Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-g8jcs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-26T04:48:11.108Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The celebration, condemnation and reinterpretation of the Geddes plan, 1925: the dynamic planning history of Tel Aviv

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  19 December 2012

NOAH HYSLER RUBIN
NOAH HYSLER RUBIN*
Affiliation:
Bezalel Academy of Arts and Design, Jerusalem 91240, Israel
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract:

The article presents the short urban history of Tel Aviv as a case-study for critical readings in urban planning. Focusing on Patrick Geddes’ celebrated plan for the city (1925) and its various interpretations along the years, the main claim made in the article is that when present planners are confronted with a past which does not suit current needs, history is contested, or reinvented entirely. The appreciation of Geddes’ plan over the years always reflected the city's contemporary image and its planners’ attitudes, which initially reflected the pioneering spirits of the city's Zionist creation. The plan was later blamed for the city's deterioration; and finally celebrated again, alongside the city's new found architectural heritage and urban spirit.

Type
Eastern European Cities
Information
Urban History , Volume 40 , Issue 1 , February 2013 , pp. 114 - 135
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The International Planning History Society inaugurated in January 1993 and the Society for American City and Regional Planning History was founded in 1986. Both promote scholarship on the planning of cities and metropolitan regions over time, aiming to bridge the gap between study and practice.

2 AESOP 2009 Conference web page (last accessed 15 Mar. 2010) www.liv.ac.uk/aesop2009/theme.htm.

3 Lowenthal, D., The Past Is a Foreign Country (Cambridge, 1985), xvii.Google Scholar

4 Ibid.

5 Ibid., 25.

6 Beauregard, R.A., ‘Subversive histories: texts from South Africa’, in Sandercock, L. (ed.), Making the Invisible Visible: A Multicultural Planning History (Berkeley and London, 1998) 184–97Google Scholar; Muller, J., ‘Although God cannot alter the past, historians can: reflections on the writing of planning histories’, Planning History, 21 (2) (1999), 11–19Google Scholar; Sandercock, ‘Introduction’, in Sandercock (ed.), Making the Invisible Visible, 2–5.

7 I. Borden, J. Rendell and H. Thomas, ‘Knowing different cities: reflections on recent European writings on cities and planning history’, in Sandercock (ed.), Making the Invisible Visible, 135.

8 Sandercock (ed.), Making the Invisible Visible, 1.

9 Kruckeberg, D., ‘Planning history's mistakes’, Planning Perspectives, 12 (1997) 269–79CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Sandercock, L., Cosmopolis II: Mongrel Cities in the 21st Century (London and New York, 2003), 37Google Scholar

10 Krueckeberg, ‘Planning history's mistakes’; Muller, ‘Planning histories’, 11–13.

11 Sandercock, Cosmopolis, 39–40.

12 Lowenthal, Foreign Country, 26.

13 Marom, N., Ir im conceptsia: metachnenim et Tel Aviv (A City with a Concept: Planning Tel Aviv) (Tel Aviv, 2009), 9 (Hebrew).Google Scholar

14 Hysler-Rubin, N., ‘The changing appreciation of Patrick Geddes: a case study in planning history’, Planning Perspectives, 24 (2009), 349–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

15 Kallus, R., ‘Patrick Geddes and the evolution of a housing type in Tel Aviv’, Planning Perspectives, 12 (1997), 281–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

16 Shavit, Y. and Biger, G., Ha'historya shel Tel Aviv, vol. I: Leydata shel ir (1909–1936) (The History of Tel Aviv, vol. I: The Birth of a Town (1909–1936)) (Tel Aviv, 2001), 17–19Google Scholar.

17 Razi, T., Yaldei hahefker: hechatzer ha'achorit shel Tel Aviv hamandatorit (Forsaken Children: The Backyard of Mandatory Tel Aviv) (Tel Aviv, 2009), 126–7.Google Scholar

18 Weiss, A., Reshita shel Tel Aviv: Yissud ha'ir veyoman (The Beginning of Tel Aviv: City Foundations and a Journal) (Tel Aviv, 1957) pp. 84–5Google Scholar, quoted in Marom, City with a Concept, 12–13.

19 Razi, Forsaken Children, 126–7.

20 Azaryahu, M., Tel Aviv: ha'ir ha'amitit (Tel Aviv: Mythography of a City) (Beer Sheva, 2005), 63Google Scholar; Marom, City with a Concept, 13–15.

21 Ashworth, W., The Genesis of Modern British Town Planning: A Study in Economic and Social History of the Nineteenth Century (London, 1954)Google Scholar; Hall, P., Cities of Tomorrow: An Intellectual History of Urban Planning and Design in the Twentieth Century (Oxford, 1988)Google Scholar; idem, ‘The centenary of modern planning’, in Freestone, R. (ed.), Urban Planning in a Changing World: The Twentieth Century Experience (London, 2000), 20–39Google Scholar; Meller, H., Patrick Geddes: Social Evolutionist and City Planner (London, 1990)Google Scholar; idem, Towns, Plans and Society in Modern Britain, prepared for the Economic History Society (Cambridge, 1997).

22 Ferraro, G., Rieducazione alla Speranza: Patrick Geddes Planner in India, 1914–1924 (Reviving the Hope: Patrick Geddes Planner in India, 1914–1924) (Milan, 1998)Google Scholar; Welter, V.M. and Lawson, J. (eds.), The City after Patrick Geddes (Bern, 2000)Google Scholar; Welter, V.M., Biopolis: Patrick Geddes and the City of Life (Cambridge, MA, 2002)Google Scholar.

23 B. Hyman, ‘British planners in Palestine, 1918–1936’, unpublished University of London Ph.D. thesis, 1994; Hysler-Rubin, N., Patrick Geddes and Town Planning: A Critical View (Abingdon and New York, 2011)Google Scholar.

24 Kallus, ‘Housing type in Tel Aviv’, 289.

25 Hyman, ‘British planners’, 199–205.

26 Marom, City with a Concept, 84–6.

27 Kallus, ‘Housing type in Tel Aviv’, 295.

28 P. Geddes, ‘Town planning report – Tel Aviv – Jaffa’ (Tel Aviv, 1925).

29 Geddes, P., The Masque of Learning and its Many Meanings (Edinburgh, 1912)Google Scholar; idem, ‘Palestine in renewal’, Contemporary Review, 670 (1921), 481.

30 Geddes, ‘Tel Aviv report’, 58.

31 Hyman, ‘British planners’, 315.

32 Geddes, ‘Tel Aviv report’, 3–7.

33 Hashimshoni, Z., ‘Mishkenot ha'oni beTel Aviv’ (The Tel Aviv slums), Ariel Tel Aviv Usvivoteyha (Ariel Tel Aviv and its Sites), 48–9 (1987), 151.Google Scholar

34 Geddes, ‘Tel Aviv report’, 51–62.

35 Ibid., 56.

36 Ibid., 54.

37 Ibid., 27.

38 Ibid.

39 Kallus, ‘House type in Tel Aviv’, 297–300; Weill-Rochant, K., ‘Myths and buildings of Tel Aviv’, Bulletin du Centre de recherché français de Jerusalem, 12 (2003), 159Google Scholar; Marom, City with a Concept, 89; Biger, G., ‘A Scotsman in the first Hebrew city: Patrick Geddes and the 1926 town plan for Tel Aviv’, Scottish Geographical Magazine, 108 (1992), 7CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hyman, ‘British planners’, 225.

40 Kallus, ‘Housing type in Tel Aviv’, 295–8.

41 Yosskovitz, B., ‘ Tichnun vepituach Tel Aviv-Yaffo’ (Planning and development of Tel Aviv – Yaffo), Tichnun Svivati (Environmental Planning), 57 (1999), 60–4.Google Scholar

42 Kallus, ‘Housing type in Tel Aviv’, 314–15.

43 Marom, City with a Concept, 129–30.

44 Kallus, ‘Housing type in Tel Aviv’, 300.

45 Ibid., 314–15.

46 Hashimshoni, ‘The Tel Aviv slums’, 151.

47 Shavit, Y. and Biger, G., Ha'historya shel Tel Aviv, vol. II: Me'ir medina l'ir bemedina (1936–1952) (The History of Tel Aviv, vol. II: From a City-State to a City in a State (1936–1952)) (Tel Aviv, 2007), 139Google Scholar.

48 Marom, City with a Concept, 113–17; Shavit and Biger, City in a State, 166–7.

49 P. Abercrombie, ‘Report on visit to Israel’ (1952), Central Zionist Archives A175/200, quoted in Hyman, ‘British planners’, 225.

50 Hashimshoni, ‘The Tel Aviv slums’, 157–8; Mazor, A., ‘Megamot pituach beTel Aviv’ (Development trends in Tel Aviv), Ariel, 48–9 (1987), 98Google Scholar.

51 Shavit and Biger, City in a State, 160; Marom, City with a Concept, 186–8.

52 Marom, City with a Concept, 95–101.

53 Yosskovitz, ‘Planning and development of Tel Aviv’, 61.

54 Ibid.; Shavit and Biger, City in a State; Mazor, ‘Development trends in Tel Aviv’, 97–103; Marom, City with a Concept.

55 Marom, City with a Concept, 161–74, 186–9.

56 Hashimshoni, ‘The Tel Aviv slums’, 157–8.

57 Mazor, ‘Development trends in Tel Aviv’, 98.

58 Marom, City with a Concept, 260.

59 Shavit and Biger, The Birth of a Town, 33.

60 Kaiser, D.et al., Profil ha'ir: tochmit estrategit leTel Aviv – Yaffo (City Profile: Strategic Plan for Tel Aviv – Yaffo) (Tel Aviv, 2002), 24–5Google Scholar; Marom, City with a Concept, 263.

61 Mazor, ‘Development trends in Tel Aviv’, 99; Shavit and Biger, The Birth of a Town, 33.

62 Vizaltir, M., ‘Yesh li sympatya’ (I have sympathy), in Mashehu optimi, ktivat shirim (Something Optimistic, Writing Poems) (Tel Aviv, 1976), 48.Google Scholar

63 Azaryahu, Mythography of a City, 143.

64 Ibid., 106, 113.

65 See, for example, Landa, M. and Oesemnik, A. (eds.), Our City Tel Aviv (Tel Aviv, 1959)Google Scholar (Hebrew); Vardi, A. (ed.), The City of Wonders (Tel Aviv 1959) (Hebrew)Google Scholar; Yaari-Polskin, Y., Meir Dizengoff – His Life and his Deeds (Tel Aviv, 1936) (Hebrew)Google Scholar.

66 Dunevitz, N., Holot shehayu lekrach (Sands which Have Turned into a City) (Jerusalem and Tel Aviv, 1959), 83Google Scholar (Hebrew).

67 Biger, G., ‘Al Patrick Geddes ve'oda lo-noda'at “the Return to Zion”’ (Of Patrick Geddes and an unknown ode to ‘the Return to Zion’), Beeri, 1 (1988), 35–44Google Scholar (Hebrew); Confurius, G., ‘Tel Aviv und die Transportfähigkeit der Moderne’ (Tel Aviv and the transportability of the Modern Movement), Daidalos, 54 (1994), 52–61Google Scholar; Kallus, ‘Housing type in Tel Aviv’; Payton, N.I., ‘The machine in the Garden City: Patrick Geddes’ plan for Tel Aviv’, Planning Perspectives, 19 (1995), 359–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Weill-Rochant, K., ‘Tel Aviv des années trente: béton bland sur la terre promise’, L'architecture d'aujourd'hui, 293 (1994), 41–7Google Scholar; idem, ‘Myths and buildings of Tel Aviv’, Bulletin du Centre de recherché français de Jerusalem, 12 (2003), 152–63.

68 Shavit, G. and Biger, Y., Ha'historya shel Tel Aviv, vol. IV: Ir metropolinit (1974–1993) (The History of Tel Aviv, vol. IV: Metropolitan City (1974–1993) (Tel Aviv, 2002), 111–12.Google Scholar

69 Ibid., 24; Azaryahu, Mythography of a City, 145.

70 Azaryahu, Mythography of a City; Mann, B., A Place in History, Stanford Studies in Jewish History and Culture (Stanford, 2006), xiGoogle Scholar. This notion of the ‘dark ages’ in the history of the city is also reflected in the most comprehensive chronicles of the city to date supplied by Yaacov Shavit and Gideon Biger, in which the volume intended to cover the years between 1952 and 1974 was never published.

71 Azaryahu, Mythography of a City, 227; Shavit and Biger, The Birth of a City, 45–6.

72 Payton, ‘The machine in the Garden City’, 363.

73 Yosskovitz, ‘Planning and development of Tel Aviv’, 60–4.

74 Ibid., 61–4; Kallus, ‘Housing type in Tel Aviv’, 290, 293; Payton, ‘The machine in the Garden City’, 359.

75 Payton, ‘The machine in the Garden City’, 361.

76 Shavit and Biger, Metropolitan City, 24.

77 Gavrieli, T., ‘Hatochnit ha'estratgit leTel Aviv-Yafo: ekronot, tahalich, matrot tichnun, yissum’ (The strategic plan for Tel Aviv-Jaffa: principles, process, plan targets, implementation), in Kipnis, B.A. (ed.), Tel Aviv-Yafo: me'ir ganim le'ir olam: mea hashanim harishonot (Tel Aviv-Yafo: From a Garden City to a World City. The First One Hundred Years (Tel Aviv, 2008), 447.Google Scholar

78 Shavit and Biger, Metropolitan City, 106–7, 111–12; Hashimshoni, ‘The Tel Aviv slums’, 121–2; Mazor, ‘Development trends in Tel Aviv’, 97–103.

79 Shavit and Biger, Metropolitan City, 99–100, 106–7, 111–12; Mazor, ‘Development trends in Tel Aviv’, 124–6.

80 Shavit and Biger, Metropolitan City, 121–4.

81 Kallus, ‘Housing type in Tel Aviv’, 293–4. This was nevertheless an accepted idea at the time and mirrored Meir Dizengoff's view on the priority Jews gave to industry over recreation and sea bathing.

82 Shavit and Biger, The Birth of a Town, 33.

83 Azaryahu, Mythography of a City, 115.

84 Shavit and Biger, The Birth of a Town, 46; idem, Metropolitan city, 99–100; Azaryahu, Myhography of a City, 115.

85 The intermediacy of development and nostalgia is apparent in the volume of Ariel of 1987 (48–9) dedicated to Tel Aviv, in which great building projects were hailed side by side with nostalgic tales of small-scale, historic sites, all displaying the city merits regardless of their inherent differences. Ariel, 1987; ‘TelAviv bat Shmonim’ (TelAviv at eighty), Et-Mol (Yesterday), 84 (1989), 2.

86 E. Zandberg, ‘Halbinu et Ha'ir HaLevana’ (Bleach the White City), Haaretz (The Country), 14 Feb. 1999, gallery section, quoted in Shavit and Biger, The Birth of a Town, 34.

87 Shavit and Biger, Metropolitan City, 114–15.

88 Kaiser et al., City Profile, 105–6.

89 Levin, M., Ha'ir Halevana – Hasignon habenleumi bearchitectura be'Israel (White City – the International Style in Architecture in Israel) (Tel Aviv, 1994)Google Scholar; UNESCO, 2003 27COM 8C.23 – White City of Tel Aviv – the Modern Movement (Israel), Site Declaration (last accessed 15 Mar. 2010) http://whc.unesco.org/en/decisions/718 quoted in Szmuk, N., Tel Aviv's Modern Movement: The White City of Tel Aviv, A World Heritage Site (Living on the Dunes exhibition catalogue, Tel Aviv Museum, Tel Aviv, 2004)Google Scholar.

90 Szmuk, Living on the Dunes, 9; Rotbard, S., Ir Levana – Ir Shchora (White City – Black City) (Tel Aviv, 2005), 28–36Google Scholar.

91 Szmuk, Living on the Dunes, 19–20.

92 Ibid., 35.

93 Ibid., 21–2.

94 Kallus, ‘Housing type in Tel Aviv’, 381.

95 Confurius, ‘Tel Aviv and the Modern Movement’, 55.

96 Weill-Rochant, ‘Tel Aviv during the 1930s’, 41.

97 Szmuk, Living on the Dunes, 33–4.

98 Ibid., 13.

99 N. Szmuk, quoted by E. Zandberg, ‘Yesh makom leshimur’ (There is room for conservation), Haaretz, 8 Oct. 2009, gallery section.

100 Berger, T., Dionysus Bacenter (Dionysus in the Center) (Tel Aviv, 1998)Google Scholar; Mann, A Place in History; Rotbard, White City – Black City; Rotbard, S. and Zur, M. (eds.), Lo beYafo velo beTel Aviv: Sipurim, Eduyot veteudot meshchunat Shapira (Not in Jaffa and not in Tel Aviv: Stories, Testimonies and Documents from Shapira Neighbourhood) (Tel Aviv, 2009) (Hebrew)Google Scholar.

101 Two exceptions should be mentioned: Welter, Biopolis, incorporated Geddes’ work in Tel Aviv in an overall narrative of his work as a spiritual modernist; and LeVine, M., Overthrowing Geography: Jaffa, Tel Aviv, and the Struggle for Palestine, 1880–1948 (Berkeley, 2005)Google Scholar, who described Geddes’ work in Tel Aviv as part of the Zionist project of territorialization and land conquest.

102 Krueckeberg, D.A., ‘Between self and culture or what are biographies of planners about?’, Journal of the American Planning Association, 59 (1993), 217–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar