Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-r5fsc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T00:42:31.794Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘PROTESTANTISM’ AS A HISTORICAL CATEGORY

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 September 2016

Alec Ryrie
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The term ‘Protestant’ itself is a historical accident, but the category of western Christians who have separated from Rome since 1517 remains a useful one. The confessionalisation thesis, which has dominated recent Reformation historiography, instead posits the two major Protestant confessions and Tridentine Catholicism as its categories, but this can produce a false parallelism in which the nature of the relationship between the confessions is oversimplified. Instead, this paper proposes we think of a Protestant ecosystem consisting of self-consciously confessional Lutheranism, a broad Calvinism which imagined itself as normative, and a collection of radical currents much more intimately connected to the ‘magisterial’ confessions than any of the participants wished to acknowledge. The magisterial / radical division was maintained only with constant vigilance and exemplary violence, with Calvinism in particular constantly threatening to bleed into radicalism. What gives this quarrelsome family of ‘Protestants’ analytical coherence is neither simple genealogy nor, as has been suggested, mere adherence to the Bible: since in practice both ‘radical’ and ‘magisterial’ Protestants have been more flexible and ‘spiritual’ in their use of Scripture than is generally allowed. It is, rather, the devotional experience underpinning that ‘spiritual’ use of the Bible, of an unmediated encounter with grace.

Type
Research Article
Information
Transactions of the Royal Historical Society , Volume 26 , December 2016 , pp. 59 - 77
Copyright
Copyright © Royal Historical Society 2016 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Luther, Martin, Luther's Works, xlv: The Christian in Society II, ed. Brandt, Walther I. (Philadelphia, 1962), 70 Google Scholar.

2 Marshall, Peter, ‘The Naming of Protestant England’, Past and Present, 214 (2012), 87–128 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, esp. 112.

3 Chillingworth, William, The Religion of Protestants: A Safe Way to Salvation (RSTC 5138.2, Oxford, 1638)Google Scholar; ‘Chillingworth, William (1602–1644)’, Chernaik, Warren in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, ed. Matthew, H. C. G. and Harrison, Brian (Oxford, 2004)Google Scholar; online edn, ed. David Cannadine, Jan. 2010, www.oxforddnb.com.oxfordbrookes.idm.oclc.org/view/article/5308 (accessed 26 June 2016).

4 Shultz, Kevin M., Tri-Faith America (Oxford, 2011)Google Scholar.

5 Charbonnier, Jean-Pierre, Christians in China: ad 600 to 2000, trans. Couve de Murville, M. N. L. (San Francisco, 2007 Google Scholar; cf. French edn 2002), 352. There is no common Chinese equivalent to the generic term ‘Christianity’.

6 Schilling, H., Konfessionskonflict und Staatsbildung (Gütersloh, 1981)Google Scholar; Schilling, H., Religion, Political Culture and the Emergence of Early Modern Society (Leiden, 1992)Google Scholar; Reinhard, W., ‘Reformation, Counter-Reformation and the Early Modern State: A Reassessment’, Catholic Historical Review, 75 (1989), 385–403 Google Scholar; Die Katholische Konfessionalisieung, ed. W. Reinhard and H. Schilling (Gütersloh and Münster, 1995). The literature on the confessionalisation thesis is vast. Amongst the most useful in English is Confessionalization in Europe, 1555–1700, ed. J. M. Headley, H. J. Hillerbrand and A. J. Papadas (Aldershot and Burlington, 2004); and Lotz-Heumann, Ute, ‘The Concept of “Confessionalization”: A Historiographical Paradigm in Dispute’, Memoria y Civilización, 4 (2001), 93–114 Google Scholar.

7 Driedger, Michael D., Obedient Heretics: Mennonite Identities in Lutheran Hamburg and Altona during the Confessional Age (Aldershot, 2002)Google Scholar.

8 See, for example, Marshall, Peter, ‘Confessionalization, Confessionalism and Confusion in the English Reformation’, in Reforming Reformation, ed. Mayer, Thomas F. (Farnham, 2012), 43–64 Google Scholar.

9 Kaufmann, Thomas, ‘Die Konfessionalisierung von Kirche und Gesellschaft’, Theologische Literaturzeitung, 121 (1996), 1008–25Google Scholar, at 1112–21.

10 Gordon, Bruce, Calvin (New Haven, 2009), esp. 161–80Google ScholarPubMed.

11 George, Timothy, ‘John Calvin and the Agreement of Zurich (1549)’, in his John Calvin and the Church: A Prism of Reform (Louisville, 1990)Google Scholar.

12 Wengert, Timothy, ‘“We Will Feast Together in Heaven Forever”: The Epistolary Friendship of John Calvin and Philip Melanchthon’, in Melanchthon in Europe: His Work and Influence Beyond Wittenberg, ed. Maag, Karin (Grand Rapids, 1999), 19–44 Google Scholar.

13 Kolb, Robert, ‘Luther, Augsburg, and the Concept of Authority in the Late Reformation: Ursinus vs. the Lutherans’, in Controversy and Conciliation: The Reformation and the Palatinate, 1559–1583, ed. Visser, Derk (Allison Park, PA, 1986)Google Scholar, 36.

14 Kolb, ‘Luther, Augsburg, and the Concept of Authority’, 36, 38.

15 Scherer, James A., Gospel, Church and Kingdom: Comparative Studies in World Mission Theology (Minneapolis, 1987), 66–9Google Scholar; Tanis, James, ‘Reformed Pietism and Protestant Missions’, Harvard Theological Review, 67 (1974), 65–73 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

16 Ryrie, Alec, ‘The Afterlife of Lutheran England’, in Sister Reformations: The Reformation in Germany and England, ed. Wendebourg, Dorothea (Tübingen, 2011), 213–34Google Scholar; Patterson, W. B., James VI and I and the Reunion of Christendom (Cambridge, 1997), 165–80Google Scholar; Batten, J. Minton, John Dury: Advocate of Christian Reunion (Chicago, 1944)Google Scholar.

17 Susan Royal, ‘John Foxe's “Acts and Monuments” and the Lollard Legacy in the Long English Reformation’ (Ph.D. thesis, Durham University, 2014).

18 John Bale, Yet a Course at the Romyshe Foxe. A Dysclosynge or Openynge of the Manne of Synne (RSTC 1309, Antwerp, 1543), fo. 51v; [John Bale], A Christen Exhortacion vnto Customable Swearers (RSTC 1280, Antwerp, 1543), fo. 6v.

19 , Elsie Anne, ‘A Lay Voice in Sixteenth-Century “Ecumenics”: Katharina Schütz Zell in Dioalogue with Johannes Brenz, Conrad Pellican, and Caspar Schwenckfeld’, in Adaptions of Calvinism in Reformation Europe, ed. Holt, Mack P. (Aldershot, 2007), 81–110 Google Scholar.

20 James M. Stayer, Anabaptists and the Sword (Lawrence, KS, 1976), 141–3.

21 Oliphant Old, Hughes, The Shaping of the Reformed Baptismal Rite in the Sixteenth Century (Grand Rapids, 1992), 52, 54–6Google Scholar.

22 See, for example, The Works of John Knox, ed. David Laing (6 vols., Edinburgh, 1846–64), i, 298–300; Alec Ryrie, Being Protestant in Reformation Britain (Oxford, 2013), 335.

23 MacCulloch, Diarmaid, ‘Calvin: Fifth Latin Doctor of the Church?’, in Calvin and his Influence, 1509–2009, ed. Backus, Irena and Benedict, Philip (Oxford, 2011), 33–45 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

24 Ward, W. R., The Protestant Evangelical Awakening (Cambridge, 1992)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Jacob Spener, Philip, Pia Desideria, trans. and ed. Tappert, Theodore G. (Philadelphia, 1964)Google Scholar.

25 Ryrie, Alec, ‘Mission and Empire: An Ethical Puzzle in Early Modern Protestantism’, in Sister Reformations II: Reformation and Ethics in Germany and in England, ed. Wendebourg, Dorothea and Ryrie, Alec (Tübingen, 2014), 181–206 Google Scholar.

26 Alister McGrath, Christianity's Dangerous Idea: The Protestant Revolution (2007); Gregory, Brad S., The Unintended Reformation: How a Religious Revolution Secularized Society (Cambridge, MA, 2012)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

27 Luther, Martin, Luther's Works, xxxiv: Career of the Reformer IV, ed. Spitz, Lewis W. (Philadelphia, 1960), 317 Google Scholar; Luther, Martin, Luther's Works, xxxv: Word and Sacrament I, ed. Theodore Bachmann, E. (Philadelphia, 1960), 361–2Google Scholar, 397; Luther, Martin, Luther's Works, liv: Table Talk, ed. and trans. Tappert, Theodore G. (Philadephia, 1967), 79–80 Google Scholar, 373, 424, 452; Seeberg, Reinhold, Textbook of the History of Doctrines, trans. Hay, Charles E. (2 vols., Grand Rapids, 1958–61), ii, 300–1Google Scholar.

28 Luther, Martin, Luther's Works, xiv: Selected Psalms III, ed. Pelikan, Jaroslav and Poellot, Daniel E. (St Louis, 1958), 36 Google Scholar.

29 Rogers, Jack B. and McKim, Donald K., The Authority and Interpretation of the Bible: An Historical Approach (San Francisco, 1979), 78 Google Scholar; Gerrish, Brian A., ‘The Word of God and the Words of Scripture: Luther and Calvin on Biblical Authority’, in his The Old Protestantism and the New: Essays on the Reformation Heritage (Chicago, 1982), 51–68 Google Scholar at 55.

30 McNeill, John T., ‘The Significance of the Word of God for Calvin’, Church History, 28 (1959), 131–46CrossRefGoogle Scholar, esp. 143–4.

31 Calvin, John, Institutes of the Christian Religion, ed. McNeill, John T., trans. Ford Lewis Battles (Philadelphia, 1960), 78–81 Google Scholar.

32 Hendrix, Scott, Tradition and Authority in the Reformation (Aldershot, 1996), ii, 147 Google Scholar.

33 Lehmann, Paul, ‘The Reformers' Use of the Bible’, Theology Today, 3 (1946), 328–44CrossRefGoogle Scholar at 329; Gerrish, ‘Word of God’, 59. Cf. article vi of the Anglican Thirty-Nine Articles.

34 Harrison, Peter, The Bible, Protestantism and the Rise of Natural Science (Cambridge, 1998)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

35 Sources of South German/Austrian Anabaptism, ed. Walter Klaassen, Frank Friesen and Werner O. Packull (Kitchener, ON, 2001), 19, 24–9.

36 Ibid ., 44–5; A Collection of Ranter Writings from the Seventeenth Century, ed. Nigel Smith (1983), 102; A. L. Morton, The World of the Ranters: Religious Radicalism in the English Revolution (1970), 82; George Fox, A Declaration of the Difference of the Ministers of the Word from the Ministers of the World; Who Calls the Writings, the Word (Wing F1790, 1656), 12.

37 ‘Memoir of Old Elizabeth, a Colored Woman’, in Six Women's Slave Narratives, ed. William L. Andrews (New York, 1988), 16.