi Hasegawa
Junichi Hasegawa*
Affiliation:
Faculty of Economics, Keio University, 2–15–45 Mita, Minato-ku, Tokyo 108–8345, Japan
*
*Corresponding author. Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Urban policy in Japan gained greater significance in the late 1960s. In 1968, a new City Planning Law was enacted, and urban policy was a prominent issue in that year's House of Councillors election. Scholars have regarded the ruling conservative party's fear of a threat to its hegemony as the primary force driving this increased attention to urban policy. This article examines the political factors surrounding the reforms enacted, concluding that politicians actually underestimated the degree of public interest in urban policy and made largely empty political gestures to appease urban dwellers while responding more readily to agricultural interests.

Type
Research Article
Information
Urban History , Volume 48 , Issue 2 , May 2021 , pp. 364 - 379
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2019

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

†

I would like to thank Professor Simon Gunn and the two anonymous referees for their comments and suggestions, which have done much to improve this article.

References

1 For a general account of Japan's rapid economic growth, see Nakamura, T., The Postwar Japanese Economy, 2nd edn (Tokyo, 1995), 53–212Google Scholar.

2 Vogel, E., Japan's New Middle Class, 2nd edn (Berkeley and London, 1971)Google Scholar, especially 271–83.

3 Tipton, E.K., Modern Japan, 3rd edn (Abingdon and New York, 2016), 209–11Google Scholar.

4 On the development of environmental movements and politics in Japan, see McKean, M., Environmental Protest and Citizen Politics in Japan (Berkeley and London, 1981)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Broadbent, J., Environmental Politics in Japan: Networks of Power and Protest (Cambridge and New York, 1998)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Ishida, Y., Nihon Kindai Toshikeikaku no Hyakunen (Tokyo, 1987), 299–305Google Scholar.

6 Asahi Shimbun (Asahi), 1 Jan. 1965, 1, 17–19, 25 and 27.

7 On Ishida, see Watanabe, S., ‘The obituary of Professor Yorifusa Ishida (1932–2015): a pioneer of planning history in Japan’, Planning Perspectives, 32 (2017), 119–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8 Ishida, Nihon Kindai Toshikeikaku no Hyakunen, 295–9 (quotations on 297).

9 Sorensen, A., ‘The developmental state and extreme narrowness of the public realm: the twentieth-century evolution of Japanese planning culture’, in Sanyal, B. (ed.), Comparative Planning Cultures (New York and London, 2005), 223–58Google Scholar.

10 Smith, H.D., ‘Tokyo as an idea: an exploration of Japanese urban thought until 1945’, Journal of Japanese Studies, 4 (1978), 45–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 Ishida, Y., ‘Japanese cities and planning in the Reconstruction period: 1945–55’, in Hein, C., Diefendorf, J. and Ishida, Y. (eds.), Rebuilding Urban Japan after 1945 (Basingstoke and New York, 2003), 17–50Google Scholar; Tiratsoo, N., Matsumura, T., Mason, T. and Hasegawa, J., Urban Reconstruction in Britain and Japan, 1945–1955: Dreams, Plans and Realities (Luton, 2002)Google Scholar.

12 Ishida, Nihon Kindai Toshikeikaku no Hyakunen, 14, 303 and 315.

13 Calder, K., Crisis and Compensation (Princeton, 1988), 376–410Google Scholar (quotations on 378, 401, 406 and 408).

14 Hebbert, M., ‘Senbiki amidst desakota: urban sprawl and urban planning in Japan’, in Shapira, P., Masser, I. and Edgington, D.W. (eds.), Plans for Cities and Regions in Japan (Liverpool, 1994), 70–91Google Scholar. See also Hebbert, M. and Nakai, N., How Tokyo Grows: Land Development and Planning on the Metropolitan Fringe (London, 1988)Google Scholar.

15 Broadbent, Environmental Politics, 350.

16 Sorensen, A., The Making of Urban Japan: Cities and Planning from Edo to the Twenty-First Century (London, 2002), 200–13Google Scholar (quotations on 204, 207, 210, 212 and 213).

17 Hasegawa, J., ‘Drafting of the 1968 Japanese City Planning Law’, Planning Perspectives, 29 (2014), 231–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

18 Krauss, E. and Simcock, B., ‘Citizens’ movements: the growth and impact of environmental protest in Japan’, in Steiner, K., Krauss, E. and Flanagan, S. (eds.), Political Opposition and Local Politics in Japan (Princeton, 1980), 223Google Scholar; McKean, Environmental Protest and Citizen Politics, 263.

19 S. Flanagan, K. Steiner and E. Krauss, ‘The partisan politicization of local government: causes and consequences’, K. Steiner, ‘Progressive local administration: local public policy and local-national relations’, and G. Allinson, ‘Opposition in the suburbs’, in Steiner, Krauss and Flanagan (eds.), Political Opposition and Local Politics, 450–3, 350–2, and 96–7, respectively.

20 Garon, S., ‘From Meiji to Heisei: the state and civil society in Japan’, in Schwartz, F. and Pharr, S. (eds.), The State of Civil Society in Japan (Cambridge, 2003), 60–1Google Scholar; Avenell, S., Making Japanese Citizens (Berkeley and London, 2010), 191–4CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

21 Pekkanen, R., Japan's Dual Civil Society (Stanford, 2006), 8–10Google Scholar.

22 According to the Japanese Newspaper Annual 1970, the circulation figures for 1970 were 5,724,113 for Asahi, 4,628,733 for Mainichi and 5,431,438 for Yomiuri. See Nihonshimbunkyōkai, (ed.), Nihonshimbunnenkan Shōwa45nenban (Tokyo, 1970), 74, 103 and 112Google Scholar.

23 Outline of 24 Apr. 1967, in the National Archives of Japan (NAJ), Honkan-4A-030-00·Hei15Housei00385100.

24 ‘Toshikeikakuhōan’, dated 8 May 1967, 24–5, in NAJ, Honkan-4A-030-00·Hei15Housei00385100.

25 ‘Toshikeikakuhōan’, dated 14 Jun. 1967, 24–5, in NAJ, Honkan-4A-030-00·Hei15Housei00385100.

26 ‘Toshikeikakuhōan’, dated 14 Jul. 1967, 22–3, in NAJ, Honkan-4A-030-00·Hei15Housei00387100.

27 ‘Toshikeikakuhōan nitaisuru Kakushōchōtō no Iken no Gaiyō’, 2, in NAJ, Honkan-4A-030-00·Hei15Housei00385100.

28 Minutes of the House of Representatives Construction Committee (HRCC), 3 Apr. 1968, 20–8 (quotations on 27).

29 Minutes of the Joint Research Councils of the Construction Committee and the Agriculture, Forestry, and Fishery Committee of the House of Representatives, 18 Apr. 1968, and of the House of Councillors, 10 May 1968.

30 Minutes of the HRCC, 11 Apr. 1968, 7–8.

31 Minutes of the HRCC, 19 Apr. 1968, 4–9.

32 Minutes of the House of Representatives Plenary Session, 19 Apr. 1968, and of the House of Councillors Plenary Session, 17 May 1968.

33 Asahi, editorial, 14 Apr. 1968, 2; Mainichi, editorial, 17 Apr. 1968, 5.

34 Yomiuri, editorial, 20 May 1968, 2.

35 E.g. Asahi, editorials, 28 May 1968, 2, and 3 Jun. 1968, 2.

36 Asahi, 30 May 1968, 5.

37 Yomiuri, 20 Jun. 1968, 5.

38 Yomiuri, 10 Jun. 1968, 3; and Asahi, 14 Jun. 1968, 4.

39 Yomiuri, 20 Jun. 1968, 5. Also, Kiyoko Nishi, a commentator, stated that they had to ‘see if the parties’ housing pledges would be realized’ because they were ‘rather generous’ and thus ‘dubious’. Yomiuri, 10 Jun. 1968, 3.

40 Asahi, 28 Jun. 1968, 5.

41 Asahi, editorial, 1 Jul. 1968, 2.

42 Asahi, 12 Aug. 1968, 2, cited in Calder, Crisis and Compensation, 406.

43 Mainichi, 11 Dec. 1968, 19.

44 Yomiuri, 4 Dec. 1969, 7; see also Yomiuri, 26 Dec. 1969, 5.

45 Asahi, evening edition, 28 Dec. 1969, 3.

46 Asahi, 24 May 1971, 2.

47 E.g. Yomiuri, 3 Jun. 1971, 5.

48 Yomiuri, 15 Jun. 1971, 21.

49 Asahi, 28 Jun. 1971, 11.

50 Tanaka, K., Nihonrettō Kaizōron (Tokyo, 1972)Google Scholar.

51 See e.g. Asahi, 9 Aug. 1972, 2.

52 See a table of the parties’ election pledges in Yomiuri, 14 Nov. 1972, 4, and 9 Dec. 1972, 7.

53 Asahi, 29 Nov. 1972, 2.

54 Asahi, evening edition, 4 Dec. 1972, 2.

55 Asahi, 12 Dec. 1972, 22.

56 Yomiuri, evening edition, 14 Aug. 1970, 1.

57 Minutes of the House of Representatives Local Government Committee (HRLGC), 23 Feb. 1971, 16.

58 Yomiuri, 5 Mar. 1971, 1.

59 Minutes of the HRLGC, 9 Mar. 1971, 2–4 (quotations on 2 and 3).

60 Minutes of the HRLGC, 23 Feb. 1971, 4.

61 Yomiuri, 15 Feb. 1972, 2, 3 Mar. 1972, 2; and Asahi, evening edition, 9 Mar. 1972, 1.

62 Minutes of the HRLGC, 14 Mar. 1972, 29.

63 Minutes of the HRLGC, 16 Mar. 1972, 4–8.

64 Minutes of the HRLGC, 30 Mar. 1972, 8–9.

65 Asahi, 7 May 1972, 2.

66 Yomiuri, 23 Mar. 1973, 1.

67 Yomiuri, evening edition, 23 Mar. 1973, 1.

68 Asahi, 29 Mar. 1973, 1.

69 Minutes of the HRLGC, 27 Mar. 1973, 2–13.

70 Minutes of the HRLGC, 24 Apr. 1973, 5.

71 Asahi, 26 Apr. 1973, p. 2.

72 Minutes of the HRLGC, 24 Apr. 1973, 6.

73 Minutes of the House of Representatives Plenary Session, 9 May 1974, 1031; minutes of the House of Councillors Plenary Session, 27 May 1974, 772.

74 Minutes of the HRCC, 11 Apr. 1968, 4 and 9.

75 Ishida, Y., ‘Toshikeikaku no Seisakuketteikatei niokeru Jūminsanka’, in Gyōseigakkai, Nihon (ed.), Seisakukettei to Kōkyōsei (Tokyo, 1973), 174–214Google Scholar.

76 Asahi, 29 Dec. 1969, 14.

77 Yomiuri, 17 Dec. 1969, 1, and 20 Dec. 1969, 5.

78 Yomiuri, 13 Jun. 1971, 1 and 5.

79 Yomiuri, 6 May 1973, 6.

80 Asahi, editorial, 25 Feb. 1973, 5; Yomiuri, 30 Mar. 1973, 6, and 5 May 1973, 6.

81 Asahi, 24 Feb. 1973, 1.

82 Some local organizations of the Central Union of Agricultural Co-operatives threatened to work against the LDP in the 1969 House of Representatives elections over the issue of the producer's price of rice. In the end, the attempts ‘misfired’ and the LDP obtained 41, the largest number of candidates recommended by the Agricultural Co-operatives, followed by the JSP's 11, the Democratic Socialist party's 7 and one independent. Asahi, 11 Dec. 1969, 2.

83 Yomiuri, evening edition, 18 Jul. 1973.

84 Yomiuri, 24 Mar. 1973, 7.

85 Mainichi, editorial, 24 Mar. 1973, 5.

86 Mainichi, editorial, 2 Apr. 1973, 5.

87 Yomiuri, 13 Jun. 1971, 5.

88 Ishida, Y., Nihon Kingendai Toshikeikaku no Tenkai 1868–2003 (Tokyo, 2004), 245–6, 271–83Google Scholar and 315–26.